Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Observations sharpening now that I'm done

Posts

Observations sharpening now that I'm done

#1

Observations sharpening now that I'm done

David Weaver

I'm not done with the test, but fortunately, I don't have to keep repeating that sharpening procedure.

This isn't for all sharpening, it's just the feedback the steels gave me.

3V - slow. Surprisingly slow on diamonds. It takes twice as many swipes to sharpen it on small diamonds. This was somewhat of a surprise after mauling it on a fine india stone and then doing at least a serviceable job with the japanese natural stone.

V11 and A2 - indistinguishable on the diamonds. Both took an edge well off of it. I didn't raise as much of a wire edge with the A2 as the v11. The V11 held on to the wire edge weakened by one micron diamonds and then let it go at once.

Tsunesaburo blue steel - my 1200 grit diamond is tired, it doesn't cut brash or raise a huge wire edge fast, but the tsune iron almost refused to hold a wire edge. It's hard. They claim 65 or something, and it probably is. You can't tell with diamonds because they cut anything at any hardness. After faffing with the wire edges from 3v, A2 and V11, it was welcom

My O1 iron - similar to the tsune, but not quite as drastic (it will hold some wire edge)

(the chinese HSS iron was almost an afterthought - it seems similar with the wire edge to V11 and A2)

The real issue with the wire edge is that when you remove it, you have to do so with some care for two reasons. If you give in to the temptation to just rip it off, you can damage what would otherwise be a defect free edge. Not a terminal damage, but the kind that makes it less wonderful to start with. The more uniform an iron starts, the better off you'll be - especially with more highly alloyed steels (we'll test this later).

I wouldn't look forward to sharpening 3V on a day to day basis, but I would probably find a faster diamond hone and see what I could get away with. It's that step (the secondary bevel) that takes the time. I would also get a cast setup for the back bevel or just the back face.

It seems like a pretty good iron, but I wouldn't look forward to finish planing with it (true finish planing) because it's so punishing if there is a small nick to work all the way through it.

Re: Observations sharpening now that I'm done

#2

Re: Observations sharpening now that I'm done

David Weaver

I forgot..the other wire edge issue.

Sometimes on the finishing step, a visible bit of wire edge comes off. On a cast plate or hardwood, this is a real problem if you're chasing a 1 micron edge. The rolling wire edge will definitely damage whatever drags over it.

Re: Observations sharpening now that I'm done

#3

wire edges on cast iron

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My only joy of sharpening is watching the tenacious wire edge generated on 3V finally float free of the blade tip (chisel in my case). On cast iron with WD40 lube, and plenty of it, this junk and all the other junk, floats off the edge of the plate, making the mess that many object to. An adequate layer of WD 40 keeps junk suspended where it can float away. All reasons I don't use anything but cast iron as a substrate. Copper printed circuit plates are wonderful for coarse grits but the junk stays on the plate and embeds.

What I do have to watch for is the initial wire edge. It is well to be sure it is bent up or it will score the plate.

Re: Observations sharpening now that I'm done

#4

even the tiny ones..

david weaver

would do some damage that would show up on the microscope, but I don't know when it becomes material. I think most people - especially anyone sanding, would think I'm nuts for talking about the tiny wire edges, and for the purpose of shaving lifting, they're probably right.

In this case, my feet are to the fire on the pictures, though. If you look at the scratches I left on my O1 iron, they are plentiful but relatively shallow. I couldn't have left those scratches on one of the commercial irons or any failure around them would've nullified the test results to some extent.

Your familiarity with what you see also means, though, that you're better at preventing - and knowing that you're preventing - anything untoward getting on the cast plate and sticking so that it can bruise the edge. Using wood has allowed me to see the wire edge and pick it off or push it off of the surface, but even then, I have to be careful. Anything on my fingertip (even a stray piece of dirt) could scratch an iron all up at the level of magnification being used.

Thankfully, the O1 iron pretty much wore past those little scratches quickly and never showed any effect from them.

It'll be interesting in a subsequent test to see if one type of iron is more forgiving of such a sin than another.