Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

3v at 50 shavings

Posts

3v at 50 shavings

#1

3v at 50 shavings

david weaver

newly sharpened


at 50 shavings


couple of tiny nicks, but otherwise very good surace quality.

Re: 3v at 50 shavings

#2

This one will get a redo...

David Weaver

..just as I gave the V11 a redo, this iron is the one that has to go in a different plane because it's larger. I have to be sure that the small nicks aren't related to dirt that I didn't manage to get off of the plane. I filed the mouth of this plane and added a peined tab to the cap iron a few days ago - definitely opportunity for contamination.

If I get the same results again (small nicks), we'll continue on.

I think it's safe to say that this level of edge uniformity to start is rare (not the 1 micron finish, that's easy to get - but the lack of any lines or nicks or anything at this magnification level after you sharpen and handle an iron.) Once this test is complete if the results are reasonable in one go, I will test other things, and that will provide the ability to see how the irons do with more ordinary edges.

Re: 3v at 50 shavings

#3

Re: redo at 50

david weaver


similar results. some lines on the work, but minimal. a real pain to sharpen on a fine diamond stone, though!! 200 strokes to remove a small nick and 100+ more to give it the 1 micron diamond treatment.

Re: 3v at 50 shavings

#4

Re: 3v at 100 shavings

david weaver

tiny defects still there, but evening out with wear? less wear to the naked eye than other irons (the wear bevel is visible on all irons at this point)


Re: 3v at 50 shavings

#5

Re: 3v at 150 shavings

david weaver


not much change, but there's that three dimensional look again - just less shallow than v11. why is it so distinct on the powder metal irons?

Re: 3v at 50 shavings

#6

Re:Particle Steel product by process

E Phillip Smith

Good to see my old friend doing OK. I ground the initial bevels on the 3V irons for Wiley and company. Just for reference this is the lowest carbon steel in the irons you are testing, CPM list the carbon content as 0.80% carbon, significantly below the carbon content of the other irons.

I spent decades in product development in the chemical industry. For pure products you can often define products solely on composition. But formulated products the end product is often defined by both composition and process. This is the case formulated (Steel which have high performance carbides which have poor solubility in the steel matrix) steels.

The process is what sets the particle steel apart from traditional steel of the same composition. Briefly the process entails mixing all of the components in a crucible to get a uniform distribution, then forcing the liquid steel through a nozzle to atomize the steel (think spray gun for paint) under nitrogen and quenching the very fine particles in LIQUID NITROGEN to instantly freeze the very fine particles (think talcum powder), the very fast quench causes the carbide particles to form in a very fine structure in the already small powder. The powder is then heated to forge temperature in inert atmosphere and pressed to consolidate the powder into a steel with extremely fine structure. The billets are then rolled to the desired thickness. THINK DEMASCUS STEEL on steroids.

Re: 3v at 50 shavings

#7

Re:Particle Steel product by process

david weaver

The method that it wears - if you look at the erosion of the steel at the back of the wear bevel on the LV, it really does look like it wears different than the more traditional steels.

My O1 iron kept excellent uniformity, but I'm disappointed in the clearance running out for the purposes of this test. It wouldn't bother me in daily use, though, because I would have it back up and running with a single stone in about a minute and a half, and the lack of damage means that no matter what, the next shaving will leave a good quality surface (even if I fail to make a wire edge large enough to remove all of the wear).

I'm sort of at the edge of my seat waiting to see how the V11 iron will continue on as the visual side of things suggests that the wear bevel on the top of the iron is really deep, so much so that scaling the pictures, it's actually a little shorter (the edge of the iron is wearing back, and the steepness of the back side of the wear bevel makes it easier to see than it is on any of the other irons).

This isn't a scientific test, and it's not going to branch out into me trying to assert things other than number of feet planed and some subjective things that I feel while planing, but it's still interesting to observe.

I've learned from your posts and others during the process.

one of the early things I saw with particle steels was a knife test where a smith put knives in a vise and bent them. The particle steels didn't tolerate that well, so I wrote off their toughness as being something that may not be that great for tools.

Do you think their composition, being sintered together from already established particles would assist in them leaving go of those particles more uniformly? that's the kind of old wive's tale kind of potential guessing that can lead to false statements, but I'd love an explanation for why the v11 and 3v have such uniform hollows on the top. At the same time, I'm surprised with so much wear, clearance isn't an issue.

I know from the other study that bill is getting translated that it's not just the amount of wear that's different from steel to steel, but the actual shape of the bevel side and the back side of a tool differs from one to the next, and it may be coincidence that the two particle steel irons seem to show the same thing at different rates - maybe those two do, but another type of particle steel wouldn't.