o1 at 50 shavnigs
david weaver
house made iron, high hardness o1

at 50 shavings
surface quality excellent, no notable defects
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
o1 at 50 shavnigs
david weaver
house made iron, high hardness o1

at 50 shavings
surface quality excellent, no notable defects
Re: o1 at 50 shavnigs
David Weaver
Of note here is how pronounced the wear bevel is. As stated in prior posts, to some extent, one that looks more pronounced than another may just be a matter of interpreting light.
However, one might look at this and see the line where the wear stops as probably close to where the cap iron was. That's not the case, though. The cap iron was probably about 4 times as far away, or near the dark line.
I noticed that even though I have the cap set sort of tight (I checked a set under the scope, and it's about a hundredth of an inch, but it is by no means tight like one would interpret from the K&K study work), the shaving is manipulated pretty significantly. Shavings are about 2 1/2 thousandths thick on average. Because it's hard to measure them precisely with calipers - due to springback - I figured I will weigh them and make sure each iron has removed the same volume of wood at any given point. Anyway, the point here is that I think that the stiffness of maple (which i would perceive as stiff relative to hardness) makes the cap more effective at this set than it might be with a softer wood. This is pretty close to what I would call a "typical" smoother set, though. In anything else, it would be very difficult to generate much tearout, and this set would probably allow a 4-5 thousandth shaving in cherry if you really wanted to push it.
Re: o1 at 100
david weaver
excellent uniformity, but wear is very visible to the naked eye.
Re: o1 at 150 shavnigs
david weaver
o1 is showing signs of giving up. the the edge is wonderfully uniform but it feels like clearance is just barely adequat at 600 feet. The refresh will be easy, but it is seemingly early.