Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

chinese hss at 50 shavings

Posts

chinese hss at 50 shavings

#1

chinese hss at 50 shavings

david weaver

freshly sharpened and then after 50. We can see the wear bevel, fortunately.



no significant defects

Re: chinese hss at 50 shavings

#2

Re: chinese hss at 50 shavings

david weaver

at 100


many small (tiny) defects but surface quality still very uniform, just slightly less bright.

Re: chinese hss at 50 shavings

#3

chinese hss at 150 shavings

david weaver

also more wear but more uniform


Re: chinese hss at 50 shavings

#4

wear bevel at 600 feet - naked eye

david weaver


notice the expert planing resulting in no wear bevel at the edges. haha. :b

This wear bevel is about as bright (subjectively) as the LV wear bevel, it just didn't take a face on photo as easily because it doesn't reflect light quite the same way.

You can't really confirm which is more worn than the other even though the V11 picture looks brighter - all you can confirm is that you can see both.

Even at 50 strokes (200 feet) planed, you can see a wear bevel on irons, as long as you know what to look for. It's not as prominent, but rest assured, the very edge that you prepare is soon gone once you start planing, and what's more important is how the edge wears vs. how perfect it was when starting. To the extent that the starting perfection allows more even wear, though, that may be very important. We'll try to test the condition of the edge in pictures at 400 feet or 600 feet later with different starting conditions (my beloved washita will be used to prepare at least the O1 iron, and we'll see how the 3V iron does off of the natural stone that i showed. The natural stone left a less good starting edge under magnification, but believe it or not, it was far faster to use than 1 micron diamonds. fine india to hard ark to that stone is a matter of a minute or two at most.

I also think that the photo standard for the is partly at fault - I probably spent two minutes per iron just on the 1 micron diamonds, and because i'm using wood instead of cast, I had to apply diamond pretty liberally, and reapply to make sure some was on the surface of the wood. One charge on cast iron would've been enough to do all of this, I'm fairly sure. I've charged wood at least 8 times. The sharpness result is the same and I don't have to deal with potential photo ruining contaminants on wood, though (and the diamonds have no subsequent use after this testing - i don't and won't sharpen using this method going forward - it slows things down).