Re: My perception of the V11 steel...
david weaver
..I don't have a great grasp on how much particle M2 would differ from standard M2, so the particle part, I can't account for.
I'd said at the outset early on that it seemed a lot like 440C in friodur to me in terms of how it feels on the stones, but as you and Rob attested to its hardness (after reading up more on 440C, it appears that the reason that friodur uses it slightly lower than typical hardness preference of mine - like 61 or so - is because 440Cs maximum recommended hardness in tools is only 58 or 59. I may be wrongly concluded the friodur razors were a little soft so that they could be used on natural stones. That may have been a beneficial side effect).
Point of all of that being that other than the same feel, friodur was not particle but it was one of the early cryo treated steels. A simple steel with a process that distributed or dispersed the carbides, and it didn't suffer any of the less than fine edge taking characteristics that a lot of older stainless steels do.
It's also one of the few irons that I have where the cap will rust but the iron doesn't. A2 is sort of like that (Chromium?), but it will rust at a slower rate than the cap. Carbon steel will rust at a slightly slower rate than the cap, but rust on one usually means rust on untreated parts of the other. I guess hardness slows the depth of rust, or maybe that's just incident to the fact that the iron is handled more with oily hands. Don't know.
But I've not had a V11 iron of any of mine rust. The M2 irons (I'd have to go look at the composition again), will rust a little, but slower. They are very slick feeling and the cap iron of the plane slides across the face of a polished chinese iron easier than it does across V11.
All of that leads me to believe that compared to some of the more exotic CPM steels, it's very simple (like 440C is, relative to a lot of the newer stainless steels with a whole bunch of vanadium in them - I call them barrel scrapers. You can scrape a rusty barrel with them and they only give up the initial edge - but then they never want to hold the initial edge and always seem toothy - even a strop will fragment the very tiny edge). It doesn't exhibit the same lack of refinement that most alloy steels do and is wearing just a bit more evenly at the edge than the M2 and more evenly than the 3V. After 400 feet, the 3V was less worn geometrically than others, something that will be easier to confirm after it gets its next 200 strokes.
Whatever the results of the test may be, I prefer the v11 as it is (sharpenable, smoother wear) vs. something complicated that wouldn't wear as evenly. I'm still dying to see how it will compare to the LN A2 given that the sharpenability of the two is about the same, and subjectively, the hardness seems to be similar.
The picture of the back of the V11 groove is also interesting. It looks very eroded, and rough, but it has zero effect on the feel of the plane. It could just be a light-assisted illusion, too.
One more round with the O1 will also help to see (O1 is definitely simple) if the wear pattern is similar. I expect it should be and the erosion should also be more three dimensional and offer the same shading, and hopefully uniformity at the edge that's as good.