Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

updated - v11 after 50 shavings

Posts

updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#1

updated - v11 after 50 shavings

david weaver

i'd prefer to keep the typing minimal on this computer since i have to use ascii codes for two of the letters.

i gave the v11 a big dose of diamond plate to bring the m-bevel up to a full millimeter and then gave it quite a bit more of a session on the 1 micron diamonds so that no microcraking would be present. i'm not aware of any significant amount occurring at 1 micron. The results are worlds different. no edge defects after 50 shavings.

the remaining irons will get the same treatment before their turn to keep things fair.

if there are bad results, we will still go back and find the medium that each iron likes.

freshly honed:


50 shavings:


This iron was too tight to work in the stanley plane where i'd want a smoother cap setting to be, so i have switched to a ln brone (now another letter doesn't work) 4 for testing as it would just be another problem one i get to the ln iron.

This is much more in line with what we'd expect for results. i'm pleased.

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#2

This leads to some questions..

David Weaver

..first, what was causing the failures the first time around. If they don't recur, I don't think we'll ever know, and I'm not a fan of substituting an assertion without proof.

Second, I've changed planes - the inability to set the cap iron properly was really bugging me. My option with the stanley was to file the mouth, but it's my favorite smoother, so no way. No civilized person would move the cap back twice as far as it should be from the edge, so that is rectified. BUT, what happened to the wear on the back of the iron right at the edge? The shavings are about 2 1/2 thousandths. I shot for two early on, but my calipers keep you guessing with a little bit of springback without wood in them.

I'd guess the setting for the cap now is somewhere in the 6 to 8 thousandth range because it's influencing shavings but it's not really adding much resistance. This is exactly where I"d have it for smoothing. The shavings are straightening, but not compressed. IF you were to use this plane and want to take a shaving half again thicker or a little more, it would compress the shavings some - you could work quickly with no risk of tearout.

But ...where's the wear bevel on the back, I thought we saw it on the other ones. I don't know. IT could also be that the polish is so bright now that it will have to be bigger before it contrasts enough to see it.

On the actual wood, after this, there are two tiny lines. They may not even be seen if I was using a washita to smooth, but the uniformity of the edge on this and the sharpness makes them stand out on a super bright surface.

As you look at the second picture, you'll see mostly removed lines that terminate just before the edge. That they do is important, because any depth of lines getting to the edge creates an unsupported corner and that unsupported corner will erode on both sides making the defect bigger.

There's a double layer of relief tonight, too. I was wary of coming home to a house where the mrs. saw a guitar was delivered, but before leaving work, she called to tell me that she was taking the kids to the pool - unboxing and stowing of the box and throwing the case into general population where the newbie wouldn't be noticed was achieved without detection. YAY!

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#3

A simple point about the pictures..

david weaver

Bill reminded me of this, I may have said it in pieces. You can't really trust the light levels and wear on the face of the iron when the differences are subtle. This is a $425 indian microscope with chinese software (that cost includes the base and camera). It's really good for the price, but it's not an SEM.

What I rely on (I bought this scope to judge natural stones and to examine edges of razors that I sell, though I don't do that regularly now) is the actual picture at the very edge. If the edge is uniform, especially at this level, you can generally conclude that it's well sharpened. After some wear, if it remains uniform, you can generally conclude that it is wearing in very small bits, and will be thin. The more uniform, the thinner the edge will be where it meets wood.

You can see wear on an iron like this with the naked eye, even though it doesn't show up in the second picture. It could be that the wear is removing the tiny scratches from the initial sharpening, or it could be that the focal length isn't the same in the two pictures. But the uniformity of the edge itself (where it disappears into black) is what we're looking for.

Despite the fact that the edge looks shiny freshly sharpened and then less so in the second picture, you cannot see reflection of light when it's freshly sharpened (a good ancillary thing to check when sharpening) and even with 200 feet of maple planed, you can see just a tiny bit of light reflected back at you if you look at the very edge. In the same way, you can look at a straight razor and see if it's been stropped with bare leather because you can only just see the tiniest amount of reflection from the edge.

So, though the curiosity about the features reflected back makes for interesting guessing, it's only the very edge that we're concerned about until or unless a much more prominent pattern of wear emerges (and for planing quality, even then, we're still concerned about the edge).

We've got a long way to go with wear, though. When the iron is sharpened well and the wood is clear, last time with the A2 irons, I'd say I got at least 1000 feet of good planing out of an LN iron, and then another 700 to 800 feet of struggling to try to get the iron to stop cutting (it never really did, but the quality of the wood surface really got horrid as i continued to force on). That was also on hard maple. I didn't use the cap iron back then, so I'm interested to see if the number of feet planed improves with these irons with the cap set.

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#4

One more thing to test - jams

david weaver

One of the things that happened with the stanley plane the first couple of passes is that the tight mouth and cap iron set (the former being impossible to avoid due to the mouth size on the stanley and the thicker veritas iron vs. stock) is that I got a couple of jams. They were mediocre in nature (continue shaving, they come out. Then recur again at the beginning of a subsequent shaving).

I may have had 6 of these in each of the first two tests.

I am wondering now (as the LN has a gaping mouth with the frog set back) if the pressure of that jam up may have aided in causing the iron to fail. I never use a plane with the mouth that tight and won't for the rest of this test, but never considered how a shaving jam may weaken or push the very edge of the iron over or off where it's the thinnest.

I'll test this later.

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#5

Trying to understand this...

Chuck Nickerson

As this thread spreads out it harder for my old brain to follow the flow.

(That's not a criticism; there's a lot of information and experimentation here.)

Are you saying you spent extra time sharpening the micro-bevel using the 1m diamonds? I could imagine a blade starting with few/no defects is much slower to acquire fractures at the edge.

Did you just spend 'extra time' or were you examining it with the scope?

Thanks for the work and documentation.

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#6

Re: Trying to understand this...

david weaver

By extra time (you're welcome to criticize, by the way), I mean this:

My first process was:

* take the new irons, flatten them (no such thing done with the V11 iron, and little with LNs - they don't need it)

* grind a 16th inch off of the irons, a fat 16th...that haven't been used before just to eliminate the potential that any issues would occur with heat treating (I suspect not, and that the bevels are fully cut after heat treating, but take that variable out).

* add a microbevel with a 1200 grit plate that is way worn out and fine cutting for that grit (pictures will be taken of that vs. something standard and new for comparison - like fresh abrasive on a 1k waterstone)

* secondary microbevel with 1 micron diamonds on wood, and then flip the blade over and work the back using charlesworths ruler trick to ensure that both edges meet with no defects

What appears to be the case is that something else was causing the defects. What, we won't know. It could be the jamming that occurred with the V11 iron due to thickness (I'll test that) in my stanley 4, it could be from the brash grinder wheel leaving tiny fractures in the very edge, whatever it was, I suspected it probably wasn't the 1200 grit diamond hone or the 1 micron diamond.

So, the "giving it extra" on the diamonds was beyond just getting the edge uniform, but also spending another full minute or two grinding the microbevel further to remove some more of the edge off of the grinder, and then spending much extra time on the back bevel and making it larger than it normally would be to attempt to get to metal that's representative of what's in the iron after a good bit of use.

things just didn't seem right with the V11 iron, and it was an opportunity to improve the method and make the results ...well, a lot more valuable.

I stuck with the diamonds for another go-around and improved the amount of fine work done by them because I remember seeing some analysis at some point (don't remember where) that large diamonds can indeed make detectable cracks in steel, but at smaller levels, it's negligible or materially none. I didn't want to switch media and have the edge failure pinned on the Ezelap when that wasn't the cause.

I have to be careful now and make sure I give the same level of deference to the $8-$11 irons. I came up a little short in flattening my O1 iron, and ran it over the wood anyway, but I'm going to redo that one. I feel like it's OK if i cause my own iron to look like crap, right :b but someone may make additional judgments to other O1 irons based on how mine performs, and I don't want that.

This study has two main purposes - two use until material failure (as defined by a plane not staying in the cut without undue top pressure), and to examine surface quality along the way. To some extent, those are linked, but both could be important to some users, and some may choose one or the other and discard the one that they don't care about. All decent irons last long enough for me. I don't really care that much about edge longevity, but I do care about surface uniformity. Maybe others might not feel the same, so I'm going to do my best to provide both.

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#7

Re: v11 after 100

david weaver


wear is evident, but surface quality still very good. perhaps slightlt improved with wear.

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#8

v11 after 150

david weaver

edge getting more uniform at 150


Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#9

Re: v11 after 150

David Weaver

OK - let's have some fun guessing at what's going on in this picture. It looks as if the edge is receding vertically, like a cavity is forming where the edge is eroding from the rub of turning a shaving up.

However, the edge appears as if it's getting more uniform rather than less. Slightly less bright, and maybe that's helping to hide some of the lines, but they are less pronounced at 150 than they were at 50 and 100. Does some rounding of the edge protect it from creating further nicks as it wears?

No sign of coming out of the cut yet, and this is after 600 feet.

This dark cavity appears in any focused setting on the scope. The chinese HSS has less of this cavity, but also less uniformity at the very edge.

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#10

Re: v11 after 150

David Weaver

This dark line is visible to the naked eye. The wear bevel looks like one bright line, a tiny area that's not worn (when in fact it may be more worn) and the area behind it has been burnished and slightly worn.

The super polish from the 1 micron diamond makes this easier to see because behind all of the wear is a bright polish which reflects light only when the reflected ray of incident light is right at your eye.

I think the worn edge scatters light so it's visible as a bright cloudy wear bevel at more angles.

Hard to explain - I didn't take physics past high school and certainly didn't cover any of this stuff that I can recall.

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#11

"the morning after"

david weaver

I don't have much time to plane in the evenings during the week. The kids are either awake, or they're sleeping above the shop.

What's going on with this iron is really curious to me, and it kind of gives me warm fuzzy feelings. The wear looks stark, and the scooped edge actually looks shorter (as if it's wearing down and thus shortening the wear bevel). But look at the uniformity of the edge.

If you haven't looked at a lot of scope pictures before, rounded edges tend to not have much definition, but the very edge here is crisp.

It's as if it doesn't wear quite the same way. The HSS chinese iron (we really don't know the quality of that one, so it's not a bar to judge anything by) doesn't appear to have the same depth of erosion, but it's also not quite as crisp at the edge. to the naked eye, both edge (of the board) surfaces still look very similar.

It'll be interesting to see if the other irons develop this three dimensional look with the shade. I will post a picture of the edge to the naked eye shortly.

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#12

to the naked eye after 600 feet

david weaver

The camera exacerbates what this edge looks like. It's visible, but the contrast is not quite as stark as the camera makes it look. With this and the microscope picture, you get the idea that there's quite a bit of wear. With a less refined sharpening method, you wouldn't see it as much. There is no bad behavior from this or the chinese iron in use, though. The shavings are smooth and lifted easily from the board. I am using the cap iron (with no intention of setting it off), which changes both the wear pattern and the behavior in the cut, so I'm not sure how different single iron would be (or cap set off far enough to allow the shavings to scratch a shallower and longer wear bevel on top of the iron).


The unseen variable here is the bevel side of the iron, but I don't think that's useful unless you can see the wear profile from the side (which we can't see), and the geometry of taking a picture of the bevel side face on would require me making some kind of special stand for the microscope. It's made for viewing flat samples and there's not much room between the table and the lens. At this magnification, movement of any type is magnified in the view.

Even this cheap scope will go 4 times closer than this optically, but it becomes extremely difficult to tell what you're seeing when the magnification is that high and the field is that small. This setting is the one I use to check razors - it's plenty good enough for this test, and already makes defects in the edge look orders of magnitude larger than they are from the perspective of a person pushing the plane. None of these irons has a defect big enough to split even a thin smoother shaving.

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#13

Concavity at Edge *LINK*

Steve Elliott

Some insight into the shape of the edge can be gained from a study Kato and Kawai did with a scanning electron microscope.

Here's a link to a summary of the study.


Kato and Kawai on Wear with Cap Iron

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#14

comparing Chinese vs LV PMV11 steel properties

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If we presume the Chinese is M2 it is likely not a "particle" M2. The less expensive Chinese M2 jointer knife stock available at my wood tooling shop is not particle steel, consistent with this presumption. If we further presume we have correctly identified the steel used to manufacturer PMV11 blades then we can compare published properties of the two steels. The property that stands out in comparison is toughness. The superior toughness of the PMV11 could be the factor that results in the different wear. You may be discovering that abrasion resistance is not the only steel property of importance to planing edge life. That would be a nice discovery. K&K observed many cases where the shape of the wear differed as a result of steel or plane set up variables.

In the K&K paper on cap iron performance they noted under some configurations a self sharpening effect resulting from erosion of the blade face caused by the concentration of shaving force in this area. They were able to see this effect in the SEM pictures. I can't recall if it was reflected in the planing force data which is the data that most closely correlates with a tactile feel for what the bade is doing in hand planing.

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#15

Re: Concavity at Edge

david weaver

I know i've read through all of your stuff at least twice. In the event that I end up repeating some of your experiments without recalling that i am, my apologies for that. I'm resisting going to your page (and haven't for a couple of years) because I'm afraid it will taint what I see and my interpretation of it (as in, if you come to a conclusion, then I am going to view things through a lens of expecting to see the same and people often find what they expect to find).

That said, I remember those pictures and I remember seeing them when i first started setting the cap, thinking "oh no, I'm going to cut a big divot in the back of my iron that's really hard to sharpen out". Fortunately, it doesn't seem to have happened that way - the wear on the back is still easy to remove at the edge.

But these pictures themselves made me think (when I took them), oh....the concavity...I can't believe i'm seeing in person what's on the K&K documentation from the planing machine. For lack of a better way to put it, it's one of those kind of "it looks the same as it does on TV!" kind of moments. Whether it's lack of confidence in my methods, consistency or ability to see things from a vertical viewpoint in an inexpensive microscope (relatively, still $425, but not the much more expensive scopes that seem to do better focusing on a wider range of distances from the lens at the same time)...I just didn't expect such a good match.

I'm at the edge of my luddite seat waiting to see if the wear patterns on the other irons will match.

This is definitely not the case of varying irons getting different cap iron sets. I took pictures through the scope and all are 8 thousandths to .01". The constant rotation of the plane should eliminate most of the arguments about whether or not I just planed wood with varying characteristics (I'm still on my first test board, but boards 2 and 3 are from the same load of lumber and none of a distinguishable grain direction, so if the irons all had identical characteristics, we should get the same results. It would've been a smart thing to add a second identical iron of high quality - like the A2 or the V11 so that we could see that two versions of the same iron experience the same results with both placed halfway apart in the test rotation. Oh well, maybe in another decade, i'll do this again).

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#16

Re: My perception of the V11 steel...

david weaver

..I don't have a great grasp on how much particle M2 would differ from standard M2, so the particle part, I can't account for.

I'd said at the outset early on that it seemed a lot like 440C in friodur to me in terms of how it feels on the stones, but as you and Rob attested to its hardness (after reading up more on 440C, it appears that the reason that friodur uses it slightly lower than typical hardness preference of mine - like 61 or so - is because 440Cs maximum recommended hardness in tools is only 58 or 59. I may be wrongly concluded the friodur razors were a little soft so that they could be used on natural stones. That may have been a beneficial side effect).

Point of all of that being that other than the same feel, friodur was not particle but it was one of the early cryo treated steels. A simple steel with a process that distributed or dispersed the carbides, and it didn't suffer any of the less than fine edge taking characteristics that a lot of older stainless steels do.

It's also one of the few irons that I have where the cap will rust but the iron doesn't. A2 is sort of like that (Chromium?), but it will rust at a slower rate than the cap. Carbon steel will rust at a slightly slower rate than the cap, but rust on one usually means rust on untreated parts of the other. I guess hardness slows the depth of rust, or maybe that's just incident to the fact that the iron is handled more with oily hands. Don't know.

But I've not had a V11 iron of any of mine rust. The M2 irons (I'd have to go look at the composition again), will rust a little, but slower. They are very slick feeling and the cap iron of the plane slides across the face of a polished chinese iron easier than it does across V11.

All of that leads me to believe that compared to some of the more exotic CPM steels, it's very simple (like 440C is, relative to a lot of the newer stainless steels with a whole bunch of vanadium in them - I call them barrel scrapers. You can scrape a rusty barrel with them and they only give up the initial edge - but then they never want to hold the initial edge and always seem toothy - even a strop will fragment the very tiny edge). It doesn't exhibit the same lack of refinement that most alloy steels do and is wearing just a bit more evenly at the edge than the M2 and more evenly than the 3V. After 400 feet, the 3V was less worn geometrically than others, something that will be easier to confirm after it gets its next 200 strokes.

Whatever the results of the test may be, I prefer the v11 as it is (sharpenable, smoother wear) vs. something complicated that wouldn't wear as evenly. I'm still dying to see how it will compare to the LN A2 given that the sharpenability of the two is about the same, and subjectively, the hardness seems to be similar.

The picture of the back of the V11 groove is also interesting. It looks very eroded, and rough, but it has zero effect on the feel of the plane. It could just be a light-assisted illusion, too.

One more round with the O1 will also help to see (O1 is definitely simple) if the wear pattern is similar. I expect it should be and the erosion should also be more three dimensional and offer the same shading, and hopefully uniformity at the edge that's as good.

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#17

Re: I have a new motto

david weaver

Sitting here smashing down my lunch.

If V11 manages to outlast A2, and perhaps any others. They could tout the uniformity of the edge as it fails.

"PM V11 - Engineered to Fail Successfully"

I'm still enamored with the way the cavity is forming even though I doubt anyone else is.

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#18

Summary of Kato/Kawai Studies *LINK*

Wiley Horne

Link to Kato/Kawai data, at Steve Elliott’s website:

http://planetuning.infillplane.com/html/review_of_cap_iron_study.html

Review is by Bill Tindall and Steve Elliott, with essential translation by Mia Iwasaki.

Wiley


From Steve Elliott’s website

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#19

Re: Summary of Kato/Kawai Studies

david weaver

Yep on steve's stuff. I remember reading it a couple of times previously and thinking that the amount of actual information that he has ...or for that amount, he never gets the credit he deserves.

I'm resisting looking through the site again now in the middle of these tests in order not to start anticipating results and substituting anticipating for observing.

But the cavity in front of the cap iron (my previous views of wear were without it) does have a "just like the real grown-ups show it" kind of feel to it.

Re: updated - v11 after 50 shavings

#20

Research

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When you are doing research and in the course of it confirm other's results it adds credibility to your new results. Given what you have confirmed of K&K's work it confirms that their work is relevant to conventional hand planing, and, I will have no reservation about the conclusions you arrive at when your arms give out or you run out of maple. :)