After 50 shavings....
david weaver
this is a base post to keep trak of the pitures of irons after 50 passes. This is 200 feet approximately on hard maple.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
After 50 shavings....
david weaver
this is a base post to keep trak of the pitures of irons after 50 passes. This is 200 feet approximately on hard maple.
v11
david weaver
Finish on the board is very bright, but there are two distint lines (kan you tell whih key is missing on this keyboard? my skope doesn't work with my new p-see, so i'm forsed to use a keyboard with no see and no ekkkkss key.
i will lokate the niks in the edge later tonight and find them on the skope. i took the piture of the edge first and then viewed the test board.
The test board was planed klean of any kontaminants before starting this test and will be stored vertikally so that it will not get any kontaminants settled on it.
Waay OT, fractals.
Mark Nowicki
Absolutely no relevance to your post.
Tropical resort seen from above;

Re: Waay OT, fractals.
david weaver
Looks close enough!
Could be a tool edge. I'm going to post some defect pictures shortly. They don't look a whole lot different.
Re: To a screeching halt for now..
david weaver
So, there are surface quality issues after 50 shavings with the V11, but being completely clear about it, I cannot be absolutely certain they're caused by wood, which means I need to refine my process, by (i've done these things already):
* scraping the surface of my paraffin wax bar (never know if it's taken on some particles or dirt as they do get dirty on the outside)
* checking the entire center of the iron with the microscope, as these defects are really small, a thousandth or two for the largest and probably a thousandth or less for others. I was hoping to avoid this because the scope field view is small and it takes a while to scroll across an inch of iron edge, but I think it's necessary.
* checking the surface of a board after the first pass. It should be shiny with no defect in the first foot or two
I suspect the v11 iron will do better than it has, and have given it two tries so far, but realize that I really need to view the entire iron to confirm that there aren't defects in it.
The relatively high level of sharpness also makes it even harder to hide any defects because of the surface brightness. I have always thought there is some argument for using a slightly less sharp medium with good uniformity (like an oilstone) to avoid seeing the smallest of defects. The overall brightness of a piece isn't much different, but I've been down this road before with japanese planes years ago - the higher the degree of sharpening, the more wet a surface looks right off of a plane and it can be torture as the slightest issue with anything at all creates visible lines on a piece.
pictures of the defects so far
david weaver
...after 50 passes, or about 200 feet of maple.
small defects
large defects (these are the biggest, leaving a nick that you can feel with a fingernail. Still something you wouldn't care about if you were scraping or sanding)

And then, there are spans that look like this:
I resharpened and got the same things after 50 more passes, so the test hasn't really started yet. I realize I need to confirm for certain under the scope that the entire edge looks like the sharpening pictures before starting.
It could be me and not the V11.
Sharpening is done with the charlesworth process because I still have my old jigs for that. Grind then 33 degrees with a 1200 grit diamond stone (Broken in), then 35 with 1 micron diamonds (thirty strokes) and heavy back bevel work with a steel ruler to make sure the diamonds get all the way to the edge.
If I can confirm that the edge is uniform when I restart the test and these defects occur again, I will continue on. I never finish planed with V11, so I don't know if this is typical or if it's me. This kind of thing is typical with A2 after not that many strokes, which I would refer to as a broken promise.
The promise is longer edge holding than carbon steel, but it's broken when you can finish a surface straight off of the plane.
I have never looked for opinions on maple, it's reasonably hard for wood from the united states, but it's very uniform and to my knowledge, not that hard on edges.
The wood that I'm using is straight grained, knot free and has been cleaned off and planed on the edge by another plane before this one to ensure that the surface is clear to start.
I had planned on making comments about edge defects only, but I realize that when I organize all of this stuff and post the results somewhere, I could be accused of bias. We all have bias. But I'm trying to make my bias in these tests toward the results being accurate, not what I think will happen.
Suppose some of these irons take defects..
david weaver
...like the ones in the photos, something I didn't expect. I'll run the test and let it run its course, which is to view wear, but also to find out when an iron won't stay reasonably in the cut, which is the last point where the average person should use a plane (going beyond that requires unnecessary down pressure and leads to tired users).
I'm going to run the test a second time to see if the defects that occur are consistent (specifically, that the level of them seems to stay relatively the same from iron to iron type), and then I'm going to try the irons that take defects more than others with various sharpening mediums to see if I can find something that pleases the steel
I don't want to resort to testing more steps with diamonds, etc, as that kind of goofiness leads to 4 or 5 step sharpening process that deter sharpening (when you have an edge defect in a finish plane, you start to care less about overall edge life and more about how quickly you can sharpen so that you can get rid of the defect to get a suitable finish).
Re: pictures of the defects so far
Wiley Horne
Hi David,
Just an offhand thought: the iron is either too sharp (for maple), or the wrong kind of sharp. I am guessing the latter.
Suggest regrind the V11 iron, eliminate the 1200g diamond plate, and go straight to the new suita stone. Strop on chromium green, and retest.
Now, you have eliminated diamonds. So, if you still have microchipping, retest on cherry to see whether the iron edge is just too sharp, or too thin for sugar maple.
But, if eliminating diamond cures the problem, then (a) you’ve taught us all something about diamond sharpening, and (b) you have a way forward.
My chief suspect: the 1200-grit fixed diamond really can raise hell with an edge that has been ground all the way back to new steel—would ‘t surprise me if the damage is more than skin deep. And remember, they rate that plate at 1200g, but you’re really dealing with a statistical distribution, and you have to wonder what is the mesh at two std. deviations above the 1200g?
2 cents.
Wiley
Exactly...
david weaver
...I'm accommodating the 3V with the diamonds, but I intend to follow up the irons that chip with diamonds by experimenting with gentler abrasives, first and then with adjusted honing methods. I don't get defects like this sharpening carbon steel on a washita, and polishing further with a hard arkansas when necessary.
I have seen similar with A2, though, with "normal" abrasives.
We are early on here. I can break out a synthetic waterstone and finish everything other than 3V on a sigma power 13000 after a natural stone -step up to that (something like an inexpensive "hard" arkansas that's not really as fine as a black or trans. Stones don't get much gentler than that).
I'm reluctant to use j-nats as a standard in this test because I think most people who buy them get stuck by people selling very blah-type modern stones at a high price.
I expected that the diamonds may actually be more rough with my over-hard O1 iron just because my experience with them (and why I don't use them regularly) is that you cannot use them on some japanese chisels or the edges will crumble either in use or as you're finishing the sharpening regime. One of those kiyotada parers that you sent me is very hard, and it taught me that even silicon carbide can cause that. If gentler abrasives are used and then the finish is a natural stone, the edge holds up well. If the primary bevel is ground to shape with a crystolon stone, the edge won't even make it through the sharpening process.
It's my belief in working with irons that the gentlest abrasive that works is the best choice. Speed in honing is based on proper steps and not fast stones, but I'm afraid that if I don't do diamonds for all of these and the 3V gets them and others don't, and then it outperforms, then I can't say that it isn't the diamonds that helped.
Brent beach used honing films, which is, I guess, a nice way to guarantee that you have a closely graded abrasive, but anyone doing any serious amount of woodworking will flee from them after they have to faff around with them and end up cutting one in the middle of sharpening, or dealing with the horrid feel of glass under a moulding plane iron or carving tool.
We'll get it all worked out. I'm not going to let any of the irons fail to defect and then not try to find a way that it will work without defect, or minimizing them. A good woodworker would take what they have and figure out how it works best. The initial control test will all be done on a same-regimen basis, though. V11, A2, 3V and the chinese iron should tolerate it better than my house made iron or the tsunesaburo iron (that iron is clearly harder than any of the others in this test, and it has the unfortunate pleasure of also getting the hottest when you grind it - even with a light hand - due to the mild steel lamination attached to the iron. Mild steel always generates a lot of heat on a power grinder, even with CBN. But none of my grinding is hot enough to affect temper, not even on that. Just uncomfortable to place the iron immediately into the palm of my hand and hold it there. Any tiny bits of edge remaining that may have gotten hot are honed off. All of these irons have a honed bevel after grind that is approximately 1mm long. then the fine diamond part is a fraction of that. One wouldn't go that far with an iron they were actually using, but I don't want anyone to suspect that there isn't adequate freshly honed iron supporting the edge vs. violently ground edges.
Re: pictures of the defects so far
Wiley Horne
Hi David,
Just an offhand thought: the iron is either too sharp (for maple), or the wrong kind of sharp. I am guessing the latter.
Suggest regrind the V11 iron, eliminate the 1200g diamond plate, and go straight to the new suita stone. Strop on chromium green, and retest.
Now, you have eliminated diamonds. So, if you still have microchipping, retest on cherry to see whether the iron edge is just too sharp, or too thin for sugar maple.
But, if eliminating diamond cures the problem, then (a) you’ve taught us all something about diamond sharpening, and (b) you have a way forward.
My chief suspect: the 1200-grit fixed diamond really can raise hell with an edge that has been ground all the way back to new steel—would ‘t surprise me if the damage is more than skin deep. And remember, they rate that plate at 1200g, but you’re really dealing with a statistical distribution, and you have to wonder what is the mesh at two std. deviations above the 1200g?
2 cents.
Wiley
Moderator, please delete—duplicate
Bevel prep?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
David, are you honing a full bevel, secondary micro bevel, or micro bevel on a hollow grind?
I would recommend a hollow grind to reduce the amount of steel to a minimum. This will enable some non-diamond media on 3V (such as Spyderco), as well as most media on PM-V11.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Bevel prep?
david weaver
Hollow grind high 20s in degrees (I do this freehand), followed by a secondary bevel in a guide at 33 degrees (larger than I'd normally make it - let's say, I hone it until it's "third hone" size for what you'd normally do, just to make sure there's support) and then 35 degrees for the final sharpening media.
I guess it shouldn't be a surprise that I have microscope pictures from this particular diamond plate, and they are pretty clear and uniform. At this level of magnification, the wire edge is gnarly.
The back of the iron is finished and then a back bevel applied with the 1 micron diamonds, again, to a point where it's bigger than I'd typically make it to ensure that the edge meeting front and back is free of defects. The back bevel ruler is about 1/2 mm thick.
I noticed the other day that I still have the original autocad pictures describing this method that a friend of mine provided when I first started woodworking. they are still on my wall. Talk about oblivious.
I never use this process in day to day honing, but it is cheap to apply (requiring only an eclipse type guide) and the average person who may question my results can go duplicate them.
It also removes me as the variable setting the angles, but allow me to tell you just how precise and repeatable my final bevels are by freehand method 
(actually, someone pushed me to measure this last year, and they are within about a degree of each other, but someone will suggest a one degree difference could tip the balance).
I never hone a full bevel other than japanese chisels, and even on those, I bias the last and finest part of the sharpening process to round the tiniest bit of the edge. why? because the edge holds up better that way, but there isn't much metal wedge created with that, so there's no additional perceived resistance and performance of the chisel isn't affected. These kinds of biases are hard to communicate, so they're out for this test.
The other important part of this...
david weaver
..I've used this method successfully before, for years. It is the one thing early on that I learned would limit the chipping that comes off of A2. In fact, it does reasonably well to limit the chipping on everything.
But I still get slightly better results freehanding the bevels and rounding the last bit slightly (this is one of the reasons that I prefer slow finish stones - that can quickly be overdone). I'll test that once I get past the initial iron tests.
I once heard DC and Rob Cosman referring to irons they'd seen in their classes being improperly sharpened all but 2 or 4 times in their career. I haven't found the honing guide method to be any better, but I'll need to prove it in a test. my habitual angle on the final rolled edge is around 33 degrees. I didn't gauge it early on, but any less, you get chipping, any more and you start to wonder if you have enough clearance.
Crystolon for 3v after grinding
Wiley Horne
Hi David,
That 1200g plate is really brash for an iron ground to virgin steel, even 3V. The flat that was on that iron when you received it was off very quick work with an 8000g plate. Now, silicon carbide will easily cut 3V, cause that’s what is on my Tormek, so you might try crystolon on all your alloy irons if you want to eliminate the 1200g plate. Or use Derek’s idea.
Easy for me to be a sidewalk superintendent, with you doing all the work
.
Wiley
Re: Crystolon for 3v after grinding
david weaver
We'll see how the CV holds up. Yes on the brashness, but the amount of bevel that exists on the steel due to the 1 micron diamond final bits is pretty significant. As in, if there is microfracturing at the very edge, most of it should be removed.
If I get through the first fifty passes with every iron on the diamonds and every one of them has huge lines of nick-evidence on the wood (that i'm not accustomed to seeing - little bits aren't uncommon, but things you can feel with a fingernail should generally be other than in rough or dirty planing).....then we'll need to re-evaluate a way to accommodate all of the irons by using something other than silicon carbide for the microbevel or grind (silicon carbide is too filthy, fracturing and contaminating for most people to keep control of. So, too, is anything other than final diamond size - as in, the plate is being used because my experience with loose diamonds in various sizes is that contamination is imminent. It may not make much of a difference in just planing to get to scraping, but under the microscope, it would be STARK.
I believe bill uses this method (something on the order of 15 or 10 micron diamonds to 1 micron without interim steps and has no issue. I have used it in the past on nasty irons.
The one issue with adding steps after grinding is that most people are going to be doing what I'm doing if they're dry grinding - they'll get to the edge or very near each time they grind with a pretty harsh wheel...mine is a partially worn 80 grit CBN wheel.
Time will tell with the others, but I think that this should work OK for any modern iron, definitely not with white steel, though it's possible the best of it might tolerate it, and I've ground carbon steel right to the edge many times in the past (on the CBN wheel) and had no issues. I think this diamond hone is probably less damaging than something like a shapton 1000, as it cuts quite a bit finer and slower, even though it's diamonds.
If a clean start shows no nicking with diamonds after I look at the whole edge, I think it's reasonable to figure that I did something else to cause the problem (dirt in wax, dirt on plane - the plane is being stored in a towel between tries to prevent sitting on something).
Re: I'll go to the other end of the spectrum ..
david weaver
..tonight. maybe. I bought a guitar today and will be in trouble when I get home.
But if I get to the shop, I'll try the new overhard O1 iron in this test and see what it does.
The O1 iron has seen rougher treatment than the V11 because I just made it, Normally an iron like this would never see diamonds at all, but in haste, the flat side of the iron always gets the hollow for me (same with chisels - the hollow side will be opposite the bevel side). This one was fairly hollow compared to others I made, so I blasted it with the 600 grit diamond hone, then ground it off square, reground the bevel and did the honing process here.
I expect it will be OK, but I don't have any reason to expect that. It's seen only abuse, and my coffee can forge, I feel like I have good control over the heat so that the tip doesn't get overheated, but that's only based on what I see. It could be quite spectacular if it fails, providing jackolantern teeth all over the place under the microscope. Its toughness would be better at 60 hardness, but that's not what I'm looking for here.
I have another iron that I made that's the same (Starrett) steel and closer to 60/61.
Re: The other important part of this...
Warren in Lancaster, PA
I once heard DC and Rob Cosman referring to irons they'd seen in their classes being improperly sharpened all but 2 or 4 times in their career
After reading this I watched Rob Cosman sharpen a plane iron on U Tube. He raised the iron up off the bevel to sharpen on a 1000 diamond stone. Then he raised it even more and sharpened on a 16000 Shapton. It was over 40 degrees plus the ruler trick. Pitiful.
There are some difficulties in planing hard maple, Acer saccharum. One is that some boards are very abusive to the edge. I guess that if you have a board that is reasonable to plane and use it for all tests, that is alright.
The other problem is that if the iron gets too dull it can act like it has lost its temper, like it generated heat from rubbing. Sometimes you have to sharpen quite a bit off to get to good steel again. Even harder woods don't seem to have this problem. We hardly ever see case pieces made of hard maple in 18th century work, even though it was available and used for table and chair legs. More often Soft Maple.
Diamond sharpening is not issue if done correctly
E Phillip Smith
I haven't sharpened with anything other than diamonds in well over a decade. Typically hollow grind primary bevel on high speed wheel (10" diameter, half inch wide coarse pink stone running at 1800 rpm) I can grind CPM 3V, CPM M4, V11 and regular carbon steel with no trouble. Very little heat in the steel with light passes.
Follow wheel with fixed diamond plate to bring clean edge, finish with 1 micron diamond on cast iron plate. Both fixed diamond and 1 micron diamond are done free hand.
I think I saw in one of the post you are using cherry support for 1 micron diamond. If so the cherry is soft and the diamond will bury in it and not cut nearly as effectively as diamond on cast iron. We tried several substrates when developing sharpening process, and we found nothing better than cast iron for diamond past.
Re: Diamond sharpening is not issue if done correc
david weaver
Yes on the cherry. It's not efficient, but I can plane it and it's clean. I don't have a cast plate, and have a surplus of diamonds, so that's OK.
It means wasting diamond charging too often vs. cast where you can charge rarely.
The other issue with cast is that when its new, it needs to break in before you can be certain that there won't be any mill marks or any other such issues that will raise a wire edge on a tool or leave marks.
None of those things really matter if you're just planing (I'd guess 99% of people using a plane sand or scrape or both before finishing anything) to get an initial surface, but I'm gauging two things in this test (edge life and edge quality) and will be tortured if the edge doesn't come out defect free off of sharpening.
Yes on the boards
david weaver
I have two boards that are reasonable to plane. I wonder if its uniformity causes it to overheat edges. I chose it because:
1) I don't use it for anything, but have it
2) it's relatively uniform, at least in the boards that I have, and it doesn't have the same variance in density that I seem to find in cherry
I'm intending to cut about 200 feet of shavings, then change the blade to another plane, and do that until I'm through with all of the blades, then start over for feet 200-400.
I am not rushing the plane through the work, but i am moving it briskly so that it's similar to the pace one would use planing. Years ago, you summarized it as "just not a very nice wood to work with hand tools". That's a short statement that pretty much nails it.
I made a couple of planes out of it before I had beech. It really turned me off compared to beech. For its hardness, it resists chisels and doesn't pare well, etc, whereas beech is very smooth.
If I complete round 1 here with the first 50 strokes (200 shavings) and everything looks terrible, I'm going to be forced to do something else. Change sharpening media or change wood. I've got a lot of 5/4 beech that's quartered so that the edge is flatsawn. It would be a good second option. I hate to waste it, but it wasn't dear to get (about $3 a board foot, and I'll probably never use it all).
FWIW, I did use hard maple when I tested A2 irons, and LN's went long on it without too much defect. I no longer have that iron, but a different one, so we'll see if it manages to do the same again. I gave up on the last iron at 1100 strokes on a 20 inch board. It was horrid to plane the last several strokes, but I didn't know enough at the time and was trying to get to the point that it was impossible to get shaving at all. The shavings were like suede. This time, I will shut it off when I have to help the plane stay in the cut, which is subjective, but not that inaccurate - combined with a final edge picture, it should be pretty usable.
Re: Diamond sharpening is not issue if done correc
E Phillip Smith
When I did this originally I had a machine shop make about a dozen cast iron plates. They were Blanchard ground flat. Mill marks were not a problem. If I were doing over I would buy Stanley no. 5 or larger plane cheap at flea market and use as cast iron substrate. Cherry is not a good substitute for cast iron. If I were going to put this much effort into testing I would find a cast iron substrate.
Re: Diamond sharpening is not issue if done correc
david weaver
We differ in that. cherry works fine. see updated results- the roughness of the grinder may have been at fault.
in my opinion, also, most of this stuff is a waste of time vs. a washita stone, so i'd prefer not to create some notion that people should go out and buy cast plates as a matter of productivity.
Re: Diamond sharpening is not issue if done correc
David Weaver
Not being dismissive for the sake of it, by the way. I'm pinning down a method and using it consistently across the variety of irons tested. I suspect there will be a lot of folks who want to see something done differently, but it would certainly be fine for them to run a similar test.