Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A couple more scope pictures before testing

Posts

A couple more scope pictures before testing

#1

A couple more scope pictures before testing

David Weaver

Commercial Photography

Just getting my routine ironed out for using the microscope and what magnification. I believe this is 150X actual, the second lowest setting on my scope the way it's set up. Up from this are 300x and 600x, and below it is 75 or 100 ,not sure.

Commercial Photography

The length of the edge shown is between .015" and .02" - the wire shown is a steel bristle from a grill brush and it is .007" in diameter, just shown for scale.

The interesting thing is how fine the edge is off of the japanese stone. I don't have many plane iron pictures to compare yet, but once this thing sees tiny diamonds, I believe the picture will change to a shiny surface with no or nearly no tiny grooves all in a row.

Bill has reiterated something I mentioned in a prior post, that there's nothing in this stone that should sharpen the vanadium carbides. What I may not have mentioned clearly enough in other pictures is that the play with the natural stone is just that - play, curiosity to see if I can get a reasonable edge with a natural stone before all of the tested edges see submicron synthetics. It's also important at this point to get the edge reasonably fine before going to them so there aren't any hidden defects from harsh abrasives straight to fine.

This iron has one very bad habit on my setup (I like to raise the initial burr with a fine india. This iron actually pins the fine india, and then the pinning beats up the edge in tiny amounts. This just means subsequent sharpenings will be done only with diamonds to avoid anything of the sort. Kind of a downer as the reason I like the fine india to cut the initial bevel is that mine is settled in well, and it's in an oil bath, which means as it rotates, i never have to do anything to clean it. Anything on it just spills into the bottom of a norton IM 313.

Still, I did not expect edge quality as good as this off of a natural stone given the reputation of this steel.

(I also sharpened the V11 iron on the natural stone - it sharpens at least twice as quickly on it).

Re: A couple more scope pictures before testing

#2

Re: That edge is sharp, but...

David Weaver

...surface quality on very thin shavings suffers a little bit. You can see tiny lines even when the sharpness his high enough to get a shaving half a thousandth thick.

Those lines don't show up on a carbon steel iron for obvious reasons.

I have no idea what size the particles are before heat treatment (3 microns, 5 microns?). If they're around that, they'd be 1 to 2 ten thousandths of an inch.

I don't think we'd see them. So I'm not sure what we're seeing on those irons. Separate post with diamond pictures - which as suspected creates tiny uniform scratches.

Re: A couple more scope pictures before testing

#3

Re: Same iron with diamonds..

David Weaver

..and two others. The 3v on 1 micron diamonds (I can't find my submicron diamond vials, but it doesn't really matter. 1 on wood is finer cutting than one on a metal substrate would be. Diamond sharpening is done with a piece of cherry.

I dragged out my old setup from when I used to use eclipse type guides. Two angle guides and a stainless rule.

Sharpening for the penultimate bevel is with a 1200 grit (but worn out) eze lap diamond hone.

First the 3V (you'll notice these all look remarkably similar..of course).

Commercial Photography

tsune blue steel.

Commercial Photography

V11

Commercial Photography

There are three others that I will be testing, too - A2 Lie Nielsen, chinese HSS and either a hock high carbon steel iron or one that I just made out of starrett steel that is on the hard side. Not sure which. My high carbon steel iron is cambered severely to be used as a jack in a record 5 1/2 (eons ago).

This sharpening method is a bit faffy. There are consumables involve (I hate that) and I have to protect the piece of wood with diamonds on it like it's made of gold and make sure no particles settle on it.

I have used WD40 as the lubricant with the diamonds so that the irons can't oxidize before I get to use them. The dewpoint has been in the mid 70s the last two weeks and the temperature in my shop is about 80 most of the time in the summer, unless there is a cool snap.

Re: A couple more scope pictures before testing

#4

WD40 smudge

david weaver

Noticed in the picture that the tsune iron looks a little different than the other two.

That's just tiny particles of WD 40.

It's interesting that any oil or anything at all on an iron will show up on the scope as a huge amount. This is the amount of WD40 on an iron after it's been wiped off with a rag or jeans, etc. I'm guessing that it's still there because that's the amount that's left on your jeans after you wipe oil off of the iron. Not a groundbreaking thought, but interesting that when we think about wiping oil off, we're really sharing it between iron and rag, and whatever is on the rag and iron will go back and forth.

the other two irons that are clean are double wiped off...once on jeans or rag, and then again on tshirt before taking microscope picture.

The tsunesaburo iron is clearly harder by a mile vs. the other two. Diamonds don't really care about anything except they do penetrate slightly less deep in harder steel (natural stones certainly do this, making the finest edge on low carbide steel when the hardness is approaching the max a stone can handle).

Even with 1 micron diamonds, the edge is exceptionally fine and whether or not the penetration is slightly less deep on one iron vs. another is meaningless. I think the reality of an edge like this is that chasing finer with honing films and other things meant really for pigments (and some have been adapted to razors) is really pointless, especially if it either adds steps or increases the chance that an edge is unfinished.

I used to use diamonds eons ago and used a 0.25 or 0.5 micron powder. I have (in theory, if I could find them) those in vials still, as well as 0.1 micron. Discretion in actually working wood over the years tends toward making sure the edge is finished without too many steps vs. trying to get edges finer than that in these pictures.

Since the pictures are not three dimensional, what we're actually looking for when we take a picture like this is no three dimensional aspect to the edge where it disappears, and that the disappearance is nearly a straight line, or as close as possible. Scratches that terminate away from the edge are relatively meaningless. The tiny scratches right at the edge are probably from the bias of pressure there (they are the 1 micron diamond scratches) as well as some spring back from a honing substrate.

Still, this is a very "precious" feeling method. You have to keep everything clean, and i can understand why people using it would chase an iron that promises long edge holding vs. one that's easy to refresh. That fact probably won't be conveyed in simple wear tests.

It'll be interesting to see surface quality as these irons wear, though. I suspect the blue steel iron will wear a little faster, but leave a better surface and stop cutting reasonably at a higher level of wear.

I don't think brent beach took irons to the point that they were no longer producing an acceptable result (can't remember), but I am going to do that.

Re: A couple more scope pictures before testing

#5

Diamond scratch depth

Wiley Horne

Hi David and all,

On the 3V iron, it appears to me that the prominent diagonal diamond scratches, each terminate in a ‘low place’—an incised place—at the edge. I can’t make out whether this also happens on the Tsunesaburo and V11 irons. So it may be, at least on the 3V iron, that the diamond is ploughing a furrow which carries away a piece of edge where it daylights.

If so, what is the relationship between the depth of scratch on the bevel, and the depth of incision at the edge? Ordinary geometry would say that,

Incised depth= furrow depth/tan(included angle). Or, for 33 degrees.

=furrow depth/0.65.

Well, this is pretty fanciful, but suggests at least a possibility that the effect at the edge is greater than the furrow depth itself. Meaning the diamond is creating toothiness at the edge, which may be greater than intuition would suggest.

So what? Well, what I wonder is: In a duration test, if two irons differed only in their toothiness, which edge would last the longest? Would the toothy iron, or the more ‘compact’ iron last longer. My guess would be that the more compact edge would outlast the toothy edge, because each grain of the compact edge has more support on either side (and above and below) than the toothy edge. The toothy edge is more vulnerable to attack, and would unravel faster.

But maybe it ain’t so. Maybe the toothy edge puts up a better fight against the wood fibers.

Your photographs add a lot! I’ll be curious to see how the more deeply scratched edges do versus the more compact edges.

Wiley

Re: A couple more scope pictures before testing

#6

Re: Diamond scratch depth

david weaver

Wiley, I think all of your comments are right (I didn't check your math, but the precise number isn't important, the sentiment about removing a depth of metal against an acute angle below is correct).

As far as toothiness, that's precisely what's going on. The diamonds create tooth - even when they're a tenth micron, they create tooth. I suspect that either this toothiness or the loss of it and the slight rounding that results creates the very transient sharpness feel that diamonds have. The transient feel is, i'm fairly sure, responsible for the errant assumption that too fine of an edge doesn't hold. of course, there is a transient feel, but the absolute (nominal if you could measure it) sharpness after it's gone is still at least as good or better than a less well finished edge. Certain things favor this edge chasing more:

* harder irons that also don't chip

* harder wood that takes better clearance to be cut properly, and also is more of a challenge to the edge

* tiny shavings that only get removed from a surface well if the edge is reasonably thin and also has excellent clearance

These little teeth also punish people when shaving, so even something like a 0.25 micron diamond is often followed with 0.5 micron chromium oxide pigment.

The real question for woodworking is when do the grooves get big enough to have a material acceleration on edge failure, and the answer, I'm sure, includes a whole list of factors:

* how thin of a shaving

* how long does sharpening take

* how often is it acceptable to redo it

* at what point do the tiny lines actually show up on the surface of something (and is it OK if they do - plane, scrap, sand routine isn't going to care about tiny little lines showing the exact path of the plane)

I think the 1 micron diamond size is a very good compromise in terms of fineness and edge life vs. speed, and I don't think any of the tiny scratches in the microscope picture are going to be showing up on a planed surface.

Re: A couple more scope pictures before testing

#7

An additional considerstion

Jim Matthews

* Buy in cost for sharpening medium.

Uppa heya in Miller's Falls country, oil stones are plentiful - and affordable.

Rarely will even manufactured water stones come up for sale, unless there's a restaurant supplier offering clearance.

Clapped out, thrashed and warped diamond plates sell for stupid money.

There's a gig in this, for a "Steel sommolier" to pair a given blade with an appropriately priced sharpening set.

Re: A couple more scope pictures before testing

#8

Re: Following with interest

Jonathan Elliott

David,

Thanks for all your work on this, I don't have much to add but really like following this experiment and find the pictures and discussion very interesting.

Thanks everyone else for your added thoughts and experience as well!

Re: A couple more scope pictures before testing

#9

Re: An additional considerstion

david weaver

I could probably be "that guy" recommending stones. One of the reasons I sold japanese natural stones was to try to take a bite out of people selling $60 stones for $250 on ebay and etsy.

I got to look at a lot of stones but didn't actually make a profit on them (that wasn't the point, the point was to get graded stones out to users and try to get rid of some of the mystique).

So, I wouldn't be that good of a candidate to be "that guy".

Oilstones and simple steel are still the most productive thing for me (in terms of total time spent). The IM313 (I have no expensive stones in mine) and a decent finisher outside of it would be the last thing I'd give up if I came upon hard times.

Re: A couple more scope pictures before testing

#10

Last three irons

david weaver

Chinese HSS - the not so secret green iron:

Commercial Photography

House O1 (I'm too lazy to reprofile the hock HCS, but I may do a second group of irons as I have more types than just these six). This iron needs a little bit more refinement. I flattened it on a diamond hone that doesn't seem to be as flat as I'd like. This iron is tempered at 380 degrees, so it's on the hard side compared to most O1.


And last, but not least, LN A2:

[url=https://imgur.com/QcNMgoW][/url]

Re: A couple more scope pictures before testing

#11

Tiny scratches on some but not others

david weaver

I figured out why some of the irons appear to have tiny scratches at the very edge (in line with iron length) and others don't. That's actually based on the focus of the microscope. All of the irons have scratches at the very edge like that, but the focus can be set to the surface of the iron instead of slightly lower. That's probably the biggest challenge in all of this - getting consistent pictures.

Each iron reflects a little big differently and the scope software tries to compensate changing brightness and contrast. The result is different light/dark in pictures.

that's not a material nuisance, though. What we see in wear should be a lot more significant and viewable regardless of color.

Testing starts this weekend at the latest. I'm not going do do it in a rush for several reasons:

1) handling the irons - sounds stupid, but with six irons, you have to be ultra careful to not allow any edge to get touched in handling. I lay them on top of each other in two piles staggered so that nothing can touch their edges.

2) avoiding other issues of failure that are unintentional - like making sure the board edges are all clean

3) stopping and taking pictures (goes back to handling the iron) of the edges. It would be easy to bang an edge on something while moving it around on the scope. I'm also a horribly disorganized person, and if I try to do the test in a rush, I'll probably end up losing track of something.

I'm debating weighing the shavings that come off of each test round. I shoot for uniformity in shaving depth, but that is a constant adjustment while planing. As clearance starts to go with use, the depth needs to be advanced. I'm not sure if high humidity days would affect the accuracy of weighing the shavings, though. I think it'll all even out in the end, and may not post shaving weight data, but one of the irons will be using a separate plane vs. the others, possibly two.

Re: A couple more scope pictures before testing

#12

The point where scratches don't show up..

david weaver

Since I realized that the 1 micron scratches will show at the edge of all of these pictures if that is where the depth of focus is set, I wondered at what point I wouldn't see scratches at all in a microscope that relies on light. Since this is a metallurgical scope, it has a top light only and relies on reflection.

It looks like the answer regarding the wavelength of light is that purple is somewhere around 0.38 micron in wavelength and around double that for red.

So we should expect that if the 1 micron diamonds get a decent bite at the end of the iron, they will leave visible grooves. Whether a finer grade of diamonds does or doesn't will depend on contaminants and grading of the diamonds. No edge looks completely scratch free under the microscope.

I have stropped razors fairly hard on chrome oxide (graded) previously, and that does leave an almost perfectly smooth surface when it's fresh, but instead of seeing something that looks like a mirror pane, then you can see any contours left over from prior honing - even if they're tiny contours. It's like someone took a picture of a razor with scratches on it and then smudged the picture.