Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

found stones... ping David Weaver

Posts

found stones... ping David Weaver

#1

found stones... ping David Weaver

bridger berdel

I live in a place with varied geology and some good hiking trails. A few times I've picked up rocks thinking that they would make a good finishing hone. A few have, most not so much. The latest batch seem like a pretty good bet. I've sliced up a couple of chunks on the tile saw. The next step is to lap a flat face to 600 grit or so and see just what it is that I've got here. David, I know you have a good microscope and a fairly in depth knowledge and feel for natural finishers. If you're willing I'd like to send you a lapped bit of what I have, for you to play with. I'm not going to try to make any kind of commercial endeavor of this as I don't have available material at scale. Mostly I'm trying to satisfy my own curiousity but I guess I have a bit of desire to encourage others to play with found rocks.

Just what you need, anther rabbit hole, eh?

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

#2

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

Jim Matthews

You found them in a rabbit hole?

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

#3

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

David Weaver

Sure, I'd take a look at one and see how it does against other natural finishers on a razor. I can't remember if you're also a shaver and use stones like this on a razor?

From time to time when I'd read the razor boards, someone would find a nice section of rock and cut it into hones, but when they would start sending rocks around, I wouldn't accept any pieces

Almost without question, they wanted to sell it

Shortly after and use whatever people said to push the stones. Since you're not doing that, no problem. I can grade it against finishers that I have.

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

#4

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

bridger berdel

I think i can get about 6 or 8 stones of varying sizes and shapes from the bits i have on hand. If anyone else wants to play i'd be happy to accomodate

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

#5

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

bridger berdel

Cut some up and lapped them roughly to 400.


img

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

#6

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver 


img

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

#7

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

bridger berdel

The rough material


img

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

#8

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

bridger berdel

The first 5 or 6 people to reply I'll send a pece to. No obligation but I'd appreciate it if you'd spend a lttle time using it and post feedback. Keep the stone, pass it on, whatever.

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

#9

looks like agate

David Weaver

I've got a couple of chinese agate stones and would say that agate's behavior is a slow burnisher once a stone is broken in, and a slurry that has a brash but quickly softer feel and settles down faster than most anything else.

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

#10

Re: looks like agate

bridger berdel

I think it's quartzite. That behavior sounds likely.

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

#11

Re: looks like agate

John in NM

Maybe quartzite. Grain looks a bit wrong, but judging from a picture is a fools errand -- and I was always better with igneous rocks and ore minerals than sedimentary rocks and their metamorphic products.

Doesn't look like an agate to me. The grain looks macrocrystaline, like a marble, though I doubt it's one because a carbonate stone wouldn't trick you into rubbing a blade on it, they are softer than the blade.

Armchair petrography at its best! :D

Cool that you're messing with found stones too. You never know what kinds of useful stuff is lying around until you start experimenting.

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

#12

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

John in NM

Those look like quartz vein material. Bull quartz is what I used to hear it called. Depending on where you are you might see veins a few feet wide. Kinda dull stuff to the geologist, but might make a decent finish stone.

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

#13

Re: looks like agate

Bridger Berdel

It's not marble for sure. It's definitely silica, and definitely well bonded together. Probably a bit too well bonded to release much, so at best a polishing stone. Once it's broken in I'd expect more burnish than abrasion. lapped at 400 grit it generates a little bit of black from the steel but that may disappear as it gets smoother.

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

#14

Re: looks like agate

Bridger Berdel

these came from an old mountain that seems to be uplifted granite. there are bands of this stuff here and there on it generally a foot or two wide. I have found garnets in the granite as well as the talus. My hope was that because of the age and decayed nature of the granite that the more dense quartzite materials might be a bit less tightly bound. they may, but it seems not enough to release particles under steel. some use will tell the tale a bit better, I guess.

Re: found stones... ping David Weaver

#15

Re: looks like agate

John in NM

Yeah, I wrote the comment above before looking at the picture of the rough material further down. That is definitely vein material, and what you tell me about the host rock confirms it - you'd never find a quartzite cutting across a granite.

That type of quartz vein is extremely common in granitic rocks, and what you say about the texture of it is consistent with vein quartz that crystalized from hydrothermal fluids.

Should make an excellent polish or burnishing stone.