Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

The Pocket Fisherman of Planes

Posts

The Pocket Fisherman of Planes

#1

The Pocket Fisherman of Planes

david weaver

https://www.finewoodworking.com/2019/06/26/tool-news-bridge-city-tool-works-introduces-two-new-hand-planes

The handle design baffles me. Experimenting with a few quickly shows why the stanley/english woody type handle has a pretty consistent angle and the hump. No great reason to deviate from that, and quite a bit of risk in doing so (my first two low angle planes hit the road precisely because they made my wrist hurt -i understand the high bench thing, but it really doesn't work that well with serious planing or it would've been the standard when people did serious planing).

There was a fellow in ohio (near me) a couple of years ago who had two of everything B/C had ever made. Some of the more traditional tools (simple squares and layout tools) look quite nice, but I've never been tempted to buy anything. At any rate, the fellow died. At least one of each design was untouched , in some cases the second tool had been used. His wife was left with all of his tools, and they ultimately ended up in the hands of a dealer. I'd hate to know what kind of bath he took on buying those tools and then not having any way to sell them directly.

All that said, the new owner says he's going to bring back some legacy designs. If that includes some of the more standard layout type tools, that could be quite nice. Maybe not the least expensive option, but some of the tools like centerscribes would be useful to me (I'm aware that single size versions are really easy and cheap to make).

Strange thing about E's designs is that once in a while something more traditional comes out (like little infills) at a really reasonable price for what it is, and then it's followed up by something from star wars.

Re: The Pocket Fisherman of Planes

#2

Re: The Pocket Fisherman of Planes

bridger berdel

Personally i find his design sense to be bafflingly bad. But then I've never had any in hand, much less tried to use them.

Re: The Pocket Fisherman of Planes

#3

Re: The Pocket Fisherman of Planes

David Weaver

Much of it is pretty horrid, and it seems like there is nothing wood and brass now. With cites rules, that probably won't change until cites comes through with relaxing their rules on small items, or not at all now that the manufacturer specializes in anodized aluminum stuff.

Some of the ad copy is baffling. Like advertising saving you money by offering one block plane that's far more expensive than two.

Re: The Pocket Fisherman of Planes

#4

Re: The Pocket Fisherman of Planes

Jim Matthews

"Bridge City" is in China.

https://www.woodworkingnetwork.com/news/woodworking-industry-news/bridge-city-tool-works-sold-chinese-manufacturer

Re: The Pocket Fisherman of Planes

#5

Re: The Pocket Fisherman of Planes

david weaver

Yes. I got the sense that perhaps a lot of the stuff has actually been made in china for a while (since the chopstick maker and maybe other things were). EDIT - just reading the website sort of suggests that, but doesn't provide a date - that harvey industries has been a or the licensed manufacturer for Bridge City tools for some time.

I think if folks thought there was a pack of $30 an hour employees roaming around california making Bridge City tools - I just don't know how a low volume business could afford that.

The interesting comment on the web page from the current owner is that some legacy tools will come back, but which ones? If they came back at a reduced price, the new owner might be able to make a go at offering a few of the useful tools continuously, but I doubt there will be a reduction in price - just my sense, because business portfolios don't usually transfer at zero cost, and at least in the US, paying off a loan for ownership (or justifying cash flow attached if the business was bought for cash or equity) is generally an after tax venture, making repayment yucky.

Re: The Pocket Fisherman of Planes

#6

I was wrong about the lower prices...

david weaver

..people not in the US or UK can apparently get a lot of the BCTW tools at lower prices. Some due to currency conversion, but some just at lower prices.

That's pretty annoying.

Re: The Pocket Fisherman of Planes

#7

Re: I was wrong about the lower prices...

Jim Matthews

The entire BCT concept is annoying.

Re: The Pocket Fisherman of Planes

#8

Re: I was wrong about the lower prices...

Wiley Horne

Just like medicine!

Wiley

Re: The Pocket Fisherman of Planes

#9

Re: I was wrong about the lower prices...

david weaver

I can't disagree, but John E reminds me of some of my self-made relatives, so I kind of understand the way he thinks and writes. All the way down to the quotes that he uses in his blog posts even when they're "not really needed".

My relatives in that situation have been chief in charge of every part of their businesses for 30 years, and have done well. John's opinion of himself as the foremost tool designer is, well, my relatives would say the same thing about themselves in their areas because in their view, they've "just done it better than anyone else could or would".

Sort of an M.O. and confidence that isn't always great, but it's kind of a throw back to a bygone era, and focus on the potential rather than indecision about whether or not something is good...it does allow for continued progress. The progress just isn't my taste.

If you could separate someone like George Wilson from his drive to continue to make things, and get his design sense and practical experience with hand tools, you could probably come up with some really attractive tools. Would they be more functional than Leonard Bailey's design? Probably not - nobody has really bettered that, but they'd be really easy on the eyes.

Re: The Pocket Fisherman of Planes

#10

I was thinking the exact same thing!!