Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

The V11 Iron has Arrived...

Posts

The V11 Iron has Arrived...

#1

The V11 Iron has Arrived...

david weaver

...nothing special in terms of that, I realize that probably thousands of these have arrived, and this is now my fourth one.

But the other three are gone because the planes they came in are gone.

I'll use the new one a little bit before beginning testing irons for two reasons:

1) to confirm that it's in order (I seriously doubt this is necessary at all, but #2 is more important)

2) to get the iron used a reasonable amount so that I'm comparing irons in like shape

Eons ago, I bought a bunch of hard maple from a clearance pallet at rockler. Never figured out what to do with it, but it will work well for this test because the wood is uniform, already pre thicknessed to the same thickness and I'll never use it otherwise. It's also four feet long, which should help vs. the last time I tested an iron (wood < 2 feet long - LN's iron finally failed around 1100 strokes. Not looking to duplicate numbers like that).

The test lineup looks like:

* LV V11

* LN A2

* Hock HCS

* China (green if you ever look at things on ali express) HSS iron

* Tsunesaburo blue steel

Wiley, I don't want to separate you from a fine iron if it's something you like to use (the 3V), plus it's not commercially available (not sure if a good test result would encourage someone to make one, but I also don't trust most folks to make something commercially and use the same level of care that Steve did).

If you want to see how it fares, though, I'd be glad to test it. It could be a couple of months before it comes back, depending on how the first round goes and whether or not repeat iterations are needed. It may be nice (even though labor intensive) to do all of the tests twice, and alternating irons every 50 or 100 strokes (to minimize variability that might occur with boards) and taking pictures of their conditions in the microscope will slow things down considerably.

Re: The V11 Iron has Arrived...

#2

Re: side comment...

david weaver

The finish level of the LV irons as they arrive is really a treat. Regardless of how the test turns out.

I kind of like working an iron into flat because I've devised a good setup for it and it facilitates removal of some of the surface material, but I'm sure it's not necessary for performance (or almost sure) and in this case, for flatness, there's absolutely nothing to do.

The last LN plane that I got a couple of years ago (the only one that I have), they have stepped up their efforts at LN a little bit and the iron appeared to be hand lapped at the edge.

Sort of a novelty to me, but probably beneficial in both cases to a brand new beginner who has a set of sharpening stones and no clue what flattening is.

Re: The V11 Iron has Arrived...

#3

Re: The V11 Iron has Arrived...

Wiley Horne

Hi David and all,

I will send the Elliott 3V iron early this coming week. Keep it as long as needed. My recall is that the standard or default heat treat involved tempering to Rc59, but Bill T., Phil, and Steve decided to have Paul Bos temper to Rc61, which I believe was top of the recommended range. Perhaps Steve can clarify if I have this wrong.

I do have one question. You are testing and comparing all these different steels. At 33 degrees bevel. What will be the honing treatment? When Steve did his testing, he eventually settled on finishing all the irons with 1/4 u diamond paste, then did an initial sharpness test, before the test planing commenced. Will you give each iron what you judge to be the optimal stone choice for that particular steel? Or give them all the same final honing? Or something else entirely?

Wiley

Re: The V11 Iron has Arrived...

#4

Re: The V11 Iron has Arrived...

david weaver

Hi, Wiley - thanks for your generosity in providing the iron to test. I will be sharpening each iron on a finish regimen of the Sigma power 13k and checking them under the scope for sharpness. My scope goes up to 600x, but things are unintelligible at that level of magnification, so I'll probably be using a true 100-150 both to examine edge condition and note wear.

If any of the irons aren't properly finished with that stone, then I'll adjust. If it has to be submicron diamonds then I'll do whatever is needed.

A separate test later might be interesting for some of the natural stones - I do believe that the standard set by a guide and submicron diamonds is hard to surpass in a fine shaving test like this (maybe not possible) - in my experience, diamonds are harsh on some edges (usually high temper HCS), but at such small finishing levels, I've not seen anything untoward on plane irons.

The faffing (and in a working ship, the need to protect surfaces from contamination, or want to sharpen carving tools and other profiled stuff) keeps me from using something like diamonds all the time, but I have them. I'll probably go back after all is said and done to using self-made O1 irons, maybe the cheap green HSS iron from china and vintage stuff on oilstones. I've learned to accommodate the more plain stuff by not taking so many thin shavings. But not to accommodate the irons so much as to accommodate myself (less effort to save the thin stuff for just the last little bits of work).

I may do a test of my big/little smoothing routine with an older stock iron vs. the gold standard of a sharp high durability iron and thin shavings.

In the thin shavings test, it'll be interesting to see how the V11 compares to 3V.

It's interesting that Steve found favor (he mentioned so elsewhere) in driving the hardness spec up. What I've found is the same with good irons - the specs are necessary with knives that need to have edge toughness, but we don't test it too much with planes in good wood. The 1095 and O1 irons that I'm going to put together on the side are just a side show, but this testing beyond the initial wear test doesn't need to all be done this year -I'd like to get the wear testing done to get something on the map for V11 in wood in the next couple of months. I'm agnostic about how it should end, and it could very well end up promoting V11, but that's not my intent.

The rest of the stuff can be added little by little. Steve has probably done quite a bit of it, but if I want to compare other things, I have to do all of the data with my own setup and try to compare apples to apples.

i have some other things to build for the house now, and it would be lovely if I could incorporate this testing with that, but I just don't think there's a practical way, too, so one will give a break from the other, and somewhere fiddling with making chisels now (which I didn't think I'd do as near ago as last week) is something that can just sit around until I feel like holding steel against a grinder wheel and doing nothing else.

I could be criticized for not building furniture, but I have to be honest, at this point, I don't really feel like doing it. I'd rather build tools and guitars and hold off the mrs for a while in the two pieces she wants built.

Re: The V11 Iron has Arrived...

#5

Re: The V11 Iron has Arrived...

Wiley Horne

David,

I just shipped the iron. It’ll get there next Friday according to UPS.

The Sigma 13K won’t touch it. I’ve tried. Before shipping, I ground it on Tormek to a primary burr. Absolutely new steel. Even then the Sigma would not put the tiniest flat on it. So I put an edge on it with the DMT 8000g, gave it a couple of licks on 1/2-micron green (the one that’s graded to 1/2 micron). Then it slid through the edge of a page of NYT like it didn’t see it. Then I wrapped and shipped.

Only diamond cuts this steel, and chromium green will refine it. M

Have fun!

Wiley

Re: The V11 Iron has Arrived...

#6

Re: The V11 Iron has Arrived...

david weaver

CBN grind and diamond it is, then. The others will be able to accommodate. I've got more diamond than I know what to do with.

I see that there's about 2.75% vanadium in that stuff, I guess that's the rub (or lack of ability to rub?).

It'll give me a chance to test something that I found with that fallknaven knife. It just resisted everything, but it gave itself away like it was nothing on the medium crystolon. Everything that I have has done that so far, even the PM M4 japanese chisel. Too bad it doesn't stay flat. Testing grind and edge finish will be CBN for all and identical, though, all the way down to the size of the flat that works its way into the hollow.

Re: The V11 Iron has Arrived...

#7

Re: The V11 Iron has Arrived...

Steve Elliott

The blade Wiley is sending is at Rc 61. When I made my first 3V blade I used that heat treatment and got good performance. A few years later I tried Rc 59 to see what the difference would be and liked it less. I think it wore more quickly and formed more of a wire edge when being honed, but it's been so long I can't remember for sure.

My hat is off to David for taking on this kind of testing--it's a lot of work and often people will find fault with the test if they don't like the results.

With respect to Wiley's question about how the final honing will be done on the different alloys, I would guess that as long as a sharp edge is achieved on each blade the results of the test will be valid regardless of whether the same honing media were used on the blades or not. If a test is meant to find the greatest initial sharpness of different alloys that would be affected by the honing media. For a test of edge durability as long as the edge preparation doesn't include large jumps in grit size that would leave subsurface damage to the steel the honing media don't matter.

Re: The V11 Iron has Arrived...

#8

Re: The V11 Iron has Arrived...

E Phillip Smith

Once you move to the particle steels it's amazing how many feet of shavings they can produce. Testing can take a while when you have several irons.

Re: The V11 Iron has Arrived...

#9

Re: The V11 Iron has Arrived...

David Weaver

That was very insightful at the time to go with extra hardness. I don't know that much about all of the steels (more than the average person, but not like a knife maker would - I know what the alloying elements do in razors, because most of them were tried at some point - either professionally (especially tungsten, but also chromium and nickel) - or by amateur knife makers (vanadium - not good in a razor no matter what the particle size).

At any rate, I saw a spec sheet for 3V that showed toughness dropped by about 40 percent from 59 to 61, but we're not pushing toughness on a plane iron, we're pushing probably a combination of adhesive and abrasive wear. The gain in those two points for adhesive wear is 20-25%, and I wouldn't be surprised if you got that or a little more in edge life from 59 to 61.

either along side this test or separate from it, I'm going to make a couple of O1 irons from the same stock (I made another one last night) and see how they hold up at different tempering temperatures (which should be a good proxy for hardness - I use settled-in oilstones most of the time, and that gives a very god indication of hardness in a very narrow range until or unless stuff like vanadium shows up in steel. Even if it does, if the hardness isn't high, the oilstones will waste it away).

I expect that at least two iterations of each iron will be necessary, and before I start, I'm going to take the two that are little used (blue steel and the V11) and use them a fair amount to make sure I'm in the sweet spot of the irons.

If something comes out funny with a commercial iron, I will buy another one and test it again as a comparison to the original. I don't expect that to happen, though.