Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

Posts

A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#1

A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

david weaver

..last year, or maybe two years ago, I asked if files were high carbon steel all the way through or if they were case hardened.

I got various answers when I asked that question. Since then, I've made about 10 knives that I call squash knives out of files (heat a used file, squash it with a hammer, refine the profile with a grinder, files or belt grinder and then quench, temper and sharpen).

These turn out to be dandy little knives. whatever they are, if you treat them as you would O1, they hold up really well to things you'd use a small knife for (marking, cutting up boxes, etc). I have a distaste for utility knives because they're bulky and the blades are often soft, even modern ones.

These squash knives have taken over everything I do in the garage (cutting down cardboard boxes, etc, cutting package labels out of printed paper, whatever - and marking, of course) because the blades are thin and small and you can wrap the rest of the handle if you need a better hold, but they just slip through everything because of the blade profile.

I sharpen them with a gray deburring wheel and then a hard buff, and then once in a great while, take them to a norton IM 313 (the best knife profiling device in the world) and restore the edge to straight of it's getting a little out of whack).

Not a single one has exhibited behavior that is untoward (low carbon or any other kind of flaw), and i have no clue why that is because I don't know what they are other than that it's clear they're enough high carbon steel and little enough alloy that they work really well.

I've since smashed and ground some larger files into double hollow knives to keep the profile thin, and they also work a treat, but anything larger than small, high carbon and hammering into shape is heavy work.

Yesterday, I was off center (following up vacation and a busy work week and a bunch of chores, just out of gas) and didn't feel like starting anything gainful that required too much thinking, so I made three of them (think equivalent type project to turners saying they turn pens when they're feeling a little uninspired because you can just turn a couple and be done with it). It takes about an hour for me to make, grind, and treat three.

What i noticed was one of these was with the width waste off of shootenstein's iron stock (presco O1, fantastic stuff), and to my surprise, very light straw O1 steel at high hardness still likes to hold a little bit of wire edge. If I can find some large triangular vintage files, I'm inclined at this point to think again about making chisels - hammer down the apex, grind the back annealed, reharden and then grind out a profile.

I expected that the first couple of these would be marginal or unusable, but due to their lack of conviction with the wire edge, and lack of deflection in use cutting up boxes, etc (the heavier file knife is fine to profile wood), they're a treat to use and the O1 knife comes in second.

Seemingly heresy to us because O1 is often the plainest steel offered now at high hardness, but I had the same experience with razors - honing for someone who was a good customer of mine when I was selling japanese natural stones. He'd bought some new Hart razors and I just didn't find them very nice to hone. They're O1, and spec hardness, but they want to hold on to just a little bit of a wire edge, and at 18 or so degrees of total bevel angle, that is a toxic habit. When it comes off, they're damaged.

As far as chisels go, I've given up figuring out how to make an integral bolster, so I think I'm going to make a tapered tang and file a tapered hole into a bolster to fit and heat it and just tap it into place as far as it will go.

I am also tempted at this point to locate good quality 1095 and see what it will do when it's only lightly tempered. We don't usually see 1095 that hard - it's in pocket knives or something else where it will hold a wire edge just because of it's lower spec hardness, but the way the smash knives hold no wire edge and then get no deflection in use is....well, something I've only seen in japanese knives.

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#2

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

Frank D. in Montreal

Thanks for the post,

Very inspiring and interesting. A couple questions (including dumb ones):

How thick are the blades after you forge them?

When you say deflection, is this the same thing as flex?

What kind of files do you use? Just curious...

If you're happy with the results, why would you look for vintage triangular files to make chisels instead of using the same brand as the smash knives? Is there something about the knives that would not translate into good chisels?

For the bolsters, a tapered tang and fitted hole seems good, but isn't most of the strength going to come from the shoulders resting on the bolster? Seems to me that this would be the place to invest time to get a good fit.

TIA

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#3

Mostly Nicholson and bahco

David Weaver


A couple of these are o1 and some are files. I mention getting bigger triangular files because their triangular shape makes them easier to hammer flatter.

By defletion, I mean the very edge of the steel gets bent, probably because o1 is a little less tough than plain carbon steel and it shows up when stropping a very low bevel angle.

The files used for these are smaller. I used x heavy taper files to cut the teeth into my frame saw. Those would've made good starting stock for chisels, but I threw them away when they were dull. The small knives made of triangular files here are about a sixteenth thick at the spine.

They could be made more neatly and filed to a nicer shape with crisp lines, but they're just to sharpen on the buffer, so they're sloppy as can be.

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#4

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

david weaver

Yes on the bolster, by the way. I intend to pretty much copy old chisels except that I can't forge the bolster integrally. I don't have enough heat, the tools, and most importantly I don't have the skills. What I'll do is make the bolster separately and file the hole tapered so it fits tight on the tang and all should be well.

There is a thread on the other side (now aged off of the front page) where I measured some of my better chisels at the tang, and I have a nice old used flat file that's worn out that I'm going to turn into a 1" chisel (it's about a quarter inch thick - unusually thick which will allow for proper thickness and taper). I started it last night, annealing it and cutting it and then hammering the end flatter and thinner. Now the harder work begins (cutting everything to shape). It'll be interesting to see how it turns out - I could be wrong, and it may be crumbly when done or just break easily, but I hope not. I broke the tang of the file off to look at the steel and it looks very cast - brittle (but to be fair, I'm sure it's very hard) and I can see the grain, but it's not too coarse. Someone referred to a Chinese site last week where they mentioned that the grain is sometimes left coarse with large carbides in files to promote wear resistance - not really what we're looking for in chisels.

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#5

Re: The discussion on wire edge and deflection..

david weaver

..is very esoteric. We generally consider O1 to be a very plain steel. I like it a lot for plane irons as long as it's hard enough, or in general at any reasonable hardness for anything other than smoothers (from last week's discussion about good-working jack and try plane irons not needing the biting hardness at the edge).

What's surprising is tempering these things at 350 degrees in the air fryer, seeing that they come out with the very light straw that you're expecting and then a foil is raised on the O1 off of the buffing wheel (I use a 5 micron al-ox compound from mcmaster carr - it's cheap, and has enough influence that you're not just dawdling, and it also ends up cutting very finely because it's on a buff) and it hangs on with the O1, but not the other knives.

It would come off in use, I'd think, but it's annoying to look at because it looks like a breaking edge, and you should confirm that it's just wire edge by jeans stropping or something and then visually looking at the edge to see that it's disappeared.

Before sharpening razors made of O1, I considered it to be probably a good steel for them because it's so plain. But compared to what's in good razors, it's not nearly plain enough. You can drive up hardness to relieve some wire edge holding tendencies, but that won't solve the problem when you hit an edge with the strop on a razor - the very last bit of edge is the important part and that part needs to hold up to the leather, release any loose bits and then wear a tiny bit. O1 just isn't good at it.

I think that these qualities are what makes the very old very plain water hardening steel dreamy when people run into it (like wiley discussing the older moulding plane irons and just how they sharpen. These characteristics are very useful on a moulding plane iron where you just want to sharpen the profile and not faff with much of a wire edge, and you certainly don't want chipping because of the difficulty in moving the edge back by grinding or heavy honing).

In practice, white II steel hardened between normal japanese and western chisels behaves like I'm discussing above, and is not particularly fragile. The iyoroi mokume chisels that I mentioned take some flack for being less than full hardness for japanese chisels (they are probably 63 or something, they're still harder than western chisels), but they feel a lot like old steel.

I sort of get tied up thinking about this stuff because I like making tools, not because it's really that useful for someone who is just making things out of wood. It's probably not.

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#6

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

Rum

In my very brief and not entirely successful foray into knife making 30 some years ago as a mid/late-teenager with little understanding of how things worked and only having access to a doug-fir bark fired forge... I, almost certainly inadvertently, made one of the best knives I've ever used out of an old file.

I'll recap my process here, not under any implication that its particularily valuable in and of itself but perhaps it might be interesting to see if there are parts I was completely off line on.

First I annealed the file by doing the traditional cherry red and then slow cool in the forge. Basically at the end of the day after repairing some hay rake teeth (and probably something else) I heated it all up then just kind of collapsed the fire in on the steel and left it overnight. I think this is probably slower than the cool-in-ashes method but I don't think it probably matters to much.

Next I ground off all of the file teeth. My basis for this was my dad claimed that it was less likely to have flaws carry through the steel from the sharp gullets on the file teeth. In theory this minimizes cracking potential. I don't actually know about this part but it sounded good so... I went with it.

The piece was then hammer forged to rough shape. This involved cutting the end of the file off on the hardy, and squaring up the tang a bit and putting a bit of a "sharp" (ish) tip on it (I generally "boil a deer horn tip until the inside is soft and then drive the tang into it" trick for a handle back then.. minimizes the amount of steel needed). The blade was hammer formed to "pretty close" to shape modulous the hollow grinding. I forged a bit of a sharp edge at the transition between the tang and the blade for the bolster to rest on, that was crisped up with a file after the next annealing step.

Another annealing step to take out all of the hammer stress and soften it to make it easy to grind.

Grind to basically finished shape leaving the edge a bit thick. Also do a reasonable rough polish.

Heat to cherry, quench briefly (until it just stops sizzling). Quickly pull out of the oil, hit it with a file to show the colors, watch the colors run until you're just about pale straw at the edge then plunge back into the oil for final quench. This will end up with a somewhat differentially hardened blade with the back a smidge softer that the edge hardened just a bit under straw (you loose a little between observation and final quench). At this point I'm not sure I wouldn't just quench fully and then post heat treat to get the right temper... My success rate at gettting a good blade past this point was kind of dissapointing. When its done just right though it makes a really nice blade.

Do the final grind being careful to not pull the temper and then polish and sharpen. Assemble the handle.

Standard test was to put a soft piece of 1/4" steel wire on a chopping block, rest the blade on the wire, and then wack the back of the blade with a 2x4. repeat along the blade every 1/2" or so. If the blade bent or chipped it wasn't good otherwise it was deemed ok.

The one blade that came out REALLY GOOD from this was used to skin a cow entirely in one pass with no sharpening and was still super crispy sharp at the end. Now that might not seem like a big deal but basically every other knife we ever used for butchering needed to be sharpened at least twice for a large animal.

This knife rode on my belt for some years until the hold down came loose and it bounced out of its sheath somewhere along a mountainside (I know the mountain, I know the trail, never found the knife).

I also had a couple that shattered on testing and a couple that I couldn't seem to get to harden very well either. There seemed to be some variance in steel quality/composition even back then based on spark tests and general post-working behavior. I certainly didn't know enough to quanitify it further back then and pretty surely still don't now.

Not sure what this tells anyone other than "yeah some files definitely have really good steel" and "here's one way that worked a couple of times" for whatever that's worth.

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#7

A great and helpful summary...

david weaver

I'm glad that you took the time to write that out, because it made me consider a couple of things i hadn't thought of.

I smashed the teeth down with the hammer on the blank that I hammered out and have started shaping it. I figure the teeth layer will probably be gone with shaping, but you never know. It would've been smarter if i'd have ground them off first and then hammered, as you say, you never know what's in the gullets (or even on the surface - they could have some small pinning that I missed, or oxidation, etc).

If this chisel works out, I think I will go back to trying 1095 as I've found a site that has thicker 1095 (needs to be 1/4" thick to get the taper and tang thickness necessary for rigidity, and so that I can taper the thickness on a curve making the business end suitably thin for at least a couple of inches).

as I was tapering my blank yesterday and grinding the tang out (only have a 6" baldor for that kind of thing), I considered what you said and realized that there's little chance that I'll have chisels that are consistent working.

Read some knife sites, too, and the back and forth from the knife makers was that anyone considering 1095 would be better off with 1084 because it's closer to the eutectic limit and much easier to harden accurately. All things to consider. I could also just leave O1 at very light straw, and its behavior would be improved, and I also wouldn't have to worry about cracking if the bevels were cut delicate before hardening (I have some concern that in file steel and 1095, they won't harden ideally).

Sorry to hear that you lost your knife. I've heard a million similar stories - one bump and your favorite knife or wrench is lost to the wild forever. I knew a lot of old timers at home who wouldn't carry a nice knife with them in the field or put nice tools in their tractors. They were mostly farmers and referred to those tools as "having been planted". "it costs more to plant a nice wrench than a cheap one".

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#8

Re: A great and helpful summary...

Rum

I have some mixed opinions on grinding the teeth off or not, but your description of smashing the teeth down brought back memories of my dad explaining that that wasn't the way to do it and prompted my post. I think probably if you heated it up hot enough to burn off the surface junk, scrubbed them with a wire brush well, then applied flux and hammered them down well at moderately high heat there would be relativel little chance of issues. OTOH annealing and grinding wasn't super hard to do either so.. its probably worth it once you consider the amount of effort expended on the rest of the exercise. I'm also thinking my dad probably had some good reasoning behind the warning (he usually did hehe).

There's also the probability that small flaws like that won't show up until after some use. We had a kitchen knife from that had a number of stress flaws along the back of the blade. These weren't visible at all (at least not visually) for at least 5 years (might have been longer), but one day it got bumped and the blade broke into three pieces! Examining the breaks and then looking at the blade closer I could see where the flaws were pre-existing, and had slowly propagated into the steel. Having a blade catastrophically fail on a knife or a chisel can be a really bad day.

I think the main thing I learned from the whole exercise is that the traditional double plunge tempering is quite difficult to get just right. Hardening then tempering after is much more forgiving, but there is certainly a fair bit of a hit and miss aspect doing small amounts in a make-shift home environment either way. I'd bet that you'll be able to get to where you're 95%+ serviceable, although they likely won't all hit your idealized goal. That is part of the risk of craft or some such heh.

I agree in general that (somewhat) lower carbon is more forgiving, the usability characteristics of higher carbon when it works out right is pretty nice though. My take is that theres some amount of acceptable "didn't work outs" to get the piece you're looking for. I'm also quite sure that file steel varies considerably depending on the source so you're definitely going to be fighting a lot of inconsistency there, again for messing around.. probably worth it. I also believe (with minimal supporting evidence) that older files (say pre-1990 with some variance around that) were generally simpler high carbon mixes and will very likely yield better results with the type of processes we're talking about here.

I've certainly planted my fair share of tools and knives. This one was just particularily hard because it was certainly the best I've ever done. On the other hand if you don't carry something like that you're not using it so what do you have it for anyway? I've never been to much of a having just for having kind of person, others might feel differently.

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#9

Re: A great and helpful summary...

david weaver

I considered a couple of things this morning, but it feels like i'm about to go on a bender building tools, so practicality isn't really that important compared to experimentation.

The two files i've got that are a quarter thick and an inch wide are portugal, but not bahco. Generally, those have been good files and this feels like good steel. LOTS of spark on grinding the annealed material and it cuts wonderfully with a vixen (which I use to shape things by hand if i can get a hold of a blank. You can draw file steel off in long pigtails with enough structure to cut you using a vixen - far better than a file, but still the same hand worked thrill and control.

Those teeth could have an awful lot in them, as you say. But the remaining variables are bigger. I'm assuming that a thin oil quench will be fast enough on water hardening steel, but it may not be if the cross section gets bigger.

I also ordered 1095 and 1084 today, two steels I've never worked with (I've had great luck with O1 stock, generally no problem matching commercially available O1, even with some hardening errors. I made a moulding plane iron once that I didn't quite get hot enough, but close. It attained enough hardness to be used, but didn't attain enough to skate across sharpening stones. I never tempered it, and by luck, it has worked great).

If chisel 1 with a file works well, then I'm moving over to quarter inch W1 bar stock. If the W1 proves too flakey in heat treat, I'll try a bench plane iron in 1084 to see how well it does when it's left a little bit on the hard side. I'm sure 1084 would make a wonderful sharpening knife blade.

I don't have a great heat source, but I think that works a little in my favor hammering. I cannot get the steel super bright orange, but i'm also unlikely to be decarbing it very much. A blacksmith would forge much further by hand than I do, I just do a little and combine with annealing so that I have some less hand work to do tapering thickness. Same with knives. I don't know that my hammering does anything, but it makes it much easier to shape a knife blade.

Chisels and knives up to about 5 inches will be the limit of what I can harden, and that's OK. Much appreciate the very useful discussion!

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#10

Re: A great and helpful summary...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

In 1980 I was restoring an 18th century blacksmith shop that had burned and I retrieved a large Nicholson file that lost its temper in the fire. I made a large skew chisel for turning from the file. I shaped the skew end and ground down the teeth somewhat, then took it to a blacksmith for quenching. He wanted to temper it also, but I did not trust him, so I tempered it in a kitchen oven. I have used it for many years now.

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#11

Re: A great and helpful summary...

Rum

Interesting on the vixen, I've never really tried using one on steel but as you say on annealed stuff it should do a pretty good job. Certainly seems like it would be faster cutting than most files! I'm not even sure if I have any.. will have to keep my eye open at the usual sales.

I mostly agree on experimentation, although it is nice to have some sort of control on the results otherwise its less experiment and more throwing mud against the wall (which is admittedly also kind of fun but perhaps less generally educational). Personally i tend to err a bit on the other side and analyze things to death beyond the point of getting anything done (I'm quite sure based on reading your posts that you can't relate to that at all :b ).

I have very limited experience with water hardening, having mostly worked with whoknowswhatium as opposed to actually known quantities and oil is a bit more forgiving. I have used a brine for some steels, the general theory being that you get more aggressive hardening because of less cavitation (and something about temperature transfer which I can't quantify meaningfully other than to say "faster than plain water"). Some people also use various sort of soaps or detergents as surfactants to increase stickiness/and I believe the quench speed. Brine can be pretty fast though, and you don't want to do the "hold it in until the sizzling stops" but more "get it past the phase transition and pull it out quick". I suspect for thinner stuff you're probably going to get less warping and breakage in oil so would probably stick with that unless you have issues. You could thin the oil with kerosene or diesel up to maybe 50/50 if you want to get a bit faster quench.

You can kind of tell if you're hardening to fast by either the steel telling you while quenching (pings, warps, self destruction) or if upon grinding back you find the surface was a lot harder than the core.

Almost all of my work has been in carbon rich (tree bark and coal) based fires which are pretty reducing so I haven't really worried to much about decarbing (other than keeping the piece well buried in the fire). Using the propane setups might well be more of a problem. There is surely some tradeoff between fewer higher heats and more lower heats as decarbing increases with time at temperature but I don't know enough to quanitfy it. At dull red you're bumping the lower end but probably not maintaining heat long enough to get very far into the steel.. probably...

I've also kind of wondered if with the higher carbon steel I might have been inadvertently benefiting from some decarbing. This is all highly annecdotal, but I had more issues with some larger pieces ("bowie knife" style made from a rasp) being glass brittle once hardened before tempering (or more accurately when I double dipped a little to soon.. sigh) whereas I didn't have the same type of issues with smaller stuff. There's some tradeoff between tough and hard there but again lots of unknowns in the underlying material that could have a large affect on the whole thing.

I think that the old hay rake teeth were something really close to 1095, they were some sort of high carbon spring steel anyway. They were kind of tricky because you had to be super careful not to burn them up. Its easier to put a lot of heat into high carbon than it is into low. For instance I could forge weld small (3/8" round) high carbon stuff like rake teeth with a fir bark fire, but you'd have a really hard time getting more mild steel like a horse shoe or the like hot enough in that kind of fire (good charcoal or coal yes.. bark.. not so much). That probably has some implications on the workability of your 1095 vs 1084 samples (not quite sure how 1084 behaves), if you're not hot enough pounding on it to much causes cracking. OTOH I also believe that if you get it hot enough to be plastic then hammer deforming it helps smooth (smear) out defects and inclusions giving you a better grain on the finished product.

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#12

So far on the chisel..

David Weaver

Some tang and bevel refinement yet before heat treat. Wider bevels would look better, but I feel like I'm playing with fire if the cross section gets too complex, potentially inducing a crack in heat treat. About 3.6 mm at the business end and 6.5 mm at the edge of the tang.

Rough finish will be cleaned up of it makes a decent chisel, and tang tapered to a point with bolster added last.


Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#13

Re: A great and helpful summary...

david weaver

I'm not surprised that a file would make a good skew. I have a small power lathe and use HSS, but i hone it instead of grinding it. It works well, but doesn't remind me of carbon steel. I don't turn enough to think too much about it, though.

Of all of the things that I've hardened, none of turned out bad, but the couple that I've had to reharden have been due to overshooting a shop temper tempering by color at the front of my small forge. Even when the color is OK, some thin cross sections end up soft, so I do as you do and use the oven (or on small items, I have an air fryer that I've used, it works OK, but I'm less sure about its temperature control than my kitchen oven).

It's just too important. I wouldn't have let the blacksmith do it, either.

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#14

Re: A great and helpful summary...

david weaver

Plenty of heat to hammer, just not enough to get to forge.

The first time I tried to make a pocket knife blade, I let it cool, and then sprayed it with a little bit of water to make sure it was OK to touch. That little bit of time that metal can be moved after a heat...well, that took that away and one light tap and the blade shattered like glass :(

I can get the files hot enough to raise a flux on the surface, but don't really want to do that. Lots of stuff I don't know, though. I've often heard that the better japanese smiths would try to use as low of heat as possible when working their tools, and when forge welding.

My small can forge with two torches in it (I usually use one) will get steel hotter than I want to, and I guess it could probably get it up to bright orange or close to yellow, but probably not sparking like a coal fire. Since the inside of the forge is without carbon, I don't want to get the steel too hot and have it migrating out. I also don't want to hammer it cold and stress it.

1084, I know little about it. Just read that for people who want to forge 1095, 1084 is a good place to start because it's much more forgiving in the quench. I've always got O1 to fall back on - with O1, you heat it to orange right at the flux or a little bit before, quench it, temper it in the oven. It turns out the same every time. The only marginally hardened blade I had, I was trying to heat the blade with one of those 500k btu weed torches without anything to hold the heat. Turns out that the radiant heat from that thing made it hard for me to hold the blade, even with gloves on. felt like a sunburn - I got it to orange, quenched it and headed inside. I'm not sure that I ever tempered that blade because it didn't need it, but it, for some reason, is an excellent plane blade to use. Still hard enough for all but the hardest file to skate on it, but not too hard to sharpen on an oilstone.

(I do get stuck in the details! But my first attempts at making tools and just wasting time resulted in tools that didn't work as well as purchased types, and that's something I don't like. I've thrown most of those tools away. I've got a lot of "purchased" tools, and aim to make a tool that is their equal so that I'll actually use it. This file chisel might not be that, but the next six or so had better be at least that good. If I can't get them right with 1095, I've got plenty of O1 stock on hand to work with.)

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#15

Re: A great and helpful summary...

Rum

I was probably trying to move the metal around more than you are so thre's some tradeoff on heat/mallebility. I don't really know how to define reasonably where the line is ("depends" is as close as I can get).. I believe the desire for some smiths to forge colder is to reduce the decarbing issue, walking close to that line is tricky and requires a bit more skill than I certainly have.

You certainly don't need or want to get anywhere close to sparking, that's heading on welding heat. I guess mostly just judge by how easy the metal moves and try to get it more or less evenly heated through. Judging color is also a bit tricky because it depends on the ambient somewhat. The old forge I was working on was in a nice log cabin like structure with 1800's era dusry windows so it was just the perfect shade of dim to forge in. There was a bench with a bigger window/by the door where the grinder and and cold work vise was... that all worked pretty well.

The glass hard steel issue is certainly familiar >( A couple of dagnabbit!!! intances there for sure.

Most lower carbon will be more forgiving than higher carbon, so that definitely makes sense. I don't entirely understand how all of the other components affect the crystal formation (I've read Verhoeven's Metallurgy of Steel for Bladesmiths .. but it was kind of like reading the water chemistry book for brewing, some useful prescriptive information but the fundamentals exceeded my grasp) but that definitely matters. O1 is kind of magically nice to work with in that regard.

If you haven't gotten a couple of good blacksmith's tongs, they're easy enough to make from mild steel and long handles are super nice :)

My main interest is in making things I can't reasonably buy, or that are interesting to make in some alternative fashion. Mostly the former, so a lot of it ends up being pretty rough and ready.

It'll be interesting to see how your 1095 adventures go.

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#16

Re: A great and helpful summary...

david weaver

I'll report back.

Thanks to the magic of youtube, there are some videos that are credible, and some that are not (except it's credible when someone records their first attempt at quenching 1095 and puts it in water and leaves it there....you can hear the cracking on their videos).

It appears that oil is the medium of choice, rapeseed, canola, soy, whatever it may be - preheated to about 130 degrees or so to speed the quench vs. cold more viscous oil. And a full dip into the quench and up an down motion rather than side to side (as the side to side can cause warping due to differential temperatures).

I'm an O1 swirler, so it was nice to see that.

I didn't look that hard, but all of the custom knifemakers showing their methods used oil - I didn't see anyone using water like I recall blacksmiths doing when I was a kid - interrupted. Dip in the water, pull out of the water 6-8 seconds and then dip again.

Interestingly enough, there were third world commenters (like southeast asia and phillipines) who said water is the standard where they are and interrupted dip is still common there. Often differential hardening with knives.

The guidance in the videos confirmed my suspicion that too much shaping of bevels (such that they're gradual and much thinner at the edge at an acute angle) may invite cracking issues.

It's interesting in the chase for chisels that have ideal characteristics both in use and on the stones. One that I could avoid by just using O1.

FWIW, the low mid orange that I see is in the day, but in a garage. It would probably be quite bright at night. The steel does not move easily with it, but I don't move it too much, either. It'll be a long time or never before I gather the skill to start forging shapes instead of just doing some minor work to hedge my bets and reduce the work with the vixen.

That comment with the vixen, btw - I use them only if I can find them sold as old stock. Their new cost is pretty stiff, but the two sided body files can sometimes be found in lots on ebay for $5 each. One of them would easily shape a whole set of chisels. The literature sometimes says non-ferrous metals only, but at $5, who cares? I have bought ten of them and after two infill planes and a couple of knives and this chisel, I'm not sure if I've flipped the first one to its second side. The center is certainly tired. It takes little filing to remove the marks from the vixen, but they can be trouble at the edge of work since the teeth are far apart - a bit of horsing one through a cut can cause a catch and mark annealed steel pretty deeply.

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#17

without youtube...

david weaver

..I guess I'd have been searching for a book in the past, or three, to make sure that all of them agreed on technique. But the uniformity of the better knife makers in terms of method and statement about few failures and very consistent post temper Rc testing is encouraging.

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#18

Re: A great and helpful summary...

Rum

I think in general sharp edges invite cracking. Whether that be at the future cutting edge or along the other sides.. so some mild rounding on all edges before quenching and then refining to a crisp edge after tempering seems smart imho.

Interestingly this is the same behavior when making things from green wood and drying them - sharp edges == more cracks, and ditto overly fast or uneven drying (aka shrinkage which is more or less the same issue as an overly fast quench). It seems the more you learn the more its all related.

My (again wholly unsupported by direct facts) belief is that the interrupted water quench mostly evolved mostly due to a lack of reasonable tempering equipment that could hold temperature accurately for a long enough time. It's certainly a higher skill technique and more prone to error. I think also the differential hardening can be beneficial for some tools but its not an extremely compelling feature for 99% of the things.

Alignment when quencing also can make a big difference in the success rate regards warping and cracking. Generally even to heat, even to cool gives the best results (within the constraints of the equipment). My dad was of the "alignment with the magnetic field" matters camp as well (at least for knife blades plunged vertically facing north/south), I think there's something to that because the reforming crystals will pick up some magnetic alignment, but I'm unsure how much difference it makes in practice. I'm also unsure how that would translate to most of the tools we're talking about here.

On literature, somewhat dated, but still pretty interesting from a backyard blacksmith perspective is "Hardening, tempering, annealing and forging of steel ; A treatise on the practical treatment and working of high and low grade steel" by Joseph Vincent Woodworth. I also have a copy of "forging" by John Jernberg which is similarily useful. Both have at least a couple of copies on archive.org as they are long out of copyright (I have an inordinate fondness for dead trees but its often useful to read things before commiting the shelf space when possible). I can't say they're more directly accurate than the various modern internet sources but tend to have a somewhat broader and less bladesmith specific perspective.

Learning some forging is imho useful as its a lower effort than bulk removal of material and I kind of like some of the aesthetics :) But I'm currently living with similar capability restrictions so you have my sympathies there. I'd like to move to someplace where I could setup a decent smithing shop again one of these days but it's not in the immediate cards. Ah well we work with what we have.

On 99% of things like files I'm mostly into buying old stock or deals on new-old-stock when I can find them. I'm pretty sure I've seen a vixen or two in some of the hot-rod head estate sales around so will be keeping my eye open. The newer stuff is often rather dodgy hardness as well (point of course belabored to death everywhere already). If I only used tools for their intended purpose that would loose me about 1/2 of what I do 8) For example I had to do a small amount of sheet metal work for a friends project the other day but don't have a decent pair of duck bill sheet metal pliers but an upholstery webbing stretcher worked pretty nicely (and making a small redneck brake of sorts out of four old power planer blades plus a couple of vise grips worked a trick as well).

Another technique that is extremely useful but hated pretty universally by everyone who uses it because of the hot metal shards is hot rasping. I don't recall seeing a lot of discussion of it in the literature but it's pretty commonly done by farriers shaping horseshoes (where I learned it) and can remove a hell of a lot of metal in a hurry. The nice thing about it is that you really only want to use files and rasps that are pretty much shot already as sharp ones are way to grabby, so those old files that Bogs marked with red as "never to sharpen again" can have a bit of a life extension for this (before getting recycled into something else). I think for your purposes it would likely be a really good trick to have though. I won't go into the details much more as there are various youtube videos now that show it better than I can explain it.

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#19

Re: A great and helpful summary...

david weaver

Thanks for the tip on hot rasping.

it looks like someone put both of those books you mentioned back into production in October, 2018. I'll have copies of both of them soon.

The comments on the hardening book are funny because it's a description of industrial process around 1900 and one of the readers didn't like that the steel descriptions are antiquated (I'm used to that, razor publications use the same somewhat antiquated descriptions).

While modern alloys might thrill the average knife maker (they're very marketable) or etsy blacksmith, it's precisely the early 1900s or razor-type alloys that I'm chasing. If it doesn't work out, I can go tail between legs and back to trying to get the most out of material removal with O1.

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#20

Re: A great and helpful summary...

Rum

I picked up the "Forging" book as a LeeValley Classic Reprint (mildly addicted, they generally have better print and binding quality than a lot of the other reprints) although it doesn't appear to be available there anymore unfortunately. That's a place I like to watch for interesting books though :)

I agree that the simpler historical alloys are pretty interesting as an amateur, and I think a lot of the time they actually work as well or better for many practical applications as you aren't fighting the steel as much. That isn't to say I don't like some exotics (the Thompson lathe tools in CPM10V are, for instance, pretty sweet), but its application specific what's the better material.

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#21

I just learned the term warm forging..

david weaver

..anything below critical temperature, but above work hardening temperature.

Wide range!

I see that the chance of me hitting above critical for long but not forming scale is pretty low. I generally didn't form much scale when hammering the file into shape. This is a bonus for me with the equipment that I have (no scale) because it suggests I'm not doing anything anything to completely reset the grain structure and I don't have to deal with the scale (which I could brush off).

In the world of unknowns, I see forgers talking about this being the ideal range to forge steel and other suggesting there will be cracks. Industrial talk about warm forging is focused more on dies and tight tolerance forging of more complex shapes than cold allows.

So, I have no idea if I'm doing anything other than making the steel thinner on the business end of the chisel to lessen material reduction, but I think so far, I'm going to just keep doing the same thing. I was kind of surprised just how bad the bolster got after a few high heats (uneven carbon content and enormous amounts of scale).

The chisel above so far holds up as well as anything I've had, and better than anything that's below where I prefer hardness to be (it's far better performing than the sorby type chisels that are intentionally soft...of course, I could potentially break it mortising a plane body and find out that it's not that great! But I mortised some hard maple with it last night to see how it would hold up, and it hasn't shown any bad tendencies. 30 degrees colder on the temper and it had noticeable microchipping tendencies.

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#22

Re: I just learned the term warm forging..

Rum

My limited experience is that the low end of the "safe" (no cracking) temperature varies quite a bit depending on the steel. Given the number of variables there and my relatively limited set of experiences I'm hesitant to try to quantify it much more than "it depends" hah. I've had a few pieces I remember that seemed to want to crack some even when hot forged around mid orange. My recollection is that the higher the carbon the more of a problem it is. The extreme example of this being cast iron which is 2.5-5% and works like crumbly brittle crap until you heat/beat some of the carbon out, vs say super low carbon wire that's hard to get to even work harden quickly. There is also some technique around how you move the metal that lessens the problem as well, I can't adequately describe that very well.

I should probably put in the disclaimer here that I'm mostly dredging up experiences 25+ years old here... so.. memory is a fallible thing, add an appropriately sized grain of salt.

I do believe that post forging annealing prior to hardening can be super important for stress relief. Forging (or really any deformational shaping) can add a lot of weird stress points into the steel and that doesn't come out with just a tempering heat.

The way steel behaves in response to heat is still very weird to me, I really haven't internalized it at all. The fact that heating it 30 degrees harder changes the composition so much is .. expected .. but still fascinating and odd. Really makes you want to break/cut a bunch pieces apart and put them under a scope (I"m unsure I'd learn anything useful but it would still be fun lol).

The more I read your experiences the more I'm thinking that running a coal or bark fired forge was doing a lot to keep me from getting in trouble being that I was able to maintain very reducing fire. The fact you're not getting scale is encouraging, but the bolster experience is mildly troubling. I'm wondering if you can adjust the gas/oxy mix to get even more of a reducing atmosphere, I don't have a lot of propane forge experiences (heated a couple of horseshoes in one, but shortly after left for a more sendentary occupation with arguably less back pain). Granted it doesn't matter to much for the bolster itself, but as a test piece it's still an interesting data point.

It's pretty cool that it worked as well as it did though, I honestly don't think 4 hours is all that bad for trying out something entirely new like that.. I'd bet I'd have managed to stretch it out to a whole day somehow :D

Re: A follow up on file steel...(squash knives)

#23

Re: Bolster and chisel definitely different

david weaver

When I heat the chisel prior to heat treat, I pretty much keep it at low red heat for a while, but non-magnetic. All I have is a can forge, which can easily be used to make a tiny thing like the bolster bright colored so that it will move easily, but the rest of the chisel never gets subjected to that. I'm afraid of carbon loss and messing up whatever was done to refine the grain in the original tool.

MAPP and the can at high heat with my torch is just enough that if I don't move the chisel, I could get flux bubbles (which I don't really want, just as the whole thing is even in color before quenching, I'll raise flux bubbles on a non-critical part to see that the rest of the chisel is close to it).

I think if I had more heat, I could get in a lot more trouble, but I really don't want more heat. It's sort of like burning meat - it's easy to want more and more heat to speed up the cooking process, but once you get careless and burn something, then you can't take that back. I can heat smaller areas of the chisel (to hammer) to a slightly higher heat, but I don't want to go too high - I see from reading that above 2100 degrees F or so, the metal will move a lot easier, but I have zero interest in doing that. Slow and steady, just a little hammering

(thinking back, I probably did heat the bolster and the tang when driving it on a little higher, but once the bolster was on the chisel, I never heated the whole thing up to bright - too afraid that it would end up bent with no way to hammer it back). I have two holes in my can forge and could double the btu's, but don't want to. The literature on carbon steel suggests that a slower heat to critical, even and slow, is better before a quench. I'm in no great rush. Only did one so far, though. The next one could turn out to be a turd with cracks in it.