Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Another blade

Posts

Another blade

#1

Another blade

Winston

If you're interested, I have a 2" Tsunesaburo blue steel blade that I could send you. I got it from Tools from Japan, but I believe this is the same blade that one can still get from Axminster.

This might be outside the scope of your tests, but I'd also be curious about how much it helps to sharpen the blade with a higher grit. I usually stop sharpening on an Norton 8000 stone. I have a Shapton 12000 which I haven't really be using because it doesn't make for a noticeably better result, but if using it would mean that an edge would last longer, I would use it.

In a similar vein, I'm also curious about the effect of a strop on edge longevity. I have been using a plain leather strop after sharpening because it makes the edge noticeably sharper. I test it by cutting into a piece of plain white printer paper across the grain, with no skewing or slicing, and I find that stropping the blade makes it significantly easier to make a cut like that. I initially didn't think that a plain leather strop would make much of a difference, but after I saw read some of the stuff at https://scienceofsharp.wordpress.com/ and saw the pictures there, I tested it out, and I found that it did indeed make for easier cutting, and noticeably so. (Whether good results on the paper test translates into better wood cutting, or a longer lasting edge, is something I'm not 100% sure of, but it seems likely, and the effort spent stropping is small, so that's why I do it.)

Re: Another blade

#2

Oops

Winston

Oops, my message was meant to be a reply to David Weaver's post "Anything else to test? Testing iron durability", but I made a rookie mistake and made it a new post instead.

Re: Another blade

#3

Re: Another blade

David Weaver

Hi Winston, that one is a good suggestion. I may have one laying around here, but if I don't, it's because I sold it in a plane a couple of years ago. Those are one of my favorite irons.

As far as edge life goes with initial honing it's generally dependent on how thick of a shaving you normally take. The heavier you tend to work, the less benefit you'll get out of going further with sharpness.

I'll note that as a test to run after completing wear tests.

Re: Another blade

#4

Re: Another blade

David Weaver

I forgot to say, I'll just order another one if I don't still have mine. Does sting a little more to buy one now that stu Tierney is out of business, though.

Re: Another blade

#5

Re: Another blade

david weaver

I do, indeed, have one of these irons, so I'll add it to the group. In my drawers, I have more than 100 irons (mostly older irons for infills and wooden planes), so sometimes I forget what I have.

As far as stropping goes, the discussion requires context. When a wire edge exists, stropping does help as long as the wire edge is something that can come off without damage.

Strop honing (abrasive on a surface, leather or whatever) on an appropriate surface may also protect the edge a little bit, but too much of it is just creating the same profile as wear will create.

In the context of use, an easy way to tell if it improves initial sharpness (bare leather, oiled preferably) is to shave hair off of your arm with an iron. Turn the iron over and try to do the same thing with the other side of the bevel. the last stroke usually points the wire edge in a direction. Stropping will remove it and the edge will shave cleanly equally on both sides (if stropping is done properly). without stropping, a finished edge usually shaves on one side but not the other, or at least not nearly as well. It could be the case that most of the foil that's left is removed without damage on the first stroke if the finishing regimen is fine enough.

As far as wire edge removal goes, the more blunt the bevel and the harder the steel, the less need there is for stropping. Some softer steels can also be deflected, but anything that gets deflected like that is either a bad alloy or too soft for woodworking.