Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

My most unusual chisel, steel related

Posts

My most unusual chisel, steel related

#1

My most unusual chisel, steel related 

David Weaver

A couple of years ago when I made about two dozen planes, I was experimenting with chisels to find something that lasted well and didn't stick in the cut making the mortise. After initial excavation, sticking isn't an issue, but I recalled a discussion that earlier mortise chisels were relieved in their length.

I found a chisel type like this, Chinese and hss, and got a set. These seem like the same hss as muji irons, but this chisel sharpens well on Japanese natural stones, which is unusual. It's really fine in its edge taking and holds an edge for a really long time, but it didn't hold up at the ferrule because it's just stabbed into the handle.

I hate to say it, but it might be the best modern steel I've seen in a chisel, but the shape and construction method leaves a lot to be desired.


Re: My most unusual chisel, steel related

#2

Re: My most unusual chisel, steel related

Wiley Horne

Hi David and all,

Thanks for the post! Too bad we can’t find what that steel/heat treat is. Doesn’t Chris Scholz have connections in China? But then China is a big place....

The ferrule didn’t hold up because the ferrule is brass. That chisel is no more “just stabbed into the wood” than an oval-bolstered chisel is just stabbed into the wood. The shank shoulders bearing on the ferrule, which then spreads the load, is mechanically a bolster. Put a thin steel washer between the brass and the shank and it’s good to go. It’s kinda ugly, but the parts are all there.

Wiley

Re: My most unusual chisel, steel related

#3

What is the wood? 


Re: My most unusual chisel, steel related

#4

Re: My most unusual chisel, steel related

David Weaver

It's not quite equal to a good white steel chisel, but it exhibits none of the corner losing habits that white steel can have in heavy use.

I realize most people use their chisels to waste half blinds or trim tenons, and I guess at this point, that's more common for me. The sort of in between of hard edge but no deformation in beating makes this steel nice. It is not quite like anything else I've tried.

It is made by woodwell (mujingfang) and in my opinion, they're plenty strong about their price ($70 for five of them is a princely sum for chinese chisels, and 3 of the five sizes are too large to do anything practically - they must work differently than we do, or perhaps these are intended for sculpting.

The wood is chinese mystery wood, sort of like beech, sort of like maple. Not identical to either.

you are 100% right about the design of the chisel as it fits in the handle - it is a pure guess on their part, and the T gives the chisel some strength, but it prevents it from working further into the handle. This is a worse design than the one that I criticized previously....but they're less than $15 each.

The steel looks like it's water cut or something similar straight out of sheet stock.

I guessed a couple of years ago when I mentioned this type of steel that it's similar to T-HSS, but I seriously doubt that's the case. I was just trying to guess why it is so tolerant of natural stones but still hard.

Some of mujis tools are nice, but these are more strange and contrived. Still, I wanted to try a chisel that was tapered. Less taper, a better chisel design and the same steel would just about give anything a run for its money. I don't expect that'll happen.

I intentionally ground one of these off on the corner and then into a V to cut a fingernail groove in a pocket knife blade (annealed). When I ground it, I let it get orange - the hardness seems to be unaffected. (eons ago, japan woodworker advertised muji goods as A2 steel, but JWW has often been more interested in creating the story than conveying what I want to know).

I did the same with a muji iron, ground it on a glazed wheel until it glowed - no problem.

The other strange thing with the irons (as a matter of comparing the fineness, and these are also similar to the green HSS iron that I have planing corian in a thread below) is that the edge does not fail or sharpen in a way that it gives up chunks like A2 does on a washita, or like I fought with the SGPS on. It fails finely. Brent beach got good pictures of it. It almost fails like carbon steel, and probably is at least equal to 3V (its wear bevel in brent's test was similar, but the resulting edge after dulling is slightly finer looking).

While it's not damaged by the washita like A2, it is also not able to be sharpened in any practical way on the washita, either - just burnished. Activating the washita with a slurry would probably make it work, but I don't like to do that to my washitas.

I had settled so solidly into trying to maximize O1 that I forgot a lot about this. Last week, I was at the beach and had a lot of time to post about it, thus the long stream of pondering. For practicality, I'm not improved in the shop by any of this, but I'm curious, anyway. I just don't understand how this steel was backed into in china and how it fares as well in edge holding and fineness. I have 6 or 7 examples now of muji planes, these chisels and other HSS irons that are probably also just made by muji and painted green. They are all like this (as in, this isn't just a "good one").

Re: My most unusual chisel, steel related

#5

Chris Scholz

Re: My most unusual chisel, steel related

Chris Scholz

Sorry, no experience with HSS steel.

We did experiment with 52100 ball bearing steel which is a rather conventional steel with very nice properties.

The problem with many modern steel types is that they are almost useless for laminated blades because they don’t ‘stick’ to the backing material. You might make this work with some heavy equipment, but no chance with manual hammering.

Re: My most unusual chisel, steel related

#6

Re: My most unusual chisel, steel related

david weaver

Agreed - the HSS that's laminated is glued rather than forge welded. Forge welding requires very plain steel, and power to do it practically (without voids and to get a good forge weld).

From a practical standpoint, I don't know how one would heat treat 52100 or 1095 in a fast quench without a backer. I bought 1095 drill rod when I was thinking about trying to make my own chisels (which is a serious time waster and a danger of spending a lot of time to make a subpar tool if you're doing it with plain carbon steel and filing in bolsters, etc) and then read about heat treating after that.

The only good answer I saw was to quench it in oil as it would warp or crack in water or brine if not laminated or very thick in cross section. So as far as I can tell, I've stuck myself into either making it very thin or just having something not as good as O1.

I'm not aware of any laminated HSS that isn't glued prelaminated material. Woodwell's HSS is either a solid chunk brazed to something (to make an entire iron), or like these chisels, just a solid slab. A shame in the case of this chisel as it has potential to be as good as anything at any price if it could be made in proportion to older chisels. It's a novelty as it is, but they are useful to grind into things if you have a use (engraving tools, etc). the wings could be ground off of this one and a purpose made bolster installed further down, but I'm not lacking chisels, either.