Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A Steel Primer by Crucible Products, LLC

Posts

A Steel Primer by Crucible Products, LLC

#1

A Steel Primer by Crucible Products, LLC

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Anyone interested in steel properties and the interrelationships among hardness, toughness, abrasion resistance and the like will be interested in the information provided by Crucible Products .

http://www.crucible.com/Products.aspx?c=25

This link will in turn link to PDF files relevant to steel used in edged tools. Of particular interest will be "Knife Steel Basics". This PDF explains how composition and heat treatment combine to yield particular properties and the compromises involved. More in depth information on particular steels will be provided by the "Crucible Niagara" link.

The link "Knife Maker Information" provides a description of the manufacturing process for "particle steel". The resulting properties relevant to edged tools will explain why it was desirable for LV to choose a particle steel for their edged tools, and why I specify particle steel for jointer and planer knifes. As an aside, I got to meet at an MW-TCA event one of the people that developed the particle technology for Crucible Products. His description of the explosive sintering of the powder was as entertaining as a typical Myth Busters show.

Re: A Steel Primer by Crucible Products, LLC

#2

Re: A Steel Primer by Crucible Products, LLC

David weaver

Charts from steel producers remind me of statiins. What I mean by that is the studies for statins were not honestly done in the first rounds, the data they reported was low credibility and incomplete result sets. Several years ago, the institute of actuaries released a population mortality study and found no increase in life expectancy for individuals under 65 in qrisk categories 20 and below unless individuals already had a severe event. However scads of folks were put on statins and subjected to side effects like earlier onset of type 2 diabetes.

The average life expectancy increase due to statins was approximately 2 years but not due to things assumed earlier (rather due to prescribing to older patients and those already compromised). Because of my daytime work, I find this thing highly offensive.

The charts for these steels often don't describe how the results apply to knives with bevels set for slicing or woodworking tools with appropriate bevels in wood. In your efforts to make chisels, you came up short of good white steel chisels, but did well otherwise.

Likewise, scads of uber expensive kitchen knives have been sold that cannot match simple steels in durability in slicing tasks. However, the exotic steels make better dies, and more durable slicers if you're willing to have a 60 degree edge on knives. And narratives about them are valuable for marketing as well as the ability for makers to try substituting technology for skill.

Lv appears to have hit a triple with chisels and a solid single for plane irons. From a marketing standpoint, it's a home run. Ashley iles was already on base and a small maker in Japan and many others are on the bench after finishing their home run trot on a smaller contract.

Similarly in pocket knives, I've seen nothing better in use for slicing than tidioutes 1095.

Re: A Steel Primer by Crucible Products, LLC

#3

Good heavens!

John in NM

Talk about comparing apples to oranges! More like comparing apples to penguins! :D

Re: A Steel Primer by Crucible Products, LLC

#4

Re: Good heavens!

David Weaver

Hey, let's keep this on topic. Comparing Ottawa senators to Pittsburgh penguins!

The statin comparison is relevant because presumably the data that came out in the older studies was correct, but it was irrelevant to the actual purpose in some cases in that it was presented in such a way that it favored prescription for a lot of classes where it didn't do any good ...as in, it didn't reduce mortality and morbidity for many of the classes of folks it was given to.

Cardiologists interpretations in some cases were that even people with normal cholesterol had improved outcomes, even at younger ages. That was outright false, and until an outside group came along and measured a large population and actually quantified death rates, the advice was bad except for cohorts with really unusual risks or for older individuals.

How does this compare to the charts? Simple, if you read the data as it's presented, you'll probably conclude that almost anything makes a better plane blade or chisel than carbon steel. Or, a better knife. All of the charts and data are right there for you. But, the charts don't do a good job of informing about what people really like using knives, and that is a sharp knife that's really good at slicing, that stays sharp as it wears and wears predictably and can be put back to fresh condition in a cycle of work easily.

It turns out that the simple steel knives do that the best whether they're low tech stainless or carbon steel. The same turns out to be true for razors where wondersteels produce unacceptable results. Even o1 makes a very marginal razor.

Re: A Steel Primer by Crucible Products, LLC

#5

Lies, damned lies, and statistics

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, one of the issues with reading numbers on research documents is that they may not reflect important and more relevant subtle information that is not tested or scored.

You cite an example from your world, and I have numerous from mine. For example, questionnaires or psychometric tests used to diagnose psychiatric disorders cannot explore subtleties that only an interview by an experienced clinician can do (sorry, that is my hobby horse).

The point is, it is possible that an experienced user of blades can judge which steel is better than is reflected in test scores. However, if you want to convince others of your observations, you need meaningful results. For this, you need meaningful tests to provide meaningful results.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A Steel Primer by Crucible Products, LLC

#6

As I mentioned below...

David Weaver

.. I just don't want to be the person who runs the tests for these blades on wood. I did it at one point for various A2 irons and found in the case where I tested blades that the LN A2 irons were the best of the irons that I had on hand. Another group at the time (IBC) had sent me an iron and cap iron set and I'm sure as it often is with tools made available, there is some hope for feedback as well as free marketing in the form of discussion.

I don't know what most people do with tools when they evaluate them, but I felt like I couldn't comment unless I did something to test the irons. So I got a piece of uniform maple and planed thousands of strokes on it, stopping periodically to adjust depth and wax the plane that I was using to make sure I was using a uniform shaving thickness and being as fair as possible.

The LN iron alone lasted about 1100 strokes before it stopped cutting. IBC's lasted about 800, but the point where I would've sharpened both was probably 400 and 300, respectively (actually, the IBC iron was a little more prone to chipping, so it would've seen the stones earlier and knowing what I know now, I'd have stepped the angle up until it stopped chipping). I'm sure you remember the discussions we've had about A2's edge holding really being a factor of finding where it doesn't chip and then it's maximized there.

A simple solution in this case would be brent beach running the same tests he already has with V11 and posting it.

But, I agree with what you're saying - someone has to want to run a test. It's the same as the hardness results (which can be a little misleading even when they're accurate), someone with no interest and the means to do the test would need to do it.

All that said, marketability, intangibles (LV being able to claim something that others don't have), ability to make something with the labor pool, skills and equipment available, manufacturing preferences...they all weigh in.

Personally, I think your testing of chisels has been pretty invaluable, because it let the water out of the tub on a lot of things, and left it in on others - in wood.

Re: A Steel Primer by Crucible Products, LLC

#7

Re: A Steel Primer by Crucible Products, LLC

Charlie

A2 was totally it. Clark & Williams tight-mouthed single iron smoothers were totally it (before cap irons were totally it). D2 was totally it (you just need the right honing media [insert confused/frowning smiley here]). PM-V 11 is totally it. I'm betting that PM-VI 12, 13, and 14 will be totally it, too. Manage that pipeline!

Most of it is marketing bull$hit, and/or internet one-upsmanship, or 18th century crapola from one or two sources who weren't even woodworkers, etc., etc., etc.

The truth is somewhere in the middle, where it's always to be found.

Re: A Steel Primer by Crucible Products, LLC

#8

As long as the market is beginners...

david weaver

....today's best tools will be technically unusable (there will be a .gif image on a web page showing in bar charts why that's the case) in a decade, and the tools that people used professionally for a couple of hundred years will be antiquated tools for "stupid people who would've used bevel up planes and diamond plates if they'd have been available".

I can't imagine that there will be any time in the future that the market isn't beginners.

Larry did a pretty good job of fooling a bunch of people about the planes that eliminated the style he likes to build. Lots of words and a lot of enthusiasm about it. I was convinced. It wasn't correct, but sometimes that's secondary to enthusiasm.

Re: A Steel Primer by Crucible Products, LLC

#9

That's a bit rich, David.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I use BU planes. I like high angle planes. I even use diamond stones.

Horrors ... I ... must ... be ... a ... Beginner!!! :O

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A Steel Primer by Crucible Products, LLC

#10

Nobody is really original....

david weaver

...in posting that message, you may think I made it up :) I'm not that original, though.

The comment about BU planes is actually something that was said over on SMC, but also added to it at the time was A2 steel.

I was able to justify all of the advice by spending more time with the it-stuff and learning to accommodate how it wanted to be used. Then, the learning curve for anything else was certainly due to its inferiority. FW at the time complied by providing tests of tools available with buy recommendations, and the new LN chisels, of course, fared better than anything else. I needed mortise chisels, and that meant there was really only one choice (but they were square sided and gosh were they tough to use. Anything else would've been worse, though, I had the comparison article to prove it).

We're only about 10% of the market, apparently (people who read forums). The fact that the (automatic) answer is no longer a brese infill, a scraper plane or a bevel up plane when someone talks about tearout may not parallel actual sales of goods.

This isn't all "PT barnum is trying to get us", though. Tom reminds us from time to time what it was actually like to woodwork in the 1980s and 1970s when there really wasn't a market and someone had to create something current. the manufacturers have to figure out more variables than we do with wants (how to design things, make them efficiently, support them, cover costs, and perhaps the most important thing from a humanitarian point of view - give people meaningful jobs in the process.)