Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Elusive Tools - What's yours?

Posts

Elusive Tools - What's yours?

#1

Elusive Tools - What's yours?

david weaver

I'm (I think) at the end of my tool buying binge after a decade and a half of a torrid pace. that's involved selling off a lot of things that I didn't find that great.

On the other side where there was a discussion re: designs of certain chisels, Wiley mentioned "we know that you have a preference for older english patterns in tools".

I'm sure that I've actually used that term, "english pattern" for tang chisels with a bolster, but I don't see myself as a "team" guy on anything, and (jokingly), I thought "Oh yeah, i'll prove you wrong!! I've got those in american made tools".

I don't know that much history about all of the makers. I assume that the Bucks went back and forth, and I don't know which tools were made where, so in that sense, I've got a gaggle of Buck tools. Maybe some americans.

But tang chisels surviving in any significant numbers from the turn of the century era don't seem to be that common with an american mark.

I found a single solitary LI&J white tang chisel with a forged bolster in my cabinet today. I have always admired their style (wiley's probably right, I gravitate to what's a more English style) and thought drawings of them were really striking in catalogs, but have not found much that isn't a large gouge, slick, framing chisel etc (things I don't really have a need for).

So, that makes them my elusive tool. Li&J white "normal" tang style bench chisels.

Here is a picture from a maybe long sold listing, non matching, but one of the close ups shows how neatly they were made.

https://www.jimbodetools.com/products/extra-fine-set-of-eight-l-ij-white-beveled-tang-chisels-in-leather-roll-79338

Re: Elusive Tools - What's yours?

#2

Re: Elusive Tools - What's yours?

Wiley Horne

Hi David and all,

My ears were burning, so thought I’d speak up. There are two groups of tools I have a never-ending wantsa for—early-American ones, and certain hammers.

For example, here are two Jo. Fuller ogees, from around 1800:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/48002951638/in/album-72157708928491397/

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/48002934592/in/album-72157708928491397/

They still make beautiful profiles, and I’ll ask you to take my word for it for right now. And the irons take plenty of use. I think (not sure) that the Americans were still using imported English steel at that time. Under the mercantile economics imposed on the colonies at that time, the Americans shipped iron (and cotton, for example), and then bought the finished steel and woven goods from English factories.

Another vision quest was for a smithing hammer, a real one. Kayoko, who some of you know, sent me this one:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/48002950838/in/album-72157708928491397/

It’s about a pound and a half. For scale, shown here with a chu tataki chisel. I really like it for mortising. Different view:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/48003016778/in/album-72157708928491397/

Wiley

Re: Elusive Tools - What's yours?

#3

Re: Elusive Tools - What's yours?

david weaver

Wiley, you have such good taste. Those planes both have great style.

I have some irons that date back to the early 1800s, and I don't know what the steel is that they have in them (english or whatever it may be), but it's exceedingly fine.

Never thought about a smiths hammer for mortises, but it does seem very directed.

Re: Elusive Tools - What's yours?

#4

Re: Elusive Tools - What's yours?

TomD

One of my long searched for tools was a whaleback saw, which I eventually got in Mass. Another was one of those saws that FK has that saws around the corner when making certain dovetails. I am more waiting for some manufacturer to come out with one, and at this point it looks as though it will never happen.

I also chased the elusive blacksmith hammer. I think I got two, but I can't remember whether they were of the size for chisels, which would seem to be some kind of kludge. What they actually are, or how they started was just cutting off the back of a sledge. I have seen that tool, and made one myself.

Another tool I liked and found after a while was one of those Japanese hammers with the plane tapping, end, or whatever that is for, but in a huge size. I got a pretty large on, but probably not huge, forget the spec. Maybe 750 grams.

The longest and most frustrating search was for any kind of saw that would cut dovetails as though it was meant to. I did get one early on, a Masterpiece Tools value saw. But it was so fragile I barely used it. What was wanted was a good tool that worked as though it meant it, that could be sharpened by the owner, and didn't cost a fortune. And they are heavy on the ground at this point, but man, it was a long wait.

Re: Elusive Tools - What's yours?

#5

whalebacks and bent saws..

David Weaver

..I also had a jones for a maebiki. Last year when I was buying and reselling stones from japan yahoo, I found a gaggle of maebiki over there and they're cheap as long as you're willing to wait for ground shipping.

I found a nice one (scouting the listings waiting for one with good teeth, not so much corrosion and relatively large size) for about $75 plus another $50 shipping.

Tons of them listed on ebay, but they're being flipped and cost much more.

As you're aware with FK's saw, many of the non-premium bow saw blades are soft enough that they'll tolerate being gradually bent the same way fk does it. I wonder what the results of that saw would look like in hardwood dovetails, though (or if it would be able to make its turn in hardwood). I only make a drawer a couple of times a year, so it's not on my list, but should be easy to make.

Life without a bandsaw has given me the impetus to make several frame and bow saws dedicated to faster work.

Re: Elusive Tools - What's yours?

#6

Re: Question Wiley

Hank Knight

Is Kayoko still brokering tools? I haven't heard from her in a long time. Is she still at Misugi Designs?

Re: Elusive Tools - What's yours?

#7

Re: Question Wiley

Wiley Horne

Hello Hank and all,

Some years ago, Kayoko sold all her inventory to Hida Tool, and retired. This was about the time Yataiki died, and she was very instrumental in helping care for him in his last days. She has a daughter who is a physical therapist (at last report), and a son who is a pediatrician (also at last report) in the Bay Area.

I heard from her last September from this email, for those who wish to drop her a line:

kuroiwausa@gmail.com

Wiley

Re: Elusive Tools - What's yours?

#8

Re: whalebacks and bent saws..

TomD

I got mine around 2003, might have still been during ebay's beanie baby phase. I did find one I liked a year or so ago, but since I hardly use the one from '03, I didn't buy it.

I have seen various attempts to home make the FK saw, and the problem is the brake to get a long low angle kink free bend is not easy to find. The samples I have seen showed the concept worked, which is obvious, but they did not seem like something I would want to actually use.

The problem is that, as you know, every dovetail joint, conventionally cut requires one to "crosscut" the equivalent of one end of a meeting board by chopping it with a chisel. If they are not all that efficient they may precede that cut with crosscutting their plank with a fine toothed fret saw. Despite the handtool revolution, I do not see many people paring back their tool kit to not include a crosscut saw, but they are happy to crosscut planks when dovetailing, using a chisel or a fret saw.

None of this is too wearing until you get into making really huge boxes. I made some furniture for my shop that were like large blanket cases, and require maybe 8 feet of dovetail. I just had to find a work around for that kind of grunt work, that did not involve all the messing around. But it isn't a subject for this board.

I can't imagine not having a bandsaw. I have 5, which is crazy also. When i started out, they were probably 1/3rd the price of a car, say 2K in late 70s. Not a car guy, maybe they were already more expensive. I know we bought a Volvo at the factory for 3K in the mid 70s.

Anyway, that was way out of reach. Then the Chinese tools came along, under 400. I keep getting ones people are getting rid of. I am at a transition point where I will need to cut back, so I already have a small inca I can use when I have to get rid of the large one which is a Laguna. They sent the laguna out without their decals for some reason, it has an Italian decal on it. Thanks for making my resale easy!

I did the panel resaw thing in the 80s. It was necessary due to the cost of alternatives. While I like the fact the shop provides exercise, I am no more going back to that than I am walking to and from the lumberyard. But I am tempted to try out some of the new hardware that keeps popping up.

Re: Elusive Tools - What's yours?

#9

Re: Question Wiley

Kevin Adams

I also emailed with Kayoko last fall. I’m always delighted when I hear from her and thanks for the reminder as I will reach out. She was organizing a trip to Japan and was encouraging me to consider it, although the timing was not right for me. I was also asking about Imai and he is getting up there, but still making chisels. Kayoko is as special and spiritual as they come.

Hope you’re well, Wiley, take care.

Kevin

Re: Elusive Tools - What's yours?

#10

Re: Question Wiley

Wiley Horne

Hi Kevin and Hank,

Doing OK. I was prompted by Hank’s inquiry to fire off an email to her yesterday—she got right back as usual. She is full of energy, and gives tutorials to her granddaughter’s 3rd grade class, then goes and visits in the Bay Area with her son and other grandkids. She did get a small Japan trip organized this past March-April and a few went. She also goes on her own to see her mother in a care situation, and for an annual Yataiki memorial service, with his 3 daughters and their husbands. He had no son, so the smithing came to an end in that family.

Apparently she keeps up contacts in Japan and said if I wanted anything from over yonder to let her know.

Wiley

Re: Elusive Tools - What's yours?

#11

Re: Question Wiley

Hank Knight

Thanks for the update, Wiley. I'm glad to know that Kayoko is still "up and around." She is a special lady in my book. I lost track of he when she returned to Japan to care for Yataiki in his last days. The email address you published for her is the same one I have.

Re: Elusive Tools - What's yours?

#12

Re: Question Wiley

Kevin Adams

Thanks, Wiley and Hank. Kayoko embodies grace for sure and glad she is well.

Take care, fellows.

Kevin