Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Marples chisels: trying again

Posts

Marples chisels: trying again

#1

Marples chisels: trying again

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I owned some Marples chisels, purchased new, back in the 1970s. I found them frustrating: they chipped way too easily. So I got rid of them. Today, at a moving sale, I gave in to temptation, and purchased a full set of Marples chisels with boxwood handles, nearly unused although a touch rusty. We'll see if I have the same issues, or if I'm smarter now and thus better able to use them.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#2

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

Kevin French

Good luck, I have a set of Blue Handles that I use for non-essential cuts. I like them.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#3

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

Doug Reynolds

I have a set of the Blue Handle version. One chips constantly.

They are now my “rough” work chisels.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#4

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill

I have a small set of the bench chisels, plus a larger number of gouges. I admit that I am a sucker for the boxwood handles. I love the looks.

The bench chisels I have are light and wonderful in the hand. The edges do not last long, and one must be prepared to hone frequently. No chipping, just dulling. Definitely not a chisel for chopping (mine at least).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#5

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

Jim Matthews

May I suggest the "convex bevel" approach?

My set is likely from the 1970's (handles say MARPLES RIDGEWAY) and I use them constantly - even shallow mortises - and they're decent steel.

I don't use power grinders, so the first licks on a coarse stone took awhile.

Now, a medium fine stone and strop are sufficient.

There are more precise approaches but this works.

Fine India (carborundum) /Lily White Oachita /Strop with jeweler's rouge

I had poor results with more coarse stones, in which the steel "plowed" tracks.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#6

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

David Weaver

The boxwood chisels are pretty and can be rehardened if they're not right.

I have a set of those that I mentioned several weeks ago. I also had two blue chip sets from UK manufacture, and each was decent with the exception of one soft chisel. Not the same size between the two. I ultimately sold the., but could have rehardened the soft ones.

George Wilson did all of his work with a single older set of pre chrome vanadium marples and he said they were all suitably hard, with one overhard that broke.

The older chisels that I've used, and I have a couple now, were probably more typical Sheffield hardness of 61 or so. Entirely different than the more recent ones.

Strangely enough, the recent Sheffield blue chips unused are not very good but the sets with no use or very little use bring an absurd amount.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#7

I'd be interested to hear...

david weaver

...what you come up with when you get a chance to use these. I realize it may be a little while before you have the opportunity to prep and use them.

When I got mine, I was in one of those wild hair moods where I though "when these come in, if they're decent, I'll sell most of the rest of my chisels and finally settle on something in a proportion i like" :b

That's sort of a dumb thought, though I do plan to dump a bunch of stuff.

I tried working the bevel on the first one and then paring across cherry and the edge rolled over. Not a little, but a LOT. So, I honed some off and had increased the initial quite a lot (I didn't want to file the chisel and mar it) and realized that it was unhardened.

I checked around out of curiosity today as these appear to have been made in pretty large numbers with the round bolster, and I saw several other folks who mentioned having to reharden them (rather than just coddle them a little). It's a shame as they're a nice proportion for a handle gripper.

I also had a set of three parers from the same era (they said "chrome xxxxxx" something or other on the back in print and they worked quite well). Luck of the draw, I guess.

When I buy something I don't need and it ends up in my drawers (I'll never sell anything substandard), my first reaction is "well, great, this is what I get for buying stuff I don't need. Now I can either throw them away, sell them as defective and unhardened at a great loss or faff around with them and make them reasonably hard and then still probably sell them at a loss".

At least they harden fine in soy oil.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#8

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

TomD

I got a set for my father about 20 years ago, and I ground the ends off so about half the blade was gone, makes a really nice chisel with the right harmonics... For a Marples. Really, they are a steel spike, for softer wood, cherry and down, work fine.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#9

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

Warren in Lancaster, PA

This reminds me of the time I read on this forum that Henry Taylor carving tools were good for cherry and pine, but would just fold over if used on white oak. At the time I was just finishing up carving white oak for four months straight, all day, every day, with H Taylor tools. Production work, as much as my body would take. I have done a lot of work in white oak with Marples chisels also. Maybe people think that because the wood is hard they have to beat the crap out of the chisels.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#10

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

david weaver

When the marples chisels are OK (as my parers were), they are fine.

The trouble with them is that they sometimes release chisels or entire sets that are partially or mostly unhardened.

Robert Sorby's more recent offerings are more uniform, but are several points softer than they should be. A member on another forum did some hardness testing of current and some older chisels and found them to be somewhere in the ballpark of 57 hardness, which doesn't sound like much, but there aren't many vintage chisels there.

He speculate that there is an ASTM standard for chisels to be listed as "chisels" from a trade perspective and that 60 hardness is above it.

The first thing I tried the sorby chisels on cherry. They didn't tolerate it. Whether or not mine are also 57, I don't know. I set them aside (i like their proportions). This weekend, I dovetailed a pine drawer for a cabinet (it only had one drawer). They worked great. They probably need a couple of degrees more to hold up better in slightly harder stuff, but they're already just south of 30 degrees.

It depends if things are a little soft or if they went through a defective period.

57 is usable, you could learn to live with it. 60/61 makes for a chisel that holds up well on cherry and works cleanly on pine, too. The marples set that i had must've missed the water (or whatever fluid is spashed on modern chisels that are zooming by on a line after being heated by induction) on the hardening process.

Henry taylor covers a very broad range. more than half of my carving tools are henry taylor, and not new, but not 150 years old. they are fine - harder than the two R. Sorby sets of chisels that I have. They may have also gone through a process change at some point that made they iffy.

The other kind of obnoxious thing about chisels that are just above the mid 50s is that oilstones will hone them even when an oilstone is settled. I mean hone them fast. The R. Sorby chisels will raise a pretty stout wire edge even when you're trying to finish an edge. Their softness returns a second favor by making the larger than expected wire edge much more persistent (but they do hold up well in pine).

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#11

Window of hardness

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There is a window of hardness for usable tools. Too hard and the chisel might chip, too soft and the chisel might fold. I find that window to be rather large. I almost never get chipping or folding in chisels.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#12

Re: 58-62

David Weaver

I've had some tools tested in the past and would put the window around 58-62.

It sounds narrower than a beginning woodworker might suspect. At 58, anything will form a fairly large wire edge on an oil stone. At 62, an oil stone is starting to struggle.

More than half of the difference that people perceive with a2 vs o1 is a difference in spec hardness

What I found hardness testing is that I had a chisel that I couldn't get anything out of

It was a witherby parer, and I tried to give it to a friend. He had it and a bunch of other stuff tested on a version three strikes and averaged them. The chisel tested 53. I had another witherby socket chisel that had a nice profile, and it tested 59. It was decent, but not great compared to older tang chisels.

Ln's mortise chisel and an iyoroi mortise chisel both tested 61. I didn't have any good quality Japanese chisels back then, but they're carbon steel so I can get a pretty good guess now based on japanese stones that I have, or if I get some well made Japanese chisels that are several points soft, they will sharpen wonderfully on a washita alone (too hard for much removal, but they can be kept in shape indefinitely). Because they're at the stone's limits, they'll take a very fine edge whereas the witherby chisels will take something that I'd call serviceable.

I've found over the years that Japanese makers who advise that they have a very easy sharpening plane iron made of some kind of specialty steel, often swedish, the real difference is that they're usually tempered software.

When Japanese makers stick to some of the book specs and go way up in hardness, natural Japanese stones struggle with them, too, despite being fifteen percent or a little more aluminum oxide.

The other thing I found is that when a tool is marginal, it'll usually go from very poor performing to fine in just two or three degrees. Ultra hard Japanese chisels tend to have a more spectacular type of failure

....like loss of corners until you find where they hold up.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#13

Re: 58-62

David Weaver

Not hard and fast and not to suggest Japanese chisels can't perform well above 62 hardness as they definitely can.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#14

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

Jim Matthews

This is an important, and overlooked point regarding tool use.

We don't have this sort of discussion regarding handplanes; if the shaving is too heavy it jams up the works.

I have often blundered past fine tools that didn't respond to heavy handed use.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#15

Re: Use it the way that it wants to be used...

david weaver

..One of the things that magazine reviews and tests don't do well is conveying the idea that a tool generally will have a way that it wants to be used or sharpened.

But not some kind of woo thing, where it's some big secret to be sharpened a certain way (geometry, that is, not an arbitrary level of polish), just that some chisels that seem subpar are all of the sudden fine with two more degrees - whether they're hard or soft. We can curse them for days on end about not being what we wanted if they don't work in preset parameters, or found out how they like to be used and then just do that.

The menu of tools left that can't be accommodated (with very little adjustment) to do anything useful and productive is very small, and limited mostly to entirely defective designs or tools with makers' defects.

The strawman beginner with a 3 pound hammer hitting as hard as they can notwithstanding.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#16

Re: Use it the way that it wants to be used...

Jim Matthews

"The strawman beginner with a 3 pound hammer hitting as hard as they can notwithstanding..."

That describes my first years, rather neatly.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#17

And that...

John in NM

Reminds me of the first workbench I made out of 2x4's and CDX plywood with what I thought at the time was clever "joinery" :D

I had some rather soft yellow handled Stanley chisels that would fold when trying to chop through spruce.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#18

Re: Use it the way that it wants to be used...

david weaver

I didn't do too much of that, but I tested the limits of good taste on how low a bevel could be, and then did try the 3 pound hammer after seeing an actual professional do it (actually, I think it was a short handled 6 pound hammer in the hands of a dai maker named hisao. He was taking huge amounts of macassar ebony out of a dai, and not subtly. I didn't find anything remotely similar to that to work well and gave up quickly. That was part of the story of how I got the imai timberframing chisel to fail - a 3 pound hammer. I would've given it a pass if a $15 vintage US timber framing chisel hadn't held up better in the same task with the same hammer)

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#19

Re: Window of hardness

TomD

Me too, people pry, they chip, and sometime news ones chipped, or used to. Modern tools are prepped for the duffer who will send them out to be sharpened.

There are chisels that are intentionally manufactured for tool belts or like users, to be sharpened with a file, on the jobsite. The Bluechips I bought, actual plastic ones when I started out, were in that neighborhood. That was late 70s or early 80s. Other people's mileage may vary. It isn't a flaw, and if anyone wants to show their superiority by chopping in ebony with that kind of tool, go right ahead. Mighty stylish of you.

I had one batch of horrible plane irons I tempered out of doors during winter, some cracked, others looked OK. I did have a rockwell machine at the time, but they looked OK. I used the file on them, but that can be unreliable depending on the surface. If the file seems to skate, going at it over and over can ruin the file, so I missed one. I put it in my jack plane prototype worked fine, seemed to hold an edge. Then at one point I hit one heck of a hard knot, and it bent the end of the blade. I felt silly, but what was really remarkable was that the plane had seemed to wear nicely and do good work. Kinda the same exception as those hand filed floats people used to make that did not get heat treated, but worked anyway. The reality is that people once worked wood with copper tools.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#20

Jack planes are a nice exception

David Weaver

It's funny you mention a soft iron in a Jack plane. In my travels in planemaking, I've run across some soft irons. I never put a new iron in my wooden planes because I don't like the way that they look. That leaves me picking up irons on Ebay or from English tool sellers.

Two of the older irons are often soft. Dwight and French, and butcher. They work great in Jack planes, and to some extent try planes. A hard iron in a Jack plane really gives no payoff. In a smoother, yes, because clearance is so critical, but not in a Jack plane.

Not all butcher irons are soft, but many are. I've only had two dwight and French irons and can't conclude anything for sure with two. The very soft one that I have encourages the user to set the shaving thicker where clearance is less of an issue. I think I learned more about productivity from soft irons than hard ones.

My favorite try plane iron is a butcher iron that's not at all soft, and came from Jim Andrews who I'm assuming is the Jim Matthews posting on here.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#21

Re: Dodo makes a plane

TomD

I have been making planes for 40 years, and so a number of mistakes have occurred, Usually not terribly costly ones. The jack problem was solved with a new blade. It is interesting to hear your experience with blade softness. That is curious. The way old blacksmiths worked, it was hardly any more difficult to make a fully hardened blade than a soft one, though if they used a less hardenable steel it might have been cheaper. I have never thought of making a blade for this kind of use out of hi tens steel and super quenching it, but maybe that would work, though I don't particularly need to do that.

The other oddity I created making a jack plane was one with a self wedging Japanese iron, a cheap one. It works great but I didn't count on the handle making it difficult to remove the blade with hammer strikes. I could have placed the iron a little further forward, but my personal preference is for centrally located irons, when possible. Turned out that was not the best option in this case.

Re: Marples chisels: trying again

#22

Re: Dodo makes a plane

David Weaver

It's not so much that I look for a soft blade, but more that if I have a softer 2 1/8 double iron set that really isn't great for a smoother, it'll still do well in a Jack.

Too soft for a smoother to me is something that is subjectively below about 58. A couple of more points below that and it starts to feel like you could roll a burr on a blade.

I've also got a big cocobolo coffin smoother that I put a marbles blade in that's a little soft just because it was a nice blade and cap iron. It just isn't up to much fine smoothing work, so I set it aside and use it set at five thousandths to remove planer chatter with the cap iron set property so that it doesn't create tear out. One or two passes across a board and everything is clean..no chip marks from the planer rollers and no chatter. It'll do that type of thing for a long time before needing to be resharpened since clearance is less critical the thicker the shaving becomes. At least clearance in the sense of the tiny amount of contact that occurs with a dulling blade.

The double irons that I have gotten are probably almost entirely in the 58-62 range discussed a couple of days ago and all of the vintage Japanese irons and chisels a probably well harder.