Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

Posts

Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#1

Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

David Weaver

Hi Mike - seeing as I resigned my membership on SMC, I can't respond to your post there about Phil's chisels.

That era of marples is hit or miss, but they are very pretty and somewhat substantial but nice-to-hold chisels.

I have a set of them where 4 or 5 of the 8 are unhardened and the rest are OK, but could use rehardening, too.

I wouldn't search them out unless you're comfortable rehardening them. You might get something good or you might not.

If you can find an older set in that style with an octagonal bolster or even just dull looking handles, they'll be better for most things. Phil's working mostly mahogany in his videos, which doesn't really differentiate one chisel from another.

I did have a set of parers from that era (sold them), and they were quite nice, took a nice edge and held it well. I sold them when I found older parers. They generally (anything 70s or later, guessing a little at the time frame) say "chrome vanadium" or something on the backs, but I wouldn't lump them in with that sort of cheap coarse grading - they were just below some of the better vintage chisels.

Their proportions make it somewhat important that you're a handle gripper and not a blade gripper if you decide to search them out. I'd suggest the older versions, but I think the style is dandy.

Heavier than ashley iles chisels on the bigger chisels by a good bit. I believe they're forged in a die, probably hardened in open atmosphere in a bath/splashed on a moving line at high speed (thus the failure to be done right sometimes - it's not possible for them to be as bad as mine are if they are done by any careful process).


Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#2

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

David Weaver



Not sure what happened with the picture links.

I'll give the set more care once they're actually all usable. Unhardened isn't an exaggeration on the bad ones of these, there is no wood that they could be used with - not even balsa.

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#3

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I saw that thread on SMC, and could have replied (to the question what chisels) as I had recently watched Phil Lowe in a video. My apology.

These Maples boxwood handled chisels have become very popular since Paul Sellers began using them in his videos. I do love the look of the handles, and the blades are slim, which adds to a more delicate feel. But, as David notes, the blades are likely to be variable. I have a small set, collected individually. They take a good edge, but do not hold it long. I want to use them, but quickly become frustrated as they dull.

Regards from Perth

Derek

ps. David, what is the point in resigning from SMC if you continue to read the forum? Why not post there, than do so here for there?

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#4

Older steel and species match

Jim Matthews

To be fair, do you find Cast steel adequate for imported (to Oz) species?

I had some South American Angelim Pedra that was impervious to my handtools.

On North American Cherry or Walnut, plain Jane Marples do just fine.

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#5

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have some Marples chisels from 35 and 40 years ago. They are certainly adequate for professional work.

My cast steel chisels from early 1800's can make hundreds of end grain cuts on the dreaded Jarrah and still pare end grain quite nicely. We have some hard woods here in Pennsylvania also, but we generally don't use them for cabinetmaking.

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#6

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

david weaver

Philosophical difference about how Keith treats people with experience (not me) when they offer firm opinions. I don't browse it every day.

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#7

Inflection Point

david weaver

At some point, marples went from chisels that we'd typically see to ...I don't know what.

By what we'd typically see, I mean like stormont, older marples with the clover, etc, I. Sorby...whatever the maker may have been.

I'm sure cost pressures and decline in purchasers from cabinetmakers to construction trades put the pressure on them to change what they were doing.

four or five of these chisels would never have done any work. I'm not sure how old they are for sure. The others in this group were no prize, either, perhaps high saw temper.

Before the inflection point, George got a set of these and I think he said something along the lines of having done all of his professional work with them. He guessed at 61 or so hardness for his - two different animals.

The parers I had were just fine, too. But fine is fine, and I could've lived with them without issue if I hadn't found nicer and older chisels for the same money.

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#8

Re: Older steel and species match

david weaver

I'd say that the parers that I had (which were quite good), were a step below cast steel. Both in hardness and in gumminess, but the ones I had were nicely proportioned and not fat (I wouldn't have gotten them if they weren't).

There's an alternate discussion going on over there that I saw about japanese chisels. I'd agree with pete, if you're just looking for something that holds an edge well, japanese chisels do it better when set up properly than anything else I've found.

But I also found when mortising a couple of cocobolo plane bodies that I could take a typical older stanley chisel and add less angle than I thought and get them to hold up very well.

I didn't pay that much for the marples chisels that I bought ($160 or something for a set of 10 unused), and they'll be worth that when I've rehardened all of them, but I paid about the same amount for a set of shipped ashley iles bench chisels (which are much less heavy - especially in the larger sizes), and none of the marples chisels of that era would be the equal.

In all of the things that I've bought - I thought about showing my chisel racks in case someone would accuse me of not having the things that I say I have, but the volume of crap that I have might draw some heat....anyway, in all of the things that I've bought, this is probably the worst set of chisels and I'd imagine it was just a short term quality problem, but they're there.

Few of the sets of chisels I had wouldn't be good for everything set up properly. Even stuff like cocobolo.

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#9

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Warren, I am interested in your opinion what available (modern) chisels do you consider to be the closest match to yours?

Japanese (the ones that are hand wrought)? Others?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#10

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

david weaver

Not speaking for warren, but just providing a side comment as someone who shuffles through things out of curiosity.

The only modern chisels that have the same feel as a typical 61 hardness vintage cast steel chisel ( in terms of steel ) are decent quality japanese chisels that aren't as hard as they say they are.

Iyoroi come to mind - some of those aren't that great, some are fine. I had a set of wrought white #2 chisels that probably were 61/62 hardness and sharpened well on oilstones. I liked the trade off better than the chisels that are in the nearly untempered range - they were more practical for work.

In proportion, the ashley iles chisels are closest to the vintage chisels for handle grippers, but on the light side of things. similar steel/edge holding, not quite as "dry", but only a person using natural oilstones would notice the difference.

A friend and I had a whole bunch of chisels tested on a versitron years ago. we had one iyoroi mortise chisel that was probably specified at 64, but it averaged 61, and sharpened like 61. It would probably be quite nice to use, but he's the kind of person who doesn't use hand tools unless he has to. I broke a much "nicer" japanese mortise chisel at the lamination line - one that was truly full hardness - miyanaga, I think. They don't take abuse, but it wasn't getting abuse. I'd assume that there was some fault.

i'll stop before I risk going on about 80 different types of chisels.

The best way for someone to get vintage chisels of good quality is just to look at uk ebay (they bring money now, though - there's a nice set of marples shamrock on ebay that will probably cost close to what good new chisels cost when all is said and done).

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#11

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, in bench chisels I have used Iyoroi for about 15 years. I prefer Koyamaichi, which I have used for over 10 years. I have Kiyohisa parers, which are simply out of this world - sharpen easily and hold an edge so well. But of course they only get pushed, so the dynamics are different. I have just received a 1" Kiyohisa bench chisel, and will be using it in my current build soon.

I suspect that Warren will say that the Japanese steel may resemble that of the old blades he has, but Japanese chisels are different in regard to chisel design (e.g. blade thickness), and so a comparison here may be difficult.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#12

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

david weaver

>differences, differences<

That's one of the reasons that I don't get on SMC, the discussion doesn't evolve. I don't know how many times I can type the same counterpoint to things like "hollow grinds make chisels weak and should be avoided" or "lie niesen says not to use a grinder" or "makers 150 did the best they could with what they had, but tools are better now".

The differences that I perceive after who knows...80 sets of chisels and another couple hundred oddballs......I don't know what people want to know, but limited bandwidth and my final thought about them is just like sharpening stones. I doubt the new ones are really better than the old ones, but I also think the equation is 85% user and 15% tool.

re: the iyorois, mine were kamaji backed iyorois and for whatever reason (care? I don't know), they were better finished and more consistent (in terms of edge holding) than the typical red oak handled inexpensive iyorois. If they were 62 hardness (my guess, the oilstones will quickly rat out anything that's not 63/64 or harder - those chisels will not sharpen well on novaculite, and anything softer than 61 or so will sharpen quickly), they were the best 62 hardness chisels I've had.

At the same time, I had older ouchis that were definitely full hardness, koyamaichi chisels (which are separated fairly little from the best chisels when it comes to edge holding, they're just made in dies and coarsely finished), and a couple of kiyotadas - and then maybe 40 unallocated older japanese chisels and another set of multihollow older more delicate chisels. Only the iyorois were softer than their spec, but they always seem to be. I think they prefer it, and for heavy work, I do, too. heavy handedness with chisels like the ouchis or anything else that's 65/66 hardness will lead to broken chisel corners and some of those chisels will not tolerate any harsh abrasives or the edges will crumble in later sharpening stages. For mortising planes or fast work in dovetail sockets (as in, also heavy handed, not tidy show-me type work), they're also better.

But their proportions are not like western chisels, only their edges are.

as you know, I took microscope pictures of various edges, and what I found by guessing was confirmed - those iyorois liked natural stones a lot and their hardness was ideal for them. They took a better edge off of oilstones and natural waterstones than most western chisels because they were a little harder, but they lacked fragility that some harder japanese chisels have and that. Very good chisels tainted both by a name as well as the spec book desire to have a 65 hardness chisel.

Rob (can't remember his last name) did a nice hardness test on various chisels, and as many stones and tools as I've been through, when someone tells me they have a 65 or 66 hardness chisel that sharpens really easily on natural stones, I usually speculate that the chisels aren't 65 or 66 hardness. People love tasai chisels and some of the other "specially refined" chisels from certain makers, but the ones that sharpen really easily are just softer. Nobody wants to admit that they like a tool that's softer (not aimed toward you, just people in general). It goes across hobbies. Thiers issard tried to make ungodly hard razors out of carbonsong 135. In public view, everyone gushes about them. In private messages, I would get "hey, do you know what stone will sharpen this razor? the edge seems to crumble easily when finish it, and i can't get it sharp". It's too hard. sell it to someone else and get a razor that was made for a professional user, and not a catalog spec.

That said, the vintage japanese chisels that I've gotten in odd lots from buyee are often also very very hard. A couple are a match for the best chisels I've ever seen, but they're $8 or $10 a piece if you're willing to get rid of the half of the lot that aren't that great.

It's fun for me to look at all of these things out of curiosity, but I tend to favor the western types because of the way I sharpen, or the iyorois. I could sit and do a case of half blind sockets with the iyorois (again, not the production ones) with a single natural finish stone and spend about 5 or 6 minutes total and have a fresh chisel at the end. Never having to stand to do anything other than switch boards. A full hardness chisel may have done the same thing at two degrees less total angle, but i never appreciated the punishment they could dole out if a corner disappeared.

Shape and steel like vintage chisels if this is a tight constraints conversation? There isn't anything out there, nobody has the skill or patience to make chisels as fine now. Oil hardening is close. I could get along very comfortably doing almost everything I've done with a $35 set of mifer chisels off of ebay, though. With their proportions as they are, I'd prefer them over lie nielsen's chisels.

Maybe I'd have different opinions if I worked with 2000 hardness janka wood all the time. Cocobolo is the only thing that's hard that I'll work with on a regular basis - i challenged myself to use a stanley chisel to do a couple of plane bodies, and then the same in beech, and found that I was fine with them. An extra two or three degrees made a chisel that I thought wasn't holding up well hold up really well, and it was a little less slick through the wood, but something I wouldn't notice without doing an a-b side by side comparison.

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#13

Re: The original point of reply to Mike...

david weaver

...lost from my advice as someone who has actually bought these chisels..

... if there's a desire to get chisels of that style, go older and don't buy exactly the same thing that phil has. There's a fairly high chance of being disappointed with marples chisels after the cross over from drill rod die forged chisels (probably made of something like O1 or "silver steel" drill rod that gets a nice gray patina with age).

The older chisels disappoint very rarely. The newer ones, not a majority of the time, but often enough - I'd go so far as to say with marples in general, having had about five sets of their chisels (all blue chips from sheffield or higher spec), only the three parers didn't have a chisel in the group that wasn't off. I can only guess that the hardening process is the splash type on a machine that doesn't do consistent work.

The type of hardening that I'm talking about can be seen with buck brothers on "how it's made" with chisels on youtube.

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#14

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks for the detailed reply, David.

"Rob (can't remember his last name)" .... I think that was Rob Streeper.

A comment regarding the Koyamaichi. The 8 Iyoroi I have are mentori shaped and used as general purpose bench chisels, but the 6 Koyamaichi are shinogi and used for dovetails. The larger Koyamaichi (12mm - 19mm) are from the early 80's, while the smaller ones (3mm - 6mm) were shaped for me by Mr Koyama (Stu contacted me about a year before he began selling Koyamaichi on his site, and set this up for me). Apparently, Mr Koyama was amused that I wanted these smaller chisels to have minimal lands. For all this, I think that you are correct that Koyamaichi are not as well finished as other makes (the single Kiyohisa mentori I have is a work of art). On the other hand, they hold a great edge and hold up to hard woods. Before these I had a few Matsumura, and they chipped. I was not impressed with them.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#15

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I bought some Aldi chisels out of curiosity, but otherwise have not bought a 20th or 21st century chisel in 35 years. I have never owned a Japanese tool.

I know four blacksmiths who are capable of making 18th century style chisels, the kind that a journeyman cabinetmaker could buy for roughly an hour's wages in the 1790's. I tried to order chisels from two of these but had no success. One was quite put off when I said he did not have to bother making a handle. How could a woodworker make a handle as fine as a blacksmith?

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#16

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

david weaver

Well finished isn't intended to mean anything other than that. I had the dovetail versions of the KI, and I had a couple of "matsumura" paring chisels, which were probably on par with the production iyorois. The edges were a little crumbly, they were just OK.

The KI chisels were great. Hard and though they weren't pored over in terms of finish, they were neat enough.

I recall the picture of your early dovetail chisels. People tend to see what they want to, so when the shinogi style cabinet chisels showed up, everyone called them dovetail chisels and remarked that the lands were flat. The KI chisels that were then made and sold at LV with the tiny lands are excellent for what people think they want to do with "dovetail" chisels, but they can be a pain to sharpen - at least relatively, due to the tiny cross section.

The subtle fine finish on the nicer chisels is a work of art, but I get the sense that it's important for a maker to get the balance of hardness right and use good stock and not ruin it in processing. KI's process is simple, I know he uses dies to forge the chisels. That probably prevents him from making the stinkers that occur occasionally with the more involved makers.

Many of the very hard much older chisels that I have don't have the extreme amount of time spent on finish like the later kiyotada or the kiyohisa types. They often show up with a rounded bevel on them - nobody likes that dirty secret, but they are not amateur chisels. I'd suspect their hardness dictated that for day to day use - so they could be ground quickly. Some are very contrary to natural stones of any type due to their hardness. I flatten them out for aesthetics, but would make note that this isn't the kind of sloppy care that a lot of western tools get, but rather carefully maintained (they're still sharp and were deliberately done the way they were done).

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#17

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

david weaver

I can't imagine any blacksmiths making chisels even though I'm sure some could.

They'd probably have to make something thinner and straighter than they'd want to make, and it would take a long time to get good at doing it quickly - even for a good smith.

If there is anyone who can make and finish an octagonal bolster in all steel, and quickly, I don't know who they are. George mentioned that they troubled over the bolster at Williamsburg and thought they'd devised a way to get one forged, but the first guess is rarely correct (that last part is my own comment).

Then you start running into a blacksmith's opinions - if you said you'd like 1 to 1.1 carbon steel at least as pure as silver steel, I'd imagine they'd have a preference for something else, like 1080 or something like that. It just seems like an impossible task for anyone other than a semi-retired enthusiast to take on.

Die forging and then hand finishing could make a very very good older style chisel, but there's way too much hand work involved and too small of a market.

Not sure who would make the dies - and at least a hydraulic press to work with them would be required.

Someone on sawmill creek or here or anywhere else would see a chisel that was obviously hand done and call it "sloppy". Ashley iles chisels are wonderful, but the bevels are very apparently hand finished. They're thirty dollars each if ordered from the UK without going through the distribution markup here, and without the VAT tax (shipping isn't that much because they're light).

What do they get in return for their lovely work? Forumites calling the bevels "sloppy". They are wonderful in use, consistent in hardness, and not overly heavy in cross section for a handle gripper.

Now that I've switched over to building guitars (which I'd never sell for any reason other than making room), I see gobs of reviews that do not address the core things that make for a great guitar. Instead, they focus on "how do the fret tangs feel? how do the sides of the cavity routs look?"

Who cares? What kind of wood is used, what's the density, what is the orientation, does the neck match it? If it doesn't, some of the guitars described will have movement problems early and more will develop them later.

Only a tiny part of the market rewards doing things right across the board.

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#18

Blacksmiths

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I saw video of a Williamsburg blacksmith making a chisel. He had no trouble making a nice bolster. This video was probably fifteen years ago or more, so George's comment might be somewhat dated.

I was willing to give an unreasonable amount of money for a chisel that might not work so well, just to have an example to show. It would take some real devotion for a blacksmith to learn to make historic chisels that were really fine.

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#19

Re: Blacksmiths

david weaver

You're probably right - george's experience likely predates that.

I'd bet historically, a blacksmith would've done that bolster quickly. I wonder how they did it? did they have a fixture to hammer it to shape and then hand finish it?

I have thought about hammering some stock out and then doing excessive finish work to remove the hammering, and then cut and grind the bolster out, but it would be a waste of time. My experience with the properly oriented ground stock from domestic sources is that it's as good as anything I've ever used - at least in terms of oil hardening steel. It's fine grained, tough and doesn't retain it's wire edge too stubbornly.

I don't know anything about the process used to make it, though - how it's refined. As little as i know about forging (other than just hammering steel into rough shape - not with enough skill to do it without a lot of grinding, etc), I'd probably only make it worse than it already is.

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#20

"How It's Made" Chisel Episode *LINK*

David Bassett

Well that video was hard to find. (Apparently not on YouTube, anymore, and unknown to Google....)

It is the fourth segment in Episode 13 of Season 4 and available from Science Channel's website. It requires a logon with one of a fairly long list of providers. (We have uVerse, I clicked that choice and it automatically logged me in since I was connecting through a uVerse gateway. Don't know details of other options.)

Seeing all the automation used in the chisel factory was very interesting and now I understand "splash type" quenching process. Thanks for the pointer David!


https://www.sciencechannel.com/tv-shows/how-its-made/full-episodes/yacht-wheels-braided-rugs-automobile-thermostats-chisels?

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#21

Re: When you see that, it's kind of alarming..

david weaver

...we all assume first (or some of us do), that either there is some machine immersing chisels into a liquid or there is someone carefully running all of the tools through an automated heat treat process that is also...well, careful.

I saw a razor manufacturer - still in business - hang razor forgings on a wire rack, immerse the razors in what looks like molten lead and then quench them in oil. It would not by any means be an expensive process, but I guess an insurer might not like it because ...what if someone trips and falls in or whatever. Who really knows.

The bottom line is that it's not hard to do much better than a lot of the modern process work like what may have been done to my marples - with nothing more than a two hole coffee can forge and a couple of bucks worth of gas. Every iron that I've minded the details on has turned out great.

The mystery steel chisels that have come soft and who knows whether or not they're supposed to be good coming out of an oil quench....still fine. Not as ideal, but much better than as delivered.

We get a small view of modern process by tools made with care (LN and LV, which are probably done in a vacuum environment or by some automated machine that works to a tight spec) and don't get a good sense for how bad things were after the "inflection point" that I mentioned.

Another interesting one is buck knives. You look at a new 110 and say "not really that neat, but I can't figure out how they'd make it for a price that would wholesale and meet the retail target of $40 or so".

And then you see a guy stick a blank on a wheel, it goes around in a circle and the blade is ground. If that process makes something good, then that's what you get. if it makes something mediocre or inconsistent, then that's what you get.

I'd like to be a fly on the wall in the Ward manufacturing operation 150 years ago. I'm sure it wasn't some little bald guy with an apron poring over the details of every chisel and kissing each one as they were finished, and I'm sure it was plenty industrial. But the result is that each unit was made with deliberate care, and despite the stuff about old chisels being inconsistent, within each actual make, they were VERY consistent. Wards are generally very similar. Buck, very similar. Wards and bucks are different to each other, but that's because they chose different specs. Operations like LN, etc, make nice tools, but they have to be tailored to modern process.

Not sure where I'm going other than that for most folks, beware buying anything made after steel gets dark with age, and don't assume that modern stuff is better than vintage stuff when you get the right vintage. In my estimation, chisels lost their quality first, and then their shape. You can get in trouble buying a chisel that looks like it has nice proportions, but was made after quality went out the window with other details - just like my set of marples. I can clean them up so that they're good, but would anyone ever give $160 for a set of chisels that have been rehardened. I don't know. If I clean them up, maybe. I'd have to be a real jerk to play coy and pass them along the way they came to me.

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#22

Link from youtube...

david weaver

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8fAIdYZYU20

This one is still up, but you're right about youtube. Copyright strikes on videos that generally aren't economically valuable still remove information that is otherwise valuable like this.

I'm speculating, as I've had three different sets of chisels made by buck here - they were all a little soft, almost identical. I'd guess 57/58 hardness based on what the stones say. But, they were relatively uniform.

the first set was the ash handled chisels craftsman studio sold "buck firmers". I sold them on ebay, they cost $89 from craftsman studio and the winning bid was $143 for them used :\

I refunded the guy who won the difference, and he was happy.

Quality of the steel the same as you'd find on the yellow handled ones that used to be on the wall at home depot. Different shape, seemingly same thing.

Somehow, marples managed to do worse than this. If they'd even done something like dipping 100 at a time in molten lead and then oil to quench, none would've been that bad. I guess that was too expensive of a process - or maybe a salesman sold them a dream argument of a machine that did the process and eliminated a skilled worker.

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#23

Re: Link from youtube... *LINK*

David Bassett

That's a better link of the chisel segment. (Neither Google nor YouTube search turned it up for me, it doesn't seem like it should be hard...?)

This thread has me poking around and I notice TFWW has two short videos they shot at Ashley Iles. Not really a step by step process documentation, but it does show banging on metal, (with hammers, power hammers, and die presses,) and actual quench baths. They also show a number of grinding / polishing steps.

PS- the Ray Iles video is mostly handle making and not nearly as much about the chisels themselves.


https://www.toolsforworkingwood.com/store//store/more/met2012.php?v=v

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#24

Apologies for the Brain Dump!

david weaver

For anyone reading who just wants the Fine Woodworking "best overall", "best value" stuff, my apologies.

I'm not that guy and I can wear people out. Who else has a metallurgical microscope to check edges, and for a legitimate purpose (I was and still am selling straight razors - but not on here, so this isn't an ad, and I have none listed now - and natural japanese stones - used, so that people could get a properly graded stone for razors without paying a shyster - that's run its course, so I'm out of that).

What I do have is the experience with tools across types and eras (often multiples of each) to know what's what with all of them. I get into the weeds when it's more "what's your opinion of these". I have granular thoughts about stuff like "this chisel is super hard yet still easy to sharpen" (there's probably a compromise not being told - usually it's the hardness), and what's best in an idealistic way (japanese white steel chisels and vintage western/western european chisels). But I don't expect anyone to adopt my opinions, just stating what i've seen.

No secret that I'm more interested in tools (and guitars) than furniture.

Re: Mike Brady - Phil Lowe's Chisels

#25

Re: Thanks..

david weaver

Thanks for pointing me to the iles video. There is far more hand done there than I expected, though the videos show gouges.

Even if it's half that much done hand wise with the chisels, I'm surprised.

The quench is as I expected - heat them in a common group, dip them in a large oil bath. The result should be very consistent without the need for anything more complicated.

It's a shame that such hand work is what gets the average newbie to the hobby complaining about them looking "inaccurate". And what they charge is very little (looks like about $30 per chisel after shipping in a set of 6 unless they've closed the ability to order directly from the UK and skip the VAT).

Nobody has them in stock, either. I hope that's not a sign that the operation is intermittent or on the rocks.