Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Cutting oil with oil stones?

Posts

Cutting oil with oil stones?

#1

Cutting oil with oil stones?

Chuck Nickerson

I'm curious if using cutting oil with oil stones is a good idea.

I'm guessing it's intended for metal to metal but perhaps stone to metal as well?

Any experience to share?

Re: Cutting oil with oil stones?

#2

Re: Cutting oil with oil stones?

david weaver

Is it oil based or water based? It probably doesn't really matter.

Any thin lubricant will work well on the fine stones, as will anything up to medium mineral oil. On the heavier stones (like medium crystolon or more coarse, especially if friable, an oil bath or thicker oil like light to medium mineral oil at least - is needed to keep the stone from loading).

What you use or don't use is more about feel - what you like or don't like. Some people love dish soap-based water on oilstones. I hate it. Some people don't like WD-40 on medium and fine stones (like fine india or finer) - I really like it.

Re: Cutting oil with oil stones?

#3

Re: Cutting oil with oil stones?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have used cutting oil off and on for about 25 years. It is about the same viscosity as honing oil and mineral oil, but it is somewhat more refined (and more expensive) than mineral oil and less refined (and cheaper) than honing oil.

A less refined oil will get gummy if left on the stone for long periods, so honing oil is best in that regard.

Re: Cutting oil with oil stones?

#4

Re: Cutting oil with oil stones?

Jim Matthews

Do you like the smell of cutting oil?

I tried "lamp oil" which is cheap, and comes in manageable bottles - but hated the lingering odor. The smell of WD40 is pleasant, it cleans up easily and works well.

Alan Little of "Ask Woodman" recommends Simple Green as a cutting lube.

(But it's expensive.)

Re: Cutting oil with oil stones?

#5

Thanks. I'll hunt down honing oil.

Chuck Nickerson

In Los Angeles every hardware store had a knife display case and honing oil when I was a kid.

Now it's much tougher to find.

Re: Cutting oil with oil stones?

#6

Re: Cutting oil with oil stones?

William Duffield

Read the label on the cutting oil. It warns you of its toxicity. Do you want the additional effort of using nitrile gloves every time you need to sharpen something.

I prefer 20 weight non-detergent motor oil. I think it's very similar to 3-in-1 honing oil, and at least two orders of magnitude cheaper. To clean off swarf and to keep the stone from gumming up, I clean it with WD-40.

Re: Cutting oil with oil stones?

#7

Re: Thanks. I'll hunt down honing oil.

david weaver

norton sells a nice type, but it's a little expensive.

if you pass a commercial kitchen supply place anywhere, light mineral oil for meat slicers, etc, is generally about $15 for a gallon. Once you have it around, you'll find uses for it elsewhere (like mixing 50/50 with beeswax, and you'll never use hand creams or chapstik again, etc)

Re: Cutting oil with oil stones?

#8

Re: Cutting oil with oil stones?

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi William and Chuck,

I've used clear, odorless lamp oil on my Arkansas stones and it seems to work well. It has about the same viscosity as WD40. I'm pretty sure the lamp oil I have is refined paraffin oil.

I use lamp oil when I final sand my ebony/silver/gold/pearl bow parts from 400 grit up to 2500 SiC paper, so it is always within easy reach in a small squeeze bottle. Many bow makers "wet sand" the pernambuco stick with odorless lamp oil. Can't use water due to the reaction with the dye in the wood. The lamp oil doesn't react. The oil does evaporate in a few hours, so make sure you wipe off the stones.

John