Opinions on magnetic closures
Wiley Horne
Hi all,
Request your experience or opinions on magnetic closures for kitchen cabinets. More generally, what do you prefer?
Wiley
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Opinions on magnetic closures
Wiley Horne
Hi all,
Request your experience or opinions on magnetic closures for kitchen cabinets. More generally, what do you prefer?
Wiley
Re: Opinions on magnetic closures
John Schtroumpf
My current kitchen cabinets have spring hinges, they are my favorite.
When it comes to catches, I prefer magnetic catches over other types.
Re: Opinions on magnetic closures
John in NM
In various furniture/cabinet shops, I've installed the plastic body ones with some kind of spring/magnet catch I don't quite remember. They worked well, but were ugly.
One of those shops made a wood magnet holder that matched the wood of the cabinet. Really nice solution, but fussy to make.
I've used various configurations of rare earth magnet as well, in the little holders LV sells, just set in the wood, etc. I really like the trim look, but eventually they seem to come out. No epoxy I've found seems to hold them over the long term. Maybe the crazy 3 minute cure urethane I use for casting? That stuff seems to stick to everything you don't want it to stick to.
Our most recent kitchen came with spring hinges (no time to build that kitchen, had to buy it). I like the concept, but the soft close tends to stay just a little open for me - I think they're designed for slammers and I'm a naturally soft closer, not wanting to fix the door one day.
Re: Opinions on magnetic closures
Steve Elliott
The magnetic latches I've used all seem to be loud and sort of abrupt in the way they let go of the door. The kitchen where I've lived for 30-plus years has catches with two rollers that spring open a little to capture a folded metal piece attached to the door. I've found that pinching the metal piece with pliers will make the action quieter and more gentle.
I've used the Lee Valley rare earth magnets in cups that had a screw to hold the cup into the wood. If the magnet and cup end up exactly flush with the surface of the wood a felt pad over them hides the magnet and makes the grip gentler. I've never used that type on kitchen cabinets, just on jewelry cases or other small projects where the catch needs to be subtle.
All the kitchen cabinets I make these days use self-close European hinges with a built-in soft close feature. It's what customers want.
If you decide to go the magnet-in-cup route I have a few tips for getting the cup exactly flush with the surface that I'd be glad to share.
Re: Opinions on magnetic closures
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi Wiley
It is not too long ago that I rebuild our kitchen. In this I used European hinges throughout. These hold the door with a spring against the frame ...

Drawers are soft closers, and similarly pull against the frame.
I am not a fan of magnets, for the same reason Steve gave. That is, they make a tight connection which, when opened requires a hard pull and, when closing, can spring close with a clunk (but then so can any door/drawer - adding a layer of felt or rubber is helpful). Mainly, I do not like the extra effort in opening.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: Opinions on magnetic closures
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
For the first time, I implemented something I'd seen in the magazines: I drilled holes in the edge of a hinged window screen on a casement (thus, pretty much a door) and in the mating edge of the casing, and epoxied some rare earth magnets into each hole - I'll get around to plugging the hole with a thin wood plug. Once I remembered to orient them correctly*, I love the effect. It's a soft but firm opening, and it self-closes as soon as the screen/door gets within a few inches of the casing. I had to stack several small-diameter magnets, from my hardware store, in each hole; three, as I recall, in each hole.
*My first attempt had the sets of magnets oriented to repel each other. Ooops.
Re: Opinions on magnetic closures
David Weaver
Big fan of blum's soft/self closing hinges. you just give the doors a push and they stop short of closing and then close themselves - silently. The soft close feature costs about an extra dollar a hinge.
Thanks to all!
Wiley Horne
Big thanks!! Everyone’s opinion added to my meagre understanding.
Backing up, it’s not practical for me to do the sensible thing and tear everything back to the bare walls and start over. So I am dealing with three different face frame situations: partial overlay, inset, and narrow-stile leaded glass doors. All would benefit visually from concealed hinges, if it is possible.
I was beginning to think that you had to be born knowing where and how your door fit into Blum’s bewildering ecosystem. But spurred by the discussion here, I found this excellent guide,
https://d2.blum.com/BEC003/concealedhinges_ep_dok_bus_$sus_$aof_$v8.pdf
which may help others as well.
Blum will take care of my needs, except for the narrow stile doors, which won’t take a 35mm bore in the right place. Could use the 26mm hinges, but right now am leaning toward the opposite approach of decorative Cliffside hinges.
Thanks again for your help!
Wiley
Re: Thanks to all!
TomD
The squelch on guy projects is that they get carried away with something from the craft perspective, and the woman of the house (huge stereotype warning) is then stuck with something that is less usable, and to boot ends up having to say what a genius the maker was, over and over. I ran into this head on when working up a spinning wheel plan, and my contact in the spinning community said they all dread being the person whose husband wants to make the wheel, as what the woodworker thinks would be a cool project bears no comparison to what the spinner actually wants.
So stereotypes aside, whoever is going to need to open this thing a thousand times a week, should consider seriously the way they want that to work (as in this case you are). The state of the art at this point is probably the cushion self closing Blum door hinges, worth it just to deal with heavy handed users if. Something like a corner display cabinet and it can be a very different experience since it only gets opened occasionally. I think Krenov got that one right with knife hinges and his wooden catches, were nice feeling.
Re: 100% agree...
david weaver
.. you can dicker on the aesthetics, but the function had better please whoever you're trying to please (even if you have a 50% stake in it).
I went with the soft close hinges but not drawers because:
* the hinge format never seems to change, and most importantly, my wife complained about hearing doors close in the cabinets. I grew up in a household with parents who were children of farmers. They could've used an anvil in the hall and I'd have slept through it, but my wife can hear ANYTHING anywhere in the house, and the madder she is at me, the more she can hear. So the soft close hinges have been a life saver.
* Years ago, I remember some of the soft close drawers not lasting that long, and I figured I just don't want to get in the cabinets to change them. I wanted drawers without guides, but the Mrs didn't agree so we went with BB drawer guides - or, I picked those for her.
It's interesting to watch people when you have self-closing door hinges. They always close, 100% of the time. If you slap the door shut, they just get closer to the close before they take over, but a real control freak will feel the need to push them all the way closed manually. I won't say who does that when they visit because it'll get me in trouble, but I have one OCD family member who just can't tolerate letting them close on their own.
They are the lazy man's friend, though - you can open the doors and flip them shut while you're walking away and they'll eventually close themselves without any noise.
(and my wife has a heavy hand, and though she doesn't follow them closed, she could really slam the old cabinet doors sometimes. Mine are solid panel and frame, and I really don't want to see if the folks in my house could manage to bash them off the wall eventually by slamming the relatively heavy doors).
Re: Thanks to all!
Wiley Horne
That’s hilarious, Tom. Because it’s so true. Get the woman opinion and you’ll never walk out the clothing store in a green suit. [“It was the fluorescent light honey, and dark too.”]. Let em pick the car color too, or they may never get in.
Drivers license exam coming up in May, so time to get new glasses to see the chart. When time to pick frames, showed the nice lady my go-to 1960’s aviator style frame—no, no,no,noooooo....so old fashioned.....Properly chastised, I had her pick em.
Playing defense on the hinges—out of sight.
Re: Thanks to all!
david charlesworth
One of the best uses I saw was on a small corner cabinet.
There was a sliding bar which changed from pull to push orientation.
It looked as if a ghostly hand was opening the doors!
best wishes,
David Charlesworth