Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

Posts

Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

#1

Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

Steve Voigt

I stayed out of the A2 discussion because frankly I'm not interested in rehashing that topic any more.As much as I disliked Charlesworth's post, I just don't care any more. But the following quote from Wiley really caught my eye:

The metallurgist John Verheuven, in Steel Metallurgy for Non-Metallurgists, shows quenching data that demonstrates the problem in through-hardening unalloyed high carbon, such as 1095 (same as W1), when the thickness gets above 0.09” (3/32”). When you get up toward 1/8” or 0.145”, it takes extremely fast quench times to avoid the formation of pearlite or bainite in preference to martensite. And the problem gets worse with finer-grain steel.

The common explanation for why Japanese irons/chisels/etc perform so well is that the unhardened backer (mild steel or wrought iron) acts as sort of a shock absorber, allowing the cutting edge to be left very hard (around 63 RC) without suffering from chipping. For what it's worth, I have never bought this explanation.It's like claiming that great shock absorbers allow you to drive over nails without getting a flat tire.

An alternative explanation is that the greater carbon content of Japanese steel (roughly 1.2% vs 1% in W1 or 1095) is the difference-maker. I'm skeptical of this as well. The japanese tools are much more intensively forged than western tools usually are, so I believe much of the excess carbon is burnt off during forging. And if the steel is till hypereutectic (i.e. above roughly .75% carbon) when it finally gets heat-treated, the excess carbon is not going to get used unless the steel is kept at the critical temperature (roughly 1450 F) for at least a few minutes--something that is not happening at the one man shop level, where the smith is heating the steel up to critical temp and immediately quenching it.

So, we are left with the explanation Wiley (via Verheuven) is suggesting: that lamination keeps the cross section of tool steel very thin, and as a result it gets hardened more completely than would be possible with a solid chunk. This is the only explanation that has ever made sense to me.

I will tentatively suggest, based on my own limited experience, that laminating the tool steel to a big chunk of wrought iron also constrains the fromer from warping and distorting during HT, something that is hard to avoid with a solid chunk of O1.

I guess I don't really have a point here, but I'd love to hear more thoughts from Wiley or anybody else.

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

#2

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening st

david weaver

I literally emailed the same thing to someone today, that while I'd like to have water hardening steel, I don't think you can do a really good job with it (except for marginally with thin pieces in oil, but then you might as well use oil hardening steel)....anyway, can't do a really good job without having the lamination to stabilize it.

LN tried (I've seen conflicting information, but their older irons remind more of W1 than O1, and most of the people stating that the old ones are O1 haven't been around that long). I don't think they'd have had the warpage problem they had with O1, either - at least not to the point that they'd harden only part of the iron's usable length.

You can buy pre-laminated white 2 from time to time, and the hardening schedule isn't that big of a deal, but I have only seen it in three piece sandwiches (soft/hard/sort) in small amounts, and nothing big enough for a plane iron, anyway. I probably wouldn't fiddle with it, but the pre-lam sandwiches are the right thickness for a bench plane iron.

The last variable that george mentioned elsewhere (otherwise, I wouldn't repeat it) was that blacksmiths had difficulty at wmsbg with higher carbon water hardening steel, in terms of getting a good lamination to wrought iron. He didn't know why, and I haven't been there in almost 30 years, but I'm guessing they aren't using power hammers whereas the higher end japanese makers are.

From what i understand, at least in terms of how it's touted, the japanese irons from the older and smaller volume makers are often forge welded at a temperature that's as low as the maker can get the forge weld to be good. I've seen irons for sale with bad forge welds (for a discount) because some of the makers don't want the defectives to go to waste. They're still not cheap. The ones that get nutty about the lowest possible forge temperatures are usually the White #1 experts. Even those guys can make duds from time to time - some are overhard, and some I can't tell the difference from white 2.

I sure do like O1 as a garage tinkerer, though. It seems to always turn out at least passable, and often really great.

At any rate, It seems to me that your supposition is right, that aside from maybe an argument for early cost issues, I don't remember seeing really good water hardening steel without the steel being laminated. I don't know that much of it ended up in laminated tools in england after the turn of the century - while they continued to make tapered irons for a long time, they feel like oil hardening steel when you're sharpening them.

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

#3

Qualification of data

Wiley Horne

Hi Steve and all,

Prof. Verhoeven’s book is very expensive in hard copy. However, he made a point of having the book readily available online,

http://www.hybridburners.com/documents/verhoeven.pdf

The material I quoted is about p. 88. I should have qualified my statement properly, to say that the through-hardenability of unalloyed high carbon is heavily influenced by grain size. The data I gave were for the fine-grain sample of 1086. A larger grain sample did through-harden, even up to 1/4” thickness.

There is a very interesting chapter on techniques for achieving fine-grain, using multiple heats, which is what the Japanese smiths are reputed to do.

I should add: this book is not ‘Steel Metallurgy for Dummies’. Nor is Verhoeven strictly a popularizer: he wrote an academic metallurgical text, replete with the high-end math one would expect. I think most will find this book pretty heavy going, regardless of one’s degree of book-learning.

Wiley

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

#4

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening st

Jim Matthews

Which steel was used in your early smoother and "mini-smoother" you made for me?

They're easy to sharpen, without a grinding wheel using two oilstones and a strop.

My favored Marples chisels shape up quickly with the same two stores.

Jim in Massachusetts

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

#5

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening st

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The early cast steel chisels were not laminated. The smiths were not able to laminate cast steel for some decades when it first appeared. Apparently the cast steel deteriorated when brought to welding heat. I have four cast steel chisels from around 1830 that are solid construction. I also have a 200 year old skew chisel for turning that is cast steel and appears to be solid steel.

In the Seaton chest there are two kinds of chisels: laminated chisels and cast steel chisels, which are not laminated. The cast steel chisels are about 35% more expensive.

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

#6

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening st

Steve Voigt

Dave, I sure do agree about O1. It works very well with almost no effort on my part--just heat treat it and temper it. My interest in laminating etc. is mostly academic, because I would be putting in huge amounts of work for only fractional gain. It's fun to spitball about on forums but at least for now, that's as far as I go (but I still like to spitball!).

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

#7

Re: Qualification of data

Steve Voigt

Wliey, I read most of the PDF version after you posted the link a few years ago. I don't remember seeing the stuff about thickness of W1, but I must've glossed over it. In any case, the book is super useful for anyone who wants to go off the deep end with this stuff. As you say it's tough sledding, but not impossible by any means.

I'll go back and look for the thickness data.

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

#8

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening st

Steve Voigt

Howdy Jim! You are taking me back--those are some of the first planes I sold. Your early encouragement had a lot to do with me opening up shop.

Anyway, all my irons have always been O1. As I said to Dave above, it is hard to beat for pretty much everything I do. I own a handful of vintage irons and chisels that are better steel, but most are about the same and plenty are worse. O1 is very dependable.

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

#9

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening st

Steve Voigt

Warren, it says in the Seaton book that the smaller sizes of cast steel tools were solid, but the larger ones were laminated.

As far as I know, the earlier (pre-cast steel) tools from the early 18th c (and before) were laminated. And every 19th c tool I have that's marked "cast steel" is laminated. So I think the issue with welding cast steel to wrought iron was mostly confined to the second half of the 18th c. It does, however, point to the non-trivial issues involved in laminating tool steel. If it took 18th century smiths half a century to figure out how to laminate cast steel effectively, the backyard blacksmith today is likely to have some issues. For sure it is not as easy as the Japanese smiths on youtube make it look!

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

#10

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening st

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Seaton chest book, page 65, Update about chisels, it says none of the cast steel chisels show a weld line.

My early 19th century chisels, which I prefer, don't seem to have welds, later in the century there are welds in cast steel chisels. I should note that I don't think it is because they are solid that I prefer them; I just like the way the steel in the earlier chisels sharpens and performs.

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

#11

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening st

david weaver

What you need is a power hammer and a shear!

And a forge.

And wrought from an old bridge.

And..

OK, O1 is good.

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

#12

Re: aside, even though it's just in theory to me..

david weaver

...there is a guy (joe calton or something) who is making very hard and very thin paring knives out of 1095.

Talk about a limited market.

I believe that he claims to see more ability for the steel to survive at high hardness with multiple heats. It's not the kind of thing I'd buy, but interesting to see someone pushing the limits.

High hardness for him is something like 65 in a paring knife. I've got a hard parer, but it's stainless and not close to that - more like 61. A thin hard knife is a thing of joy for dissecting veggies and soft meat. Not for a kitchen with kids in it, though, and has to be hidden when MIL is in town - she likes all knife cuts to be the pinch type where the knife blade touches your thumb at the end of the cut.

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

#13

Nailed it.


Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

#14

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening st

Steve Voigt

Warren, you're right, I missed the update.

Bringing this back to the main thrust of thread, it doesn't really matter if those chisels are laminated, because they are typically around 1/16" thick at the cutting edge, well under the 3/32" that Wiley cited as the point at which it becomes difficult to convert all the carbon to martensite. It only becomes an issue with tools like a mortise chisel, a 19th century firmer, or a plane iron. And many Japanese tools (which is what I was talking about in the OP) are VERY thick at the cutting edge.

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

#15

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening st

Warren in Lancaster, PA

My early 19th century skew chisel (1 1/4, turning) is cast steel and is .127 inches thick at the point where I am now using it. It is not laminated. It was undoubtedly somewhat thinner at the tip when it was new, but the relevant point is that the edge that I now use is in the center of the tool. 1/16 from each side when the hardening took place.

It certainly is thin compared to today's clunky offerings, which are often two or three times as thick.

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

#16

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening st

TomD

"The common explanation for why Japanese irons/chisels/etc perform so well is that the unhardened backer (mild steel or wrought iron) acts as sort of a shock absorber, allowing the cutting edge to be left very hard (around 63 RC) without suffering from chipping. For what it's worth, I have never bought this explanation.It's like claiming that great shock absorbers allow you to drive over nails without getting a flat tire."

First off when we speak about explanations about Japanese tools, that have currency, where did these come from originally? Some marketing materials probably.

I don't think that is the (or even the colloquial) explanation of why they work so well in any case. It is a fact that some of them are hard, and it is a fact the steel is laminated. It is also a fact that some of the smiths are descended from sword makers, where getting the properties of extremely sharp and hard edges, together with some ability to deal with impact, was probably important. But the shock absorption of the material is not the reason the chisels cut better. Nor is it necessary with the hard steels. Right off the bat one is dealing with ignorant newbie thinking such as, how does one stop chisels from chipping. Yeah, guys who were through an extensive apprenticeship, and a slave to the trade, where worrying not stop about how not to be idiots in using their tools. One good test of whether ideas are true, and of whence they came, is to ask yourself whether a competent person would be concerned about that.

"An alternative explanation is that the greater carbon content of Japanese steel (roughly 1.2% vs 1% in W1 or 1095) is the difference-maker. I'm skeptical of this as well. The japanese tools are much more intensively forged than western tools usually are, so I believe much of the excess carbon is burnt off during forging."

I don't believe you burn carbon out of steel that is not exposed to the air, you can certainly burn the periphery, but I have not seen a problem with the steel when it is ground back to clean material. There are many things smiths can do to control this effect, and if I am not getting it hacking away, I see little reason why they would.

"So, we are left with the explanation Wiley (via Verheuven) is suggesting: that lamination keeps the cross section of tool steel very thin, and as a result it gets hardened more completely than would be possible with a solid chunk. This is the only explanation that has ever made sense to me."

I think that is part way, but in reality if i use 3/16 O1, my back should get hit just as hard as his, sure it isn't all the way through, but that is not a problem with single bevel tools, as most of ours, and certainly theirs, are.

Who knows. One thing that interests me is that steel is not only one thing. You can water harden oil hardening steels in some situations, and then you need oil in others. I have always been taken by the fact that the J. smiths seem to be hardening in a giant thing of water. That would be great, and it is not something that most western smiths get away with. I forget where I came across it, but the mere fact of the section of the of the Iron makes it possible to dip the whole mess in water. So you get your very rapid drop for hardening, but you don't get the tools cracking because it is in a large block, and most of it is not a hardening steel. I think that is where the HT part of the magic comes from.

As far as performance, unrelated to these maters is concerned. The Japanese catalog of tool makers runs into a LOT of people. I had a catalog at one point and it was about the size of the current LV, say .5". page after page after page of product we never see. A dense catalog of plane blades and chisels. Not just a few pieces. And the same is true to a lesser extent of the Japanese Makita catalog I once saw. We think we know it all over here, but we actually have few makers, making few tools, for virtually no pros, and we don't have any steels that are developed exclusively for woodworking, it is all borrowed. I don't know about Japan, but there are so many makers they may even be catered to.

Re: Lamination and quenching in water-hardening steel

#17

Re: Newbies

TomD

When I wrote those snide newbie comments, I wasn't just sneering. I was in the LV store back when the only TO store was the west side store, maybe mid to late 80s. They had the Iyoroi 1/8" mortising chisels on a really deep sale. I asked why they were blowing them out so cheaply, and the manager said they were the last few. They would no longer be selling then because even though the blades where about 5/8" deep, they had suffered an almost 100% return rate for snapped off blades. I still have mine, and I was not then or now a pro. But like most of the people here I figure tools out a little before I use them. The 100% return rate user is apparently the norm, even when you reach up to expensive tools. I think there is actually a better argument that in several ways the laminated construction makes hacks more likely to break or chip the tools. But I can certainly imagine why the discussion drops into the gutter when people back then where setting the tone for explaining these things.