Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Mahogany Les Paul Specials

Posts

Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#1

Mahogany Les Paul Specials

David Weaver

While I'm waiting for the varnish to dry on two other telecasters, and looking for a diversion from building two cabinets that the mrs. wants done, I can start two les paul specials.

I like this guitar type better than a typical les paul, but have never bought a gibson version (I do have a collings 290, which I can sell if these turn out well - collings isn't a familiar name to most, but they are a company who builds probably the highest quality electric guitars in the world without getting weird. Perhaps the same can be said for acoustic. They do everything by the book (wood selection, etc) first and set the price later.

Anyway, I've never worked mahogany before since I don't build much furniture, and was curious as to how it would plane. This is honduran, by the way, not an imitation.

I intentionally planed it against the grain to thickness it to see what it's like, and it's very agreeable to say the least. I'm not finish planing this because it'll take its lump in construction, but it's important that it's flat and tearout free. On the telecaster forum, that's "only achievable with a drum sander or router sled, it, it tears out if you plane it".

I didn't finish plane it, so I don't know what the ultimate brightness will be, but with sizing shavings (4 thousandths or so off of a smoother to clean up the surface, it's agreeable in every direction with the cap set). I wouldn't typically measure the smoother shavings, but I figured it's worth knowing, as before the double iron, I'd have taken much longer to plane this, and perhaps saved my billets and gone to a local shop here that has a three stage drum sander. That'd have been a shame. I'd have finish planed it walking on eggshells just like the D&W video shows the the cabinetmakers doing with walnut.

I've never planed anything that's as easy to work, and I've never sawn anything that's high quality and as well behaved. I can see why gibson gravitated toward it for their solid body guitars.

This blank was a cut price blank because it's too close to the center of the tree, and even at that, through seasonal shift, the cupping is minimal and I can center the neck and bridge/pickups etc in the center of it and what little that occurs after it is under finish (not much) won't affect the playability or stability of the guitar. Paying the same price for a multi-piece blank would've been technically better, but it doesn't look as good. A good quartered honduran mahogany blank like this that's low density as this is would be $200, and I haven't made a good one of these yet, so maybe later. Gibson will not put a blank even like this one in a guitar less than $3000. One of the perks of building is controlling the materials and components without having to pay a huge premium for them. The downside is that it's probably a fair expectation that if you didn't want a guitar you built, you could probably get the cost of materials (about $400), and Gibson could get 6 to ten times as much. I don't know if they'd (to be fair, they're providing warranty service, paying wages and servicing a substantial level of debt).

I don't think this plane has been used for many decades - many, but someone was nice enough to keep it in a dry place. In all of that time, it stayed flat and well fitted, and I think it took a total of about 45 minutes to complete sole flattening, and get the iron and cap iron prepped initially.

https://i.postimg.cc/C1L0nYZH/20190222-190926.jpg

https://i.postimg.cc/15yd9Mqw/20190222-191144.jpg

https://i.postimg.cc/2yDKL7Xp/20190222-191843.jpg

https://i.postimg.cc/P539VZNZ/20190222-191942.jpg

https://i.postimg.cc/T25dVd7C/20190222-191958.jpg

https://i.postimg.cc/jjng8Fp0/20190222-192016.jpg

https://i.postimg.cc/wBnPgpXj/20190222-192608.jpg

https://i.postimg.cc/GtxSFTZ4/20190222-192901.jpg

https://i.postimg.cc/52RKSVkS/20190222-193017.jpg

The wide shavings with holes in them (tearout) are from against the grain with the try plane. Not set close, set sort of close. The final smooth shavings come out without holes in them (even though they're relatively thick) once you hit your mark.

I saw a video of someone planing mahogany at CW and to use the word deliberate would've been a huge understatement. The curator described a time budget of about 1 hour per board foot for dimensioning and smooth planing. It boggles the mind! I doubt that's historically accurate, and felt a little bit sorry for the guys in the video doing the planing. I don't think they'd be open to my suggestions (I know that as a matter of policy, they don't allow double irons).

You can see a festool sander in the background. When I made my kitchen cabinets, I wanted them to look factory, so I sanded them. I thought it would be a time saver, too, but I think it's only a time saver if you have an industrial setup and can do most of the work with multi-stage stationary sanders. I hate the amount of consumables you go through. The cabinets my wife wants are going in adjoining areas to the kitchen and she wants them to look the same. I'm on the fence about using the sander for the cabinets that go outside of the kitchen, but the first one in process is an extra cabinet to replace something in the kitchen that I thought we'd keep (an RTA rolling cabinet with a butcher block), so conceptually, I'm sanding that one to keep the look uniform. Nobody would notice. Hopefully when I make flat top and arch top guitars, I'll have some use for the power sanders.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#2

Number two of the LPs will be Sapele

David Weaver

I've not used sapele, but will see how that planes. If it was as good as bigleaf mahogany (i expect it won't be), it probably wouldn't have been used as a replacement for bigleaf, but I browse guitar blanks based on looks and price.

For whatever reason, guitar blanks are a weird area of the market. If you can find a board big enough to make them (one piece blanks) so that you could have affordable consistency with materials, it's generally more costly by the board foot than the blanks are. Sometimes by a lot.

I've never seen bigleaf low density mahogany quartered in a 14 inch wide board and full 8/4 thickness, regardless of price. Collings manages to get a bunch of this, but given that they do this kind of stuff for a living, they probably pay whatever it takes and have reliable suppliers who go to them rather than listing materials online.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#3

Re: One final word about accuracy and speed

David Weaver

I don't have a power tool option here, so speed doesn't matter - I'm doing it this way. But I do get a charge out of trying to figure out how this was done historically (as in quickly, and accurately) with planes. Thus the fascination with the double iron.

I constantly see that if you dimension by hand, you'll be using inaccurately prepared stock and spending gobs of time. to size this blank (Which was a tenth thicker on one side than another, and slightly cupped), I took calipers and measured the corners. I know what my planes take off in each pass to a reasonable degree of accuracy (the flattening is done with a try plane that I made, then the smoothing). As a matter of just getting good surfaces on this, I checked once part of the way through with the calipers (on the corners) and then one more time as I was finishing. I guess it's a welcome break for a fraction of a minute, whatever you'd want to call it.

The relative accuracy that I end up with taking strokes to get two flat faces (and nothing else, not truing after that) and knowing about where each corner is, and then being able to turn the blanks around to put the thick corners on the far end (thanks to the double iron) is about one hundredth of an inch on the thickest corner to the thinnest. 1.69 to 1.7 inches in this case. I probably won't examine thickness again unless something bad happens to the blank.

The total time to face, even the thickness, get an initial surface on this, and then cut the blank out with a turning saw is about 1/2 hour. The incidental level of accuracy is better than my portable planer. The work is pure joy, it's a hobby. No dust collection, no sanding, no bandsaws, etc. i'm sure that professional makers can do batches of these far faster per blank than I can get to this point, but I'm also sure that a lot of the people using power tools and asserting that you can't get anything done if you do all of the work by hand could make it take longer to do this, fiddling with dust collection, trying to find something that could work a 15" wide blank that's short, changing bandsaw blades, cleaning up dust, etc. And they'll occasionally ruin a blank. I have lost one piece of stock preparing by hand in the last 5 years. A piece of cabinet sticking that i mismarked. When I had a full power tool setup, I usually ruined at least one thing each weekend.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#4

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

TomD

What kind of pickups, and why?

There is a reason why so much old furniture was made of mahog, it is like butter. Basically all my necks are made of some mahog I built up a reserve of back in the day. I also have some acoustic back and sides. Funny story about that. It is CITES listed now, so don't move it in and out of the country. So a rare wood, one would think. Yet I paid about 40 for back and sides. I also got some Indian Rosewood at that price, and my maple was consistently 100 or over. Yet rosewood was an instant $500 upcharge, maple was a little up. Maybe 100, but hard to sell, and mahog was the intro market. All prices circa year 2000.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#5

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

TomD

I should add that my comments about Mahog have nothing to do with it's choice in a solid body guitar where issues and preferences are different. Wouldn't want any of what I said to seem to others to apply to your righteous choices.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#6

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

David Weaver

Hi, Tom - Gibson burstbucker pros in one of them, and either duncans (SH1/SH4) or lollar p90s in the other. I won't have to decide the second one until later (routing the pickup cavities), but if I build a third and fourth, I'd like to get those all in, as well as one with lollar mini humbuckers.

The wood is a weird thing. There's a lot of hunduran left around, but it's generally not quartered and usually really heavy. Gibson has started using that stuff and chambering most of their guitars (which I'm sure you're aware of), and I guess they may use khaya - they never specify unless they're charging an awful lot.

Like you said, in raw material form, it's on the cites schedule.

I heard that CITES may be relaxed later this year for guitars and other items that really don't put pressure on the woods. It's at least 90% due to the chinese market for mahogany and rosewood furniture. Affluence there has brought up their imports to the point that they're using 90% of the supply, and something like 10 times what they were using 15 years ago.

The market (what people are buying) is weird given what you said - how much people will pay for routine stuff. If you're not looking for a constant supply, you can sometimes find indian rosewood backs and sides on ebay for $100 (you can always find outright junk for cheap, but I mean something you'd actually want to use).

I've gotten two acoustics lately - both from china. One cort, one ..I can't remember the name, it's a martin copy with santos rosewood and an adirondack top. Both are really good guitars. The cort was $550 shipped with a case (new), and with a torrefied top. It's as strong as any acoustic I've ever played and the other guitar rings (but has some corners cut on it - like a scarf joint and a built up heel). Still, both were inexpensive - the factory low-human-time guitars are better than they've ever been. Everything is robot done, including the spraying.

I hope guitars come off of the cites schedules. It's a real pain for something that's insignificant as a consumer of exotic woods.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#7

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

David Weaver

No problem on woods. I don't know if anyone else on here would care, but I don't - everyone has their preferences. I like cherry in electrics, but they need to be thinner or chambered or they become butt heavy. The most end to end alive electric guitar I ever played was a collings 360, though, which is mahogany.

I like a mahogany acoustic OK, but they are really fundamental and lack the ring that rosewood acoustics have. It's good wood, and either it's being labeled improperly and exported to china, or there is some outside of the CITES protected zone in honduras and other places. Any of the $350 acoustic guitars with sitka tops and solid sides and neck are mahogany. Rosewood is a little more, but it's pau ferro (not real rosewood - my cort is pau ferro) or indian or something in similar value.

I'd hate to be making guitars for a living now, but there's never been a better time to get into the hobby of making them because there are still materials available, several good sites, and gobs of used full pickguards for fender (pickups, jack, switches, pots...all there for the same cost as a new set of pickups) and custom wiring sets and used gibson pickups for the price that gibson wants for a single pickup. And there is so much information around. If you're too lazy to make templates, people with CNC machines are selling them cheap on ebay all the time.

I managed to get a couple of honduran mahogany neck blanks a few months ago - they're around from time to time on ebay, but khaya is far more prevalent, and while it's good, it moves a little more with moisture changes.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#8

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

Don Stephan

When new neighbor last spring said his famiy has mahogany plantations in Sri Lanka my curiosity was piqued. Don't know if accurate, but I found some web sites claiming one or both true South American mahogany species (I think coastal and inland) had been planted some time ago in the Phillipines, Sri Lanka, and perhaps some other countries in that area. Don't know if those plantings would be covered by CITES protection, whether they are being harvested, et cetera.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#9

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

david weaver

I'm not sure about the phillipines, but there are definitely areas where it's OK to harvest honduran mahogany from. I'm guessing that's one of them since it's not close to honduras. CITES gives the restricted area, but I have to admit that other than to know that (unlike rosewood) that it's OK if it's not from the restricted area, I don't know exactly what the restricted area is.

The original trees were huge with wide clear wood, which allowed for things like even full width one-piece quartered guitar blanks (probably takes a 4 or 5 foot tree for that).

Someone had the foresight a very long time ago to plant cuban mahogany and indian rosewood in plantation areas. The rosewood doesn't look the same as old growth, but it's still nice (old growth is darker and much tighter rings).

CITES should be easing up on guitars later this year, but I don't know what that means for raw stock like mahogany since raw stock can always be diverted to furniture.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#10

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

Sgian Dubh

I'm not sure of the full range of plantation grown mahogany outside it's native geographical range, i.e., basically South America and parts of the Caribbean. However, big-leaf mahogany (Swietenia macrophylla) of the South American Tropical region made it into Cites Appendix II in 1996, with an alternative big-leaf mahogany source being from Fiji where it has been plantation grown since just after the Second World War. It's currently sustainable and therefore doesn’t appear in any of the Cites appendices.

I've used some of this material in the recent past, and my experience is that it was a bit woolly, rather interlocked and rather anaemically pink in appearance compared to earlier examples sourced from non-plantation South American forests, some boards I used having been in storage in my then (early 1980s) employers' timber store for nearly 200 years! Now that was remarkable stuff - most was wide, long, dark, pretty heavy and worked beautifully, and no wonder it was so popular with furniture makers back then.

Note: Cites' Appendix II is described as “includes species not necessarily threatened with extinction, but in which trade must be controlled in order to avoid utilization incompatible with their survival.” Slainte.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#11

Khaya - not as good

david weaver

I finally got to work khaya, too, for the second blank.

I don't have pictures on my phone, they're on another phone (sounds dumb, but I keep my old phones to take pictures of things and use as media devices around the house).

The khaya blank that I have is a gorgeous blank, but it's heavier, and it's dead quartered. It feels so dry and brittle compared to the big leaf mahogany. It still planed fine, but I can tell that the ribboning is weak and will not wear well.

The dilemma in terms of budget for guitars is that I can find a nice quartered khaya blank (which will look better) for the same price as a bigleaf blank that has some issues (the one in the picture here is a bit close to the pith, or it'd have sold for more).

I think both would make nice furniture, but a person with a choice who had to do some carving and planing would tire of the brittleness of the khaya pretty quickly.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#12

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi David,

You mention CITES and the wood bans with respect to guitars. You should see what string players (and the makers of their bows) have to contend with...

Because elephant ivory (CITES appendix I) was historically used on the tip of a violin bow, weighing about 0.1 gram, it prevents players from crossing the borders between countries. Only totally proven antique bows with original tips over 100 years old with all the paperwork in place are exempt. There are not many bows that meet those stringent rules.

For years, decades really, most modern makers switched to fossil mastodon and mammoth ivory. For both new bows as well as for repairs to old bows. Let's face it, these animals had gone extinct ~15,000+ years ago because they were delicious. Not because makers of bows did them in. Pressure was removed from elephants because a good legal substitute material had been found.

This worked until 2014 when the US federal as well as EU and other governments further restricted elephant ivory specifically and then a number of US state legislatures decided that they would follow suit and restrict elephant AND fossil ivory in all interstate commerce. So now, doing business in NJ, I couldn't sell a bow with a 0.1 gram tip made from fossil ivory.

With these pressures mounting, a number of bowmakers including myself, found an acceptable ivory substitute made of a linen/melamine composite. We then approached a major supplier with our findings, who began making and selling them, and for the most part, almost all the bow makers I know have switched from fossil ivory to the cloth/polymer substitute.

Bottom line: make lemonade when dealt lemons.

Over and out!

John

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#13

Re: sounds like a pain!

david weaver

I've heard of the troubles with ivory, though, and they predate the 2017 troubles with rosewood.

I recall ivoroid and other things being used for tools, but they don't yellow at the same rate as ivory, so things can be a mismatch. It's above my pay grade, but I've learned more than I'd like to about cites.

* first by having an early 1900s plane seized by ebay's shipping service (a norris 2)

* then by having trouble twice with japanese auction proxy services who thought they couldn't ship a mahogany guitar (not true, mahogany is not restricted in finished items)

* then by the shipping service thinking they couldn't send me a guitar with a madagascar rosewood fingerboard (which would've been true if the fingerboard was 10kg - a commercial seller can't sell directly to me, but under the rules of cites, since a shipping service was sending something that I already owned, no problem with the rules.

It was a lot of trouble and communication - I was able to get the guitars, but the plane is gone forever. The service ebay uses told me that it'd be seized at customs in the US and they auctioned it off like they do all of their seized items and ebay footed the bill to give me my money back. The trouble was, I paid 220 pounds for a pristine norris 2. No such thing can be found here.

The proxy shipper in japan offered to "dispose of my guitars" for a $50 fee each, and only knowing stu tierney bailed me out on the one with the madagascar fingerboard. They shipped to him, he shipped it to me. Of course, customs here didn't care.

if it had ivory, though, it would've been dicey.

I have a couple of guitars with d. nigra in them. I wouldn't even think of having them cross the borders, paperwork or not. The law is half the danger. The low-ranking private inspectors at shippers or newbie customs officials are just as much danger otherwise.

The effect on makers of lower-end guitars is predictable. There are a lot of pau ferro sided acoustic guitars now. Marketed under different names to make them sound like rosewood.

Nothing has been saved by any of the trouble with old planes, bows or instruments, but I guess it "provides good jobs", just like recycling centers that collect recyclable paper and plastic bottles and then bale it and send it to the dump because there are no end users for the recycled material.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#14

Re: Khaya - not as good

Jim Matthews

Interlocking grain and rough handling:

Is species choice dictated by how often, and how far a guitar must travel?

Nice to have a choice, but Brian May built a convincing case for using local materials.

PRS has an entertaining, if unsubstantiated video that illustrated the depth of the rabbit hole luthiers must navigate.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#15

Re: Khaya - not as good

david weaver

Not sure (on the travel thing). Guitars that hit the road will eventually need repair. When they need it, they get it if the person hauling them around makes money with them.

You can build a decent guitar with a lot of things as long as the wood is reasonably stable in movement (necks have to be sawn well or stabilized some way - baking maple is becoming extremely popular, and predictably, a lot of the baked necks use strange grain orientation that they'd never get away with without baking).

Not too familiar with brian may's guitar (as in, never had one and looked close), but as a slab type, it could probably be built out of anything. So can the others if density is compensated for (and I suppose fenders are generally a locally sourced wood guitar where they're built - maple necks and usually alder bodies).

Selection for acoustic guitars is more important because you can't just chamber them, and you can hear a distinct difference in something like rosewood vs. mahogany. AS far as i've seen with most guitars, breakage due to rough handling has been due to design (gibson les pauls break at the peg head often, and you don't have to shop long to see one for a good price and find out the peghead broke off and got glued back on). Fenders tolerate abuse a lot better, and the holes at the body/neck joint can get loose, but that's fixable and nobody sees it as damage - or seems to mention it.

If gibson was just being introduced now, I doubt they'd use:

* hoduran mahogany

* rosewood fingerboards

We're kind of stuck with the traditional woods because the market has a lot of inertia and won't pay for stuff in an old design that wasn't in the original guitars (e.g., you can sell a les paul in mahogany, and you can sell a fender with pine or alder body wood, but try to sell a mahogany fender and nobody wants it, or an alder les paul - same thing, it only ends up in cheap guitars. Let alone something like oak (which would probably create problems with extra work after tooling because it wouldn't come out as clean as alder or mahogany). I made a telecaster out of cherry that sounds and plays great. if fender tried to source the wood to make them (it's OK, but not ideal because it's more dense than alder and people would notice), I doubt anyone would pay extra for it. It's certainly more durable than alder.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#16

Re: Separate and aside about PRS

david weaver

....I've never met the guy, but you apparently can if you're in the right place at the right time.

He knows a lot about guitars, but I think he has a hard time separating the things that he's done that are really big contributions (he almost single handedly forced gibson to improve quality), and things that aren't that big of a deal (his strat copy that the company released last year is sort of a mix and match of strat and other guitar design elements, but if you didn't see it and listened to him talk, you'd sort of expect more from it).

That kind of "my ideas are always great, better than anyone else" can be a good recipe for success in business, though. I don't think he second guesses himself much.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#17

The line between Great and Howling mad

Jim Matthews

The difference between those remembered by History and disregarded as cranks comes down to persuasion. I've looked over Wayne Henderson's shoulder at his bench - there's no secret sauce to a fine archtop, and he's essentially unkown.

See : Bill Burr on Steve Jobs.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#18

Re: The line between Great and Howling mad

David Weaver

There are so many great makers. I've never even heard of Wayne Henderson, but a trip to reverb shows used guitars from him way into 5 figures.

You're right about no secret sauce (and no gimmicks, more or less). It's, at least as far as I can tell, a matter of getting all of the details right.

I had a dud martin once (A d-28) that I bought brand new - it was sort of a quiet guitar and kind of dark sounding. I asked george what he did with the dud instruments that he makes after I first started talking to him (thinking that maybe I could take one off his hands and tweak it - a stupid idea, but I didn't know at the time). He said "What duds? I generally have pretty good luck".

I aspire to make instruments like George has made or like Henderson's guitars, but it'll be a long time, probably never, but like tools, they are a great thing to make with minimal power tools.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#19

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

TomD

The Lacy act was the one that really scared me. I did hear they had relaxed a little on that one. But it required you to prove your innocence, and basically some guy at the border with a PHD is in Gilligan's Island reruns would be doing the species identification. There was a guy in the shipping department in a Canadian guitar store who got hung out to dry by the US feds because he was the guy who packaged a guitar that was going cross border on a repair issue. That probably was a legitimate beef if you consider the composition of the average guitar that is worth taking cross border. And you have to admire the ruthless attention grabbing effect of throwing some clerk under the bus, who is now limited by weather and criminal record to a narrow band of territory just north of the Canadian border. :)

Speaking of cheap guitars, I got a Fender acoustic for a daughter (she wreaks stuff, though I don't think she has wreaked this as it happens). It was around 100 dollars Can, so really cheap, perfect if she Chris Farleyed it. Anyway, it was a really nice guitar. The B&S were ply, but then so are they on some 10-20K guitars, and the set-up was really decent, very playable.

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#20

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

Joe Rogers, West Virginia

John, I read that a favorite wood for bows is Pau Ferro and that sourcing it is difficult. It seems your endeavor is really stymied. Do you have issues with Pau Ferro anddo you use it personally?

Joe

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#21

Pernambuco... not Pau Ferro

Joe Rogers, West Virginia

Data retrieval issue... I read about Pernambuco not Pau Ferro and mentally substituted the incorrect wood species.

Joe

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#22

Re: Pernambuco... not Pau Ferro

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi Joe,

Yes, I have a small supply of pernambuco I bought before the CITES appendix II designation. I have more than enough wood to make bows till I croak. And I've got specific wording in my will as to who and how the remaining stock is dispersed afterwards...

After the CITES designation, I and most of my colleagues, recorded the amount and weight of our stock, wrote a letter with photos of the wood and said weights, and had the letter notarized. Shows what we have and when we had it. Just to protect ourselves. Did the same for the ebony I own.

I have a supply of alternative woods including ipe, unfigured snakewood, and several swartzia species that work very well for making bows, especially viola bows. All quietly seasoning in racks...

John

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#23

John...I don't suppose I could...

david weaver

...ever make a good bow, but looking at pictures of your bows online sure makes me want to try at some point.

I could probably coin a term... "dumbow" for something at my level of making.

"If a good bow is out of your reach, try one of our dumbows! Made by hand, just like the good ones, but made by dumb hands!"

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#24

Re: John...I don't suppose I could...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi David,

Making a good bow is a combination of many factors. As a maker, there is a give and take process to make the best bow you can, given what you are dealt. These are natural materials!

First and foremost is the quality of the wood. Bad quality wood makes it very difficult, but not impossible to make a bow. Maybe not a good bow, but a serviceable bow.

Next factor are the dimensions. Too high a head and frog (the bottom most portion of the bow, near the hand) can make a bow unstable. There are ways to compensate, but not to yield a really good playing stick. Other dimensions are the graduations, the subtle tapering from the frog end to the head. I and others regularly measure to 0.1mm to achieve this taper. We are also guided by our eyes and by feel, both the bending of the bow's stick and/or for assessing the taper. If the stick is round, the degree of roundness is important.

Overall weight and balance are very important. For a modern (not baroque) violin bow, the weights range from 56 to 64 grams, centered around 60 +/- 2 grams. Players can feel a balance difference of a few mm, so it has to be right for their playing style.

Lastly, the straightness and camber - the inward curve of the bow. This is critical as it is the soul of the bow's playing qualities. The evenness of the draw from one end to the other, the fullness of the sound, the ability to bounce the bow, the quickness of the bow's maneuvering are all tied to the camber. No one knows exactly how or why the camber affects a bow, we just know though experience what works. A lot of great scientific minds have worked this problem, with positive but sometimes mixed results. I have my ideas of what's going on, but I can't prove them without difficult measurements.

And I haven't even mentioned the artistic aspect of making a bow. Frankly, there are some really ugly bows that play well, so beauty and usefulness are not tied together. Except for the fact that if a player is using a beautiful bow by a famous "dead guy", that player feels the bow is better. So, psychoacoustics come into play!

Notice I've only talked about the stick of the bow so far. The frog and button are important, especially the fit of them to the stick. Frogs and buttons mix precious metal, mother of pearl and often other materials to make beautiful but functional bits of the bow. But some makers, even super well known ones, farm out the frog and buttons to very capable firms that specialize in doing them. This was historically done - many 19th century makers made only the stick and fitted the frog and button and then finished the whole.

So yes, given these constraints, you could make a bow! Many people do.

John

Re: Mahogany Les Paul Specials

#25

Thanks for that, John!

david weaver

Very interesting. From an outside perspective, two things are apparent to me:

* the wood in the top level bows looks perfect. the workmanship, without question, the same.

* I have no clue what would make a good bow, and making something that "looks" like a good bow has near zero chance of being good

* the hair on the bow, what is it?

And all of the other things that you mentioned about balance - I can build a decent guitar already, because I know what makes a good playing guitar. I can build a decent plane, because I know what makes a good working plane.

As tempting as it is to put making a violin half a decade into the future, and trying to wade into making a bow, I would be reduced to trying to get a violin in hand, and just copy every aspect of it. And getting a good well-regarded bow in hand and copying every aspect of it.

And that seems kind of rude!!

100% agree on the aesthetics of the tools (or bows in this case as a tool for the player). At one point, the sentiment on this forum was "no professional actually cares about the aesthetics of a tool, and no professional actually buys a lot of tools".

And then, George introduced himself to us, George being probably the best maker in general that I've ever seen in terms of seeming to make a whole bunch of unrelated things to an extremely high standard and with good taste. And he is consumed with making things look nice (even routine things) so that they inspire you to work to a better standard.

Not that he can't make things quickly when needed - I asked him about the scraper that his apprentice/journeyman was using to scrape a spruce top in one of the violin videos. It's an oval shaped infill scraper, and he said basically that it's a piece of brass tubing squished into an oval with the sole sweated on and the infill made for it all in about an hour. Even his junk tools look good.

(in case I rambled in circles above and didn't communicate it as well as I should have - I much appreciate the outlining of all of those aspects of making a bow - it's a good (great) reminder that to do great work, you have to know what standard you're working toward, and just getting to know the standard can be an awful lot - but is rarely regretted).