Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Birthday gift to myself

Posts

Birthday gift to myself

#1

Birthday gift to myself

Chuck Bjorgen

The plane shown below arrived in the mail today and scratched an itch of curiosity that I’ve had for quite a while about infills. This one is a Mathieson, from Scotland, has straight sides, a Sorby iron and is a bit over seven inches. Don’t know if it was dovetailed although I keep thinking I see a sign that it is. I sharpened the iron and tried taking some shavings right away. Nothing special so far and I’ve been tinkering with the cap iron, close set and gradually moving it back. This on pine.

Two questions: these planes have very tight mouths so I’m wondering if the close set cap iron/chip breaker works against me? Also, is there any reason why a hollow grind would not be okay?I usually reshape old irons on the Tormek and finish on a variety of stones. I’ve seen Derek Cohen’s story on restoring a Spiers infill but I don’t think I’ll be going that far with this one. It’s in pretty good shape except for some blemishes and scrapes on the handle and bun. And David Weaver has moved a lot of these planes through his shop. Your comments and all others here are welcomed.


Re: Birthday gift to myself

#2

Re: Birthday gift to myself

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi Chuck,

Nice find and happy birthday! I have one similar but a Spiers. I think the Matthieson planes sometimes had the words "DOVETAILED" stamped into the metal at the front. In the center of the thicker sole piece. Unless it's a cast version.

Won't comment on the actual questions asked regarding the throat and chip breaker. Maybe others have more experience. I'm not too concerned with an open mouth if there is a chipbreaker present and is properly adjusted. And anyway, it looks like you are getting nice results already!

John

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#3

Re: Birthday gift to myself

Wiley Horne

Hi Chuck,

Congratulations! Beautiful plane! Here’s my anecdotal experience on tight mouths, with and without chipbreaker....

Anything that bends the shaving (compared to open mouth) is doing work—in the physics sense—on the shaving. This work has to be paid for, and it is paid by your pushing more, compared to wide open mouth. “More’ can be anywhere from barely noticeable to PITA more.

What I find bears out your intuition: if you add tight chipbreaker to tight mouth, it is compounding the bending and hence the work.

So you’re looking for the sweet spot on your plane—the minimum bending that gets the job done. My only infill experience is with Konrad Sauer’s infills. I hope Steve Elliott weighs in, as he is highly experienced in tuning infills. Anyway, Konrad’s planes, bedded at 47.5 or higher, with the chipbreaker retracted, will plane with or against the grain, without tearout, on most temperate zone hardwood. Bear in mind, the tight mouth just by itself is forcing the shaving through a tighter curve. If the chipbreaker is lowered, this increases the bending and the work without significantly increasing the performance. Also, I notice the plane will go with or against the grain, but against the grain is more work. It’s like uphill vs. downhill. I recall the same thing showing up in Prof. Kato’s work.

With steel-soled planes (as opposed to wood or iron), I use wax on the sole when I think of it. The steel is more friction for some reason. Some fine sandpaper on a surface plate is a diagnostic as to whether the front of the mouth is sitting down hard on the work. (I know you are very experienced—I’m just throwing this stuff in to pontificate.)

Bottom line: suggest raise chipbreaker, wax sole, and make sure front of mouth is on the work. Beautiful plane, thanks for showing.

Wiley

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#4

Re: Birthday gift to myself

Chuck Bjorgen

Thanks for the comments, John and Wiley. I found the engraved mark “steel” on the front of the sole so I’ll assume it’s not dovetailed. The maker’s mark “A. Mathieson” is stamped on the front of the bun, barely visible.

Wiley, I don’t know why I didn’t try waxing the sole because my bar of canning wax was sitting right in front of me. Tried that this morning, pajamas and all, and it was a wonderful difference. Apparently steel does offer more resistance than cast iron. I will continue to play with the chip breaker setting but right now it’s working pretty well. Will need to try hardwood next.

For those who care, this was an eBay buy now or best offer purchase. I made what I thought was a reasonable (not insulting) offer and it was accepted. The seller is a tool antique dealer and has a couple more listed, a Spiers and Norris.

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#5

Re: Birthday gift to myself

Wiley Horne

Chuck,

Glad that worked out, it seems odd that steel and iron would have different effects. Konrad put me onto it.

Now I remember why I mentioned about checking the front of mouth. This is important in conjunction with the tight mouth. In an open- mouth situation, where you’re using the chipbreaker to bend the chip to a critical point, I doubt it would matter much if the front of mouth is slightly in the air, cause the breaker is playing the critical role. But where the breaker is retracted, you’re counting on the tight mouth to force the shaving into a tight turn. The shaving is being forced into a tight turn between the blade tip and the front-of-mouth. So if the mouth is not sitting down hard on the work, the shaving has a degree of freedom to spring up a little off the blade tip, which would let the cut run forward a little and cause tearout.

There. (wiping brow) I feel much better. Thanks for putting up with windy splaining.

Wiley

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#6

Re: Birthday gift to myself *LINK*

Steve Elliott

That’s a nice-looking plane, Chuck. I prefer older tools with some dings and signs of use to brand-new shiny ones.

I’d guess that your plane is dovetailed. On Peter McBride’s website he has a number of pictures of planes stamped “STEEL” that are clearly dovetailed. You can see a line on the side of the plane that is aligned with the top of the sole, except where the dovetails are. The link is below.

My experience with infill planes has been with older ones that typically have mouths wide enough that use of the cap iron is more effective for controlling tearout. I’ve made replacement blades that are thick enough to reduce the mouth to about .008” and haven’t had problems with shaving clearance or clogging even with a very tightly-set cap iron.

Like yours, my planes don’t have adjusters so I use the “tap and try” method for setting the blade. Sometimes as I tap the blade the cap iron shifts position, usually ending up further from the edge than I’d set it. I tighten the cap iron screw as much as possible to help avoid this.

A hollow grind works fine, especially one with the 10” radius you get from a Tormek. A very tight radius could leave the cutting edge less well supported but any wheel 6” or more in diameter is big enough. I’ve used a Tormek for about twenty years and like it for sharpening blades in my kitchen where dust from grinding would be a problem. I bought a CBN wheel for sharpening at the shop where I work and prefer it for its greater speed but either grinding method will give a good edge when the honing is done well. I don’t like grinding clear to the edge because coarse scratches can degrade the steel below the surface even if the scratches have disappeared. Grinding is especially beneficial on thick blades like the ones in traditional infill planes. There’s a lot of metal that needs to be removed compared to thinner blades.

There are a few ways an infill plane is different from a Bailey plane that may not be obvious. One is the reduced length of the sole in front of the blade (on smoothing planes, at least). This allows the plane to follow the contour of a slightly out-of-flat surface instead of removing only the high spots. I LIKE this feature in a smoothing plane. It gives me more control of where I remove wood. Another difference is the increased clamping power of the lever cap. Compared to the Bailey design an infill can really hold the blade tightly against the bed. I’ve found that as a blade loses sharpness it will continue to cut acceptably well (without chatter) in an infill plane when a similarly dull blade would cause chatter in a Bailey plane. Increased useful blade life is always a plus in my book.

Like any new tool your infill will have a different feel from the planes you’re used to. This may make it feel “wrong” at first but with more experience you may end up liking it better. After almost 40 years of using Bailey planes, wood-bodied planes and infill planes I can’t say which design is best. They can all be great tools when you get to know them.


Peter McBride on Planes Stamped STEEL

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#7

Re: Birthday gift to myself

Chuck Bjorgen

Thanks for the link, Steve. I’ll probably try to do a pencil rubbing on the stamp on the front of the bun and maybe a close up photo of the “steel” mark.

Like any new tool your infill will have a different feel from the planes you’re used to. This may make it feel “wrong” at first but with more experience you may end up liking it better.

That’s definitely been my experience so far. I did manage to pick up a book “Infill Planes” by Hans Brunner that describes some of the interaction and exchange of parts between Mathieson and Spiers and another web site that even discusses forgery of the Mathieson line by creating stamps that would suggest the plane is an original. Fun stuff so far.

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#8

Re: Birthday gift to myself

Steve Elliott

I have a genuine Mathieson plane that was re-stamped with the forged stamp. The original stamp is very faint and the more recent stamp is sharp-edged and matches images of the forgeries.

I believe the forged stamp was used on old infill planes to make them bring higher prices. What matters is the quality of the plane itself, at least if it's a user.

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#9

Quality

Wiley Horne

Steve,

Where would you look for signs of quality? Invisible dovetailing? Crispness of the mouth filing, esp. the beveling on the upper surface of the mouth (exit side)?

That’s very interesting about your original Mathieson being re-stamped. Are you saying it was likely done to reassure the buyer, when the original mark had become almost illegible?

Wiley

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#10

Re: Quality

Steve Elliott

Quality to me is having all the functional aspects of the plane right so that it works well. Many of the user-made planes I've seen have problems with their geometry. If the pivot for the lever cap is too high the lever cap screw hits the cap iron an an angle that causes the blade to shift when the screw is turned to tighten the blade. If the metal shell is narrower at the top than at the mouth then the blade will have to be so narrow that there are gaps at the sides of the mouth. (When the dovetails are peened it tends to make the sides move together at the top, so this is a common problem among user-made planes.) The known makers had solved these issues and their planes can be tuned to be peak performers.

Of course the "fit and finish" of different manufacturers varied but by the time a plane is a century old the amount of wear has overtaken the original state of the plane when it was new. I've had to flatten badly worn soles and remove high spots from the blade bed to get some of my planes working well. I typically make a new cap iron to exactly fit the width of the blade. Getting the cap iron to stay in place when the screw is tightened can be difficult if the blade is a different thickness on the sides of the slot.

Planes have only a few important parts but how the parts work together can be hard to understand at first. Experience and an open mind are the best guides.

My first plane was a Stanley #4 I bought new in the 1970s. I worked with it for a while before I realized it just wasn't well made and no amount of tuning was going to make it a tool I liked. I now own a Stanley #4 that was made around 1920 and it's a gem. Looking at it closely makes me like it better, unlike that first plane.

I even have a few tools I consider ugly but great tools because they work well. I think quality is hard to define but you know it when you see it.

Oh, and I'm currently re-reading "Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance" which is all about how you know quality, so that has probably influenced my answer.

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#11

Re: Birthday gift to myself

David Weaver

I didn't read all of the other replies, and apologize if I'm repeating anything.

Most of those planes (I've got some mathiesons, but not sure that I have a plane exactly like that one, but I do for sure have some spiers and norris) have the front of the mouth filed away from the bed (similar in angle to the back side of the bun).

They are very certainly filed that way so that the cap iron can be set tightly while still leaving a tight mouth. If someone is married to a tight mouth on a stanley plane and wants to use the cap set close, you can file a stanley similarly.

I believe the makers were trying to accommodate everyone by making the mouth tight, but more importantly, getting a tight mouth on an infill is a display of skill on a plane that would've been very expensive back when they were made. Some don't have a tight mouth, but the early planes generally do.

All that said, unless the mouth is 4 thousandths (and none that I have are close to that), the tight mouth limits damage but doesn't eliminate tearout.

So, set the cap close, and examine the angle of the back of the mouth (on the sole) and see if it sort of goes with the bun. If someone has replaced a cap iron from the original plane or bungled one up, it might not work properly. I'd imagine nearly every one of these planes left the makers', though, able to set the cap close without clogging.

None of mine clog or have issues with the cap set closely.

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#12

Re: Birthday gift to myself

David Weaver

I've probably had 20 infills. I read through your original post again. Along with my comments about the sole being filed so that the cap can be set close, one thing you may need to do is lap the sole on a flat surface. Things move over time when you've got metal wrapped around wood.

Prep the iron as you would and make the front bevel of the cap iron about 50 degrees (and short, like a microbevel and then a shallower primary).

Check the bedding of the iron (the iron itself, make sure that it beds evenly), and the fit against the front of the lever cap. If everything is right and the sole is flat, it should work as well as the best stanley plane and have sort of a more luxury feel.

I'm guessing that plane probably weighs around 3 1/2 to 4 pounds?

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#13

Re: Birthday gift to myself

David Weaver

I'm guessing that plane was made by spiders. I'm not a plane historian but suspect several makers made planes for mathieson, and maybe some were made by mathieson.

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#14

Re: Birthday gift to myself

Chuck Bjorgen

I put several #4 sized smoothers on a postage scale this morning. The infill was just under three pounds. A LN #4 iron plane was three pounds. A Bedrock 604 with Hock iron was 1.96 pounds and a regular Stanley #4 came in at 2.3 pounds. I thought the infill might have been heavier but it's also a couple inches shorter than the Stanley. I also thought the Bedrock would be heavier than the regular Stanley.

I may work on the sole. It seems flat with the cutter retracted and a straight edge applied but it also has some dings. Mainly I need to get comfortable setting it up with various wood types. I'm not ready to start filing the mouth. The mating of the chip breaker to the back of the iron is quite good and that suggests to me that the previous owner knew what he was doing.

I have a couple of all wood planes, 16 and 24 inches and it took a while to figure those out. They work well now. I can't say the same for a pair of coffin smoothers which, I fear, have some structural problems, possibly the wedges.

I appreciate all your comments, folks. This was a one-of-kind acquisition for me. I don't see any further buys of this type.

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#15

Re: Birthday gift to myself

Hank Knight

Chuck, my daughter gave me a Norris A5 she found on Portobello Road in London years ago. I thought it would immediately give me unparalleled results. I was disappointed. It didn't behave much different from my Stanleys, and, in some cases it was much worse. I bought modern A2 replacement iron from Lie-Nielsen thinking that would make a huge difference. It didn't, it was worse. Without going into all the minute details, I kept working with the plane and little by little I got to know it. It is now my favorite smoother. Nothing else in my arsenal even comes close. It handles almost every smoothing task I've given it easily. I frequently use it for final smoothing in lieu sanding. it leaves a flawless surface in most any wood. My advice is to take it slow with your new plane and learn it as you go. Try the advice you get here and elsewhere, but don't be afraid to reject stuff that obviously doesn't work. Save the stuff that works. You'll eventually get to know your plane and you'll love it, just like I love my Norris.

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#16

Re: Birthday gift to myself

Chuck Bjorgen

Thanks, Hank. That’s very encouraging. I’ll stay with it.

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#17

Re: Birthday gift to myself

David Weaver

You'll be rewarded once everything is fitted. I know most blog posts would have you believe you'll be taking three ten thousandth of an inch shavings in figured petrified wood, but when you've got lots of time on your favorite plane, nothing else will match without learning quirks.

I fitted a spiers plane tonight, one that i have that's almost identical to yours that I never set up before. It has the same quirk that a lot of other adjuster-free infills have. I can set it at zero with the lever cap slightly loose. Give it a tap and tighten the screw and it's taking an idea smoother shaving, but the cap screw turns the adjustment to the right a little bit. One light tap on the top of the iron to the left and it's centered. With a cambered iron, 90% of the time, that's it. If it's cutting a slight amount too deep, loosen the lever cap screw slightly while you're using it and the iron should go right back to zero and just as it does, tighten the cap screw again and you're right back at it.

With all of my less pretentious infill planes (as in, no late model or older overweight planes), the results are similar to a perfectly performing stanley 4, but the feel is just a little better.

The 6 pound smoothers give people the impression that the plane is smoother and doing better surface work, but it's just the weight masking feel from you, and there's no great virtue in that.

The infill irons were usually on the harder side, similar to modern irons in hardness (modern boutique), but finer steel. Like the best domestic O1 steel that you can get now (which is a step up from the hock high carbon irons I've tried).


The inside of the mouth, as i mentioned in another post. The front of the mouth is filed toward the bun, very intentionally to allow room for chip escapement with the cap set close. The mouth is useful for a novice user, but only makes the surface a little better. The cap iron is much more useful. I'd imagine the mouth on this plane is probably a hundredth or slightly less. It's wide enough that it doesn't cause much resistance.

I have a self-made infill with a 4 thousandth mouth (single iron, I made it back in 2010 before I knew what I was doing). Much more than 2 thousandths of chip and it becomes like a car with the emergency brake on.

As an aside, I think something might be off with your scale. I measured two mid century stanley 4s (one a little later than that). One with a stock iron was 3 lbs. 8oz, and one with a replacement iron that I made is 3 pounds 10 ounces.

The spiers here is 3 lbs 14 ounces (at the upper end of the range I suspected in a prior post). I've got three planes of this style - one a norris 2, one an unmarked gunmetal plane and this. They're about the same in weight. I'd make a remark about there not being bloated old planes back then, but I also have a 15 1/2 inch norris A13 (an uncommon plane) and it's got a thick cast sole and weighs about 8 1/2 or 9 pounds. I want to copy the pattern, but not the weight.

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#18

Mouth gap

Wiley Horne

What David says.

Also, if you want a ballpark on mouth gap, and forgot where you set your feeler gauges down, a Post-It note is very close to 4 thousandths.

Wiley

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#19

Re: Birthday gift to myself - Spiers = Spiders?...


Re: Birthday gift to myself

#20

Re: Birthday gift to myself - Spiers = Spiders?...

David Weaver

Thanks. Courtesy of the phone auto correct. Not surprised it doesn't know what spiers is.

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#21

Re: Quality

David Weaver

The discussion of what amateurs often make as gar as mistakes go making planes reminds me of something george wilson told me years ago. That is, if you're not a good designer, you're far better off resorting to copying something good. It took me a while to figure that out.

I filed the back of the mouth on a Slater kit vertical years ago, and didn't realize until later that it needed to be filed forward. Other than that, I did a very good job. It was a panel plane, and I set the mouth at a hundredth and it still had tear out problems. That single issue made the plane substandard. I later filed it properly and sold it fully functional. The makers of those kits didn't have the sense to copy some of the elements from older planes quite right.

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#22

Re: Birthday gift to myself

Chuck Bjorgen

David — Good tip on the tightening of the screw causing a slight tilt on the iron. That was easy to correct with my brass hammer. I also found your technique for adjusting the blade depth by loosening the screw and moving the plane forward on the wood. That worked for me.

I changed the battery in my small (5 pound max) postal scale and still got the same weight reading. I should have another kitchen digital scale in hand Tuesday and will check the weight again. Meanwhile my next step is to reshape the cutter on my old Tormek. Will try to achieve a slight camber.

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#23

Re: Birthday gift to myself

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hello Chuck,

I looked again at the infill planes I own and found that those that are stamped "STEEL" on the toe are always dovetailed. I'd guess yours is dovetailed too. Those not stamped, well it's a 50:50 chance...

And I stand corrected - none of my planes are stamped "Dovetailed" on the toe end. Only "STEEL". I guess I was misremembering...

Look carefully at the front (and back) corners of the sides and bottom. If the inside corner is very sharp and defined, it could be dovetailed. The few cast examples I have show an indistinct, often rounded, inside corner. The dovetailed ones are quite sharp in the corners.

Also, the sides can often be quite a bit thinner than the bottom in a dovetailed plane. Almost half the thickness of the bottom. Cast plane's sides and bottom are nearly the same thickness. At last in my examples.

It is often very hard to see the actual dovetails. Let's face it, they were aiming to make them invisible! Look carefully and you might see them. Use a magnify lens. Maybe rub some India ink or Dykem blue over the region and wipe off the excess. Perhaps it will make the dovetail joints more apparent.

Best of luck with it!

John

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#24

Re: Birthday gift to myself

Chuck Bjorgen

Thanks, John. That's all good to know, although now that I own this plane I won't worry about it. One of the tips David Weaver passed along about loosening the screw and pushing the plane forward on the wood to find the depth sweet spot for the cutter was particularly useful. I had started to wonder if it would be good to have a Norris type depth adjuster on an infill. Now that I learned the little move from David I won't worry about it.

One minor note about a post I made a couple days ago about the weight of the infill compared to other planes. A second scale I acquired showed only a plus 1/10th of an ounce difference in the weights I posted then.

Right now the plane is working well on the chunk of pine shown in the photo. Not so fine on some of the hardwoods I've tried but I have not yet reground the cutter. I'll go with 25 degrees unless I'm convinced to sharpen to 30 degrees. Thanks all for the feedback.

Re: Birthday gift to myself

#25

On finding the dovetails...

david weaver

In terms of just how invisible the dovetails can be after 100 years, the makers had two things on their side in the old days:

1) they knew enough about the wood they were putting in a plane to make sure it wouldn't blow out and telegraph the dovetails (unfortunately, I can say that happens because one of my planes of my own make - made in the winter - telegraphed the dovetails big time - you can feel them - once the wood took on ambient moisture in the summer. Not a structural threat, but not what you're aiming for as a maker)

2) these planes were made in england and probably came to generally lower humidity over here in the states. If anything, the infills generally shrink both for that reason, and for the lack of springback that occurs in older wood (e.g., it will shrink with lower moisture, but with reintroduction of ambient moisture will only come back a percentage, and that percentage decreases with wood's age.

Long story short, the old ones are set not to blow out their dovetails initially and age sort of locks it in.

I think this spring back is the same thing that causes a lot of older instrument tops to crack over time when they can't freely shrink and move. It's uncommon as far as I've seen to find an acoustic guitar that's 60 years old with a top that is pristine and never received a repair (that was compounded for them by shrinking pickguards that crack the tops by shrinking faster than the pickguards).

Most of the older spiers and mathieson planes were dovetailed (like this one), and if you look long enough, you can find the dovetails sooner or later. An acid edge would probably find them immediately. Sanding actually hides them a little (I wouldn't do either of them).

The rounded castings or U-channel steel - some of the castings are rounded, but I think Norris used U-steel and then machined the outside for later planes. I had one (I don't think they did it, I guess, I know they did - it's really offputting in person!!, but the planes are still stable and good working planes - probably technically better than a plane with an iron casting even if the latter is more attractive).

From time to time someone like Chris Schwarz will make a remark about the design of the older planes being wonky (like the A13), which makes me want to give someone a suplex. Up until Norris started looking for cost reductions, these planes were basically works of art in a time when cost control was bearing down on everyone. The A13 bone stock and pre-adjuster is a true delight to use, as are the lighter planes of this type.

The Norris A1 that I had that was made of U channel steel, I wanted to dislike because it seemed like putting plastic hubcaps on a duesenberg, but it was also a treat to use after mastering the quirks of the norris adjuster (which changes depth if you tighten the lever cap - you can make that work for you as a fine adjuster, but it's annoying at first when you're used to a stanley, and you have to set it at an arbitrary depth that's different than what you want to use it at and then tighten the lever cap to finish the adjustment).

TMI!

(I have yet to find one of these that I don't like, but I do have a severe distaste for the norris adjuster in an A5 - it's less of a pane in a plane that's intended for heavier work, like a panel plane).