Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Stanley #80 -Repaint??

Posts

Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#1

Stanley #80 -Repaint??

Tom Norton

So on a previous post I inquired about my curly maple and the planning process. I am going to tweak all my planes and give it a go. But I was playing with my #80 yesterday for a bit and it shows a bit of promise.

But I like nice looking tools!! My #80 came from my wife's father and had white paint and such splashed on it. So would like to repaint and thought I would inquiry here.

So your advice would be great!!!

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#2

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

david weaver

Completely remove the old paint with stripper. The stuff that's sold at home depot in a can with the word "stripper" on it is very good stuff and will remove anything, any paint, any japanning. It'll burn your fingers if it's on for a while, too, but not immediately, so it's not that dangerous. If you start to feel it because it got on you somewhere and you didn't know about it, wash it off with water and soap and no problem.

Clean whatever you're refinishing well and then decide whether you're going to japan it, paint it or do some other surface treatment (parkerizing, gun blue and wax, etc) and do that after you're sure the surface is completely clean.

Nothing that I'm aware of is as durable as japanning. the high solids/high build paints look good, but they will eventually chip. Never tried anything more advanced (two part or high impact paints specially made).

The idea of gun bluing and then waxing one is attractive to me, personally, as is doing the same and putting a very light coat of shellac on just to prevent rust on the bluing. Too thick and it'll chip instead of scratching.

One of the most attractive two handle tools that I have (like the 80 style) is a bailey boston hollow shave. It has zero japanning on it, and zero rust. To me, it just looks good without anything on it at all, and has that sort of plum brown burnished look.

Just my opinions. I don't think old tools with paint on will ever be worth much (if they are common), nor will common old tools with the japanning in shambles. Do what pleases you.

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#3

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

Ron in Sterling, CT

Hi Tom,

I basically agree with David. Strip and refinish. It doesn't make the tool work any better, but they sure look nice. I have repainted quite a number of old Stanley/Bailey planes. I have not gotten into the Japanning. The ones I have repainted have been for my own use. I have used black lacquer as well as black auto engine paint. Both are easy to apply and look fine. The auto engine paint is more durable. My 2 cents.

Ron

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#4

Old Pontypool

Wiley Horne

Can’t resist. For the recoating part....

http://libertyonthehudson.com/pontypool.html

A little pricey.

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#5

Re: Old Pontypool

Tom Norton

A little pricey!!!! Wow!!

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#6

Funny...

Tony - Memphis

Everybody has different perspectives on such. I like the occasional paint spatter and wear and stains and such. I think it shows the tool's age and history. Kind of like my face! Ha! Its interesting how everybody views things like that different. I know a lot of folks that like things to look brand new, perfect, etc. Others not. And then there are the purists that think spray paint on a old tool is, well, sacrilege. By cleaning and painting and making it look 'pretty,' you are adding your own history to the tool. I'm sure whoever employs it after you will appreciate it.

I have a newish #80. I would caution you to practice on some scrap. There was a learning curve for me. There is a Kelly Mehler video out there that really helped me. I'm still not real good with it. I have a scraper plane that is still getting the best of me. Oh well.

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#7

Re: Old Pontypool

david weaver

Thanks for that link, wiley. I recall a decade ago there was some japanning for sale on and off, but each time I contacted someone, I got "I'm not making that any longer, not worth the trouble".

A quart would cover a lot of planes, and it would resist scratches and impact chipping better than paint. The seller says no oven curing - even better. I'm sure it cures faster than my house-made varnish.

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#8

Re: Funny...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Stripping/repainting it will not improve the aerodynamics. Doing it is not woodworking.

But if having it look good is important to you, you've had good advice above.

By the way, all, or almost all, older planes and plane-like tools have paint splatters. I think there's a plane leprechaun who goes around with a paint brush at night, doing the work; the older the plane, the more times the leprechaun's been around. Mostly, for some reason, white paint, although my Stanley No. 78 was apparently hit by a paint leprechaun who's a fan of Barbie or My Little Pony, because the paint splatters are pink.

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#9

No plane leprechauns here.

Kevin French

I have plenty of mice and an occasional squirrel in this old farmhouse but no plane leprechaun. I just did a check of my 13 Bench Planes and they're clean, also none are aerodynamic either. I have a few things I'd like to use the Japanning linked above on, but not my Hand Planes.

Does Japanning only come in Black?

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#10

But Kevin,

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"I have a few things I'd like to use the Japanning linked above on..."

If you japan your Japanese motorcycle or car, you need a really big oven to bake the japanning.

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#11

Re: Funny...

Hank Knight

Tony, you probably can't remove the wear stains from your face, but you should at least TRY to remove the paint spatters! :)

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#12

Re: But Bill,

Kevin French

Patriots are made in the USA

No MC

I do have a 1985 Miyata Road Bicycle. Japanning that might defeat the purpose, but it woul look good.

No Bake.

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#13

Re: Old Pontypool - Liberty on the Hudson...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hello Wiley,

Thanks for the link to Liberty on the Hudson and their asphaltum paint.

(A) I'd be interested in buying a quart of this if two (or three or four) others are willing to split it. Would be good to have some. Contact me directly and see if we can make this happen...

(B) I've purchased from Liberty in the Hudson several times and they are a great firm to do business with. I've gotten their Golden Spike Railroad and the Historic Colors, Ltd. paints. Both are full (long?) oil paints that you can brush till the cows come home to get a nice clean looking finish. I really dislike most latex paints as they feel like I'm painting with rubber that dries so fast that you can't brush it out. My opinion. Except for one room in our house, all the trim is painted with oil based primers and paints.

Over and out,

John

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#15

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??  OR...

david weaver

Thanks for that. I have two of the ingredients already and ordered asphaltum to give it a shot.

I wonder what makes the "store bought" version cure without the oven. Japan drier?

Japan drier in Japanning? :b

Todd's version requires heating to 450 or so (degrees F), which I can't do in the house, but may get a toaster oven to facilitate if japan drier doesn't work. If nobody knows, I can try it and report back. I've never used japan drier, but am getting weary waiting for sunlight with a violin varnish recipe, and will have it on hand.

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#16

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??  OR...

John Aniano in Central NJ

David,

Wouldn't the combination of linseed oil, turpentine and the pigment asphaltum simply be an oil based paint?

I looked at my larder of stuff and found I had some Gilsonite-based asphaltum powder (#47600) from Kremer Pigments in New York. The package says it is soluble in turpentine and is sold as a black pigment. So, being soluble, maybe it wouldn't be so much a paint but a stain instead. Maybe a bit of both.

I went through some other older texts I have for "japanning" and there were recipes for many colors of japanning. "Japan Black", "Japan White", "Japan Vertigris", "Japan Red", etc. all depending on the pigment used. The black version in two texts showed an additional ingredient of burnt umber along with the asphaltum, linseed oil and turpentine. The umber would definitely make this a paint since it isn't soluble in any of the other constituents. Lastly, the addition of burnt umber introduces iron oxide into the mix and can act as a drier as well as a pigment.

And yes, I'd assume some metallic driers would speed the curing of the applied coating. I use Kremer siccative #203 (which I think may be manganese- or cobalt-based) for my oil finishes on my bows. I also use a light box to help get the curing accomplished.

Neat stuff and an interesting topic! I may just try this out and report back. I have a #5 plane that needs renewing. We can compare notes...

John

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#17

Recipes

Kevin French

I like to see the recipes in you have in 'some other older texts' especially the colored variations

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#18

Ha!

Tony - Memphis

I dunno, perhaps the paint spatters act as camouflage!?! I was working in the yard Wednesday - we've had tons of rain. Came in and looked in the mirror - my face was covered in mud splatter.

My father in law had a saying..."Ugly people can't help being ugly, but the least they could do is stay home." I try.

One last story....we had a maintenance guy painting our warehouses where I used t work. He had a spray rig and was painting everything that didn't move (unless it was slower than him!). He covered his face in Vaseline and wore a sock mask thing. He looked like an albino raccoon - white all around his eyes where the sock didn't cover. It was pretty funny. Too bad we didn't have cell phones with cameras back then.

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#19

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??  OR...

david weaver

Thanks for the comments, John. When I looked up asphaltum on ebay yesterday, there were many options color wise - maybe 5? Depending on where in the world the powder was coming from.

I stuck with black, but thought the others were neat looking. They don't appear to be intended for paint purposes, though (some of them were mixed with herbs), so I wasn't brave enough to buy them and find out that they're not good. I stuck with black gilsonite. I should've bought it from kremer pigments, but didn't think about them at the time.

I read a little bit about japan drier yesterday. Everything i read from folks is "too unhealthy to use, extremely toxic. Generally mineral salts that are some kind of cobalt (or cobalt salts?). Not a geologist or chemist, so no clue about the accuracy of that statement. I think my varnish is probably a "healthy varnish", but it would probably take years to fully cure. it takes a few months and a couple of sun sessions for it to be reasonably hard, but it's still not resistant to shellac when I use shellac to touch up any bumps a guitar gets when installing the hardware.

At any rate, I got a chuckle out of the insistence from some posts to not use japan drier (because of the toxicity of cobalt) and then subsequent recommendations to use something like epifanes. I have epifanes on hand, too, but it smells like an oil slick and is really sticky (the turp/pine/damar varnish is sticky, but less so, and easier to wash off or wipe off with some effort). Epifanes dries a little bit faster, and sure enough, the MSDS lists cobalt.

So I'm going to try some in mine. George recommended the same if I was getting impatient, but he said a drop at a time, as things can change fast in varnish and the result will be cracking and crazing.

I am not working to nearly the same standards as your bows. I don't mind some finish flaws and am not looking for a rubbed out type look, just a thin varnish finish.

As far as the asphaltum/linseed being a paint/stain, I think you're right. It'll dry sooner or later, but it might sag and settle before it does. I wonder if the heat just speeds up oxidation? Who knows. If it dissolves in turpentine, I might thin some of my varnish with turps and put asphaltum in it and see if it partially cures in the sun in a day. My varnish gets hard, but not like lacquer - it might work well. It dries slow enough that it pretty much flows out level or smooth on any surface that it's on.

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#20

Re: Recipes

John Aniano in Central NJ

Kevin,

Here are the recipes I referenced above.

The first is from "Lee's Priceless Recipes", 1998 reprint of the original published in 1895.


Second from "Fortunes in Formulas". My copy published in 1939.


Third from "Book of Formulas: Recipes, Methods & Secret Processes". My copy published in 1945.


Last from "The Universal Receipt Book" reprinted and published in 2009 by Stephen Shepherd. Original from 1824 (plus 1834 extra catalog).


Note that the third text gives specific directions including the heating steps for the japanning of metal as in the case of plane bodies as was asked in the initial posting.

Re: Stanley #80 -Repaint??

#21

Re: Recipes

Kevin French

A VERY big Thank You