ADDIS and SONS CARVING TOOL SET
ROY BERTALOVITZ
Would like help identifying my S.J.ADDIS 12+ piece carving set. Think it's pre-1926 because of the retailers NYC address. I'll send photos if there's interest. Thanks, Roy
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
ADDIS and SONS CARVING TOOL SET
ROY BERTALOVITZ
Would like help identifying my S.J.ADDIS 12+ piece carving set. Think it's pre-1926 because of the retailers NYC address. I'll send photos if there's interest. Thanks, Roy
Re: ADDIS and SONS CARVING TOOL SET
david weaver
Nobody here will be able to offer much help, but a dealer might be able to. Not sure what you're aiming to do, but if you're looking for an appraisal to possibly sell, your only smart move is to go to ebay, post clear pictures of the tools and start high on a buy it now setup and see what kind of feedback you get.
Ebay pretty much determines all but the rarest tool values these days. Addis are fairly common, and the level of interest depends on what you have (in terms of what the set is made of) and whether or not they are little used. All more easily communicated by just listing the set for sale on ebay.
Dealers will probably offer you 1/3rd to 1/2 of what an ebay sale price would be.
Clear pictures, and measure chisels (total length, and width with a head-on picture of the profile) and show all parts of them. Mention any markings on them that may not be easy to see in pictures, or even if they are.
Re: ADDIS and SONS CARVING TOOL SET *LINK*
John Aniano in Central NJ
Hello Roy,
I have a lot of Addis carving tools. Nearly 100 actually. I consider them really the very best carving tools made. Almost none were superior IMO...
There were two Addis brothers who had a "falling out". Because of this, one made tools in London, England and the other made tools in Sheffield. The tools are marked either London or Sheffield. And if my memory serves me, towards the end of the Sheffield son's working period, the name was sold and the tools made by Ward and Payne of Sheffield. Again, super quality with W&P. Most likely, the tools you have were the W&P versions if they are really from 1926. I don't think the London-based Addis was even alive at that time. He won a number of prestigious awards for his tools in the middle/late 19th century. Many of his tools also list these award dates in tiny branded letters. I have to dig around and find a copy of the Addis history that is somewhere on the web. It has all the pertinent working and award dates. A superb article on the history of superb tools!
Re: ADDIS and SONS CARVING TOOL SET *LINK*
John Aniano in Central NJ
Roy,
One of the history documents I mentioned. The link is below.
BTW - in terms of relative value, individual Addis carving tools can usually be found for around $15 and up. Depends on the width, sweep and especially if the tool is an uncommon one like the reversed ones. I've seen some large 1" wide, deep sweep gouges go for ~$60 each at tool swap meets. I'd guess a set of 12 in really nice condition might get a higher price, but like David said above, see the completed eBay sales for a better guide for pricing.
Re: ADDIS and SONS CARVING TOOL SET
joel moskowitz
who is the retailer and what is the address?
Re: ADDIS and SONS CARVING TOOL SET
Richard Jones
"Nobody here will be able to offer much help....."
Why not?
Re: ADDIS and SONS CARVING TOOL SET
Sgian Dubh
"Why not?"
If anybody's wondering, and maybe they're not(?) that Richard Jones is not this one, i.e., the one that hides behind the Sgian Dubh moniker. Slainte.
Re: ADDIS and SONS CARVING TOOL SET
david weaver
I thought that's who it was! The only other richard jones I can recall is the antagonist in robo cop.
Re: ADDIS and SONS CARVING TOOL SET
david weaver
Well, because most of these requests are a request for statement of value. Ebay is about the best way to determine that, and recent ebay (not old sales on some auction data service, no sales of sort of similar things by known dealers).
Not sure what known dealers charge, but would bet that they can get 50% more than ebay, and would expect their offer is less than ebay (the reality of running a business and paying bills).