Beech trees are dying, and nobody’s sure why
Joe in a Cleveland suburb
Thought some of you (plane makers) might be interested in this.
I don't recall reading about it here.
https://news.osu.edu/beech-trees-are-dying-and-nobodys-sure-why
Joe
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Beech trees are dying, and nobody’s sure why
Joe in a Cleveland suburb
Thought some of you (plane makers) might be interested in this.
I don't recall reading about it here.
https://news.osu.edu/beech-trees-are-dying-and-nobodys-sure-why
Joe
Re: Beech trees are dying, and nobody’s sure why
Philip F Duffy
Thanks for the heads up! Not here in eastern VA but the population of beech here is huge so it bears looking carefully come Spring. P.
Re: Beech trees are dying, and nobody’s sure why
Steve Voigt
Thanks for posting. That really sucks; I better get to work stockpiling more beech.
Re: Beech trees are dying, and nobody’s sure why
Ray Newman
My family settled in Sullivan Co, NY, and I recall one a trip back to farm (late 1980's), my uncle telling me that in the early 1980's a blight hit the beech trees there. From what I recall, the blight did not strike all the beech as there still was a large number of healthy trees in our and neighboring wood lots.
Re: Beech trees are dying, and nobody’s sure why
david weaver
Bummer - there's a grove here about a mile from my house, but in a ravine on township land, so I have zero chance of getting any of it. Some of the trees are falling early, but I haven't looked at them to see if there's anything odd.
I believe a lot of horizon's beech came from southern ohio from Mike Digity, but the last time i ordered, horizon only had euro (mike retired).
Re: Beech trees are dying, and nobody’s sure why
Joe in a Cleveland suburb
"I believe a lot of horizon's beech came from southern ohio from Mike Digity, but the last time i ordered, horizon only had euro"
I actually remembered you talking about getting beech from horizon as well as you and others here posting about using beech for your planes. So I thought the story will be interesting to you guys...
Re: Beech trees are dying, and nobody’s sure why
david weaver
Not sure if horizon can still get beech. I bought from a couple of batches, but not that long as buying a hundred board feet of it creates a pile bigger than I'm likely to build out of.
But the last batch I bought from was euro. I think beech in 16/4 has to dry very slowly, and i don't know how many kilns horizon has, but I don't think they can afford to tie one up just for that. They had spoilage or loss of some sort (probably due to that) with the last load of american that I remember waiting for and then I got euro sticks that they imported (more supposing).
It's not a horribly hard wood to dry, but there will be checking, end or side, in 16/4 material somewhere, and it molds/spalts easily.
If it goes away, I guess we'll build out of euro. If that goes away, I suppose we'll build out of birch. If that goes away, I think we'll be able to print beech by then.
Re: Beech trees are dying, and nobody’s sure why
TomD
Actually, as far as Canadian beech is concerned, it dries faster than any wood I have ever seen. Along with my plane blanks, I cut a 7 foot bench blank 5 inches thick. It seemed dry within the year. That is ridiculous. On the old CW site they made the claim that beech was particularly good for planes because it dried in two or three axes. The ends and the rays, and maybe a third kind of escape route, don't remember. Whatever the case, it dries lightning fast.
I have an outside shed, and before putting stuff in there, I put some of the larger pieces in my shop, which is cool all year round. Occasionally I would move a piece to get at something, and almost immediately, if exposed to rays of sun (we are talking Canada here), it would crack. So I don't know why that happens if it has so many exits for moisture, possibly just happens so much faster since there are surface exits according to CW. A regular piece of wood looses a lot fast through the ends only, so a mild heating of the sides doesn't precipitate anything, maybe. Unusual stuff though.
(Sun on beech was the problem that most plagued me with beech, and once identified was easily rectified. otherwise I didn't loose any. I put pieces in my hot shed, no problem. I put pieces in my cold shop, no problems when out of the sun, and it still dried fast enough.)
It has been drying for 7 years now, so it should be nice to use at this point.
Re: Good news...
TomD
for people who want beech so long as it isn't something that makes the wood unusable for political or practical reasons. Cutting wood will increase the supply if we manage to get a step ahead of the firewood purveyors, or landfill patrons. Obviously otherwise a sad story, but then what isn't these days.
Re: Beech trees are dying, and nobody’s sure why
david weaver
I would feel comfortable making a plane, if I had the wood sawn in billets, after a year for 16/4 wood (beech). It might not be completely dry, but it would be close.
A couple of years ago, George Wilson told me that if I had a plane that I thought was too light, before sealing the ends, block the mouth and put linseed oil in the mortise and it will run to the ends of the plane within a day.I did that, and it did - overnight. The oil appeared on the ends of the plane and on one side where the grain ran out slightly.
That's, I'm convinced, the reason that it can crack even after it's long dried, due to normal variation in humidity - because it expels water so fast. I don't generally have a problem with it, except when it goes from 40 degrees to sub zero in a one-day period, then some of my billets will show stress - and if the ends are exposed, they will check.
(I vaguely recall having the discussion on here a couple of years ago about it not being that hard to dry, maybe it was Bill T. Whoever it was, they tried drying it and it crack and they revised their stance. I think there was some offense taken at the time to Horizon's $13.50/bd ft plus shipping for 16/4 billets)
Re: Good news...
david weaver
There was a short bump up in supply with ash around here, some local places selling it cheaper than red oak (which is unusual, red oak is like water here - you can often get it green for a dollar a foot).
It seems like the lumber dealers, at least some, have decided that just because they can get more ash than they could ever sell doesn't mean they have any interest in marketing it like it's oversupplied. As in, they could probably get and sell 8/4 ash all day and make some money at $2 a foot. They've decided to price it back to what it was previously.
Horizon could probably tell us - the market for properly sawn 16/4 is probably saturated for half a year or a year with a partial kiln load. the other one-off sellers who try to sell it (or individual blanks) on ebay don't seem to last long.
Re: Good news...
TomD
I am sure you are right, the demand won't change because the trees are falling over so there isn't much point in increasing supply. But where planes are concerned, it is pretty easy to harvest it from firewood suppliers, since the pieces are small, or to saw one's own. Having the stuff on life support should help those of us who procure it that way.
Re: Beech trees are dying, and nobody’s sure why
TomD
I just haven't had any real difficulty drying most any woods. It was something I worried about a lot when I first started into it, but it hasn't proven to be an issue at all. I live on the Great lakes which probably isn't as bad as Arizona might be. Though the total range is pretty huge for both humidity and heat. It doesn't hurt that one doesn't feel the loss too badly as the wood is free. Though in reality after tooling up; driving; owning a pick-up; the work; the storage, it is anything but free. I only cut the beech because I couldn't find it at any price. It is a pretty nice wood once one gets to know it.
I don't do anything special, just coat the ends and sticker. I used to keep it out of doors, but really better to have a shed. Only thing that I don't do is rush it.

Re: Beech trees are dying, and nobody’s sure why
david weaver
Agree with all of that (especially the implication that it's nicer to just dry wood low tech and not worry about perfection when you have a supply that makes re-dos financially viable).
And definitely on beech itself as a wood - when it's sawn well, it's a nice stand in for maple, but much nicer to work. Not sure why there isn't more appeal to quartered in 4/4 and 8/4, which don't seem to be a problem to dry commercially.