Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

Posts

Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

#1

Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

Dave Shombert

I lost a dear friend a couple years ago, a skilled woodworker who had many hand tools in his shop. I'm now trying to help his widow sell the more valuable ones for (hopefully) what they're actually worth. At the moment, I've got some vintage Stanley planes and a couple of Record planes. One possibility is eBay, of course, as is the Classifieds board here on WC. I"m wondering if there are any other places online where good quality vintage tools are bought and sold. Suggestions appreciated. Thanks

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

#2

eBay

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Dave, this is probably a good time of the year to sell.

Unless you have a reasonable idea of the planes, and understand how to price them, your best bet is probably eBay, where the price will be set by the bidders.

If you do this, make sure you include good photos and descriptions. The clearer the photos of all the plane parts, the more interest there will be.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

#3

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

Don Orr

There is another very active Classified sales forum on Sawmill Creek website. You do have to be a contributor (6$) to list items though. Hope this is not a WC no-no with a suggestion to another Forum. Many members here also hang out over there and vice-versa.

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

#4

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

david weaver

Classifieds for more than a couple of tools is far too cumbersome.

Find the established sale price on ebay (view "sold" items in the last several months), undercut it by a few percent and allow offers.

Save an ebay template type of listing and set up a central place to take pictures. You can list a half a dozen things in not much time that way. If some of your items are similar, just copy listings and change pictures and make minor adjustments.

If you go local, you'll run into tire kickers, non-appearing buyers and professional resellers who will badmouth what you have in an attempt to just get the stuff and sell it on ebay.

I have bought and sold a lot of stuff (you might be able to guess that). If you have something relatively common and things aren't moving fast enough, a straight up auction starting at a penny and the comment "real auction" in the listing does well. If it's something that sells once every three months, a buy it now type listing is far smarter - auctions are risky.

A good friend of mine was looking at selling a Gibson R4 les paul and asked if I was interested. I told him "no, but let me see what's out there so you know what the market looks like". There are about 60 listed on ebay and reverb (a sale site here in the states for guitars). Two sales in the last three months. One at $4,600 and one at $2,750. Identical guitars, identical condition. The second person dared to list something at a real auction when it's a type of guitar that doesn't sell in high volume (they are about $7000 new - the seller took a huge loss). $4,000 would be less than any of the fixed price listings and the guitar would've probably sold within a month or so at that.

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

#5

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

John in NM

I don't think its a no-no here to acknowledge the existence of other forums, but it sure is at SMC! Or maybe its just linking to them that is verboten over there. Either way, that's why I post here and not there :D

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

#6

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

John in NM

I would go with ebay too, BUT - be ready for scammers. Almost every time I've sold on ebay I've gotten some version of the "I'll pay you extra by check or whatever and you refund the difference". I've only sold one item in the last 5 years and that didn't happen, so perhaps they've given up on that sucker bait.

The vintage tool market can be pretty variable, I'm not certain its as strong as it was just 10 years or more ago. You can always search completed auctions on ebay for similar tools to see what you might get.

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

#7

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

david weaver

I wonder why you get that. You might be on a list (your user ID).

I've never gotten that, and have sold about 400 items on ebay (not just tools, probably only 50 of those were tools).

I allow only paypal, which may be why I haven't gotten many oddball requests.

I used to sell some of my tools in the SMC F/S section, and one or two on here, but it's slow going and there is a lot of back and forth sometimes (people offering trades, or all kinds of that nonsense) when you're really looking to just sell something.

No big deal with one item, but if you're hoping to sell 50 things, it's like swimming in molasses.

(in 400 sales, I did have two harrassing ebayers who may have just been mentally ill. One guy wanted a watch that I was selling for $400 for $150. He sent me about 30 messages. I started by politely telling him about $150 watches that look similar, but he wasn't having any of it. You can't stop messages as far as i know, so I just got to ignoring them but he sent an incredible amount. My ask was half of any other listing and 10% below the 3 month average, so the watch sold pretty quickly, but he was irate and kept sending messages for several days. I have actually had more trouble with SMC b/s section - someone offered me a trade years ago. I agreed to it (near mint condition planes). When I got a picture of the items at the last second, the planes were rusty, cut off, with non-matching parts, and hang holes. I backed out of the trade (politely, but said that the picture didn't match the discussions) and the person who wanted to trade gave me a whole bunch of static for a while about how I'd put them out. There's no filter that puts you in contact only with reasonable people.

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

#8

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

John in NM

Probably it was low sales count (scammer assumes you are naive) plus taking payment other than paypal. I mostly buy on ebay, rarely sell.

I think the last auction I did paypal only, that would certainly explain it.

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

#9

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

david weaver

I don't particularly like ebay and their high fees and scammy stuff (and threatening emails to sellers now, constantly threatening to assess fees even if an auction doesn't complete, etc), but going against their vanilla setup (using standard features and just taking paypal so as to have the paper trail and exclusivity/lack of options) is always a problem causing thing.

I never sell instruments on there (those are high cost low volume type things, and reverb set the bar by having a 3.5% fee instead of 10%, and when ebay was forced to meet it, they were too dishonest to communicate why). I'm forced to sell tools there only because nothing else has the reach that ebay does. Etsy is also on the greed train and with offensive communications when you give them your opinion. "we've been listening to you, we hope that you're happy despite ___".

Anyway, offering my suggestions as a seller of things only because it's less than part time for me and I've taken my lumps as far as learning to avoid the things that waste time. My parents have three buildings full of (some of it valuable) junk, so in another decade or so, I may be forced to put all of this in play on a constant basis. I hope my sister is looking for something to do at the time instead, though.

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

#10

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

dave woodspunworkshop.com

Thanks to all. I have a fair amount of experience buying & selling other stuff online, mostly photography gear, so I know most of the pitfalls. I did some searching and haven't found much that's specific to vintage tools, at least not much that looked viable. One exception might be this guy:https://www.jimbodetools.com/collections/jim-bodes-value-guide-to-antique-tools

But most likely, I'm just going to post them on eBay. I'll list them here as well, just because - well, because I can. Thanks again.

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

#11

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

david weaver

That's a pretty good reference.

https://www.jimbodetools.com/collections/jim-bodes-value-guide-to-antique-tools/products/stunning-20-1-2-inch-dovetailed-steel-and-rosewood-norris-no-1-jointer-plane-pre-war-83552

a decade ago, or so, bode was just starting up and buying tools for cheap and trying to sell them for absurd prices. His business looks to have come back to earth on a lot of things, and those prices are about right for good-shape tools if you're willing to list and wait for buyers.

He includes free shipping with his prices, IIRC (I've bought a few things from him since).

I only posted that norris 1 because if I had seen it, nobody else would've had a chance to buy it. That bums me out a little bit.

IF you can find recent sales on ebay for some of the more common stuff, and say something in your listings like "priced 10% below the average recent ebay sales", it'll probably appeal to buyers. And do better on average than outright auctions.

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

#12

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

Rick W

Jim Bode seems to specialize in mint-or almost mint tools at high prices. His prices seem to be MUCH higher that what a similar tool might sell for on ebay.Your best guide to current prices is the SOLD auction results on ebay.

Remember that ebay's and Paypal's fees will add up to about 20% of the sale price.

Rick W

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

#13

Re: Where to buy/sell vintage tools?

Mark Nowicki

Facebook Marketplace.