Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

Posts

Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#1

Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hello All,

Went to a local flea market on Sunday morning and found this little mahogany box containing a nice Washita stone for under $20. The large label was facing down in the box interior. The person who spent the time to make such a nice box probably really liked the stone it protected.




This now makes 3 Washita stones that I've found this year, and I've pictured them here showing the label sides and the used surface views. The Pike stone is approximately 1-1/8" x 2" x 8-1/2". I've done no cleaning or flattening yet on these stones.



I measured the approximate density of each and found 2.13 g/cm^3 for the mahogany boxed Pike stone, 2.38g/cm^3 for the "WB-7" and 2.15 g/cm^3 for the smaller Norton stone. The WB-7 has been barely used.

My questions, can anyone (David W...) suggest approximate dates of manufacture for these stones? I'm guessing the Pike is the oldest - it has no mention of "Norton" on the labels. Can anyone comment on the relative differences between each stone? Also, when I flatten these, what final grit should I end with? Does it matter?

Now I just have to try them out!

John

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#2

Clint Searl

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

Clint Searl

The LILY WHITE stone will only work with real sperm oil, so don't fall for cheap imitations.

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#3

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi Clint,

Good to know. Luckily, I have some. Two tiny vials of absolutely vile smelling clock oil, guaranteed to be genuine. In the original boxes!

John

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#4

Clint Searl

That's a hoot!


Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#5

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

david weaver

I'm not really great with exact dates of these out of nothing more than intellectual laziness. I'm going to guess, anyway.

The pike stone, I'd guess right around turn of the century. It's a gorgeous stone, and probably worth about 7-10 times what you paid with that case (I'd keep it, I've not seen one identical). We generally like a coarse washita ("soft and fast", they'll say) for carpentry work, and the really fine ones are bumping up against trans or good black ark stones, but they always have just a little extra tooth. I like the way they describe it - fine and sharp gritted, that's exactly how the fine ones feel. They are superb in actual practical use and leave a very agreeable wire edge.

The WB-7 I'd guess as last 30 years (could be more), and the other norton marked stone - the small lilywhite I'd guess as 60s or something. But those are wild guesses.

The small lilywhite stones sell well if you don't find a use for them. since they're more of a cutting stone to me, I have trouble figuring out what to do with small fat stones. An engraver using old tools might like them, or maybe dental or fishhook work.

Take care if you use the fine one (I would) to make sure that the sides are sealed so that oil can't run down the sides of the stone to the bottom. The label will come off almost instantly. I think older users generally were more sparing with oils than we are - not always, but sometimes. And maybe sometimes to their detriment, in that I often get a stone that's in perfect shape on the back and the top side is black and completely loaded up and slow cutting.

re: the WB-7, I had a similar stone - same size. I found it a bit fine and not quite up to the same snuff as the other two stones you'll have in terms of cutting properties.

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#6

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

david weaver

By the way, the first stone could be older than I think. I've never seen that label before and don't know when Pike really had commercial presence large enough to have a nice label like that and a more standard size stone. The older stones are, the thicker they seem to be (1 1/8" stones are thicker than the more recent offerings). The sperm oil reference probably makes it older, too, but that may have followed on for a while after kerosene and distillates were available. Not surprisingly, I'd guess that was on the back to prevent dummies from using linseed oil or other oils that would dry to sharpen cheaply. I did see in old shaving catalogs that the original pike washita stones of lilywhite type would've been a large percentage of a craftsman's wage (they were about $2 at the turn of the century). Soft arks were about half as much, and many of the original silicon carbide stones were close in price to the washita (yuck!).

I did a little quick looking and there's not a lot out there - dating more exactly it would require finding labels in catalogs.

Anything before 1932 won't have norton on it anywhere as that was the year norton purchased pike. A reference in a norton article says that pike itself started in 1823 making scythe stones. And washita stones would've made great scythe stones, for sure.

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#7

Oil

Warren in Lancaster, PA

You can use any kind of oil you want as long as you are using the stone regularly. However if you use a low grade mineral oil and let it sit unused for a period, it will get gummy. The reason is that the mineral oil is a mixture of oils of various weights and the lighter more volatile oils evaporate over time leaving the heavier oils behind. The sperm oils is of uniform viscosity so this is not a problem. Honing oil is more refined than just any mineral oil. That is to say the oils that comprise it are in a narrow range, so more uniform like the sperm oil. There is a reason why you pay more for honing oil than just "mineral oil".

If you are using the stones daily and constantly adding fresh oil, the oil does not get gummy.

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#8

Re: Oils

david weaver

Not sure where anyone would get sperm oil at this point, obviously the norton honing oil is fine.

I haven't ever gotten nondescript honing oil, but have purchased food service light mineral oil made for machines. All of the mineral oils (be it dan's honing, vs. norton honing, vs. the good quality light mineral oils used for food service) have a slightly different feel. The norton oil has a slightly dry feel, the dan's oil stinks and feels slightly dry, and the food service oil is a bit more slick.

It looks like the stability of sperm oil and its wide temperature range compared to cheaper oils made it useful until about 1970s for fine machines and watches, but it was replaced by refined jojoba oil around then, which appears to be better at the things that sperm oil is better than light mineral oil at, if that makes sense (more stable in heat than sperm oil, and overall slightly superior).

Anyway, I've had good luck with the more highly refined very light oil that's made for food service, but never used anything heavier (like baby oil). Having used norton's oil and the food service, I'd not purchase norton's oil if a good quality food service oil is available (gallon is the same price of a pint of nortons, and there are plenty of other uses for the rest of the gallon, like beeswax salves, etc), but I wouldn't use baby oil, either, nor would I buy a gallon of medium or equine oil without knowing what it is.

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#9

Re: Oils

John in NM

Another refined mineral oil to try is the laxative kind - its probably about like the food service oil you mention. I have some from the feed store (cheaper) that I use for leather conditioning.

I always use WD-40 for honing, mostly because its right there and early on I had a fear of gumming up stones. I should try the mineral oil again.

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#10

Re: Oils - what about odorless lamp oil?

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hello All,

Would "odorless lamp oil" be appropriate for honing? It is a highly refined kerosene-like fuel oil. It is what I use for "wet" sanding on the ebony, silver and pearl portions of the violin bows I make. I start with 400 grit and work up to 2500. The oil does evaporate in a few hours. I've not seen a residue when dried.

I've used this oil for honing for a few years now. Maybe I shouldn't?

John

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#11

Re: Oils - what about odorless lamp oil?

david weaver

If you haven't noticed anything in a few hours, then there's nothing to worry about. You can always clean (soak) a loaded stone in hot water and simple green if it ever does get loaded. I'm sure there are a million other things that would work (but not with that fantastic green label on your new stone!!).

We have the luxury now, too, that if your stone gets glazed on the very surface and it isn't your finest stone intended to stay burnished, you can scuff it with a diamond stone so that there's a swarf on the surface to abrade off the top layer.

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#12

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

Joe Rogers, West Virginia

John, I’m surprised that this thread has gone this long without you getting a “ You Suck” .

Three this year? The only one I’ve ever found was at TFWW and Joel requested a pound of flesh for it! The Dr. noted the weight loss...

Joe

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#13

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi Joe,

I wondered that too! Yes, three nice stones since June of this year. The first two Washitas were more in line with David's pricing. Around $50 each.

Now, I certainly expect the groans to begin when I mention that I scored a very nice "Tyzack and Sons, & Taylor" brass backsaw the week before. Different flea market, but one also located in NJ. I'll have to take photos of that one to post here. And of the nice low knob Stanley 5-1/4 I bought at the CRAFTS of NJ picnic/tailgate in early September. Been too quiet here on the Hand Tool side lately...

John

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#14

Re: Oils - what about odorless lamp oil?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There is a reason we use oil with these stones instead of water. The reason is that water is not viscous enough to suspend the steel particles. Using oil suspends the steel particles and allows us to avoid the chore of cleaning the stone; adding clean oil is enough to keep things working. If you use a thin oil like kerosene or wd 40 you might as well use water.

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#15

Re: Oil

John Pappas

If a stone got gummy from the use of mineral oil, how would that be corrected?

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#16

Re: Oil

david weaver

boiling water or a bath of water with simple green in it and a good long soak (the water doesn't have to be hot, just relatively concentrated with simple green).

The latter is probably a better idea.

You can also abrade it off with a diamond hone, but if you don't like a brisk stone, then that's not a great idea. If your diamond hone is relatively fine, it might not do a good enough job, anyway (just leaving a graded surface).

You can also just use the stone with liberal fresh oil and the oil that is there will loosen over time.

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#17

Re: WD-40

david weaver

....is suitable for fine stones like a trans or black if someone likes the feel. Those stones will break in either way. The feel is a lot different than water and the particles won't get stuck like they do with water. Under the microscope, the edge is similar on the fine stones with oil or WD-40.

I don't know why anyone would want to use an oilstone with water, but some on the knife and razor side of things like it despite trying a huge array of oils and water based oil substitutes. In my opinion, stones like a washita get graded quickly with water and they get a bad combination of scratching and burnishing, whereas the edge off of oil (even WD-40 on the fine stones) is more uniform. You can refresh one with a diamond hone, but that doesn't make great sense to me unless you're trying to use one as a cutting stone rather than as a refining stone.

I'd never use an india or crystolon stone with water, though. Crystolon is by far the best bevel cutting stone (above and beyond diamond) with an oil bath. With water or WD-40, it'd just turn into a caked surface.

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#18

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

Dave Tardiff

A bit over a year ago I purchased a retirement house in Vermont, right across the river from the original Pike mill in Haverhill NH. I drive through Pike regularly when commuting. This summer I had a mason repairing the fieldstone foundation, and being a stone guy he's familiar with the regional history, and says he knows where the quarries were.....we can hopefully visit when he's not so busy. Perhaps I can find some of the original stone....

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#19

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

William Duffield

But Washita stones (novaculite) originate in Arkansas, not New Hampshire. You may find stones in their quarry, but they won't be translucent Arkansas stones.

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#20

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

John in NM

There is nothing geologically unique about Arkansas stones, novaculite is found all over the world. Arkansas is just the type locality associated with industrial production. Of course, they might have been quarrying something else entirely in Dave's locality.

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#21

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The quarry in New Hampshire yielded scythe stones. I think they were fine sandstone. Timothy Noyes started the trade in 1821; Pike married his widow. The Pike company did not trade in Arkansas or Washita stones until 1893.

I would try and find the site of the old factory; there are probably rejects all over the place.

Washita stones would not be very good for scythes, and I have never seen one shaped for a scythe.

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#22

Re: arkansas pike is washita, else it's name only

david weaver

While there's novaculite all over the place (there are established stones from Canada (Magog), the us (obviously - several types), crete ("cretans" or turkish oilstones), UK (cutler's green, charnley forest, ...), the fine quality translucent arkansas stones come from arkansas.

The stone that's referred to as washita not only comes from one geography, but only one specific location. If you want a washita stone, it comes from the old pike mine property. It's a different characteristic in feel and cutting power and ability to cut without having the surface abraded that isn't matched by any other novaculite with the possible exception of the turkish oilstone (which is a friable novaculite that's not porous, but is softer - if you think washitas are expensive and hard to find, a good turkish oilstone of the darker and finer type is really hard to find, but they are superb stones).

Warren's point about hoping that the processing area in New Hampshire would have scrap laying around is a good one. There still may be a bunch of waste stone. There's tons of it at the pike mine - I recall roy underhill mentioning that he took stone right off of the surface. One, they don't like it if you do that - it's probably illegal - and two, surface stones (where freezing occurs) aren't always as good as stones where freezing doesn't occur. With novaculite stone where the liquids don't go all the way through, it's probably not as big of a deal. Japanese whetstones found on the surface (exposed to weather) are considered worthless in country, though I wouldn't be surprised at all if they sell them to gaijin.

One of the best places to get old japanese stones is anywhere they would've been stuffed when the mines closed (processing areas, old military installations, old vendors who closed and never sold off everything). But out in the weather where they could get wet and freeze, no.

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

#23

Re: Washita stone aquisitions & questions...

Joe Rogers, West Virginia

Respectable hunting John!

I haven’t found any good spots here in WV yet...too busy enjoying retirement to need the recreation. :-)

Joe