Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

Posts

One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

#1

One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

david weaver

For several years, I have ripped with my right arm, and when it gets tired, I sit and rip from a seated position cutting toward me.

I have a table saw, but I just don't enjoy working with it or a thickness planer.

A couple of weeks ago, I was resawing some typical stock, and it occurred to me that I might be able to resaw indefinitely with a hand stock (I have a large frame saw, but it's not worth the trouble of getting out of ripping something 4 inches wide). I recall when I first started resawing, controlling the saw was a problem. Not for long, but it was a problem.

However, I had no issue at all resawing left handed, and by that, I mean marking a board and then making the cut without switching sides or any of that makework.

Last night, I was ripping trim for my kitchen, which isn't a quick process, I guess, and the average intermittent woodworker isn't going to rip 20 feet of 5/4 cherry in one shot with one arm. Same experience as the resawing - it was no issue to rip left handed, though I'm sure it would've vexed me if my brain hadn't absorbed several years of understanding ripping by hand (without analyzing it, just ripping and getting better at it).

No clue why I didn't try any of this sooner. Should've!!

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

#2

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

Luke Dupont

Interesting. I have just the opposite experience with both Martial Arts and woodworking.

The particular art that I studied emphasized training both sides equally, so we always start with our off hand and then work on the primary hand. In that art, I had no problems using both hands equally.

However, when I started studying a different martial art, I focused on my primary side and neglected my off hand, and it showed. My right hand was very skilled, but I was essentially a complete beginner when switching to my left.

I find the same in woodworking. I'm still not comfortable sawing, paring, or sharpening with my left hand. I've tried a few times with awkward results.

Do you suppose that over the years, you've used both hands more than you realize, picking up muscle memory in both?

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

#3

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

david weaver

I've never actually sawn with my left hand before recently. I figured it would be impractical for various reasons.

I'm sure it varies by person and by task. What I've found so far is that crosscutting isn't quite as easy left handed, but I'm sure it will be doable. The tasks like ripping and resawing are partially about learning what to do with the saw, and partially about learning what not to do.

In terms of tasks, I can switch hit a baseball (despite being dominantly left handed swinging a bat, and that's despite being right handed in general), but I cannot hit a golf ball right handed for some reason. I thought hitting right handed felt really odd (in baseball), but it's just different feeling.

This may be relatively low value to anyone who isn't dimensioning by hand, but rip sawing and planing left handed and right handed are good things for me (in terms of being able to bang out a two or three hour session of dimensioning and enjoy it at the same time).

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

#4

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

Philip Duffy

I guess some of us are 'gifted' in the sense we can do everything with either hand. Must be because I grew up on a farm, learned to drive at 8 years, and flew Navy helicopters all my adult life. So be it with sawing a board! P.

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

#5

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

William Duffield

I'm left handed, but living is a world that is biased towards right handedness, so I find that I need to do lots of things with my right hand. I can pull a radial arm saw or guide a skilsaw with either hand, but I still use hand saws totally left handed. That may need to change as the cataract in my left eye gets worse. I don't expect learning to do that should be a serious problem, since out of necessity I am adept at using carving and turning tools ambidextrously.

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

#6

bridger

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

Bridger

I'm cross dominant- right hand, left eye. Makes lots of things awkward and leads me to doing things like paring with my left hand. I run a saw righ handed though- i'll have to give it a try sinister just to see how it goes.

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

#7

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

david weaver

I'm definitely not gifted!!

I think a lot of it is just the brain's understanding of how the saw is supposed to work in the cut and how it's supposed to look, as well as the subtle things that are important to hand work, like steering a saw, which is bound to be misconstrued by anyone who hasn't done a lot of hand work, and leads to one of the two following conclusions:

* you should never steer a saw, only bad things happen

* steering is a short term thing, you just give the saw a hard twist and go

The subtle thing is the brain seeing that you're getting a little away from the mark and sort of communicating it to your hand so that you make minor adjustments and get back on track without massive thought or stark changes in the path of the saw.

So, it's not that I can do super fine motor type stuff left handed, it's just the realization that my brain can work in conjunction with my left hand far better than it ever would've if I started with that hand 10 years ago.

I wrongly concluded (without trying, which is opposite of what I usually do - that being failing to adhere to routine out of curiosity and continuing to try things when I don't need to) that I'd lack control, lack stamina, etc, with the left hand and there was no reason to try. I certainly don't have the power at this point that I do with my right arm, but that will come.

I also now enjoy even more a task that I really enjoyed a lot before (which is working wood by hand from start to finish. When I use a TS and a planer, which is rare, I really sort of resent the process). Hand working keeps you connected and gets the juices flowing just enough to really peak your brain's effectiveness and focus. Just the same as you get a "bump" in your mood if you do moderate exercise.

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

#8

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

William Duffield

If you need to train your left hand to do what your right hand has already learned, you might try this:

https://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2018-07/mu-1oe071118.php

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

#9

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

Bob Lang

My grandfather was ambidextrous. He attributed it to his apprenticeship in the early 1900s. Fresh off the farm he had no real experience with tools and beat up whatever hand was holding the chisel. When one hand got to hurting too bad to hang on to the chisel, he switched hands. When I first learned how to use hand tools I kept this story in mind and tried new tasks with both hands, figuring I may as well learn to do things left handed since I didn't know how to do them right handed either.

It comes in handy as it is often easier to just switch hands than it is to make another set up to do something with my preferred hand. I also switch directions and pull planes when I need to.

Bob Lang

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

#10

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

Steve Voigt

I'm cross-dominant too Bridger--in my case, left handed/dominant right eye. I've always found it challenging to cut to a vertical line, and from the research I've done, it appears that this is a common problem with cross-dominance.

Anyway, I never thought about this until reading Dave's thread, but I wonder if the solution is just to learn to saw right handed? In theory, coordination problems can be overcome, while cross dominance can't. I may have to experiment…

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

#11

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

david weaver

I haven't done any fine sawing left handed, but I can't imagine that it would take long.

My initial desire to use left hand is really in laziness - if you're lazy, you want to continue to work at the lowest total effort level. Getting a stiff right arm, taking a break, and then doing it again over and over offends my laziness. Standing around doing nothing while waiting does, too - it just extends the time to get something done. Cross eye dominance may just be another reason, perhaps even better.

I wonder what was done historically - perhaps a sawyer working all day developed the stamina to cut without switching arms, it's not like it's that physically taxing. A carpenter or joiner, however, would seemingly have to get into situations where space considerations made it much more convenient to switch hands.

I used to target shoot, but lost interest in that long ago due to ..... laziness (shoot 1 hour, load and clean things and drive around for 5). I remember the cross eye dominance being a problem that vexed a lot of shooters who had no idea why they couldn't get a good fix on the target -especially if the target was moving (clays, etc).

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

#12

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Interesting post, David.

While I work with areas such as visualisation and visual working memory, I do not have much experience with crossed dominance.

I was thinking about this issue, and especially the article that William linked to (VERY interesting, William. Thanks). One item that popped into my mind was the treatment for a "lazy eye", which is patching the strong eye to force the weak eye to do the work and strengthen that way. In other words, rather than strengthen the non-dominant hand, strengthen the non-dominant eye ... ?

I did a little Googling, and stopped when I found a relevant article. The conclusion was as follows:

"Cross Dominance Training through Vision Therapy

Under an optometrist's supervision, fundamental visual skills can be improved through vision therapy or VT. The aim of VT is to improve visual comfort, ease and efficiency by using therapeutic lenses, prisms, filters, occluders, patches, electronic targets and balance boards. One VT training method is working with a Bernell Rotator using visual motor integration to place an object on a moving target. The idea of the exercise is to place a peg in a target spot in the rotator with your dominant eye covered, thus forcing your non-dominant eye to strengthen. The test is repeated until you can perform the test equally with the non-dominant and dominant eye.

Train Your Cross Dominance at Home

The swinging ball exercise can be performed at home by attaching a rubber softball to a length of rope and suspending it from a ceiling so it can swing freely. Draw three one to two inch circles on the ball in red, yellow and blue. Section a dowel rod into three parts covering one third in red tape, one third in yellow tape and one third in blue tape. Suspend the ball at eye level, cover your dominant eye and step back 16 inches.Tap the colored section of dowel to the corresponding colored section on the ball.

For monocular acuity improvement, cover the dominant eye and use tweezers drop grains of rice into a small-mouth bottle or jar. Get as many grains of rice in the jar with the non-dominant eye as you can with the dominant eye in a specific time period. For an added challenge, use the non-dominant hand.

Important Considerations

The brain is "hard-wired", so the goal of training is not to change eye dominance but to enhance the visual accuracy of the non-dominant eye. Do your visual training exercises during the off-season of your sport. Many sports can be adapted so that the athlete maintains the cross dominant position. In target shooting for example, you put the gun in front of your dominant eye. Close your non-dominant eye, then draw and point at the target. Now open your non-dominant eye. You may have to shoot with the non-dominant eye closed for a while to get used to this position; but it's certainly better than switching the gun to your non-dominant hand".

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

#13

Re: One Hand Trains the Brain to Control the Other

david weaver

Interesting, their comment that the brain is hard wired, so you can work with it a little bit, but can't "rewire", so to speak.

I'm happy to have never had to trouble with it for shooting - I find shooting hard enough (at least to do it well). It seems to be yet another thing that athletic people just do better when it comes to stability and shooting offhand. At the time I was shooting holes in paper relatively often, the concept of shooting with both eyes open was "the thing to do" to prevent fatigue. Even with optics. It was pretty easy to get used to.

I think my view of all of this for woodworking is (not so much with the eyes), that for a hand tooler, it just opens up avenues to keep working. If I could tolerate doing dimensioning with machines, I don't know if I'd have ever thought of it because nothing really seems to bother my stamina other than long periods of mortising (rare) or coping out a large pattern (that's a different issue - stiff fingers).