Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Hand Planing Redwood

Posts

Hand Planing Redwood

#1

Hand Planing Redwood

Glenn Mackey

I am curious if anybody else has had this experience with redwood. I’ve got some old unused water tank boards I’ve been working into a pair of doors for an out building. These boards are very soft wood yet are chipping the edges of all my plane blades. I have been hand planing for 28 years and have never experienced anywhere near this level of edge failure with any wood.

The resawing and planing of four sides is half done. I’m just stunned at how hard this wood is on cutting edges. I’m using both old and new irons in both wood and metal planes with the same result. I start seeing tracks in the planed surface after only a few minutes despite feeling very little resistance, as you’d expect with a softwood. These are fine edge chips that require coarse stones to remove.

Re: Hand Planing Redwood

#2

Re: Hand Planing Redwood

Sgian Dubh

Old unused water tank boards? They wouldn't happen to be full of grit, rock chips or metal swarf would they that have got on and into the grain of the boards from wherever they've been stored? Just a thought. Slainte.

Re: Hand Planing Redwood

#3

Re: Hand Planing Redwood

Glenn Mackey

No, it’s not dirt or grit or other embeds. These are full 3x6 T&G I’m resawing to 1 3/4 x 5. I can’t say hand sawing has unduly dulled my saws.

Re: Hand Planing Redwood

#4

Re: Hand Planing Redwood

Sgian Dubh

I'm afraid I've no idea of the cause in that case. Slainte.

Re: Hand Planing Redwood

#5

Re: Hand Planing Redwood

david weaver

If it's not just the surface, I'd bet silica. I've had the same issue with salvage redwood from my porch (this was cladded framing lumber for sills, etc, and wasn't exposed to elements or airborne dust).

If it's just the surface, I'd bet dirt.

If wood has silica in it in particles large enough to make visible nicks, you can usually see the particles under light.

Getting the heavy work done without too much tearout and then using the cap iron will save you some time (you can take bigger bites and keep a dulling iron in the cut further into dullness if the cap is set right), but you can't get around the damage. Some HSS irons tolerate it a little bit better, but they'll still dull.

Re: Hand Planing Redwood

#6

Re: Hand Planing Redwood

Brian Holcombe

I’m betting silica also, I’ve had this happen with a board here and there, regardless of species. I had a cherry slab so difficult I was sharpening every few passes.

Re: Hand Planing Redwood

#7

Re: Hand Planing Redwood

Glenn Mackey

Sila contamination makes the most sense. Thanks.