Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Frame saws

Posts

Frame saws

#1

Frame saws

Josko catipovic

I'm curious why frame saws have fallen out of favor in the US. My earliest memories include 'helping' granpa by cvarrying his frame saw around, and I notice they are still in wide use in Europe, even for quite intricate work.

But here in New England, one doesn't see them at all. Have they been obsoleted by other saws, or is this just a regional preference.

Do frame saws still have a place in a cabinet shop?

Re: Frame saws

#2

Re: Frame saws

david weaver

Regional. They're still widely used in China, too. It's certainly easier to make a frame saw (and cheaper) than it is to make a good western style saw.

Re: Frame saws

#3

Re: Frame saws

Hank Knight

Tage Frid was a proponent of frame saws. It was fascinating to watch him cut dovetails with a big old frame saw. How he did it, I'll never know. I have two of them and I've never been able to master them. I only use mine once a year - to cut the bottom off our Christmas tree.

Re: Frame saws

#4

Re: Frame saws

TomD

Are we talking frame saws or bowsaws? I thought frame saws where the one for resawing where the blade is contained in a frame, the is normally an adjuster for tensioning, not just as string or wire. Bowsaws have to tension elements, and one strut, and frames aws have two compression elements, and one tension element.

Bandsaws are similar to bowsaws in having two tension sides and one compression frame, and an open blade. And they can theoretically do anything a bowsaw can though pieced work is really only done on bandsaws in metal.

I still think bowsaws have a lot to recommend them, but the blades are generally pretty terrible. And so far, not many people have tried to make their own, at least the way I envision them.

I still blows me away that nobody has made a commercial (cheap) blade of the Klaus type where you can saw the whole dovetail out in one go. Why LV hasn't done that for April fools, or as a miniature, I don't know. Though I have wanted one for almost 40 years, and could theoretically make it, and haven't... So maybe it isn't as much fun as one would expect.

Re: Frame saws

#6

Re: Klaus's Trick

Hank Knight

I thought Frank Klaus's trick of sawing dovetail waste with one motion was accomplished by a simple 90 degree twist in his bow saw blade. He starts the cut vertically and the twist causes the cut to end up horizontal. I think it's more a parlor trick than a practical way to cut dovetails.

Re: Frame saws

#7

Re: Klaus's Trick

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

Roy Underhill had/has a frame saw fitted with the turning blade. IIRC he modified the blade himself. He explained the blade was fragile and nearly broken at the twist where the heat was applied. He did demo the cut at the Woodcraft store where he was appearing. It required some finesse to get through the transition.

Joe

BTW username location is out of date, retired and further north in eastern WV

Re: Frame saws

#8

Re: Klaus's Trick

John in NM

I remember it being a custom bent blade - but as Joe said, fragile and difficult to master. And as you said, a parlor trick, so little point to mastering it :D

Re: Frame saws

#9

Re: Klaus's Trick

John Pappas

The blade on Frank's saw has teeth that are bent...a gradual bend, just the tips, near the middle of the saw and at a full 90 degrees.. the entire tooth, toward the end of the saw. He started the cut with the front of the saw and as he reached the bottom of the vertical cut he pushed the saw forward and made the horizontal cut using the back part of the saw. The saw was held vertical all the time. I had read that he dovetailed the crates he used in shipping his furniture to customers. There is a video on YouTube that shows him using it. No, it is not a parlor trick.

Re: Frame saws

#10

Re: Klaus's Trick

John Pappas

Correction. the vertical cuts are made with a frame saw, and the special saw is used to make the horizontal cut. Here is video of his process.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YFqY73lelq8&list=PL-oc_Usnhv_QtyRMHqhQKyLaJO5uLR3IQ

Re: Frame saws

#11

Re: Klaus's Trick

John in NM

Granted, a vernacular term like "parlor trick" means different things to different people, depending on the context in which it is learned.

I believe Hank meant (and I agreed) that it was a skill of limited utility beyond impressing bystanders. It is designed to make an impression of skill (and it does - we all remember it) but it may not be the best way to do the job.

I don't think either of us meant that the "trick" was in any way deceptive or a sleight of hand.

Re: Frame saws

#12

Re: Agree

Hank Knight

I certainly did not mean to desparage Frank Klaus with my "parlor trick" comment. He has been an idol of mine for many years. John's description and clarification of my use of the term "parlor trick" is spot on. I think the technique is s eye-catching for sure, but of limited value to us mere mortals, unless we're in a production environment where it might save some time. Consequently, while I certainly enjoyed watching Frank perform this amazing feat, I don't think I'll be spending my time trying to master it.

Thanks, John, for the clarification.

Re: Frame saws

#13

Re: Agree

TomD

I would think that with the right blade, that the time required to master the trick would be a few seconds.

It seems to consist of straight forward sawing with the corner transition being basically the same trick as starting a drywall saw. Wow! How does he do that? Must be a genius. Klausz is super, but nothing he does is impossible to learn, He showed the easy way to do things, and people just went "can't do that" because he is so dang fast. Slow it down, do exactly what he says and it usually is easy.

It would seem one might need two saws or more with the angled section fitting the bottom angle since there are two such angles in a set of DTs, though the cleanup would not be that great.

When I saw him do it first he didn't change saws, maybe the unavailability of new blades is holding him back.

Underhill's problem is bad blade temper. For commercial makers that isn't a problem because they use a "soft" stock and harden each tooth, at least that is an option that would suit this tool.

The way we do dovetails today is closer to being a parlor trick in the sense that it is too fancy and precious by half, and I like that. The first time I read about the Klausz trick he was making shipping containers for his furniture. Considering he could nearly do it as fast as he could nail them together, I think that was very practical. It both provides a great box, and it provides some kind of assurance that the guy you are dealing with is actually competent and his hourly rates aren't based on his lack of productivity.

I used to make cases for returns to the US out of dovetailed packages. I never had a problem but stopped doing it when border controls got worse as it isn't an easy package to get into. And goodness knows what it looks like in an X-ray. I liked doing that because while nobody ever turned down a return, you know what they are thinking; "not my fault, the clod broke it". Well send it in a nice box and they probably cut you some slack. Remember being in LV one time, and they were blowing out Iroyoi timber framing/mortise chisels for about 10 bucks. Turned out "every" single one they had sold had been broken, by the happy owners. who apparently though they were buying crowbars at the home center. Imagine you are the one guy who knows how to use that chisel and sends it back... Well I guess it wouldn't mater, but pride dictated returns in a nice box.

So no, it isn't a trick, it is an efficient way to make a joint that has many uses, but people hold back from using it because they take too long to make in some cases. I used housed dovetails in a transition between two materials in my back yard fence. I join panels of plywood to make sturdy boxes for the shop, though I have my own way of doing that with special tooling, but the inspiration was the Klausz/Euro trick.

Re: Frame saws

#14

Re: Frame saws

TomD

Kevin, those are some good links. My experience with the Japanese blades has not been good. The original German ones were not really all that great quality, but at least they were in the original tooth patterns for various uses. Some progress back to those designs was underway and then the German houses came out with those coarse crosscuts and the saw were back to cutting firewood.

I would like to see some more delicate blades that would be useful and cheap for cutting joinery. We have great saws, but they are expensive and this would really break the back for some use cases.

Re: Frame saws

#15

Re: Frame saws

Kevin French

Frame saws are on my 'to do list' for quit some time. Maybe this thread will spur me into action.

Re: Frame saws

#17

Re: Klaus's Trick

TomD

Nothing is gained if you are cutting drawer sides, it would be pretty gross. It is a lot faster because the teeth are larger, and you don't have to switch saws. Mostly it is the cool factor. It also ought to be cheaper as those fret saws people are now using are some of the finest ever offered. A blade ought to cost about 10 bucks. Just seems to be something I always wanted, and apparently nobody else does. Though as I confess, I still haven't got out from in front of the computer and just knocked one out.

Re: Frame saws

#18

Re: Frame saws

TomD

Does anyone remember the link from a Chinese video site on how to make their frame saw. That was another one that caught my attention after those article by Russell Jason Beebe in FWW.

Re: Frame saws

#19

Re: Klaus's Trick

John Pappas

Frank's saw is faster than a fret or coping saw. In the video you can see the cut made in one or two strokes...removing all the waste. I believe Frank used this method when cutting utility dovetails, such as the shipping crates he used to ship furniture, or in a situation where dovetails provided the strength, but were hidden is some way. Using a fret of coping saw to remove the bulk of waste and finishing with a chisel in 'fine' dovetails is not the same. Each method stand on its own.

Re: Frame saws

#20

Re: Frame saws

Josko catipovic

I'd be grateful for any insight on why Japanese blades on bowsaws might not work well. What kinds of blades would I look for on a large bowsaw that could work well for precision cabinetmaking?

Re: Frame saws

#21

Chris Scholz

Re: Frame saws *LINK*

Chris Scholz

I think frame saws just take a lot more practice to use effectively. Not too many hobbyists who have the time and will to go through the learning curve.

Some random video of a master of the craft below (lot of ads before the video finally starts)


https://v.youku.com/v_show/id_XNTYxMjM1OTgw.html

Re: Frame saws

#22

Re: Frame saws

Philip Duffy

Sorry, can not get past the McDonald's speil!

Re: Frame saws

#23

Re: Frame saws

TomD

There is no reason why Japanese style teeth won't work well for cabinetmaking. The problem I had was that for decades there were three basic sets of blades sold. Turning saws, often the lire shaped saws, not really joinery. The two for joinery were: 1) sold as a Danish saw, this one came with a rip blade and was very similar to the setup that Tage Frid used in his books and videos. Highland Hardware used to sell them. May still do. 2) German bowsaws that came with a range of blades. Several ripping, several crosscut, and a turnign blade. While a little unwieldy, you had in one package a do all saw, from dovetails to logs.

What I encountered when I finally got around to trying one of the German saws was that they were then provided with relatively coarse Japanese crosscut blades. These blades are not rare, even Home Depot carries this kind of thing in toolbox saws. Gone at the time were the German rip blades and so forth, though I managed to pick them up as singles here and there. The Germans have an affinity for Japanese woodwork and tools, there is even a fancy book comparing their rural building styles as though there was a missing link carpenter that cements the two worlds. If the Germans had simply replaced their range of blades with Japanese blades of even higher quality, that would have been ideal. If they are now available, I would love to know. It has been a longtime hope that quality Japanese blades would be made for bowsaws as that approach offers a little of everything at what could be a very low price.

Tage Frid and saw:

https://www.finewoodworking.com/1977/10/01/sawing-by-hand

Re: Frame saws

#25

Re: Frame saws

david weaver

If they're made well, they don't take longer to learn. If someone goes out and buys a large beech emmerich saw and tries to cut a small tenon with it, or dovetails, then the results will be fairly predictable.

That leaves making purpose-built saws as a good option (which that person - Xin - does in other videos). He's got saws with rotating fixtures, but he also demonstrates making saws that are fixed.

I'd assume that the average person who uses backed saws and carpenters saw vs. the average person who would put the same number of hours in bow saws would find themselves practically identical in capability for basic joints.

I really like Xin's videos - they're a great demonstration of getting on with the work without too many fixtures. It's clear that he's done each of the things he demonstrates hundreds or thousands of times.

I think we get caught up as English-style woodworkers struggling with hand saws when we first start, and then we expect to pick up a different style of saws and use them as well as we do what we've learned with. When you get away from these forums and go out to the ground level (local groups, etc), you find a lot of people who concluded that pullsaws are the best (because they're easy to start, and no sharpening is required), and they never get beyond that.