Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

French polishing help

Posts

French polishing help

#1

French polishing help

Brian Holcombe

Every few years I like to torture myself with an attempt at French polishing with shellac (as opposed to wax polishing that I believe was actually done in 18th century France).

This humidor seemed to be calling out for a french polish, but after going over the box with 4f pumice then rottenstone a dull spot called my attention. Looking closely it does not seem to be bare wood since the pores are filled. Before I attempt to wax this, or start over and simply oil it, I'm wondering if there is something else I should attempt at this point to correct these blemishes?



Thanks gents.

Re: French polishing help

#2

Re: French polishing help

Brian Holcombe

Following up:

I sanded back to 800 grit, then reapplied a coat of light shellac. After which I went to 2f, 4f and rottenstone. Then buffed and polished, seems to be cured of the blotches.

Re: French polishing help

#3

Re: French polishing help

TomD

That is more or less what I would have done. I would have sanded it out, and then padded it back up. Possibly an area that got too much alcohol, which means less finish density. So I would try and pad it up, but when all else fails, buff.

Interesting guitar story about this pair of very well known polishers who gave seminars etc... I remember thinking how great it would be to be that confident in my results. It turned out they were filling the pores with 5 minute epoxy applied with razor blades. And I don't mean to suggest they were hiding this fact, except in the routine sense that people who are normally doing seminars, and releasing articles might feed the information out. But I was going about it traditionally, by polishing to fill the pores, on through to the finish. Applying a flash coat of polish over epoxy would have made it a lot easier.

Anyone here ever try that method that uses a ROS to apply the polish?

Re: French polishing help

#4

Re: French polishing help

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Tom! George Wilson mentioned his technique to me for filling grain with epoxy as well, but I did not use it on this project.

A bit of laziness on my part, but I may try it for the next go-round. This panel has already had the finish shrink down to reveal the pore lines again and my previous humidor shows them very apparently now after some years.

I know that's quite typical for shellac, but I'd like to reduce the amount of time spent, so I may try either epoxy or commercial pore filler next time around.

Re: French polishing help

#5

Re: French polishing help

TomD

I wasn't really recommending it, though I have used it on a guitar, in mahogany where it really allows the wood to show through. Assuming one isn't trying to fake the mahogany to look like rosewood as was so often done at one time.

Another place I have used it is in rod building.

What both have in common is low sun exposure. Epoxy doesn't greatly like sun, today people may put furniture next to direct light, while in an earlier time rooms were often kept darkish behind heavy drapes.

I did one table where I filled the endgrain with epoxy rather than doing a breadboard. It has been around for 30 years without any discolouration. So maybe I worry too much.

Re: French polishing help

#6

Re: French polishing help

Brian Holcombe

I think that is one of the reasons I haven't used it, perhaps subconsciously. I am fearful of epoxy.

I used to make knives, as a kid it was my hobby making blades by hand all the way through to a finished product. The handles were often slab type that were epoxied on then pinned. I used a very high quality epoxy that is still sold today.

That was 15+ years ago, 50% of those handles are loose today. I don't put much faith in the product.

Seems like it may work well for this, but I have a lingering doubt with anything epoxied.

Re: French polishing help

#7

Re: French polishing help

Don Stephan

If my memory is working, in his book on hand applied finishes Jeff Jewitt describes mixing rottenstone or similar in shellac and using as a pore filler. I tried with limited success, AND IT DRIES HARD AS CONCRETE.