Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

lengthwise bookmatching

Posts

lengthwise bookmatching

#1

lengthwise bookmatching

Josko Catipovic

I've agreed to build a 16' tall cabinet. (2 4' sections and an 8' section top all stacked together.) One side is an ideal place to display continuous wood grain, so I'm hunting for a noteworthy 16' slab. One thought that came into mind is to resaw an 8' plank and bookmatch end to end to give the appearance of continuous grain.

I realize everything depends on the actual plank I use, but has anyone tried or used lengthwise bookmatching to give the appearance of grain continuity on a long face? I'm worried about an unrealistic, top-heavy look if I flip the upper section. Any experiences, rules of thumb, and advice would be most welcome. Thanks in advance.

Re: lengthwise bookmatching

#2

Re: lengthwise bookmatching

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

One thought that came into mind is to resaw an 8' plank and bookmatch end to end to give the appearance of continuous grain.

Hi Josko

The problem I see with this is that you are joining end grain to end grain. That will make a poor joint. If you need to make a section 16' long, you will probably be better off using veneer.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: lengthwise bookmatching

#3

Re: lengthwise bookmatching

Josko Catipovic

Sorry about lack of clarity...

The piece will be made of three independent stacking pieces; bottom two 4' tall each, and then an 8' section. So there will a cut at 8', probably trimmed out with a bit of a molding. Still, I'm trying to show some grain continuity across all three pieces, or at least use that side to showcase striking wood grain.

I'd prefer to avoid veneer because of expected high seasonal humidity variations (Cape Cod).

Re: lengthwise bookmatching

#5

Not needed it here, but I've done tails to tails

Keith Newton

About ten years ago I was commissioned to build a desk using a single curley Bubinga 10/4 board for the top. I think it was about 32" wide, and about 36" longer than I needed for the desk top. I then ripped that piece into 16" x 32", and joined them end to end to make a 16" x 64" top for a credenza, using tails to tails.

The board was so uniformly figured, and my joints were so tight that you really had to look closely to see the lines. Actually I wish they had shown up better, because hardly anyone will ever notice. That joint was unsupported in the middle, except the legs out about 4" from the ends.

I realize that Josko doesn't need to use this, but for anyone needing a board stretcher sometime in the future, this makes a good strong attractive joint.

Re: lengthwise bookmatching

#6

Re: Not needed it here, but I've done tails to tai

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Keith,

What kind of join did you use?

Wiley

Re: lengthwise bookmatching

#7

Dovetails on the end of both boards.

Keith Newton

Instead of tails and pins joining two boards at right angles, there were tails on both short pieces that were fairly symmetrical across their width, joined end to end. If I'm remembering correctly, they were about 2" long down the grain, and about 1.5" across the wide end, and probably 10º.

You could lay them out to whatever proportions you felt like. Obviously longer would have more strength than getting too short.

Do you follow that?

Re: lengthwise bookmatching

#8

Re: Dovetails on the end of both boards.

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

That’s very interesting, and your description easy to follow. I would never have guessed right, figured you were going to say bridal joint! You surely did extremely precise work to make the join disappear.

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: lengthwise bookmatching

#9

Wiley, Wiley...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

A bridal joint is where the bride goes to try on dresses.

A bridle joint is what you were thinking of - I believe.

Teasing, just teasing.

That's a clever approach, Keith, and sounds strong as can be.

Re: lengthwise bookmatching

#10

Re: lengthwise bookmatching

TomD

If you want to join panels end to end, you could just biscuit them with epoxy, would be plenty strong enough for most panels, if not wanted in this case.

It is something of a misconception that endgrain glue joints are weak. I wouldn't be surprised if they were stronger than butt joints in sidegrain. The issue is that longitudinal strength in boards is great, while crossgrain strength in boards is weak. So you need a far stronger joint than a sidegrain joint in order to get full strength joining boards end to end. But that is not the same as saying that those endgrain joints are weak in comparison to sidegrain joints.

------------------------------

Laying out a 4 way bookmatch would ideally find you in possession of a board with very little riff grain, so that the pattern projects through the panel far enough to get your pieces out. Or that you otherwise get some kind of pattern you like.

-----------------------------

Veneer should be advantageous in a seaside situation. Plywood would be the ideal panel material. Pretty much for any use, but certainly by, or even in, the sea. An extra layer of veneer over the plywood is not going to make maters any worse. And veneer is also ideal for preserving the pattern through multiple layers. That said, I can certainly understand a preference for working in solid wood, even though veneer is just as traditional.

----------------------------

Another option with veneer is Krenov's "real veneer" approach. Basically you saw heavy slices of the donor board, and bond them to a solid core. You essentially create a board that has all the appearance of the donor, board. And a board that can be worked with planes, or other hand tools just like a piece of solid wood, though you have to hide the endgrain.

Re: lengthwise bookmatching

#11

Re: lengthwise bookmatching

Josko catipovic

Thank you Tom, that is very helpful. I'll give 'Krenov veneering' a shot - when you say 'solid core', is this same species as veneer, same grain orientation, or am I better off with solid core plywood?

Re: lengthwise bookmatching

#12

Krenov veneering

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Josko and all,

Here’s my limited experience with using 3/32” to 1/8” quartered satinwood veneer. I had a helluva time applying it over 5/8” Baltic birch, even though I used the same thickness QSWO on the non-appearance side. It might have worked in a vacuum bag. It also might have worked had I used a non-waterbase glue, such as epoxy (I used Old Brown Glue, which is room temperature hide). But applying the veneer sequentially using water based glue got me into real trouble with warping, which I was able to plane out, but I would never repeat that experience.

I also glued the same quartered satinwood onto solid QSWO, without incident. Same grain orientation on veneer and oak.

The thing to remember about Krenov veneering, is that you’re using real wood, solid wood, even though it is thin. So if you’re using water-based glue, the very second the wet glue goes on one side, that ‘veneer’ will bow and/or cup sharply. So the offside, the appearance side, has to be kept wet while the glue is being applied and while it is drying. The nice lady at Old Brown Glue suggested a wet towel on the offside, underneath the clamps, and I found that worked well when gluing the sawn veneer to solid QSWO. Or don’t use water based glue.

My personal bottomline: Glue your sawn veneer to solid wood (I won’t use Baltic birch core again), and either keep both sides of the veneer wet while the glue dries, or use non-water based glue.

Caveat: just my limited experience—not an expert.

Wiley

Re: lengthwise bookmatching

#13

Re: lengthwise bookmatching

tomd

Over solid wood not ply, as the veneer is too thick to be mastered by the ply. The veneer will move so you need the core to be as similar as possible. I am guessing krenov had a veneer press. This was pre vac for most.

I think in the book the veneer was probably spalted maple so getting maple that would suit as a core was easy. Krenov had access to solid tropical woods so didnt really need to veneer them, except if like the spalted woods getting grain match was an issue