Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

Posts

Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

#1

Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hello All,

With Oskar's recent foray into making spokeshaves, I thought I'd show a pair of purchased/modified 316 stainless steel planes I recently acquired.

When I saw these at a trade show last month I realized the planes were high on the Cute Factor Scale, but I thought I could raise the CFS even more, so I modified them a bit to suit my needs.


The firm that made the bodies is CAG, based, I think in Germany. The pair were just over $100. The firm's website address is below - be sure to check out the link for the short video showing how they design and investment cast the plane bodies!

Although the planes are designed for bevel down use for the maple and spruce used for violin making, for making bows, I prefer a bevel up plane with a total angle of nearly 80 degrees. I also thought I would like thicker blades. And I prefer wedges over the screw cap blade hold-down devices.


I made new, slightly tapered blades from old pillar files, softening them first in our fireplace overnight to anneal them and then cutting and filing them to fit the plane bodies. The small blade is 6mm wide and the "larger" is 8mm wide. From the cutting edge back, the blades taper around 0.2mm in thickness over their length of just over 25mm long. I then hardened by heating with a propane torch and quenching in water and tempered them with an alcohol lamp to reach the light straw color. Flattened them with diamond stones and ground the working bevels with my Tormek. The ~40 degree bevels were sharpened with a soft Arkansas stone. Bevel angles this high allow me to plane/scrape the hard wood used for making bows.

The wedges are made of ivory, yes, the politically incorrect ivory. I bought the stuff legally in 1982, but I can't legally sell a bow with the material, so, I instead make stuff I personally will use, such as these little plane wedges. I've even made a small bevel gage and a 90/45 degree square out of the stuff. The bevel gage is about 2" long when closed.


The wedges were filed to fit and the decorative shape was cut using a coarse needle file and smoothed to 1000 grit and polished with a strop and "Paris Blue" polishing compound.

I've used these two new tools to plane the facets and round the sticks for two recent viola bows made of unfigured snakewood and they worked quite well.


And I think I succeeded in adding a few additional points on the Cute Factor Scale!

John


CAG Tools

Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

#2

Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes...

Don Orr

Nicely done! I'd love to see pictures of that Snakewood bow-and any others you might like to share.

Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

#3

Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes...

Howard Pollack

I agree with Don, above. The planes are very cool, and I'd like to see the work that you/they produce. Thanks.

Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

#4

Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes...

Hank Knight

John, those are exquisite! Nice conversion to wedges.

Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

#5

John’s bows (as in WOW!)

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

I suspect John is too unassuming to post his professional work. Here are some galleries:

http://www.jbabows.com/page3.html

Wiley

Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

#6

Very nice John!


Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

#7

Clint Searl

Cute little buggers!


Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

#8

Re: Cute little buggers!

Brian Holcombe

Very cool John!!

Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

#9

Maybe these

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Are what Denny needs, in the thread two down from this one.

They’re fabulous John!!

Wiley

Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

#10

Re: John’s bows (as in WOW!)

Don Orr

Thanks for the link and yes, definitely WOW!!!

Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

#11

Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes...

Oskar

nicely done John!

Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

#12

Question about blade holding

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

John,

Why do you prefer wedges?

Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

#13

Re: Question about blade holding

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi Bill,

Wedges look nice. When it comes to functionality, when you are planing the bottom 3 facets of an octagonal bow stick with the tightened hair in place that draws up the stick straight, a metal "lever cap" with screw can grab the hair. A plain wedge tends not to catch the tightened hair. The screw is the main culprit in terms of grabbing the hair.

John

Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

#14

Thanks for explanation


Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

#15

Re: Question about blade holding

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

John, I have twice answered and deleted my posts. I did not wish it to appear negative. You do such beautiful work, and the ivory looks sublime.

My concern is the combination of a round cross bar and a wedge. Now I do not know the compression characteristics of ivory, but I would not recommend the combination of wood and round crossbar. The crossbar would eventually create a depression in the wood, and then the wedge would not be able to tighten up. The solution is to file a flat under the crossbar - Krenov created a triangular crossbar that would rotate, which mated it and the wedge at all times.

Thoughts?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

#16

Ivory doesn't take a set

Patrick Chase

Ivory fails by chipping/cracking, and won't take a "set" from the crossbar the way wood does.

I think that the round bar is a nonissue for John's application. As you say you wouldn't want to emulate that with a wood wedge.

Re: Pair of New Bow Making Planes... *LINK*

#17

Re: Ivory doesn't take a set

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi Patrick and Derek,

Ivory will dent, if you press hard enough, trust me. You can bend ivory tips a bit by soaking them in hot water and clamping in a form. And yes, it does chip easily, something I know all too well. Fossil ivory chips more easily than non-fossil material, probably due to the mineralization from being buried for thousands of years.

So, if down the road I find the wedges wearing (denting) due to the round rod, it might be a good idea to file a flat in the rod. Something I should have thought about, and didn't attempt to correct for. Simple to do...

Thanks!

John