Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Double iron spokeshave

Posts

Double iron spokeshave

#1

Double iron spokeshave

Oskar

Almost everytime I use my spokeshave (bevel down) there is some spot where the grain tears out, or some part which for the given grain direction is hard to shape without going against the grain. And since I´m a dedicated user of the double iron in my bench planes I always think "how about a double iron spokeshave?"

Finally the itch became too strong not to scratch and I ordered a 45 mm Hock replacement blade for a metal spokeshave. From 1.5 mm mild steel I cut, filed and bent a cap iron and tapped it to receive a cap iron screw.


The spokeshave is made out of elm, with a brass wear strip in front of the mouth. The blade is bedded at 40 degrees and the mortise resembles that of a double iron bench plane. Finished with BLO and wax. The brass strip is tilted up towards the front at around 5 degrees and is filed and lapped with a slight curvature. Hence

the shave is used as a low angle wooden shave, where the depth of cut is adjusted by balancing the shave on the sole so that the contact point is closer to the blade for a heavier cut and closer to the front for a light cut.



A couple of test samples. Chestnut burl to the left and spruce with and against the grain to the right. No tearout.


I'm not an experienced furniture maker and I never made a chair. But with my single iron spokeshave I have made my fair share of tool handles, spoons, ladles, axe shafts etc. And tearout is always present. If not physically then mentally, manifested as great care where the grain is less cooperative. This usually slows the process down, by frequent repositioning of the work, or by taking a lot of very fine shavings to avoid tearout. With the cap iron I can take substantial shavings with no or minimal tear out, and thus work fast to final or almost final dimensions. Much like how a double iron try plane allows for working fast and safe to marked lines, leaving a surface that is easily smoothed.

Now, having completed the shave (and found it working as expected) the big question is: why can´t I find any double iron shaves around? No new ones, no old ones. No pictures, but plenty of references to people having tear out problems with spokeshaves. Bad googling technique? Or is this tool superfluous with the right technique and choice of materials/tooling? It is clear that for riven straight and steam bended parts this is not a problem. I'm talking about all the other cases of spokeshave use (less than perfect grain, figured wood etc. )

As a beginner it´s not my place to question the historical practices of woodworking - if this tool does not exist or is unnecessary, then there is for sure a good reason for it. Is the spokeshave simply not the right tool for chair parts and curved furniture parts in figured wood? I´m guessing this forum, with its vast joint experience is the right place to ask such a question.

Thanks for reading and I hope to hear your thoughts on the subject!

Re: Double iron spokeshave

#2

Re: Double iron spokeshave

John Aniano in Central NJ

Oskar,

What a beautiful tool you've made! It it appears to work so well, who can argue with your reasoning to make it with a chip breaker?

Great stuff!

John

Re: Double iron spokeshave

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

actually,there is one

Jack Guzman from Maine

Nicely done. That is a very nice tool you made there. You wondered why there weren't any others out there. I found this gem years ago. I believe it is made by the Butcher Tool Company(just a guess) because of the hatchet logo on the cap iron. It does indeed have a chip breaker. I've never tried it on wild grain. I think I will though. I mostly work with green oak with straight grain and have no need for such a tool. I just like it because it is unique.



---Jack

Re: Double iron spokeshave

#4

Re: Double iron spokeshave

Steve Voigt

Hey Oskar,

Great job. That looks fantastic!

I have seen pictures of large wooden cooper's shaves with double irons, but I think most of those were user made--I don't think they were produced commercially. I think the main reason is that a bevel down wooden shave needs to have a fairly large sole (from front to back), and adding a cap iron contributes to the length. Then there is also the issue of the shave splitting apart, which apparently is common on Japanese shaves.

Even though I'm a huge fan of the double iron, when it comes to bevel down shaves, I've gone the steep angle, single iron route--my current shave is bedded at 57.5°. That makes it possible to keep the sole length fairly short.

However, I definitely don't think you're barking up the wrong tree. A 40° bevel down shave is a pretty common tool in Japanese woodworking, and adding a cap iron will only make it a more versatile tool. And you were very wise to use Elm--the interlocked grain should help reduce the tendency of the wedge to split the tool apart.

I would love to see some more pictures, and some measurements, if you're willing.

Again, great job!

Re: Double iron spokeshave

#5

Re: Double iron spokeshave

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Oskar, I applaud you .... concept to execution. Well done!

Why have these not been made to date? I think that Jack is probably close when he suggests that green woodworking is fairly benign. One either learns to read grain when working with interlocked hardwoods, or use high cutting angles (such as the HNT Gordon shaves).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Double iron spokeshave

#6

Re: Double iron spokeshave

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Good on you for deciding to try something - and the results are impressive indeed. I'd like to see one more picture: the shave with the iron in place from the top, so we can see how it fits in place and how you're retaining it.

Re: Double iron spokeshave

#7

Re: Double iron spokeshave

Oskar

Thanks John!

Re: Double iron spokeshave

#8

Re: actually,there is one

Oskar

Thanks for the pictures and the post Jack, good to see that double iron shaves actually did exist. If you would take the time to tune the cap iron up and test your shave on some tricky wood I´d be interested to hear your thoughts!

Re: Double iron spokeshave

#9

Re: Double iron spokeshave

Oskar

Hi Steve!

thanks for your comments! I'm curious to see how well the elm holds up.

Indeed it is hard to keep the footprint of the shave small, and still have some meat under the bed. I can manage fairly tight curves, but its no cigar shave..

It measures 280 mm wide, 22 mm sole to top and 38 mm front to back. A couple of more pictures:





I´d be interested to see some pics of your single iron shave!

Re: Double iron spokeshave

#10

Re: Double iron spokeshave

Oskar

Derek, thanks a lot!

Your probably right, green wood and the fact that double iron shaves are harder to make and are prone to splitting. I'd like to know who the typical buyer of the shave Jack shows was.

Re: Double iron spokeshave

#11

Re: Double iron spokeshave

Oskar

Thanks for your comment Bill! See pics above for the escapment and the iron in place.

Re: Double iron spokeshave

#12

Beautiful piece of work!


Re: Double iron spokeshave

#13

Re: Double iron spokeshave *LINK*

Steve Voigt

Hey Oskar, here's a link to an Instagram post a few months ago, with pics of the shave. You did a good job of keeping the sole as short as possible…I think the only way to get it smaller is to use a metal body, like the HNT Gordon shaves.


high angle shave

Re: Double iron spokeshave

#14

Re: Beautiful piece of work!

Oskar

Thanks Don!

Re: Double iron spokeshave

#15

Re: Double iron spokeshave

Oskar

Thanks Steve! Must have missed that post. Are you satisfied with the shave, or would you make it differently if you made one more?

Re: Double iron spokeshave

#16

Re: Double iron spokeshave

Steve Voigt

Hey Oskar,

Yes, I'm happy with the shave. I use it primarily for making the long chamfers on coffin smoothers, and it works very well. I'd like to make it a little smaller, but as I said that's hard to do in wood. Maybe I'll try my hand at brass and steel some day!

Re: Double iron spokeshave

#17

Re: Double iron spokeshave

Oskar

Thanks Steve!

Re: Double iron spokeshave

#18

Re: Double iron spokeshave

Charlies

Chairs + wild grain, run-off grain, etc. is a combination that doesn't survive usage particularly well.

Re: Double iron spokeshave

#19

Re: Double iron spokeshave

Charlie

I see that I can't type my name this morning...