Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

Posts

Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#1

Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

Denny

I sometimes find that I'm hanging on to a project with one hand and trying to do some final shaping with the other hand. I've had some success working the Lee Valley low angle shave with one hand, not much success with the standard size Lee Valley shaves. Is there anything in current production that would be easier to handle with one hand? Flat bottom is what I'm looking for.

Thanks,

Denny

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#2

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

AlanWS

I don't find the Stanley ones work well one-handed, or ones with turned handles. Traditional style wooden spokeshaves with blades mounted using two tangs into a stock that's a single piece of wood seem best one handed.

This allows you to whittle with effectively a cut-depth-limited pocket knife. But it can't compare in terms of either speed or accuracy to a spokeshave used with two hands on a shaving horse.

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#4

Re: Maybe these?

Denny

Thanks, those look like they could work, but they're listed as "currently unavailable." I might give them a call in the morning.

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#5

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

Denny

Alan, do you know who might make something like you've described? I know I could make my own, but at the moment I'm more inclined to put my energy into making furniture rather than tools.

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#6

Re: Maybe these? *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Denny, I doubt they would work, so save your money - spokeshave, no matter the size, still require being balanced, and their narrow sole will skew if more pressure is placed on one side than the other. It would be very difficult to balance these with one hand, even if they appear small (I have one).

I sometimes find that I'm hanging on to a project with one hand and trying to do some final shaping with the other hand. I've had some success working the Lee Valley low angle shave with one hand, not much success with the standard size Lee Valley shaves. Is there anything in current production that would be easier to handle with one hand? Flat bottom is what I'm looking for.

The tool that I recommend - and I know that this works as you seek - is a scraper I built based on the Stewmac scraper for guitar building (link below).

Mine is the rear end of a 1/8" thick O1 plane blade that I shaped ...



This is prepared very simply by grinding the edge to a burr on a bench grinder ...


The finish is actually pretty good ...



Regards from Perth

Derek


Stewmac scraper

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Thumb Plane

Jack Guzman from Maine

Denny,I have alot of spokeshaves. All different sizes and shapes. I sometimes use one one handed but it is an awkward process. I know of no shave that would make this easier. Do you use any thumb planes? I have several that fit right in the palm of my hand and are great for one handed detail work. I'm talking about planes similar to the stanley 100 or 101.---Jack

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#8

This looks like a great idea!

Denny

Thanks Derek, I'll try this.

Denny

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#9

Re: Thumb Plane

Denny

Thanks Jack, I don't use any planes that small, I'll check it out. It looks like Lee Valley has a variety of mini planes that could work.

Denny

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#10

Another thought

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Carvers often do insanely clean and precise work with chisels. Have you considered a knife? Look for "hooked," "bent," or "curved" knives online.

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#11

Re: Another thought

Denny

Bill, that's an interesting idea. I'm sure I've got an appropriate knife hiding in a drawer somewhere, I'll try it out.

Thanks!

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#12

one handed carving knives

Ian Neuhaus

Our favourite candy store has these -- Pattern A is probably the best for final shaping.

Although these knives come with hardware, you will need to source and shape your own handle.

Link http://www.leevalley.com/us/wood/page.aspx?cat=1,130,43332,43339&p=43352


img

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#13

Re: Another thought

Denny

Well I gave it a try with a knife, but I had to stop or else I wouldn't be able to count to 10 any more...

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#14

This works well

Denny

I sacrificed a plane blade and now I have a fantastic one-handed scraper.

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#15

Re: one handed carving knives

Denny

If I use one of these I probably will be one-handed very quickly. I normally think of myself as fairly well coordinated, but a man's got to know his limitations...

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#16

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

AlanWS

There are a lot of old wooden shaves around. You are right that the new ones like this tend to be kits, but MWTCA meets (where I got mine), or reputable used tool dealers would likely have them.

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#17

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

Philip Duffy

a Very Long time ago I learned (down on the farm) to fit ax handles by breaking a window pane of glass and using a straight and very sharp edge to bring the new handle into submission. It cost Zero and it still works today.

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#18

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

Denny

That's a good idea. In fact, people also use glass knives for cutting thin sections for electron microscopy, but I think Derek's plane blade/scraper will do the trick.

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#19

bridger

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

Bridger

Something like this?

https://www.woodcraft.com/products/carvers-spoon-plane

I have similar but push cut. I don't know where to buy them, they were my dad's

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

#20

Re: Any spokeshaves that work with one hand?

Denny

That's an interesting idea, but I'd rather work with something with a flat sole. Working with Derek's idea of a scraper made from a plane blade is pretty good, but I find it not as fast as a spokeshave. Hopefully this project will be past the shaping stage soon and I can post some photos.

Denny