Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Pegging tenons

Posts

Pegging tenons

#1

Pegging tenons

Josko Catipovic

When is a tenon peg an essential structural component vs a decorative element? I see a lot of tenons without pegs, and am not sure if the joint is structurally compromised. Given modern glues, do we still need to peg them?

I also notice folks don't peg dominos - is there an essential difference between the two joints?

Re: Pegging tenons

#2

Re: Pegging tenons

Sgian Dubh

Josko, generally I'd say mechanical locking of an M&T has more importance in two main circumstances.

1. Where adhesive effectiveness could be either compromised or ineffective with many adhesives. Examples of this can be found in joinery destined for external use, e.g., gates, or joinery of wet wood, e.g., traditional timber framed buildings. In the first case the adhesive bond can break down rapidly because of large movement in the joinery and the effects of weather on the joints. In the second case most adhesives are designed for use with dry wood, with dry being defined as wood at 20% moisture content (MC) or less. Adhesives don't work on wet wood, with one exception I can think of, that being polyurethane types.

2. It may be that there is no other way to pull the joint up tight, so draw-boring of the M&T could be used instead of cramping. This might apply where long enough or big enough cramps aren't available for some reason.

For most furniture applications made of dry wood, and destined for internal use in habitable buildings the requirement for pegging or draw-boring M&Ts is much diminished, but you might apply a belt and braces principle, i.e., glue and peg the joint. One example of internal joinery frequently requiring draw-boring is holding clamped ends (aka breadboards) tight to the main field of the panel at the extremities of the clamp's length.

I can't see a good reason to peg a Domino - they're generally too small for one, and they're also designed to take advantage of the qualities of modern adhesives, so I can't really see the point of considering the technique, although somebody else might. Slainte.

Re: Pegging tenons

#3

Chris Scholz

Re: Pegging tenons

Chris Scholz

Hi Josko,

traditional Chinese woodworking from the 14th century onward would consider a construction that relies on draw boring or glue as structural elements as inferior craftsmanship. They'd rather rely on wedged tenons.

Chris

Re: Pegging tenons

#4

Re: Pegging tenons

Don Stephan

Especially well organized and thorough reply.

Re: Pegging tenons

#5

Re: Pegging tenons

david weaver

I think vintage glues would've worked fine for M&T, also - perhaps not if they get wet, but presuming you're making furniture for indoors in a climate controlled area, there should be no problem. If there was, you could just re-glue.

I agree with sgian, outdoors, I would do it for redundancy and mechanical lock.

Indoors, I don't like to see endgrain, so it's out. I haven't made any hidden m&T, which I'm assuming is what chris is talking about, and no through wedged even though that's trendy in a last 20 years sort of way (endgrain thing again). I'd rather repair an M&T than potentially destroy a piece to get at a edged M&T that's wobbling.

Re: Pegging tenons

#6

Re: Pegging tenons

Warren in Lancaster, PA

In 18th century work we see through tenons, either pinned, wedged, or just glued. We also see blind tenons, both pinned and not. The joints with wedges or pins can be glued or not. Here in Pennsylvania, there are often through tenons in the finest furniture.

I have disassembled all of these types of mortise and tenon joints for restoration work. I can't imagine taking apart a Domino joint; I think people would throw it away rather than try to repair. The use of any glue other than hide glue also greatly discourages repair.

Re: Pegging tenons

#7

Re: Pegging tenons

William Duffield

If absolutely necessary, you can replace a Domino joint: just cut through the loose tenon with a very thin saw (if it's not already broken or pulled out) and use the mortiser to cut two new mortises. Then glue a new tenon into the new mortises. The Domino machine will cut right through the old broken tenon and whatever glue was used to hold it together.

Note also that a smaller Domino tenon can be used as a peg to hold a larger tenon in place. You use the machine to punch a new mortise through the side of the assembled joint, and drive a tenon in to pin it.

Re: Pegging tenons

#8

Re: Pegging tenons

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I still am having trouble imagining a Domino repair. Let us say you have a frame and panel door that you need to take apart. Suppose it has a nice moulding around the panel that is coped at the corners. You are going to saw the stiles and rails apart and it is not going to affect the appearance, or the overall size of the door or the fitting of the coped joints? It sounds like it might be a lot of work to make it presentable again. And you have to make a bunch of mortises for the new dominos.

With a mortise and tenon joint, we take it apart and put it back together again with no loss of material.

Re: Pegging tenons

#9

Re: Pegging tenons

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Warren, a year ago I built a kitchen full of Shaker style doors in (USA) Hard Maple. As there were so many, I purchased a Domino to do the mortice-and-tenon work. This certainly made quick work of the joinery .... bearing in mind that I only have weekends, and "quick" was a period of 3-4 months.

We had an unusually hot and humid summer this year. The house is airconditioned. The combination added a great deal of moisture into the air. Three of the door frames opened at the corners - obviously the solid maple panels were a smidgeon too wide to permit expansion.

It was a fairly simple (if irritating) process to saw against the frames with a flush cutting Japanese blade in the gap. This cut the domino, which was planed flat. After removing the panel and planing off a couple of mm, fresh mortices were made with the Domino, and all reglued. It is impossible to see where a repair was made.

This is NOT a recommendation for a Domino machine. Traditional joinery is more satisfying for me.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Pegging tenons

#10

Re: Pegging tenons

Brian Holcombe

The more stuff I make, the more I move away from modern glues. The absolute last straw with modern glues was fitting up a perfect joint with visible through sections and having the glue seize the joint 1/64” prior to closing. No amount iof clamping pressure would continue to move the joint and taking it apart was no option. I build with a mind for glue surface and that is a double edged sword.

Hide glue and those same joints come together beautifully.

Re: Pegging tenons

#11

Re: Pegging tenons

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I am not sure I have seen a frame joint that so conveniently opened up enough that one could get a saw kerf between the stile and the rail. I was think of the common situation where one has to take apart an intact joint and sawing a Domino would necessitate removal of material at the stile/rail juncture.

Re: Pegging tenons

#12

Re: Pegging tenons

Brian Holcombe

I am expecting similarly to Warren that these are destructive most times as the come apart.

Re: Pegging tenons

#13

Re: Pegging tenons

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Warren, I agree with you that the situation you envisage would cause removal of material when sawing. I was most distressed when the couple of frames began to move, as you can imagine. I waited until the joint had opened up enough - and stopped opening (as that told me how much to remove from the panel). The gap was large enough to slide in a Japanese saw blade. No damage done. However other situations in which a Domino has created a join might not be so "kind" to be convenient. One of the issues I see with a domino is that they have set depths, which may not always suit the workpiece. Also, one can place them sequentially (to make them longer) and in parallel (to make them thicker), but there are restrictions in the form of set dimensions to work with (the size of each domino).

Really, the Domino is not more than a loose tenon, which has been around a long time. A loose tenon made with a router appears to be more versatile, and approximates a true tenon in that you can make any shape and size you wish. The perceived advantage of a Domino is that the joint requires minimal preparation (ala a biscuit joint). There is a place for this joinery, but not (in my opinion) when you are planning for repairs into the future.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Pegging tenons

#14

Re: Pegging tenons

Bob Lang

When I started writing about woodworking I never dreamed that one day I would be talking about fashion trends, but that's what happened with draw boring a few years ago. Enough people wrote about it, and enough people repeated what was written about it without thinking things through that now we have people confused about what it does or why it is there.

In most circumstances in making furniture a pegged mortise doesn't hurt, but it doesn't do much if the joint is sound and the material is stable. When I was putting the peg in place in the piece in the photo, a coworker asked me why it was there. My initial answer was "I am building a reproduction and the original had the peg". That answer didn't satisfy the questioner and I was asked "but what does it do?" My answer was "if the earth's orbit moves closer to the sun and the temperature gets hot enough to melt the hide glue and the wood shrinks enough for the joints to get loose, this will still hold it together.


Bob Lang

Re: Pegging tenons

#15

Interesting

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

That peg's so large in relation to the thickness of the tenon that it would seem to weaken, not strengthen it; and you'd sure have to get your drill bit dead square. Who designed the original of that piece?

Re: Pegging tenons

#16

Re: Interesting *LINK*

Bob Lang

It is a Gustav Stickley music cabinet. The tenon is 1/2" thick and the peg 1/4". The tenon is 1-1/4" back from the front of the case. The tenon is about 2-1/2" wide and the peg goes about halfway into the tenon. In theory it might "weaken" the tenon but this piece is way over built to begin with. When the tenon is in place there isn't any where for anything to go. I couldn't make the case rack or wobble either before or after the pegs were in.

Link is to more pictures of the finished piece

Bob Lang


Stickley No. 70 Music Cabiner

Re: Pegging tenons

#17

gratuitous pegging *LINK*

John Schtroumpf

Here's a shot from my dutch tool chest. If you look closely, I vertically pegged the dovetail joint of the skirt with shaker tie pegs.




shaker tie pegs