Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

round bottom spokeshave recommendation, please

Posts

round bottom spokeshave recommendation, please

#1

round bottom spokeshave recommendation, please

Howard Pollack

Hi- I'm looking for a spokeshave to work inside curves. I wonder if folks have recommendations? Thanks.

-Howard

Re: round bottom spokeshave recommendation, please

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: round bottom spokeshave recommendation, please

Jack Guzman from Maine

Lee valley has a nice wood handled version,Veritas. It is a fine tool for the job. My favorite however is the Boggs designed brass shave sold by Lie Nielsen.---Jack

Re: round bottom spokeshave recommendation, please

#3

Re: round bottom spokeshave recommendation, please

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

It really depends on the curve. Most flat bottom metal shaves can plane inside a "moderate" curve. It depends on the width of the sole. I like the LN Boggs shaves for their balance, and the round bottomed shave can plane a tightish curve. If you want to get into really tight curves, then you need something even smaller. LN make one. I have the Preston copy from Veritas.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: round bottom spokeshave recommendation, please

#4

Re: round bottom spokeshave recommendation, please

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have the Boggs, too, and really like it. I’m not able to tell what radius would be the inside limit.

Re: round bottom spokeshave recommendation, please

#5

Re: round bottom spokeshave recommendation, please

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If you can hold one in your hands, it will help. My one concern about round-bottomed spokeshaves with adjusting nuts is that the nuts can interfere with the curve. I owned a Record clone of a Stanley 151 for a while, but released it into the wild when I realized that the nuts were getting in the way - and this was a flat-soled shave. I now own solely shaves without adjusting nuts. It's a little trickier to set depth, but it can be learned fairly quickly, and the handling is much better.

As far as vintage tools, I kind of like the Stanley 63X I picked up at a yard sale: really tight mouth, pretty tight curve. I should emphasize, though, that my example may or may not be representative. This shave was sold as a manual training (shop class) tool, and it's possible that the tight mouth on my copy was an accident; other copies may be sloppier.

If the curves are really tight, you might look at a "cigar" shave, like the one Woodjoy Tools sells (http://www.woodjoytools.com/spokeshaves/brass-circular-shave), or the original design by Millers Falls (much cheaper on Those Auction Sites than the Woodjoy, though with the usual issues of used tools).

Re: round bottom spokeshave recommendation, please

#6

Re: round bottom spokeshave recommendation, please

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Howard,

If perchance you find yourself searching for a really tight-radius shave, I suggest using rasps and files instead. I tried it both ways, using a tight Preston as well as the LN small bronze shave, and a custom LN shave that Thomas LN ground down to the tightest radius possible. In my hands, rasps and files were much better than the shaves, for one thing, in a tight curve you’ll be working end grain.

Wiley

Re: round bottom spokeshave recommendation, please

#7

Re: round bottom spokeshave recommendation, please

Brian Holcombe

I agree, use a shave for larger inside curves, and very tight curves a file or rasp. 00 files produce a very good finish.

Re: round bottom spokeshave recommendation, please

#8

Thanks to everyone