Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Porcelain floor tile

Posts

Porcelain floor tile

#1

Porcelain floor tile

John Pappas

This may be the dumbest question ever asked on this board....but I'll risk it.

It is said that the bottom of a porcelain tea cup can be used to sharpen a knife. If true, can a porcelain floor tile that doesn't seem to have a glaze finish on it be used to sharpen a chisel or plane blade?

Re: Porcelain floor tile

#2

bridger

Re: Porcelain floor tile

Bridger

A granite tile can be a decent base for abrasives, either loose or bonded. I've never found a ceramic floor tile that would make a good hone though. I think that floor tiles, even porcelain ones have too much sand in the mix. Not to say that there isn't one out there, but i've looked at a lot of tiles with that very thought in mind and let's just say there are no floor tiles in my hone collection.

Re: Porcelain floor tile

#3

Re: Porcelain floor tile

William Duffield

Too much sand? The sand found most places in the world is silica. Novaculite, the abrasive in Arkansas stones, is also silica. I think a significant problem with tiles is that the abrasive particles are not consistently graded to yield a consistent scratch size. I attempted to sharpen a knife on a concrete sidewalk, many decades ago, but was not satisfied with the results. :)

Re: Porcelain floor tile

#4

Re: Porcelain floor tile

Howard Pollack

Try the experiment and find out. Report back please -Howard