Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Stanley plane tuning

Posts

Stanley plane tuning

#1

Stanley plane tuning

Josko Catipovic

I've upgraded a Type 9 Stanley #3 with a PMV-11 blade and had to file the opening to fit the thicker blade. I took my time filing, and all of a sudden the plane started to perform admirably. I can just fit a 0.01" feeler gauge between the blade and front sole; the blade is supported BOTH by the sole and the frog, and can take of a (to me) unbelievably thin full-width shaving in the trickiest of woods. (I've cleaned up and kept the original chipbreaker.)

The problem is that I have no adjustment capability, and the blade is only good for ~3 honings before I have to rebuild the primary bevel.

My question is whether to keep going (with filing the mouth) or accept this as a special-purpose non-adjustable plane from now on. It would be awesome if I could retain this level of performance with a degree of blade adjustability, but it performs so much better than my #4 LV, that I wonder if it's realistic to expect it to work as well if I keep filing the mouth.

Re: Stanley plane tuning

#2

Re: Stanley plane tuning

david weaver

File open the mouth more, until you can set the frog so that it's in line (in plane) with the bottom of the casting, and you have a mouth in the range of two or three times the size that you have.

The mouth is irrelevant for use because even at a hundredth, it won't stop tearout. It needs to be near the same size as the shaving being taken, which creates a lot of resistance.

Give yourself a little bit of room at the mouth (but not more than a 32nd or so, and if it gets in the way of the cap iron, file the angle above the plane going away toward the front a little - you're effectively then duplicating what the fine infill makers did in the early to early-mid 1900s - the most ideal of plane setups).

I haven't used a V11 iron in a bench plane much, but for any iron, you should then get predictable wear, and if you want, you can push honing a nearly dull iron 5 or 6 times before regrinding. it will be several projects' worth of planing, because use of the cap iron will extend the volume of planing that you can do significantly with each sharpening.

Re: Stanley plane tuning

#3

Re: Stanley plane tuning

Josko Catipovic

Thanks David,

I'll keep filing, but I AM nervous about giving up this sweet spot I stumbled onto.

Re: Stanley plane tuning

#4

Re: Stanley plane tuning

Patrick Chase

Both kinds of #4 LV planes (custom and older-style) have adjustable mouths, and getting a 0.01" mouth with either of them should be extremely simple. Also and as David said, that's not small enough to make a significant difference.

Whatever you've stumbled onto probably has more to do with other aspects of your setup (sharpening or cap iron set?) than with the mouth.

Re: Stanley plane tuning

#5

Mouth size

david weaver

A hundredth mouth will probably be significant to a lot of beginners because they won't get in any serious trouble with it. There will still be small tearout, but nothing large will lift.

I still remember the first piece of curly maple I planed. I fought the plane through it, and there was a little burl button or some grain that was about the size of a marble, and the half circle of it was in my board. It was interesting looking.

I horsed it with a coarse plane and the entire little half circle popped out in one piece. Terminal. That kind of significant thing is stopped, as is less significant.

BUT, it's still miserable planing with a plane if there is small tearout (like working a 1 hundredth mouth against the grain), and if you don't want to walk around your bench all the time, you're going to be going against the grain at some point, especially if you use the beginner's process of planing an X pattern.

The ability to plane and keep a plane in the cut with an even thickness shaving, even against the grain, without the jumpiness of a tearing cut ...it really can't be overstated. You just cannot accurately plane depth and thickness when one part of a board isn't tearing and another is.

It might sound strange that I'm making this claim about common pitch and a one hundredth mouth, but I set my third infill (a shepherd kit) to a 1 hundredth mouth, and never filed the front going away toward the front of the plane (it was just 90 degrees). You couldn't get the cap iron close or it ran into the "wear" in that plane. Once I learned to use the cap iron, I didn't open the mouth, but carefully filed it going away (like norris did) and reprofiled the cap iron a little bit so that it wasn't so blunt (as shepherd's slab type cap iron was obnoxiously blunt, because that was easy to make - a wonderful ward or norris cap would not have been).

The difference with that panel plane from that minor modification was night and day. Any direction on the wood, power through it (it was a heavy plane) and no jerkiness in the cut. You could do overlapping strokes from one side of a board to another, measure the depth change, and do the exact same thing over and over and the change was predictable (as was the expectation that if you were removing a certain amount of thickness, you'd do it from end to end and left to right coplanar).

Re: Stanley plane tuning

#6

Re: Mouth size

Josko Catipovic

Thanks for your help and encouragement. I opened up the mouth to ~0.04", which gives me a range of blade depths, and I don't have to rehone as frequently.

I'd guess the blade is a little less forgiving since it was supported by both the frog and sole before, but it works very well indeed.