Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

MWTCA in Medina

Posts

MWTCA in Medina

#1

MWTCA in Medina

CJ in MPLS

Anyone going to attend?

Re: MWTCA in Medina

#2

Re: MWTCA in Medina

CJ in MPLS

I talk to myself all the time, but generally not in public. I'm making an exception here.

Went to the meet, but did not see any Wood Central hats. I did note that at 49, perhaps 90% of the attendees are older than myself and in more than a few cases, some of the tools purchased today will have made their way back to the sale tables within a couple of years. Hand tool enthusiasts are frankly old. We need to see if we can recruit some more of the kids making coffee tables out of pallet wood to hand tool usage. One problem I see is the cost. Tools at one of these shows are very reasonably priced. The same tools at the local antique mall are stupidly priced. This may put the kids off the search for useable tools. Broken planes for $65 is kind of a bad introduction to the hobby.

In any case, I did well today I think. Including the renewal of my MWTCA membership, I spent $100 and came away with a 1/4" cranked neck chisel, a center finding head for my Starrett combination square, and a Zenith (Marshall Wells Hardware Co.) jointer. I was looking for a shoulder plane, but did not find one I liked.

CJ

Re: MWTCA in Medina

#3

Re: MWTCA in Medina

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi CJ,

Is that Marshall Wells jointer a transitional? Or Bailey style?

As for new blood in hand tools, maybe what is needed is someone doing it who captures the imagination of youth. Roy Underhill served that purpose at one time. And somehow, I don’t remember how, Jim Krenov became known and though he used power tools, he did stuff with handtools too. Who is out there now?

Wiley

Re: MWTCA in Medina

#4

Clint Searl

Re: MWTCA in Medina

Clint Searl

IMO the romance in woodworking is making something useful and pleasing to the eye, not in learning how to tune up a plane to make the thinnest shaving. The end justifies the means, and that means power tools are the most efficient way to the end.

Re: MWTCA in Medina

#5

I was there

Bruce, a MN Galoot

But I didn’t see you, Chris, not that I would have known you anyway. :D

It was a good show, lots of people, and one of the guys in my group won a door prize of a subscription to Fine Tool Journal. I thought the prices were pretty reasonable. If you want someone to find you a good shoulder plane, get in touch with John Walkowiak. He had the display with the really good infills and moving filisters.

I met up with Tom Dunlap, who posts on the WC main board, and we had a great talk. Very, very good guy. He even found me the protractor head I wanted for my Starrett combo square.

Re: MWTCA in Medina

#6

Woodworking Triple Point

CJ in MPLS

On the ride to work this morning I was thinking about the trade off between money, time, and expertise that occurs every time we pick up a new project. For example, if I have the money, I can buy a tool that will do the thing itself quickly and with good results. Alternatively, I can use my hard earned expertise to carry out the task in the known and efficient manner (expertise always seems to be the hardest coin to come by). Finally, I can peck away at the task in an inefficient manner until I get a result that is acceptable, if not satisfactory.

For the kids just starting out, you get a more or less straight line on the time axis. There isn't any expertise or money available. With some coaching one can broaden this along the expertise axis and with a few lucky moments at a garage sale or an auction, one get some relief along the money axis. Over time, the point becomes a region and you're cooking with gas.

One of the reasons I like the 'maker' movement is not because someone is finally meeting the long felt but unmet need for wooden six pack holders (who ever needed one of those things?), but because the makers are providing some of the coaching that is needed in a format that doesn't involve some of the 'what are you going to use that for' type of gate keeping the old salts can impose. I think this was one of Roy Underhill's strengths. He provided the information one needed, no questions asked. Also, he bleeds all over his projects which is pretty funny.

A good example of someone that can really get people into a craft is the fellow that runs the YouTube channel "This Old Tony". Not only is his stuff informative and well made, but he is genuinely funny. I've learned a quite a bit watching his content, including that metal working is a rabbit hole of epic proportions that I need to avoid. It looks like a lot of fun.

For my part, I guess I'll grit my teeth and laud the younger folks who keep making stuff out of pallets and hope that they go far enough that the triple point becomes more of a region. Once they start wondering why the home depot pine bookshelf with all in one stain/finish doesn't look like the stuff at the furniture store, they'll be hooked.

Re: MWTCA in Medina

#7

Re: I was there

CJ in MPLS

We'll have to arrange a meetup once things thaw out a bit. I live over by the University of Minnesota if you get that area at all.

Re: MWTCA in Medina

#8

Re: Woodworking Triple Point

Bruce, a MN Galoot

“I've learned a quite a bit watching his content, including that metal working is a rabbit hole of epic proportions that I need to avoid. It looks like a lot of fun.”

I read a couple machinists forums, including the one TOT posts on. One of the posters has a sig line that says “How to become a millionaire: Start out with 10 million and take up machining as a hobby!”