Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Cesar Chelor plane

Posts

Cesar Chelor plane

#1

Cesar Chelor plane

Steve Palmer

Hello,

My wife and I inherited a Cesar Chelor molding plane in her grandfathers passing a few years ago. I am not sure he knew what he had since it was packed away in a box with a pile of generic antique wood planes. I was wondering if anyone had any thoughts as to what the value might be or a what good resource to get a value would be. It would be nice to donate it to a museum, but we have 2 kids and a lot of house projects on the horizon. So, the funds would certainly be welcome. I am located in NW Massachusetts and can provide pictures upon request. Thank you!

spalmer0316@hotmail.com

Re: Cesar Chelor plane

#3

Sell it, Don't Donate it

david weaver

If a museum wants it, they can pay for it. They have donors and fundraising just for such a thing. You're entitled to receive what it's worth - they're a business despite the non-profit tag that most of them have, and they should pay for the items that they use as a business.

At the price that it will bring, whoever gets it will be someone who knows what it is, and whether or not it's a museum, it will be taken care of.

Re: Cesar Chelor plane

#4

Re: Cesar Chelor plane

Warren in Lancaster, PA

David V Englund of Seattle donated a collection of 250 Nicholson and Chelor planes to Colonial Williamsburg a little over a year ago. This is almost certainly the largest collection of this stuff. Chelor was trained by Nicholson, who freed him in his will. Chelor was on his own in 1753. Erik Goldstein is the Williamsburg curator who handles the collection.

I think I would get in touch with Goldstein; at the very least, he would be interested in pictures and might have advice about selling. And David Englund must certainly know where to go to buy this stuff. Lee Richmond, mentioned in Derek's post, would also be helpful.

Re: Cesar Chelor plane

#5

Re: Cesar Chelor plane

Patrick Chase

A Chelor may not have been valued in anything like the way it is now when your grandfather-in-law acquired it, so it's also possible that he knew what he had but not what it had become.

As David and others have said, find a reputable tool dealer specializing in such early American tools. The CW curator mentioned by Warren would at the very least know who all of the players are and can probably point you in the right direction.

Re: Cesar Chelor plane

#6

Re: Cesar Chelor plane *LINK*

Steve Voigt

I'll second Warren's suggestion. Erik Goldstein is extremely personable and knowledgeable, so I would start with him. If CW doesn't want it, he might be able to suggest another museum that would be interested.

It sort of sounds like you want to take the high road here, so I would definitely try to exhaust museum options (as Dave says, they may be happy to pay for it) before talking to private dealers. Nothing wrong with the latter, it's just that a dealer will likely sell to a private individual and the plane will disappear from public view.

You can find Erik's email on the page linked below.


CW contacts

Re: Cesar Chelor plane

#7

Re: Appraisal by Lee Richmond on Antiques Roadshow

Patrick Chase

Wow, that plane is an amazing piece and in terrific condition. Lucky kid.

Re: Cesar Chelor plane

#8

Re: Cesar Chelor plane

William Duffield

I would also highly recommend Erik Goldstein. If your plane is put in the Colonial Williamsburg collection, I strongly suspect it will be put on display and will be studied in the future by people who use historical plane designs to build historically accurate reproductions.

http://www.history.org/history/museums/expansion.cfm

CWF is building a significant addition to their museum that holds their tool collection, and are planning a major expansion of their displays of tools.

Re: Cesar Chelor plane

#9

Re: Donating and How Things can Change

david weaver

Just reiterating as I understand from the OP that he'd have use for the proceeds from selling the plan rather than donating it outright.

I grew up in Gettysburg. Quite a lot has been donated to the park service over the years, in some cases with unwritten promises that it would always be displayed. A lot of the one of a kind items that were donated have been out of public view for decades, and are unreachable by anyone who might like to purchase them and display them.

Even if CW is the recipient of the plane, I noticed that their operating expenses in a given year are about $225 million with a president's salary and value of earned other compensation nearing 7 figures.

It's nice to donate things outright, but know that whether or not CW is intending to display all of the planes they have gotten recently, there's no guarantee that anything that you donate will be displayed for long. Some of the generous donations by locals in Gettysburg have been stuffed away, and the donors should have sold their wares to local private businesses.

If getting something for the plane is important in combination with it going to a museum setting, you can always hold on to the plane and give it another go in the future. Many of the donors to the NPS (and to CW, I'm sure) have been wealthy and are in an entirely different situation - giving something to what is essentially a business isn't a big deal for them. Legacy and sharing might be more important.

If you decide ultimately to give outright because that's your decision, great. If not, hold out for a solution that suits both you and the recipient.

Re: Cesar Chelor plane

#10

Re: Donating and How Things can Change

Patrick Chase

I almost replied to Steve's post to say this, but unless the OP is well-to-do the "high road" here is to do right by his family IMO.

As David alluded in another post, museums have "development" programs to obtain large donations from people who can and should afford to make them, precisely so that those museums can compete in the market for pieces like this one.

Finding a Chelor in your inheritance doesn't make you a member of the aforementioned "should donate" group. If the OP wants to give the museums right of first refusal that would be nice, but IMO he should insist on fair market value regardless. Let somebody else's donation finance that.

Re: Cesar Chelor plane

#11

Re: Donating and How Things can Change

Steve Voigt

Patrick, I don't disagree, and I didn't mean that the OP should feel obligated to donate--I tried to say that, but perhaps it wasn't clear. All I meant was that given the choice between selling to a museum or selling to a dealer, I'd rather see it go to a museum.

Re: Cesar Chelor plane

#12

Re: Not trying to make a stink, of course...

david weaver

...My case isn't the OP's case, but I'd also expect to get something from the museum. I would, however, choose them over a dealer in a situation where the offers were anywhere close - especially with the promise of current display.

Brings another thing to mind here. There aren't a lot of pittsburgh planemakers, but there were at least two who had significant volume. There was a display of a huge collection of little used planes here at the museum that may have been on lend, and they were behind and under glass (in a case "behind" and in drawers with a glass top "under" so that you could pull the drawers out and look at the planes. Of course, if it was moulding planes in those drawers, they were all upright and packed in tight, so you couldn't see much, but they were displayed at least.

I never saw them before or since, and I didn't catch a reference to see who actually owned them (and whether or not it was the museum - in this case, the Heinz History Center - which is a really cool place for anyone who is ever in town here - but usually more glass and steel and no planes).

The Gettysburg thing stands out to me separate from that because it involved donations and promises, and though some of the private display businesses in Gettysburg are cheesy - especially the older ones - when they do have items, they tend to display them or sell them to someone else to display them. When the NPS decides they change their mind about a building design or some other such thing, and floor space gets used for something else, then the donated items just go into a barn.

Over the years, the private collectors who did keep their items (which were nickel and dime kitsch a century ago - like collections of bullets or deactivated artillery round) and sell them upon death left their families with a lot more. they will eventually find their way to museums if they get rare enough.

Re: Cesar Chelor plane

#13

Re: Donating and How Things can Change

joel moskowitz

No museum in their right mind would ever accept a donation with a "must display forever" clause. It just is too restrictive.

If you want the cash sell the item, if you want a tax deduction donate it, and if you don't care about either give it away to anyone or any organization that you think will appreciate it.

The larger the museum the great chance that your donation won't make it on display. CW already has tons of stuff that for a smaller historical museum would be an important addition but for CW not so much.

So if you want to donate consider smaller institutions too.

Re: Cesar Chelor plane

#14

Re: Agree

david weaver

Not suggesting that anyone ever demand that. It's unreasonable, and times change. My example of Gettysburg is different because the donations were made decades ago when people made handshake deals on that and didn't have their pants as tight as they do now. Promises tend to be fewer in number and much less specific once they have to go in writing.

The post above somewhere stated that CW has already received a collection of 250 nicholson and chelor planes. While they might like to add to their collection, what material difference is it? On top of that, CW is clearly a business, so I wouldn't extend them much courtesy in giving things away, but that's my take as a rank and file individual (vs. an Heir who has an in-tact collection that they'd just like to see curated). I'm sure CW is masterful at both taking their donation and then seeing if they can woo them onto the donor list (we have a foundation in Gettysburg that does the same thing - except the number of artifacts, the revenue and the people traffic in Gettysburg is probably a significant multiple of CW. The foundation is more or less a business and its function is to do things that the government isn't allowed to do).

If there is a small low-revenue hand tool museum somewhere else who has *none*, then having one to display is significant, both to the museum and to the folks passing through. But you still can't really reasonably ask someone to promise to do or not do something with an item that you're giving away, other than perhaps requesting an agreement that they will never sell or give the item to someone else. They can't reasonably promise something like that, either.

For most of us, our legacy is our kids and how we take care of our family, and as much as people get excited over Colonial Williamsburg or Chelor planes, they mean absolutely nothing at all compared to that. They're just businesses and things.

Re: Cesar Chelor plane

#15

Re: Cesar Chelor plane

Brian Holcombe

I’d be tempted to contact auction houses in addition to museums and dealers. Private individuals as well if they’re willing.