Re: Not trying to make a stink, of course...
david weaver
...My case isn't the OP's case, but I'd also expect to get something from the museum. I would, however, choose them over a dealer in a situation where the offers were anywhere close - especially with the promise of current display.
Brings another thing to mind here. There aren't a lot of pittsburgh planemakers, but there were at least two who had significant volume. There was a display of a huge collection of little used planes here at the museum that may have been on lend, and they were behind and under glass (in a case "behind" and in drawers with a glass top "under" so that you could pull the drawers out and look at the planes. Of course, if it was moulding planes in those drawers, they were all upright and packed in tight, so you couldn't see much, but they were displayed at least.
I never saw them before or since, and I didn't catch a reference to see who actually owned them (and whether or not it was the museum - in this case, the Heinz History Center - which is a really cool place for anyone who is ever in town here - but usually more glass and steel and no planes).
The Gettysburg thing stands out to me separate from that because it involved donations and promises, and though some of the private display businesses in Gettysburg are cheesy - especially the older ones - when they do have items, they tend to display them or sell them to someone else to display them. When the NPS decides they change their mind about a building design or some other such thing, and floor space gets used for something else, then the donated items just go into a barn.
Over the years, the private collectors who did keep their items (which were nickel and dime kitsch a century ago - like collections of bullets or deactivated artillery round) and sell them upon death left their families with a lot more. they will eventually find their way to museums if they get rare enough.