Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

Posts

Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#1

Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

Brian Holcombe

Good afternoon, hope you are all doing well. Wanted to update you guys on the workshop and my progress.

The kitchen design has moved in stages, in between stages and in the evenings I've had time to work out things like this chair.

My hopes for this design are that I can move toward a moderate level of production work mixed in with my custom work. I'm pretty focused on becoming a bit more known in the furniture circles. Some of my products are like that, being a moderate level of production by both hand and machine mixed in with the more open ended projects.

Along with this has been the incorporation of machinery with handtools, I just cannot meet any reasonable expectation of lead times otherwise. I feel as a handtool commenter I should mention this, but my shop now actually falls more in line with what most handtool woodworkers are doing which is augmenting machinery with hand tools. Truly I'm not sure how one lives without hand tools as even the most careful process by machine still needs hand fitting at least at my level.

So I've added an FS41 Elite S jointer/planer, Felder FD 250 mortising machine and will be adding a duplicator lathe and tilting spindle shaper to the mix once funds allow. Many I hope can see that it lends itself to allowing me to focus more so on the tactile areas of this project, such as the shaping.

https://brianholcombewoodworker.com/2018/01/16/henrys-chair/

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#2

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

William Duffield

The figure of the quartersawn ash you made the seat from is fascinating. Would you say something about how you chose the wood to get the striped pattern?

Have you seen the technique Sam Maloof used at the tablesaw to build his sculpted seats? It saves some time during the sculpting and also allowed him to use somewhat thinner wood stock for the seat. Basically, it boils down to jointing the edges of the five narrower boards he glued up to form the seat at small angles that resulted in a subtilely curved seat blank. The essence of the process is shown in this photo by another woodworker using Sam's technique:


I don't think you would find it incompatible with your techniques. If you can't figure out the dimensions and angles you would need, I should be able to find my copy of Maloof's book that provides more details.

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#3

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

Brian Holcombe

Thanks William!

I appreciate your message, the quartered ash all I can really take credit for is a bit of luck and careful selection. For reasons unknown a lot of the ash I get locally has a wonderful dark brown streaking in it, it really serves to add a bit of character.

I like how Maloof does those seats, as I hone in on my seats I think I too will incorporate a bit of that. I'll detail more tonight as I will try and join the chat after Henry goes to bed.

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#4

Welcome to the dark side.

Mark Hennebury

Hi Brian,

Nice job on the chair.

And welcome to the world of WTW ( Whatever Tool Works)

The best job done in the most efficient way..... is not a compromise!

Using any tool helps you achieve that, be it hand or machine tool is the right way.

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#5

Re: Welcome to the dark side.

Brian Holcombe

:D :D Thanks Mark!

I managed to snap up a copy lathe tonight, so..one step closer to the goal.

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#6

Re: Welcome to the dark side.

Mark Hennebury

Brian,

I made lots of tables and chairs and have used many good machines for mortise and tenon work, and would be happy to help you. Much of my work was a combination of hand tools, power tools, manual and automatic machinery. Choosing and Tuning up the machinery is the biggest part of getting top quality results.

if you need any advice on machinery anytime you can call me.

keep up the good work.

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#7

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Great work, Brian.

I can see the influences of China and mid-century Danish ... the design is like an update on Wegner's The Chair ... a bit of Windsor .... and very definitely Holcombe! :)

I echo Mark's comments on 'use the tools that work'. This piece is about the design, and its production. It is clearly not going to be a one-off.

Keep it up!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#8

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

Charlie

Works in a similar style and shows a nice mix of hand and machine craftsmanship:

https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC7FkqjV8SU5I8FCHXQSQe9Q

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#9

Re: Welcome to the dark side.

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Mark! Very much appreciate your kindness.

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#10

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Derek! I had a bit of that all in my mind as I designed. I try to never look at another work as I design but some of it comes out as it’s been in the forefront of my studies for a time. It’s certainly influenced by Windsor, Wegner and Ming.

There is also a certain wonderful enjoyment found in tool setup and process. So many of these things are not so easy to intuit but figuring out and improving the process is very rewarding.

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#11

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

Brian Holcombe

Ishitani’s furniture is quite nice, I enjoy watching those videos.

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#12

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

david weaver

Sounds like a good sign - the demands of your clientele are too great for you to meet them working entirely by hand.

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#13

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

Brian Holcombe

Thanks David! The try plane and jack will still be getting a good and regular workout....on wide boards in this case :D

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#14

Clint Searl

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

Clint Searl

A most appealing design, the execution of which is greatly enhanced by the delicate chamfering.

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#15

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Clint!

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#16

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

david weaver

No big deal if they get set aside. They've done more already than most, but regardless of whether they have or haven't, that's your business and not mine!

:)

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#17

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

Brian Holcombe

Thanks David! They’ve treated me well, a testiment to your work. My jointer planer is 16” wide do I have a feeling I’ll be putting the planes to plenty of use.

It’s nice to have the skill set in any case, my j/p is pretty good and still it will snipe about .001-.002” which is a dream by comparison to other planers but without handplanes I’d likely never find this.

It’s also great to be able to finish plane with confidence that their will be no tearout.

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#18

Re: Welcome to the dark side.

Chris C

Brian, great work on the chair. Henry will be honored and proud for years to come!

And noticed a couple months ago in another forum that you were adding some machines. I was relieved for you! Fine tooling is fine tooling :)

Best,

Chris

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#19

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

david weaver

The fact that you waited to get good equipment is a huge plus. I have junky portable stuff, and initially started off with mid-grade equipment. I guess that sort of thing is fine with kreg jig screw together woodworking, but its capability never matched the space it takes up.

Buddy of mine has older american machines, including a DC 580 (which is really no pearl stock) that he's retrofitted with spiral heads and a rigged dial gauge setup for thickness to the thousandth. Between it and the jointer, you can nail something as close as you want, the surface literally is cleaned off in a single plane shaving and the edges off of the machine are so sharp and crisp that they cut you. I have to wear gloves in his shop.

I could live with a machine like that if I had a reason to spend the money. Like you said, the tiniest bit of snipe, but it's off in a pass. I'm sure the euro machines are even better.

As far as the planes, though, I've never regretted learning to make them. I hope making pocket knives goes as well.

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#20

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

Brian Holcombe

It was well worth the wait, pretty happy with how these perform. I've yet to set the mortiser up for hollow chisels, so I'm excited to see how that behaves at that point. Works nice with a router bit but I can't live with rounded corners. :D

Nice, that sounds about the same as this setup. There is a really big plus to having a wide and reasonably long jointer. It's really nice to be able to work 95% of the material on the machine and have accurate results.

I went with a Tersa cutter head rather than spiral, they set the chip breakers fairly close and it cuts super clean. The big plus is that I can change the knives in about 2 minutes. A shop near me has helical cutter heads and they like them, but I know rotating them is a few hours process.

I made some slab shelves recently, as example, they were so flat that they literally stuck together with a vacuum seal when laid upon one another. I can do that by hand, but doing so is a waste of time in most cases rather than leaving the surface slightly hollow.

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#21

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

TomD

maloof pieced the chair seat so there was a rise in the middle, not just a collecting groove to squish one in. At least that is how I remember it.

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#22

Re: Welcome to the dark side.

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Chris! Sorry somehow I missed this post earlier.

Re: Henry's Chair - Prototyping a Dining Chair

#23

Re: Welcome to the dark side.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Interestingly, on the Australian forum, handtool users are referred to as the Darkside (not the power users, as here).

Regards from Perth

Derek