Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fox Wedge tenon??

Posts

Fox Wedge tenon??

#1

Fox Wedge tenon??

Tom Norton

I have some Shaker chair kits that I need to assemble. I am wondering about 2 things. What type of glue and should I enhance the mortise & tenon, turned strechers and legs, with a hidden fix wedge.

Advice??

Thanks!

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

Jack Guzman from Maine

As far as the tenon,I think I would use whatever joinery was in the original pieces. Shaker chairs were built to last. For the glue,you want to avoid fast setting glues. Chair joinery is difficult and takes time. I use mostly liquid hide glue for the reversability but white glue is my second choice.---Jack

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

#3

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

William Duffield

liquid hide glue for the reversibility

What Jack says!

Chairs need to be repairable, due to the stresses they are subjected to over the years. Fox wedged joints are incompatible with this precept, because they cannot be disassembled without destroying the joinery.

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

#4

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

Patrick Chase

Not to mention how difficult fox-tail wedge joints are to get right in the first point.

Make the wedge too long and joint won't close (and still can't be nondestructively disassembled). Make the wedge too short and it doesn't do anything at all.

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

#5

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

Brian Holcombe

There is a fair amount of tolerance in fox wedges because wood does compress, but yes they're nerve wracking and I tend only to use them pretty sparingly.

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

#6

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

Jim Matthews

Rather than struggle with the proper wedge size, why not consider drying the tenon so much as possible and driving it home into each mortise?

http://www.jefflefkowitzchairmaker.com/chairmakers-journal/boggs-side-chair-build-26-a-good-joint

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

#7

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

Patrick Chase

Two words: Compression set.

When it comes to chairs the real enemy is the tendency of the wood to take a compression set when it absorbs moisture but is prevented (by the mortise) from expanding. It then forms a gap, leading to adhesive failure, when it dries and contracts again. The key thing to internalize here is that the wood's dimensions in the *dry* state actually become smaller over many cycles, and the tighter the joint is to start the more compression it experiences and the more it shrinks. Pre-drying the tenon just causes it to take that much more of a compression set when it absorbs moisture, leaving you in more or less the same place as if you hadn't bothered.

IMO foxtail joints are actually of less benefit than you might think for exactly the same reason. The joint starts off tighter, but doesn't stay that way after many cycles.

Hoadley had a really good FWW article on the topic in the 80s or 90s IIRC. His takeaway was that more flexible adhesives and the ability to repair when needed were basically the only viable mitigations. Oddly enough others have raised both of those in this thread :-)

EDIT: This should be obvious and universal knowledge, but compression set is why we don't align the tenon's tangential axis with the long axis of the mortised piece.

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

#8

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

John J.

If a tenon is kerfed and a slice of veneer is tightly wedged into the kerf before assembly, it gives an automatic plane of failure. The circumferential glue joint is spared from separating.

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

#9

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

Patrick Chase

If you're going to use a kerf as a strain relief, then why bother with the fox tail at all?

Putting the fox tail in makes the joint tight when dry, and guarantees that it will take a compression set when wet. As you say, when the wood dries again it will open around the foxtail instead of around the tenon's perimeter. With that said, if you know it's going to end up that way then you'd might as well just leave the veneer piece out to begin with such that the tenon has room to expand and never takes a set at all.

BTW kerfing like that *is* a totally legitimate way to avoid compression set (though it's not free because it weakens the tenon). It's just the foxtail that doesn't make sense.

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

#10

Agreed


Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

#11

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

Brian Holcombe

The fox wedge requires a certain amount of compression built into a joint or it will loosen up. Same way a wedged tenon can become loose overtime (and they often do) if they're not driven tight (and sometimes even if they are).

Personally I've really come around to glued joints in scenarios where I would have previously used a through wedged tenon or fox wedge. Most often with a fox wedge I'm using glue anyways, which in some ways defeats the point of all the extra effort.

There are other practical benefits to simple joinery in many cases, these have to do with having a piece look tight over time. I've had wedged tenons gap at the shoulder more often than anything else during times of low humidity. Plain joints, such as simple mortise and tenons are gripping the mortise at a location nearer to the tenon shoulder.

Joints such as a draw bored mortise and tenon are better still as the mechanically force the joint to close.

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

#13

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

John J.

I reread my hastily typed response and realized when I said to "wedge" the veneer, it might have been misconstrued to mean I was advocating a fox wedge. I intended to suggest the kerf and veneer as a controlled split in the spirit of what Hoadley proposed. Thin veneer snugly and accurately filling a crisp kerf. I will make some test joints and see how it goes, never actually done it. In actual practice, I try for equilibrium moisture content mortises, slightly drier tenons, and accuracy in joints and size relationship of parts.

Re: the original question, I don't think anything can beat an accurately mating fit. It is what it is at this point.

Regarding dowel joints in chairs in general, lots of things have been tried unsuccessfully. Mike Dunbar suggested bulbous sand dried tenons in wet wood, which isn't a good solution. He later recommended fitting parts over length and relying on parts pushing against one another to maintain force. This also eventually fails, and doesn't apply to post and rung chairs. Some of his ideas also modulated based on expedience in his teaching pedagogy.

Brian Boggs used to use super dry tenons slightly over-sized, hammered in to wet mortises. Perhaps they also failed, because IIRC he moved to kiln dried mortises with slightly drier tenons, very tightly sized. I could be wrong about this point.

Re: Fox Wedge tenon??

#14

You're right

Patrick Chase

I mistook your suggestion of veneer for a fox wedge. A "neutral" strip of veneer to fill the kerf helps to mitigate the initial structural downside of a kerfed tenon, and doesn't make compression any worse.