Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Debonding Atoma plates

Posts

Debonding Atoma plates

#1

Debonding Atoma plates

Patrick Chase

A while back I purchased a spare #140 Atoma surface, and finally decided that my existing coarse-stone-flattening plate was shot (it had worn in the center where it was very difficult to get stones flat even though the plate itself was near-perfect).

Stu outlined a process on his blog (http://www.toolsfromjapan.com/wordpress/?p=919) but there turns out to be an easier way.

The key here is that most acrylic abrasives (including the one on Nitto 5015 tape) break down irreversibly by 200C. The solution is therefore to simply bake the plate in an oven at 400F for a couple hours, then pry it apart. If you've done it right the adhesive will have turned dark brown and smell "burnt" when you pry it apart, which can be done easily with a box cutter or similar.

Heating the residue also degrades its solvent resistance, so you most any finish remover will do the trick. I've tried acetone, lacquer thinner, and NMP paint remover (the slow, "safe" kind). They all work.

As a bonus the stainless carrier sheet, the diamonds, and the nickel bonds holding them together are all impervious to such temperatures. In addition the adhesive becomes weak enough that you can pry the plate off without bending it, so this may be a way to recover out-of-flat plates (I've had good luck with Atoma "replacement sheets" on glass substrate... :-).

Re: Debonding Atoma plates

#2

Remounting can be good for Atomas...

Patrick Chase

As noted in my previous post I had an Atoma plate that wasn't getting my waterstones as flat as it had in the past. I theorized that this was because it was less sharp in the center than the edges (which it was/is), but that turned out not to be the cause.

When I debonded the plate I noticed that a calcified ring of waterstone swarf had accumulated along the edges of the plate in the gaps between the tape strips that hold it to the Aluminum carrier. While it didn't lift the edges enough to be detectable with a straightedge [*], I theorized that it might be enough to cause the convexity I saw in my stones. I lapped the substrate to get rid of nicks etc, cleaned up and re-attached the plate (using the same Nitto 5015 tape as Atoma), and it now leaves perfectly flat results.

The bottom line is that if you have an Atoma plate that's mysteriously drifted out of flat (like Brian IIRC) it may be worth remounting the steel diamond carrier.

[*] In a 140# plate the diamonds sit a few mils proud of the substrate, so it's hard to detect small flatness errors.

Re: Debonding Atoma plates

#3

Re: Remounting can be good for Atomas...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Patrick,

Why not use an adhesive instead of the double stick tape to rebond the diamond media plate back to the aluminum substrate?

I would think that an epoxy or a silicone sealant might do the job more evenly and prevent swarf from building up between the substrate and media plate.

Did you use one large piece of the Nitto 5015 double sided tape? Again, to prevent the swarf build-up? I thought you said that Atoma uses three smaller pieces of the tape...

John

Re: Debonding Atoma plates

#4

Re: Remounting can be good for Atomas...

Patrick Chase

Good questions.

I used 5 narrower strips of tape instead of 3 wide ones, so while swarf can work its way in the gaps are much smaller and present much less opportunity for bulging (you would expect the amount of bulge to be roughly proportional to the square of the gap size, so what I did should knock it down by ~4x).

You're correct that a glue would have worked as well, though that brings its own complications: Fixturing and clamping to ensure flatness by providing for constant glue layer thickness across the plate, contamination/cleanup issues, etc.

Re: Debonding Atoma plates

#5

Atoma OCD

Patrick Chase

I've had an Atoma 400 plate for a long time that just wasn't quite as flat as i wanted for stone-flattening, so into the oven it went for debonding and reclamation.

Instead of re-using its existing blank I lapped the back of the #140's blank and stuck it to that. Now I have a very flat "Atoma Duo", which is handy for waterstone maintenance.

I did confirm that the blank from the 400 was a bit dished (explaining its previous nonflatness - it was right at the edge of Atoma's 2-mil spec), and lapped it flat for future use.

Seriously, for anybody out there like Brian whose Atoma has drifted out of flat, I think it's a no-brainer to debond/rebuild.

Re: Debonding Atoma plates

#6

Re: Atoma OCD

Brian Holcombe

I may do that on two of mine, though I’ve been a bit lazy about it.

Re: Debonding Atoma plates

#7

More technique

Patrick Chase

One additional suggestion: When the plate comes out of the oven, only let it cool until it's very hot to the touch such that you can only directly touch it for a few seconds at a time, but can hold it with a thick rag or pot-holder.

If you pop the steel sheet off at that point then it will come loose with almost no prying. Although heating to 400F permanently degrades the acrylic adhesive, it does regain a small percentage of its former "stick" when it cools to room temperature. You can avoid that by popping the plate off while hot.

Re: Debonding Atoma plates

#8

Re: Remounting can be good for Atomas...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Patrick,

Where does one purchase replacement Atoma sheets? You mentioned using these bonded to thick glass pieces to make your own flat diamond plates.

Thanks,

John

Re: Debonding Atoma plates

#9

Re: Remounting can be good for Atomas...

Patrick Chase

The one cautionary note is that they're not all that much cheaper than the entire plate (maybe $15 difference).

Stu usually has them in stock at toolsfromjapan.com, and has all 4 grits right now: http://www.toolsfromjapan.com/store/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=335_462_464

You can find a bunch of people in the US (and Dieter Schmid in Germany) selling them for slightly higher prices if you search for "Atoma replacement sheet". Atoma's US distribution is steadily improving, and the prices appear to be coming down as that happens.

One other thing to be aware of is that you can get the same "podded" electroplated diamond abrasive on a PSA-backed flexible copper sheet instead of the 1 mm stainless carrier in the Atoma stones. I used a little bit of that to make a dressing tool for waterstone slips a while back. See https://www.fine-tools.com/diasharpener.html (bottom of page) and http://www.toolsfromjapan.com/store/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=335_462_544.

Re: Debonding Atoma plates

#10

Nice bows

Patrick Chase

On an unrelated note, as a Cellist I instinctively check to see if I've got $4200 in loose change rattling around somewhere every time I look at your site :-).

Re: Debonding Atoma plates

#11

More OCD: "Accurizing" Atoma plates

Patrick Chase

I've now debonded and rebonded all 6 of the Atoma plates that I have in regular use (for both waterstone maintenance and occasional tool work). The process I used is the one outlined in my previous posts. In addition I lapped the Aluminum substrates to flatness (as determined with a Starrett straight edge that's spec'ed flat to within 0.0001") before remounting.

All 6 of the plates demonstrated improved flatness after remounting, to the point where I can't distinguish their results (again, as judged with the Starrett straightedge) from my Shapton plate. Given the cost difference and the fragility of the Shapton plate's resin bonding system, it seems to me that "accurized" Atomas are a no-brainer for even the most flatness-obsessed among us. The 1200 leaves a particularly nice finish on polishers.

One gotcha to be aware of is that the ends of the stainless carrier sheet can curl up a little. I deal with that by clamping them with additional pressure while the PSA adhesive cures.

Of course this is all just a distraction from, you know, woodworking.

Re: Debonding Atoma plates

#12

Re: More OCD: "Accurizing" Atoma plates

RK

Nice!

How did you lap the plates? Sandpaper on the reference plate?

Re: Debonding Atoma plates

#13

Re: More OCD: "Accurizing" Atoma plates

Patrick Chase

Loose SiC grit on laminating sheet on granite surface plate.