Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

(OT) Kamikoto 7-inch Chef’s Knife

Posts

(OT) Kamikoto 7-inch Chef’s Knife

#1

(OT) Kamikoto 7-inch Chef’s Knife

Chuck Bjorgen

I labeled this as off topic because it’s not a real woodworking topic but also know that knives are frequently discussed here. This was a Christmas gift from my son and I certainly don’t think he paid the suggested retail price of $675. That’s how it’s currently listed on Amazon. Apparently recent coupon offers of 79 percent off on this knife and it’s companion three piece set have caused cries of fake, scam and other forms of negativity. Based on some basic research on the internet I’ve discovered that these knives, while made of Japanese steel, are actually manufactured in China. As for the MSRP, I believe that’s the part of marketing that is misleading. Makes it a lot more attractive when discounted.

With the above in mind, this seems to be a very good knife that comes in a nice wooden case and is delivered extremely sharp. I did not know that most Japanese chef’s knives are single bevel on the right side and that supposedly favors right-handers to the detriment of lefties. I’m a righty. Recommended sharpening is with water stones only and a 1000/6000 grit combo stone is sold for that purpose. Stu’s set should work for me. Curiously, Arkansas stones and steels are not recommended.

The left side of the knife, of course is flat, and the right side has a large bevel about half way down the blade and finishes in a sort of working secondary bevel that is about 1/32 inch. Seems it might be tough to maintain that working geometry but I’ll try. Not wanting to start another sharpening thread but suggestions will be welcomed.


Re: (OT) Kamikoto 7-inch Chef’s Knife

#2

Re: (OT) Kamikoto 7-inch Chef’s Knife

David Weaver

Hi Chuck, you're right, those knives are being made in China and Taiwan now, and the sellers don't always excel at honesty about their origins.

As far as sharpening, keep the profile the knife has, with the secondary bevel, but keep the bevel small. You can make it a bit less steep over time, but you'll find the failure point if you go too shallow. A small secondary of about 35 degrees total angle is about the practical limit.

I have a couple of Taiwanese knives made of Japanese steel, and they're actually excellent, better than any of my German knives, and they were cheap.edge holding is similar to middle of the road rikizai Japanese knives.

Sharpen them with whatever you want. I sharpen vg10 at relatively high hardness with a fine india and hard ark..It's faster than anything else.

The best stone to work the primary bevel on a knife like that is a medium crystolon and india combination, but they can mark the knife some with stray particles. You can go more slowly with coarse and medium waterstones if cosmetics matter.

If the knives are good, enjoy them...They could very well be excellent.

Re: (OT) Kamikoto 7-inch Chef’s Knife

#3

Re: (OT) Kamikoto 7-inch Chef’s Knife

David Bassett

While that may be OK as a knife, it takes very little searching find the brand and pricing is (virtually) a scam. E.g: https://consumerist.com/2017/04/17/customer-accuses-dealdash-of-selling-cheap-generic-products-disguised-as-independent-luxury-brands/

As far as Japanese knives being single bevel, that is true only for their traditional forms which are tuned for specific tasks common in Japanese cuisine. They also make more general purpose knives that are double bevel, though often with some asymmetry. The profile in your picture is generally of a Santoku, a small general purpose knife of somewhat murky history. IIRC- it was more a marketing creation in Japan in the 1920-30's, that has slowly become popular there for smaller home kitchens. That profile surged in popularity in the US with Rachel Ray using one and then fell into disfavor amongst snobs due to the absolute garbage versions sold by her name brand.

Re: (OT) Kamikoto 7-inch Chef’s Knife

#4

Re: (OT) Kamikoto 7-inch Chef’s Knife

Chuck Bjorgen

To both David’s who responded — Yes, I’ve read most of the online stuff attacking the marketing of this brand. Still it seems like a decent knife despite all the stuff being written. When I decide to refresh the edge I’ll use my Sigmas in 1200 and 6000 grit. Your suggestion of 35 degrees seems good. And yup, in reading I’ve found that Japanese knives also come in double bevel. Thanks.

Re: (OT) Kamikoto 7-inch Chef’s Knife

#5

Re: (OT) Kamikoto 7-inch Chef’s Knife

David Weaver

I went out and looked at a picture of the knife set. They look like the same maker as knives that were sold under the brand name grand sharp.

Those were about $20 to $40 each, with shipping, but they were also laminated. Very good knives for the price at that.

Not sure about your set, they may be laminated, but I can't tell from the pictures. Still true that if they're decent, you can make good use of them.

The ad copy is pretty generic....says a little in a lot of words, but that's typical with this kind of stuff. The grand sharp ad copy was brief and honest, but they were going for something different at the time!