Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Question about an oil stone

Posts

Question about an oil stone

#1

Question about an oil stone

John Pappas

I picked up what appears to be a quality oil stone at an estate sale.

"Khaki" best describes the color. Very fine....close to a ceramic stone I have. Any ideas about what it might be? (Not that it really matters :) ) Thanks for any opinions.

Re: Question about an oil stone

#2

Re: Question about an oil stone

david weaver

It's difficult to tell. Sometimes, a khaki oilstone is a soft arkansas, sometimes it's a washita, and sometimes it's a bone colored or little darker translucent.

Quite often those are hindostan hones (which are silica and not novaculite).

If you can post a picture of the top (clean) and the sides (clean), I can give you a good answer.

On top of the above, there are also tan colored and other strange colored novaculite stones from England that aren't out in large quantities, but not unheard of. Those are more common in England, of course.

Re: Question about an oil stone

#3

I forgot ....india stones..

david weaver

..there was also a point when there were more grades if india stones, so there are some tan colored older alumina stones out there.

I've seen them as fine as a 4000 grit waterstone equivalent.

Re: Question about an oil stone

#4

Re: Question about an oil stone

John Pappas

Been having trouble posting picture. TMB problem. (Too many birthdays) If you can get some idea from this pic, fine. Otherwise, don't concern youself further. Thanks,


Re: Question about an oil stone

#5

Re: Question about an oil stone

david weaver

I sometimes call those bone colored trans stones (I haven't seen anyone else reference them - but I have two). They're not actually translucent, but they have the same density as a translucent stone, more or less, and no pores.

Really good stones. One of mine is strong cutting, and the other is very weak cutting. You just never know, I guess.

Should be a good finish stone. If it seems to slow, bias whatever you're sharpening so that only the edge is in contact with the stone. It'll reward you for figuring out how it likes to be used.

Re: Question about an oil stone

#6

Thanks David


Re: Question about an oil stone

#7

Novaculite *is* Silicate


Re: Question about an oil stone

#8

bridger

Re: Novaculite *is* Silicate

Bridger

Novaculite is a partly metamorphosed silicate, which puts it close to jaspers and agates. Sedimentary silicates like slate and sandstone are also used for sharpening stones but due to their more friable bond are generally useful at the coarser end of the scale.

Re: Question about an oil stone

#9

Thanks Bridger

david weaver

What bridger said.

There are gobs of stones that are some sort of silica. On the weak cutting end are things like hindostans and soft stones, or settled in jasper, pieces of agate, quartz, etc.

When we think of pure silica, we think of sedimentary rocks like Hindostan, and the cutting properties of novaculite are vastly different. They're different than agate, quartz, etc.

Agate is weak and dull feeling most of the time, but there is a place for it. It would probably make a great substrate for diamonds, too. Novaculite, on the other hand, is strong cutting. Jasper is jekyll and hyde. If you manage to slurry it (which is difficult to do without just scratching up the surface and making it a pile of scratches), the slurry is brash and harsh. If they break in, they can cut super-fine, almost to an optical polish on hardened steel.

Quite often, when you get on a knife forum or razor forum, someone comes in and says "they're all silica, they're all the same". That comes with reading about stones and not using them.

Re: Question about an oil stone

#10

Re: Thanks Bridger

Patrick Chase

Right. They truly ARE all Silicate, but they are not at all the same. Seems simple enough.

A Hindostan and an Ark are "both Silicate" in roughly the same sense that a clay-binder waterstone and a Spyderco Ceramic stone are "both Alumina". In both cases it's a factually true statement that means much less than uninformed some people think.

My objection was to your wording implying that Novaculite is somehow distinct from "silicate" abrasives (it isn't, irrespective of being cryptocrystalline, partially metamorphosed, etc).