Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Usefulness of certain clamp types

Posts

Usefulness of certain clamp types

#1

Usefulness of certain clamp types

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Background: I have a small shop; of late, I've been evaluating some of the too many things I've crammed into it, trying to get rid of anything that's not useful. At the moment, my attention is on the Klamp Korner. I've got a large selection of C-, F-, spring, and pipe clamps, with various specialty clamps thrown in, all of which clamp styles I use regularly (or they take up so little room that they're worth holding on to for the rare occasions I use them). But I'm wondering about whether to keep a couple of categories of clamps, and, if so, how many.

I know that I'm about to ask a heretical question here; generally, the idea is "there's no such a thing as too many clamps." If you're feeling faint on reading the previous paragraph, feel free to stop reading.

Handscrews: I have somehow acquired 20 handscrews (not counting a couple of all-wood examples and one all-metal one), ranging (using the Jorgensen numbering system) from No. 2/0 (7" long jaws) to No. 4 (16" long jaws), predominantly No. 1s, which seem the most common size in the yard sale market. Emotionally, I am reluctant to give these up; they just scream woodworker. But I don't find I use them that much.

So, please enable me (or not): where do you find them useful, and how many do you find useful to own? If you don't find them useful, please do say so.



"Universal" cabinet clamps:
I've somehow gathered five of these:


The idea is that the pivoting "foot" clamps against one side of the carcase when the screw is tightened, pulling it against the adjacent side. All five are of this style, useful as far as I know only for the outer corner of a carcase (there's another style, which turns the bar on its side, which could be used for intermediate shelves or suchlike). I believe they can be replaced in function, but with more flexibility, by F-, bar, or pipe clamps.

Does anyone own/has anyone owned this clamp style? If the answer is "yes," do/did you find them useful, or did you get rid of them?

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

#2

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

I've got a couple of them. I think I last used them about 20 years ago...

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

#3

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

Ron in Sterling, CT

Hi Bill,

When I started accumulating woodworking tools many, many years ago I obtained quite a few wooden screw hand screws. Over time I also purchased many Jorgensen, or competitive brand hand screws. Several years ago I sold off all my wooden screw types as I wasn't using them. I have never missed them.

Ron

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

Jack Guzman from Maine

I too have accumulated many handscrews. I actually only use two. Medium sized with the metal screw. I use them most often when standing a board on edge,mortising,layout or assembly. Or sometimes for edge planing. The other major use is as a drill press accessory. One of my clamps is notched for holding a round object.---Jack

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

#5

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

Patrick Chase

The nice thing about wooden handscrews is that you can adjust the angle of the jaws to positively clamp things that aren't quite parallel. Of course you could achieve the same by making wedge-shaped cauls when you have such jobs, but that's a fair bit of hassle. With that said I don't find myself needed long clamp jaws for non-parallel faces very much, so I think I have a grand total of 8.

IMO those cabinet clamps would be handy if you make very large face frames, not so much otherwise. The beauty of that design is that it allows you to clamp a corner on a very long beam without needing an equally long clamp. If I were building entertainment centers I'd probably have a bunch, as they strike me as much more usable than very long pipe/bar clamps.

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

#6

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

jerry schram

i mostly use my hand screws to hold rhings so i can use both hands to do something

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

#7

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

William Duffield

I would not even consider unloading my hand screws. I find them to be the most flexible, versatile types of clamps in my shop, and I'm always finding new uses for them. Maybe if all I were building was rectilinear solid wood boxes in boxes, I would not need so many.

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

#8

bridger

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

bridger

Bill-

I have a couple of that style of cabinet carcase clamp. I do use them from time to time. the main thing keeping me from using them more is not having enough of them. I'll be passing through your way in a month or two, and if you'd like to work out some sort of exchange I'd be happy to have them.

Bridger

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

#9

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types - Clarified

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

When I said I'd last used them 20 years ago, I was referring to the 'Universal Cabinet Clamps.'

The wooden hand screw clamps I have get used quite often. I have a dozen or more in varied sizes. Us then 'just' as clamps, as well as for work holders at the drill press and stationary sanders. With a notch or two cut into the jaws, they hold oddly shaped pieces quite well, too.

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

#10

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

david weaver

I'm not a clamp enabler. I'd choose to discard any that I wasn't using.

Of your list, hand screws are the only thing that I use with any regularity, but not conventionally (usually).

I like a hand screw at the drill press, because it holds things vertically and lays flat, and can hold mildly irregular things. You can also glue things to the jaws if you want to make it a jig to drill small things repetitively (like a dozen or so pens if you're making gifts).

I also like to use them as a mobile hook from ceiling rafters to hang strops on, but I think I might be the only person doing that (the cheap metal screws have threaded rod sticking out of the ends that make an ideal temporary hanging point).

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

#11

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

Brian Holcombe

F clamps are great, I use them regularly for glue ups.

Pipe clamps are lousy, one day I will chuck them in the trash and replace with long f clamps which do not damage the work.

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

#12

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

Patrick Chase

I've gradually replaced many of my pipe clamps with Dubuque/Universal Aluminum bar clamps. The weight difference alone is worth the extra $$$. Not having to worry about discoloring the work is also a big plus.

OTOH the nice thing about pipe clamps is that they can be made as long as needed by keeping long pipe segments on hand and/or splicing. I don't do work that requires that, but I can see why some folks would be limited by the 8' (IIRC) maximum length of bar clamps.

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

#13

clamp length

Bruce, a MN Galoot

A year ago, building our deck, we gained pipe clamps to 14’ to straighten deck boards. They were heavy and slow but sure did the trick.

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

#14

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Thanks, folks! Lots of good information here.

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

#15

bridger

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

bridger

aside from the possibility of very long sizes pipe clamps also offer the ability to apply a great deal of force.

I dislike them for most work, however. at longer lengths they flex excessively. the coarse and fine adjustments are at opposite ends. the ends tend to rotate about at inconvenient times. at shorter lengths the weight is excessive.

I have a dozen or so, but I avoid using them.

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

#16

Re: Handscrews

TomD

The sort of place where you would use 100 of them would be if you laminated long snaky things like railings on spiral staircases, bent shaft paddles, gunnels, tillers. But I end up using the C clamps I originally bought for doing canoes for those kinds of things, along with the dozen hand screws I have.

One of the advantages they have is incredible power that is really easy to crank up, due to the leverage. They also allow joining things end to end; or the application of pressure over the whole length of the clamp; or on non-parallel surfaces. How you use these things depends on your creativity in the shop.

As was mentioned they are great for random holding. Making expedient machines. Measurement stops, quick jigs where you need to align something to a fence. Holding things like a board on your bench, where you clamp one edge of the clamp to the bench and use the jaws to hold something. So you can mount them in your bench vise, then work on something higher in the clamp jaws. Or you can apply them to the end of a board, and use that to support the end of a piece that is clamped in your main vise, the way one uses adjustable stands. They make a nice small leather holding jig for saddle stitching. I use them in ways that allow me not to have a string making, or arrow cut-off jig for archery. Etc...

There are no end to the uses, but I don't need a lot of them, given that there aren't enough to use for the kind of things I mentioned in the first para. 10-20, depending on the size distribution, or 100-1000, kinda deal.

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

#17

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

Hank Knight

I chucked my pipe clamps long ago. I found them to be awkward and onery to use and they often damaged my work. I think I may have two left in the unlikely event that I ever find a use for them. I have a few Jorgy heavy I beam clamps that are capable of enormous pressure, but I can't recall the last time I used them. If I need that much pressure, there's something wrong with my joinery that needs to be fixed. I use mostly Bessy parallel clamps and "F" styled ones in various sizes, and I have a bunch of hand screws I use fairly often. I agree with those who find them versitile and useful for odd jobs. I also have a bunch of "C" clamps of various sizes that I inherited from my father that I never use, but I can't bring myself to part with them.

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

#18

Re: Usefulness of certain clamp types

Brian Holcombe

They damaged one of my projects recently, after spending a few hours repairing the damage I decided I was done with them. Anymore I feel that longer projects should just be made with a mechanical means of connecting itself. Draw boring or some other method.

It's easier and usually makes for a better result.