Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

working angles for pine, popular?

Posts

working angles for pine, popular?

#1

working angles for pine, popular?

Joseph Piotrowski

hey there woodcentral!

in order to keep costs down for shop stuff, I'm spending a lot of time working with pine and sometimes popular.

i have read some things on internet about using certain bevels on chisels and plane angles but i can't trust that information as much as i would trust it from this group.

i don't plan on buying anything just pine, but i have a few more tools than i really need so i don't mind setting aside one or two tools for just working in pine and soft woods.

i have heard 17 degrees and 20 degrees for chisels. even one claim that bevel up planes are better in pine. any of this true?

TIA,

Joe P.

Re: working angles for pine, popular?

#2

Re: working angles for pine, popular?

AlanWS

Pine varies. White pine is very soft, but yellow pine has alternating hard and soft layers, with the hard ones more like oak, necessitating a more durable edge. I don't pretend to great experience levels, but don't find bevels below 20 degrees very useful for planes or chisels.

Another feature of pine is that it can have a lot of pitch, keeping you busy removing it from tools.

Re: working angles for pine, popular?

#3

i love and hate pine

Joseph Piotrowski

for all the reason you mentioned, pine can be difficult. but i do love the smell!

home depot by me has some nice clear pine, its like you describe with hard and soft areas. i yet to try out out for a full project.

Re: working angles for pine, popular?

#4

Re: i love and hate pine

david weaver

If you've got a type of pine that's got hard bits in it, then I'd err toward something closer to standard angles, and set up a paring chisel or two with a low primary angle if you want to play.

Standard common pitch bench planes should be fine for achieving a bright surface. If there are marks, it'll be either due to an edge that's not uniform, or a burr on the subject plane somewhere.

Japanese planes provide the absolute brightest finish in pine, but it's something that gets lost a little (the brightness) vs. other planes once you start applying wax, shellac or other finishes.

I've found poplar to be fairly variable (I'm sure everyone has) depending on the source. Some of the fast-growth stuff that comes from HD is really soft, almost like radiata pine with a bit more stringy feeling. On the other hand, some of the stock that I've gotten from local independent lumbermen has been fairly dense for poplar, almost reaching what I'd consider to be the lower range for cherry density (which itself has a huge range - but then, so does pine...so does almost everything, I guess).

If you have totally clear white pine or radiata pine, then you can get pretty aggressive with low angles, and may need to to avoid breakout in dovetail sockets, etc, with chisels.

Re: working angles for pine, popular?

#5

Re: i love and hate pine

Joseph Piotrowski

i just used some pine from Hd that was labeled from sweden(IIRC) it was very white but cut nicely. used it for drawer parts for a shop cabinet so i don't really do much other than rip it to width and cross cut it but it was very easy to work.

Re: working angles for pine, popular?

#6

Re: i love and hate pine

Brian Holcombe

I wouldn't get too crazy about low angles, sharpness is more important IMO. A 17 degree chisel is going to look like it has saw teeth after some use.

25 would be as low as I would be going, and likely the majority would be around 28-30.

Bevel angle is less important than bedding angle for sheen. A low angle bed is going to provide a very clean and bright finish. Japanese planes really come alive on softwoods.

Re: working angles for pine, popular?

#7

Re: i love and hate pine

Joseph Piotrowski

see, now your just feeding my dark side! lol. I have wanted to try a Japaneses plane for a long while.

my sharpening skills are coming along nicely and have noticed that is making a huge difference. i free hand sharpen so my angles probably fall into a range somewhere around that 25 -30 mark right now.

i have one Japaneses chisels and really love it so far. i'm looking to get a wide pairing chisel and i guess a new hand plane :).

Re: working angles for pine, popular?

#8

Re: working angles for pine, popular?

North of Border

With very very few exceptions, I build with hardwoods.

For those few softwood dovetail occasions, I used my standard chisels (25 to 35 or so) and did not notice any difference in my work.

However, if you believe in what Rob Cosman preaches, for pine dovetails, he uses 17* chisels. You can find his video on youtube.

Re: working angles for pine, popular?

#9

Re: working angles for pine, popular?

Joseph Piotrowski

that probably where i heard that 17 deg. not sure where i heard 20deg from. too much information out there.

Re: working angles for pine, popular?

#10

bridger

Re: working angles for pine, popular?

Bridger

I've been accumulating and rehabbing old chisels long enough to have duplicates of enough sizes that some stay set up with pretty low angles. I tend to reach for the lowest angle tool that will perform for the task at hand, choosing to sharpen a bit more frequently for cleaner performance in softer materials. If you have an extra chisel or two to experiment with you can find an angle that gives you the balance between crisp effortless cuts and edge longevity that works for your workflow. There are too many variables to give a formula type answer.

There is a fairly brutal return on effort curve which favors quality chisels which are easy to sharpen and fail by abrasive wear rather than by chipping or deforming. An A2 chisel at low angle in wood with a lot of hardness variance between early and late grain will grind you to a crawl.