Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

An interesting look again at Beach's results

Posts

An interesting look again at Beach's results

#1

An interesting look again at Beach's results

david weaver

We could probably do these now (I could) with a scope, but I have zero interest in doing them because I don't disagree with any of them based on stuff I've used.

http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/bladetest.html

Now that we've had these discussions and I've personally had much more experience with each of these irons, the only results here that I don't match are the eskilstuna (my berg iron is hard and chippy and fails early - it doesn't feel that hard on the stones, and may just be a rare dud).

The knight iron that I commented about is apparently cryo treated. By every standard you could think of, it at least matches the A2 irons, but it's actually better.

The wear bevel is the same width as an A2 iron, but it is *miles* cleaner, and would cut much further into its wear cycle without even discussing surface quality. It would do that because even though it's the same length, the actual edge itself is less blunt.

I noted when I sharpened these irons that they abraded slowly on the stones, and attributed that to hardness, but never had them checked.

You can see they fare much better than the hock irons.

When I got into this hobby, a hock iron was described as an automatic improvement over a stanley iron, and in some cases, some of the old stanley irons (even the laminated ones) don't wear that long, but the average later stanley iron without rounded corners will generally hang even with hock's high carbon steel, wear a little differently (longer wear, i'm sure, but less defect and chipping) and be nicer to use.

Context of those hock irons early on may have been the stanley irons from the 70s that were rounded. Those are terrible irons. On a ruse, I bought one of the last sheffield stanley planes last year. It was a terrible plane for a few reasons, but most due to lack of care (the adjuster didn't even fit in the slot on the cap iron - it was too thick and the iron sat suspended on the adjuster above the frog). It, however, has a perfectly fine (actually quite nice) iron that's reasonable hardness, so i can't make a blanket statement that all irons after the round topped irons appeared are junk.

I don't know that I have any hock irons floating around (at least not in carbon steel). I sold one plane and one kit, and don't remember if I had an extra. If I did have an extra, it'd be interesting to have them hardness tested. They wear well, they're hard, and they don't chip.

If someone posed the question on another forum, "which iron lasts longer between sharpening cycles, a good A2 iron or Steve' Knight's O1?", I'll bet most people would answer incorrectly.

Steve's O1 is on par with the rikizai tsune. It's too bad once he got out of business, he didn't introduce his commercial hardening service to slotted stanley irons. They'd probably be as good as anything that we can reasonably get.

One last aside, as pat mentioned, brent doesn't really know anything about stropping. he got me off on the wrong foot regarding that, too, as someone mentioned his study to me, I didn't see it, and they said all stropping degrades an edge. I think I said something to Brent via email about that once (I know I said something to him about double irons). He's fairly dismissive of suggestions (and I offered them politely).

Re: An interesting look again at Beach's results

#2

Steve's iron does pretty well

david weaver

Steve's iron does pretty well, too, but it's not exactly easy to get out on the open market.

I have the mujis, and the original stanley HSS iron appears pretty fine (better than the muji). I almost lucked into one (a tasmanian HSS stanley iron) for a song a few years ago, but felt a need to tell the owner that their iron was relatively desirable, and they elected to keep it.

That leaves the tsune rikizai iron as the best of the bunch for general work and pleasant use through the sharpening cycle. None of the better stanley irons are shown on this test, but I'd suspect they'd wear like the fine-edged irons shown in the workup, but faster.

If I had a lot of money and an assistant, I'd make them push my O1 house iron, a good vintage stanley, the LN iron and the tsune blue through 500 strokes of work each and see how it turns out by scoping the irons to see the results. I did my several thousand strokes on another test and have no interest in confirming something I can already tell from work.

Re: An interesting look again at Beach's results

#3

Re: An interesting look again at Beach's results

Patrick Chase

To be honest I'm much more impressed by Steve Elliott's work than Brent's. I see a few major problems with the latter:

1. He's not measuring what anybody cares about (or should care about). Nobody cares how the edge looks, we care how it cuts. Scope shots of edges are useful to diagnose problems once they occur, but near-useless to figure out if the edge is good to begin with. Of course they're only useful if they're good which brings us to...

2. He's staring at tea leaves. Seldom have I seen so much certain-sounding verbiage written about such worthlessly crappy images. I would need a serious amount of LSD in my system to see even half of what he describes in the output from that Cracker-Jack-box toy scope, which finally brings us to...

3. Some of his conclusions are simply ridiculous. For example, the claim that Shapton stones are poorly graded and leave huge scratches (nope). Or the claim that for calcined Alumina in the Formax green compound inevitably leaves huge scratches (nuh uh). Or anything he says about stropping, period, as you acknowledged.

The bottom line is that he's not a trustworthy source.

Also, S53V and CPM-3V are not HSS.

Re: An interesting look again at Beach's results

#4

Re: An interesting look again at Beach's results

david weaver

The pictures of the edges after wear are actually extremely useful. I didn't recognize their usefulness at first, and brent partially doesn't, either. He's concerned with the length of the wear bevel, but the uniformity of the edge as it wears is much more important. It means predictability and a much more consistent feel through the wear profile.

It shows exactly what Brian is talking about.

As for the rest of the page beyond just those pictures and what the wear bevel length combined with uniformity tells us, I don't pay much attention to it. It's filled with absurd jigs and misleading talk about stropping.

But you can glean quite a lot from those pictures. They are probably as useful (if you know what to make of them) as anything.

In terms of the initial edge, it doesn't really matter. What matters is edge uniformity throughout the sharpness cycle.

Re: An interesting look again at Beach's results

#5

The camera is pointing the wrong way

Patrick Chase

Why not have your assistant plane some hundreds of feet and then take high-resolution images of the wood, using raking light perpendicular to the planing direction to highlight any striations?

The problem with Brent's metric here is that it has nothing to do with what we care about for fine work. Those D2 and non-PM HSS irons are carbide-ridden scratch-fests. They're also fairly difficult to sharpen. The carbides prevent the wear bevel from developing, so they score really well on his metric, but I personally wouldn't use them for anything but roughing, and even then only if I were using modern abrasives.

Re: An interesting look again at Beach's results

#6

Using the duds for junk work

david weaver

By the way, re: the roughing irons being D2 or some other large carbide steel - you'll find that fairly undesirable.

Over time, i've found that you can tolerate a very soft iron in a jack plane or scrub plane. I don't mean 50, but perhaps a couple of clicks above good saw temper (56? who knows. ...things change quickly between 56 and 61 in terms of an edge).

I don't enjoy a particularly soft iron in a smoother, though I can get by with one. I smoothed my bench top intentionally using a 1970s stanley iron in a type 20 smoother (those were stanley's worst irons). I had to sharpen once. My bench top is ash, and I smoothed it until there was no tearout.

An iron that soft in a smoother requires intentional adjustment in technique (heavier shavings) to get some mileage.

I did this to spoof david charlesworth, because david's view is that a hock iron is always an improvement in a plane, I think he used the phrase "the biggest improvement in planing" or something of that sort. I had to pick at him for a while to find out that he was comparing those irons to what he could from stanley in the 1970s. I'm sure I could smooth the surface of my bench with those irons far faster than he could with a new iron, but they are, in fact, worse than the hock irons by a long shot. The point of that at the time was that being fascinated by a million thin shavings and tight mouth, etc, regulated mechanized sharpening routines...whatever... is a good way to never learn to plane well when well means both uniformity and speed in getting there.

anyway, getting off track. The softer irons make *wonderful* jack irons, and good try plane irons (something between makes a better try plane iron - about like an old mathieson try plane iron), and I save my better irons in the jack size for smoothers.

The benefit of the soft iron in the jack is that it will still wear you out three times before it needs to be resharpened, it can get to that point without taking nicks, and when you go to sharpen it, you literally will raise a fat burr on a hard stone, thin it and strop it and then again have a very long time to plane.

If you, instead, have some dud D2 iron, then you can't stiffarm it into a quick sharpen, you have to screw around looking at the condition of the edge, and it will reward you by having a coarse edge through the dullness cycle. The best place for those irons is ebay or the garbage can.

It'd be interesting to see Beach's pictures with V11 to see how it compares to good carbon steel. We see Steve's 3V iron did very well, but it's unlikely they will come up for a reasonable price by any maker any time soon.