Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Voids in steel

Posts

Voids in steel

#1

Voids in steel

Patrick Chase

Referring back to David's scope shots showing voids in some of his chisels, particularly the AIs IIRC.

I'm kicking myself for not having recognized or remembered this at the time. Those voids almost certainly formed in the inter-dendritic regions during casting/solidification. See Ch 15 (starts on p.159) in the Verhoeven book, and particularly figure 15.2 which shows "micropore" formation, and p.167 which describes the mechanism in the long para in the middle: http://www.hybridburners.com/documents/verhoeven.pdf.

Basically all conventionally solidified (read: non-PM) steels have those in their "as cast" states. One of the purposes of hot-working by forging or rolling is to eliminate such microvoids via compression. The fact that they're present in your AIs may point to a less thorough than ideal manufacturing process.

You would not expect to find those in PM-V11 or any other PM steel, for the simple reason that they shouldn't have a chance to form in the first place. Such casting-induced defects are why PM exists, and why it doesn't need conventional forging to achieve very high performance. Similar reasoning applies to the primary carbides that form during conventional casting.

Re: Voids in steel

#2

Re: Voids in steel

david weaver

I figured that (perhaps lack of rigor). I also figured that until they're an issue, I'll pretend I didn't see them because those chisels are otherwise my favorite of new chisels.

the surprise was when getting that fallknaven knife (or whatever the brand is), the hardened powder metal center also had bubbles in, but many more. They're at the edge, and you can tell because the knife snags some hairs. Realistically, it doesn't matter. It's still sharp. But something in the process wasn't going right for there to be small voids.

When I go back to the stuff that was smashed by a hammer (either the japanese chisels, which get smashed when they're laminated in a die (or in the higher end cases, maybe by hand. I don't know. Either those, or the vintage butcher stuff), no such thing appears.

It's certainly true, though, that some of those old irons are a bit soft, and they require someone to put big boy pants on and do a little more than take a million thin shavings. I don't appreciate irons like that for a dedicated smoother, and that one that I took pictures of (the butcher) is in a single iron jointer from somewhere around 1820-1840 given the maker (and the fact that it was unused when I got it - plane and iron). It doesn't fare well in a single iron plane, but it would do OK if it was double iron.

No voids, though, and perhaps someone grinding with a sandstone and using a charnley or a slate in 1820 would've appreciated that. It's not hard for a maker to make an iron like that harder, and butchers tend to have that mild softness - it must've been their market.

It takes so long to set up the microscope and take pictures (because those scopes are designed for flat surfaces, and work holding becomes a chore with various chisel lengths, etc) and post them that I'm not sure how much I'll do. I generally use it to check razor edges before selling them. Not vital, but it ensures that I get no comebacks for things that I didn't notice, and it also ensures that I identify dud razors that don't tolerate the strop. It's interesting otherwise for woodworking, but the bar for a decent edge is much lower since the bevel angle is double.

I can only speculate on why those bubbles haven't appeared in anything old yet, and never say never, I've only looked at a few things. they haven't appeared in any japanese tools that I've looked at yet, and I've looked at a few dozen, but I doubt Hitachi would allow such things out of the factory. I have rikizai coming, but those are probably rolled, too, before they're milled. I'm guessing the weld on the rikizai is a forge weld, even though Tsune's HSS rikizai is glued. If it isn't, I don't really care, as long as it doesn't separate.

Re: Voids in steel

#3

Re: Voids in steel

Patrick Chase

The Achilles' heel of a laminated blade like the Fallkniven is that the weld itself must necessarily melt and re-solidify. If it isn't done very carefully and with the minimum possible amount of localized heating, then you lose the claimed benefits of their unobtainum "gold" PM steel.

OTOH it may just be that your sharpening setup is having trouble with the Vanadium secondary carbides [*] in that steel. Vanadium forms the hardest carbides of any common alloyant. Recall Steve Elliott's results showing that CPM-3V took a crappy edge on anything but diamond.

[*] Primary carbides are the coarse ones that form during casting, and that determine the overall grain structure of conventional non-PM steels. Secondary carbides are much finer ones that form during heat-treatment (particularly in high-alloy steels that undergo two-phase austenitization, like this one). PM does nothing about the latter.

Re: Voids in steel

#4

Re: I'll bet...

david weaver

...we'd these voids in more things than my two.

But not in the W1 that's in tidioute knives so far (I've looked at them). It's FINE stuff, unless you need big carbides to cut dirty rope or rust resistance....it doesn't have those! But if you were in the woods dressing a deer, the fact that you could dress a deer, and spend a minute on a stone and have it still shaving hair is pretty fabulous.

It zips cardboard like nothing (you know, suburban man duty - cut up the boxes) and even as you can see it dulling, it's uniform so it keeps zipping and there's not much to get out when you go to resharpen.

I'll stop there before I start going way out there on a discussion of consistency in spec vs. fitness for use or absolute level of quality for use.

Re: Voids in steel

#5

Re: Voids in steel

david weaver

There isn't actually any problem with the carbides, they're fully sharpened (I can't remember what I sharpened with, but PM actually sharpens very well on natural stones because there aren't large carbides to be pulled out).

It was strictly a problem with bubbles much larger than carbides.

I'm going to speculate that the washita is ripping carbides out of the edge of LN's A2, because every time I've ever used those blades off of the washita, they have sort of a "crunchy sharp" feeling rather than smooth, and the surface i marked up with the evidence. Not significant, but the shine isn't there.

Strangely, no such thing happens with the hard ark. It's probably related to the voids in the washita.

All things equal, I would rather sharpen V11 and a2 with a washita and hard ark, or perhaps a washita and jasper with whetstone powder on it, which is extremely low maintenance and fast, and really favors stropping.

I still haven't sharpened the 420HC, but I'll do that tonight.

I have another little pointless exercise cooking comparing edges sharpened with various pastes after the continuous nonsense about the "contamination" that's in the formax micorfine honing compound. For woodworking, it actually makes the compound more practical, and the inability of some people to use it because it's waxed base is a matter of technique and not lack of fitness for use.

There was a post on another forum last week from someone who was using autosol on a firm strop wondering what they should do next, and I suggested that the deficiency for most users is understanding removal of the wire edge on autosol - which is where that came from.

At any rate, no deficiency on the carbides in the fallknaven knife - the voids were much larger. V11 handled the washita with aplomb - no clue if it also has any vandium carbides.

(for stainless knives, including the fallkniven, I usually finish the edge with some kind of al-ox or diamond, anyway, on a harder leather. it does a better job of separating the wire edge. I have used crox powder, too, but i hate to do that because my crox powder strop is my dedicated razor strop, and it does no favors to compact the surface of it and make it concave with tools.

i don't mind having all of these steels and sharpening mediums around (I've even got a brass bar with diamond on it), but it's really a waste of time for practical use. You should feel the ply wood panel surfaces on my washita-planed remaining kitchen cabinet. they're curly cherry, and given that I've sanded the other cabinets, when you aren't paying attention and touch the top, your brain freezes for a second because they're so smooth. When it goes then toward something like mortising, I posted a chisel last week that I use for plane mortises - japanese chisel, $8 variety in a bunch - used. 15 strokes on a washita between plane mortises and it will cut another mortise. Hard enough that it generally refuses any organized wire edge off of the washita, but the first cuts of the mortise will be shiny again after those 15 swipes. For a routine like that - 15-30 seconds for 20 minutes of mortising in beech, never vist a grinder (it's not necessary), I just don't see improvement anywhere else.

There is more absolute sharpness (despite the fact that the edge will shave hair after the washita), but in mortising something like that, the resistance is not from severing, it's from wedging, and no amount of sharpness will solve that.

Re: Voids in steel

#6

Re: Voids in steel

Patrick Chase

You need to re-read my post, carefully.

PM avoids *primary* carbide formation during casting. It doesn't prevent *secondary* carbide formation during austenitization (the hot dwell during hardening).

Fallkniven's SGPS steel contains 2% V, and would be expected to form Vanadium K2 [*] carbides during hardening, much like CPM-3V. It is simply impossible that any SiO2 sharpening medium could "fully sharpen" those secondary carbides, as the carbides are MUCH harder than the abrasive.

Secondary carbides tend to be small, but steels with significant amounts of V seem to develop larger ones than others, and certainly large enough to explain the "micro voids" you describe depending on how big "micro" is. It has been amply demonstrated that CPM-3V takes a lousy edge on SiO2 for basically that reason, and I don't see any reason why the Fallkniven steel would be much different.

Put simply, that steel is a "challenging" choice for your sharpening method. PM helps make higher-alloy steels "accessible" to people using common sharpening approaches but it's no panacea, particularly where Vanadium is involved.

Of course it's entirely possible that the voids in question aren't so "micro" and that Fallkniven simply overheated the weld and formed new primary carbides. It's impossible to know for sure without more information.

[*] K1 and K2 are different chemical compositions of secondary carbides, with K2 being harder. SGPS is well into the "K2 + austenite" portion of the Cr-C phase diagram at typical hardening temperatures.

Re: Voids in steel

#7

A correction to an earlier post

Patrick Chase

A while (weeks?) back I said that Fallkniven SGPS looked a lot like PM-V11.

I was wrong, because I somehow failed to notice the 2% Vanadium content in SGPS. SGPS is probably closer to CPM-3V in terms of wear resistance (good) and ease of sharpening (not so good). It won't be as bad as 3V, but probably no picnic on conventional non-diamond/CBN media.

In case it isn't obvious, I just reread the Verhoeven eBook from start to finish. Highly recommended if you want to carry on discussions about this stuff in an intelligible manner. It isn't as comprehensive as the grad-level materials/metallurgy course I had as an ME, but it's been a long time and the Verhoeven book is a heck of a lot more accessible even to me than my old texts/notes.

Re: Voids in steel

#8

My effort is spent, and I probably won't read it

david weaver

but because I'm so contrary, I will probably disagree with myself and read it at some time due to personal goading.

But it goes back, for me, to what I'm going to use to make tools and knives, and what I'm going to use. Until electricity and a lot of heat is involved, all of the specialty metals are a complete waste of time for woodworking, and in knives (aside from corrosion resistance, but the best steel that I've ever seen for general knife use is in the friodur razors - and it doesn't appear in friodur knives, unfortunately).

So, while it's interesting, 90% of the people out there buying nutball knives would be better off with a reasonable sharpening routine, a plain steel, and a little bit of metal polish in case they let it oxidize.

In the days of many tools with little use, though, oxidation becomes permanent damage without regular inspection.

Re: Voids in steel

#9

by the way...

david weaver

I didn't notice the FK knife to be that bad on washita, other than a bit slow for the coarseness, which is to be expected. When I saw the little bubbles, which you can observe just a bit with a loupe, I thought maybe they were only on the surface and wouldn't be in the center of the sample (which means they never get to the edge).

In this case, it's not the washita, for two reasons (at least i'm concluding that).

1) they're not on the whole blade, and they're much worse in some spots than others

2) V11 - no problem. It likes the washita just fine, though all of the carbides will put the washita to sleep a little (it'll never actually stop cutting, though, it'll just cut the bleeding edge finer and finer.

This kind of sharpening requires some touch, working only the edge. The economy of that makes it fast. If one is to put something in a guide and start sharpening facets, the deal is off.

it is a variation of go slow to go fast. Something that exists in music (developing economy by learning good efficient clear technique at slow speed), manual labor (learning to stack hay bales, etc). This kind of subtlety is lost when referring to texts and assuming that more varied is more interesting and faster cutting means faster sharpening, because our eye is off the ball at that point - we're obsessed with making steel harder because the spec looks better, more alloyed because the wear profile looks smarter and then demanding faster stones because we want to sharpen a large area of them.

The washita is sort of the version of the drag car with no power steering and no extra weight vs. a 4000 pound car with a bunch of computer stuff in it. It'll probably be faster, but you have to learn to drive it. At least a washita won't kill you, though. (Substitute ark stones for washita, etc).

Out of curiosity, I'll see what the FK does terminally with the washita after stropping the wire edge off with bare leather. Often, the really high hardness steels take a finer edge off of the washita for obvious reasons - lack of particle penetration. Softer knives are a problem on the washita, more than harder, which is contrary to what you'd expect. The washita digs deep in a knife that's saw temper and you get a giant wire edge and deep grooves.

Re: Voids in steel

#10

Re: My effort is spent, and I probably won't read

Patrick Chase

I think that "all specialty steels are a waste of time" is painting with too broad of a brush.

If you look at CTS-XHP/PM-V11, Cartech took care to control both primary (via PM) and secondary (via formulation) carbide formation. Instead of going all-out for every last bit of performance, they created a steel that has nice wear- and corrosion-resistance while still taking a good edge on basically every common sharpening medium. It even got the "George Wilson seal of approval" IIRC. There are some other similar steels out there that also aim for improved performance without sacrificing usability.

CPM-3V and probably SGPS are in a sort of middle ground with somewhat reduced usability in exchange for further increased performance, while the really exotic steels like CPM-10V or CPM-S90V completely sacrifice usability to wring out every last bit of wear resistance.

Re: Voids in steel

#11

Re: by the way...

Patrick Chase

You can't really generalize from one steel to another for stuff like this.

CTS-XHP/PM-V11 is a martensitic PM stainless like SGPS, and it's also solidly in the austenite + K2 portion of the phase diageam, but its Vanadium level is quite a bit lower (0.45% vs. 2%). Its K2 carbides therefore consist mostly of softer Chromium carbide, and its secondary structure is likely finer as well. More to the point, CTS-XHP is known to sharpen very nicely (if slowly, for the reason you point out) on SiO2.

Re: Voids in steel

#12

Re: by the way...

david weaver

Both sharpen relatively slowly, but if you only have to remove wear, I believe a sharpening cycle for me with PM V11 on washita is only about a minute and 15 seconds.

The total overall time, and additional attention makes it about even with 60 hardness O1. I've come to favor an iron that i made, which totally broke the rules. I had an open area and an extremely hot weed torch, which counter-intuitively, resulted in an iron that I don't think was as hot as I'd like. i quenched it, never tempered it, and am guessing at 60 because it's a bit harder than a vintage stanley iron, but not as hard as japanese steel, and it's pretty agreeable on a washita. That kind of agreeability starts running out a few clicks above 60.

I can make a generalization that I'd work anyone with wondersteel under the table if they had a sharpening routine to use with it and I had a washita. that much is true. Most of this stuff is a waste of time, only (as Brian pointed out) to be excepted when wood is really soft and finish is paramount, but that favors carbon steel even more - just harder carbon steel. For chisels, only a person chiseling something with staples in it would prefer something other than carbon steel, unless they're low on the learning curve.

As far as knives go, actual use of most knives (other than machetes) is slicing. carbon steel and a thinner blade profile is extremely hard to beat for that, especially when the sharpening cycle is added. Marine use of a knife, or perhaps oil rig use or something where there's silica and saline - maybe those things are useful for stuff like S30V. Most of the people buying those knives, though, have no clue how to use them, and even less of a clue about sharpening freehand in a reasonable amount of time.

One other situation that I've seen someone mention a situation where S30V is useful - mercenary work where they don't want to pay any attention to a knife. Most of us aren't in danger of that.

Everything else that's related to woodworking, except for things that beginners do, is better (and more efficiently) done with a simple setup. No "master" setup like Cosman has for $1375 or anything like that (and God knows I have about $20K of sharpening stones in my house right now - but not for practical purposes), no devices that need additional honing films on glass, little slices of sharpening stones, etc. And especially once you get into things like carving elements - all of the nonsense about "modern improvements" goes away.

But it takes a little while and a few hundred board feet to see why that is.

It's no coincidence that someone like Brian will tend toward natural stones for fine work and carbon steels. Warren, too. The average beginner shows up here thinking they are backwards or performing some sort of reenactment. They're using it because it works better.

I have all of this sharpening stuff on my bench, but when I actually start a project, it gets cleared off, and the only thing on the utility bench (where the sharpening stuff is) is an IM 313 (which is closed), a washita and a suita. The other stuff needs to be set aside because it's time-sucking play.

Re: Voids in steel

#13

Re: My effort is spent, and I probably won't read

david weaver

You'll have to tell me which of these leads to increased productivity in woodworking. Perhaps along with specialty stones that also do.

Same with knife work and what kind - what practical kind the majority of most knife users would do.

I think knife users are an easy target (so does cliff stamp), because they buy stuff they don't use, and it gets a large cross section of non-makers, who are easily sold on the idea that a piece of aluminum or titanium with a strange CNC profile blade and huge carbides is superior. They're willing to pay a huge premium for it, too. For the most part, they won't use their knives other than for "testing", opening boxes ,and on occasion doing something dopey, like slicing vegetables with a knife that has a 1/4" thick spine - something that is done far better by a small knife with a thin blade that is cheap and easy to sharpen.

If you go to places in the world where people actually do things like clear brush with a knife, there won't be much factory-made expensive stuff found, just as when you go to professional woodworking shops, a lot of the new stuff doesn't appear anywhere. Not because people are set in their ways, but because it isn't better for actually doing anything other than playing.

Where that stuff is markedly better is bulk turning work, planer blades, table saw blades, bandsaw tip blades, cutting concrete, etc. But not woodworking (with hand tools).

Re: Voids in steel

#14

I've really got to avoid discussions like this!!

david weaver

There is a lens that you view this kind of stuff through once you've put a few hundred board feet of rough lumber through a plane and saw. The sharpening economy becomes more important than the alloy to some extent, unless the alloy prevents a reasonable sharpening cycle. Shavings get thicker, and the plane wears you out a couple of times before it actually needs to be sharpened, as opposed to the other way around (which by some stroke of magic, seems to happen to beginners and people who never plane more than planer chatter in any quantity).

As I was making trails through HAP tools, HSS muji irons, etc, and looking for harder and harder chisels, one thing stuck out in my mind. That was, in FWW - the old one where the articles were written more by pros and less based on pushing tools at beginners - most of the shops had sort of utilitarian planes and the most seen chisels in all of the actual articles were blue handled marples chisels (pre china), or another version of the marples chisels. I've had a couple of sets of them in the past, and the grind on the older ones is divine, but one can be a dud now and then. It was sort of like the double iron irk....I liked single iron and bought into that, but I couldn't reconcile why double irons eliminated single irons and did so at a higher cost. That doesn't make sense.

Now we're a lot of years forward, I still don't do more than a couple of hours of woodwork per week, but it often involves sawing and planing rough lumber and hand joinery. I have no use for heavy planes, the next promise in super edge retention or the next soft sharpening stone either becomes a major nuisance if it's contaminated, needs flattening (which isn't an especially productive part of the sharpening cycle), or is hard and isn't that flat (lots of diamond hones) or as fine as it says it is. That stuff inhibits work.

So, as much as books talk about martensitic steel or austempering, it really doesn't matter. My experience with the narex chisels is not that they're better than decent vintage chisels - they're worse, no matter how much more complex their process is or the textbook toughness is. Modern commodity tool steel often has flaws in it that I don't see in older stuff, or like A2, it apparently doesn't like the most time-economical way to sharpen when you're performing work. It really doesn't matter unless it moves the needle in getting something done, and it doesn't. HAP 40 chisels don't equate to more work - they are really tough, but they have a strange feel and can work sort of dull for a long time. That's not attractive. You have to have diamonds out to sharpen them economically, and I can't think of much that gets contaminated more easily than a loose diamond plate or a piece of honing film with some exotic abrasive on it. Waste of time. Great for cutting staples, I suppose.

One last thought. I recally when Tommy (can't remember his name, has a woodcraft show) had his videos. They were fun before they got gutted by the need to sell woodcraft's wares, and most of them either disappeared or became edited pay-only videos. Tommy was making super nice furniture, and he had really plain tools. He showed an LN chisel and a marples chisel and said that the LN chisel was a pain to sharpen. I didn't get it, because I was a beginner. When you're in a work cycle working in rhythm, you don't want that stuff - you want a chisel that holds a reasonable edge and that sharpens quickly.

Needless to say, that video is no longer available publicly now. I get it. I'd rather have a good quality set of marples chisels than LN's socket construction chisels. If I got a dud marples chisel in a set, I'd just replace it. I wouldn't have the marples chisels because they're cheaper than LN's chisels, I'd have them because I like their proportions a whole lot better. Just not the new ones with the fat sides. An alternative is the AI chisels. They are, to me, miles above the LN chisels...miles. I may have a dodgy bubble or two in the ones that I have, but the proportion is one of those that you'd actually use to do work if you're holding a chisel by the handle.

It spreads over to knives, too. There are 100 people telling you that they need a certain overdone knife that's pointless to have for every 1 who could actually make use of something of that sort. To a T, everyone who has come across the forums and extolled the virtues of the next wondersteel, save Derek, hasn't had a convincing reason about why it improved productivity. If derek is planing something we never see here, he's in a small sub class that might actually make use of the hardness or wear resistance. In the united states, we'd just get a different type of wood.

Something has to move the needle in use, and someone notable has to explain to me why it does. Planing 2x as many feet with a sharpening cycle that's 3 times the hassle isn't a good explanation.

Until something like that happens, I'm out, other than for general observations. I just don't care what the modern process and technical arguments, because it would lead someone to believe, for example, that Narex chisels are better than vintage. Unfortunately, that's not the case, for many reasons.

Re: Voids in steel

#15

Re: I've really got to avoid discussions like this

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David,

I can recall two professional woodworkers, who made many postings to this forum and to Badger Pond back in the day. Both liked alloy steel for their work purposes, including M2. Both would take a diamond hone to work, just in case.

Why alloy? Neither wanted to sharpen on the job. In one case it was work culture ((the colleagues), and getting the stink eye from a ‘we don’t pay you to sharpen’ boss; in the other case, he just didn’t want to stop and sharpen.

Both these guys know steels, know how to sharpen, and know their stuff. Their needs are easily differentiable from those of many on this board, perhaps all of us. And they may have adopted new practices since they posted what I have related above. But that brings up a further point: when we generalize from our own experience, N= 1.

Wiley

Re: Voids in steel

#16

N=1

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I bought a Record #7 plane thirty five years ago to use as a jointer. At that time there were only two choices in new and the antiques were more expensive. It came with a Tungsten Vanadium plane iron. I didn't really like the iron, but a jointer is my least used plane; it is often barely a minute at a time that I use it, so I haven't felt the need to replace it.

Now today I read in this thread that Vanadium steel cannot be sharpened with Arkansas stones, quite a shock after all these years.

It reminds me of when years ago people on this forum were telling me that I could not possibly plane jarrah with a Bailey plane. I'm not talking about just people from Australia; people who had never in their life held a piece of jarrah were saying this. N=1 is a lot better than N=0.

Re: Voids in steel

#17

Re: I've really got to avoid discussions like this

Brian Holcombe

I have some alloyed blades and a host of high carbon steel blades. When I first got the alloyed blades I did expect to be able to use the hell out of them and instead I found myself resharpening them as often as I do the high carbon steel blades.

I like a very sharp edge, I resharpen every 20-30 minutes or so of real planing, doesn't matter if the blade is blue steel, tougou-kou, super white or basic HC.

When I did use them beyond that I found myself forever at the sharpening bench, well beyond the few minutes I prefer to spend. It did me a disservice to use blades to that end.

One of the guys in my Kezurou-kai group went to Japan and shared his experience, they're very keen about sharp edges to say the least.

Goes for any tool really, dull is dangerous.

Re: Voids in steel

#18

Re: N=1

Patrick Chase

Warren, I pointed out that a specific stainless steel that undergoes austenitization in K2 + gamma phase will end up containing Vanadium carbides of significant size (in part because they never dissolve into solution during hardening), that can't be sharpened by SiO2 and will therefore degrade edge-taking.

The Vanadium K2 carbide is Rc90 or so, so that shouldn't be a remotely controversial statement.

It's also a much more limited and precise statement than what you impute to me. In other alloys/situations Vanadium may either remain in solution (no carbides at all) or the carbides may only form during quenching and therefore be quite small and not an issue.

You're either ignorant about this specific topic or engaged in tendentious word-twisting. Neither is a particularly good look for someone of your skills and distinction. You are (or should be) above this.

Re: Voids in steel

#19

Re: I've really got to avoid discussions like this

Patrick Chase

Well, this discussion began as attempt to explain something that some fellow noted when he purchased a metallurgical 'scope and started pointing it at his chisels. If you can convince him to stop then your problems will be solved.

Seriously, I think you make some incorrect assumptions about what I do. I do the vast majority of my sharpening and honing using a fairly basic two-waterstone-and-leather setup. I also steer clear of truly difficult alloys, with the sole exception of my HAP40 chisels (the same ones you have). CTS-XHP/PM-V11 and Blue is about as exciting as I get other than that.

The only lapping film that I use on a semi-regular basis is Chromium Oxide, which is cheap enough that I don't worry about contaminating or damaging it, though as I said in another thread I think that those issues are fairly easy to avoid in any case. I do use diamond compounds and films for initial flattening/setup and much less regularly when I'm trying to wring out maximum sharpness for some reason (for example when I was photographing sections of Brian's AYC offcut a while back).

With that said I have a deep respect for the achievements of modern metallurgy and superabrasives, and I like to learn and experiment (and talk). That's all.

Re: Voids in steel

#20

Re: I've really got to avoid discussions like this

David weaver

I'm at home today and will sharpen a record plane iron and take a picture of the edge to compare to a plain iron.

The only thing that comes to mind is that they're soft for a laminated iron, and don't last as long as the better unlaminated Stanley irons that I have, but I've never noticed anything to suggest they don't sharpen properly on anything.

It does little good to worry about whether or not you can scratch the carbides in them because they are too soft to hold them in the first place.

Planecraft shows a picture of the grain vs a straw iron and it looks tighter in the pictures, but it doesn't amount to anything in use. Plus, who knows if the pictures are an unbiased sample of a good quality brand x iron. Planecraft is an interesting book, but it is a bit of a puff piece for record.

If you did a comparison ala Brent Beach, you'd find them to fare less well than a good Stanley iron.

Re: Voids in steel

#21

Re: I've really got to avoid discussions like this

david weaver

Curious, Wiley, if you could provide sort of a two-sentencer about what it was that they were doing that their boss didn't want them to sharpen? Were they doing site work. Architectural or something? Mostly on only a little bit of hand work?

When a boss enters the picture, all reasonability can be off. My dad works at a golf course, which is open during the winter as well as the summer. The owner doesn't like him to run heat or air conditioning (because he doesn't want to pay for it) under the guise that he (the boss) isn't comfortable going in and out of the clubhouse due to the changing temperature. Needless to say, it's not a ritzy course, and older folks who are that stingy about everything aren't uncommon where I'm from.

At any rate, the boss of these guys sounds like he might be in the weeds. Pushing tools that aren't sharp or that are only marginally sharp isn't exactly productive.

Re: Voids in steel

#22

Re: N=1

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have no trouble pleading ignorance here. I was under the impression that Vanadium in the steel formed carbides. I think reading your posts might have contributed to that impression.

Re: Voids in steel

#23

One revision to the nothing new is that good..

david weaver

I got two replacement (finally) tsune rikizai irons in the mail yesterday. I thought I'd ordered one, but I guess I must've done something wrong.

I hope they live up to my last one, because they're just like a harder version of O1 and finer grained.

They're not really that new.

If the blademakers decided they wanted to focus on simpler but more pure alloys, they could do the same thing.

Re: Voids in steel

#24

Re: I've really got to avoid discussions like this

david weaver

Sorry to pull you into this Brian, you're just one of the few people I know who planes, and planes very well and planes every aspect. There aren't a whole lot of people who would really get what you're saying.

Re: Voids in steel

#25

Re: I've really got to avoid discussions like this

david weaver

Wiley, as an actuary, I appreciated the statement about a sample of N = 1 :)

None of my statements on this forums are statements of actuarial opinion, though!